
and I would like to invite sort of tank
the speakers for inviting me here so
convergence it’s one of those words that
concern of a hundred possibilities
meeting of minds to beating hearts or is
it the grand convergence of technologies
that made the internet happen inspired
by my years in science I would like to
speak to you today about a certain kind
of convergence specifically how and why
some convergences can be achieved by
design White’s I’m others may happen
more by way of chance so I’d like to
think that my first brush with
convergence happened when I saw my
father used the magnifying glass to
focus sun rays to burn a hole into paper
but the truth is it wasn’t it was this
image this picture which must be
familiar to all of you so so this
picture must be familiar to all of you
and this is probably what we all learn
in the school text so parallel rays of
light transmitted through a glass lens
convex shaped and converge at the focus
an object placed at this focus would
typically have a clarity far beyond the
clarity found in other places in the
field of view in fact a very famous lens
maker of the 17th century Anton one new
and awake who you must have heard of to
placed my microorganisms under this lens
to study life pretty much under the
microscope now this point of convergence
the focus is fundamental to all imaging
systems all systems at sea including our
eyes when I was in school I used to
pink and as you see it lens with glass
convex shape and of course light now
what happens is that glass bends light
as you all know because of a property
called refractive index which is much
higher in blast than in air the convex
shape of the lens presents different
paces differently angled faces to the
beam of light and that’s how they
converge how they do and where they do
what happened was is a grew up and I
went to work my understanding of the
electromagnetic spectrum and nature of
materials broadened I figured that based
on the wavelength of light very
different properties of materials could
be used to focus that light for instance
if you have a telescope to map the skies
with radio waves or think of an antenna
that communicates with microwaves they
are often made of their of made of
metallic alloys and they are often
concave shaped and they are often
gridded this happens because the
wavelength of light is several
centimeters long and they’re kind of
impervious to these grids the set of
gaps in the grid now what happens is
that in the antenna or in the telescope
is well parallel beams of light that are
incident from far on these structures
converge to the focus and that is how we
are able to sort of have a window to the
universe with radio waves or hear each
other’s voices across miles now what
happens is that we see through our eyes
and we listened through are yours and
the signal that reaches our brain gets
processed and reconstructed there to
form an image or form of speech or some
form of what we may call intelligent
we design these menses these telescopes
or these antennas and we choose the
material and we confer upon them you
know by through casting and molding a
shape that allows convergence to happen
so this is all physics right I mean
you’re familiar with that what happened
to me was at the turn of the millennium
chance took my research from radio waves
to ultrasound to sound waves now you can
do a little experiment let’s see how
they work you tap a finger on your head
and you will hear the sound but tap your
finger on the tummy you’ll hear much
less sound it’ll be more muffled now
ultrasound which is as you know
high-frequency sound waves that we can’t
your operates pretty much like that
tough with it on the head and there’ll
be a lot of reflection tap with it on
the tummy and they’ll be much much less
reflection it turns out that we can make
images of the internal organs of the
body using sound waves that are
reflected off them and that’s what
ultrasound machines really do now that
on the right is an ultrasound machine
but how is the ultrasound produced the
ultrasound is produced by these objects
the left hand side which are called
probes probes are made of materials that
exhibit a property called piezo
electricity and that was discovered by
the way as you probably many of you know
by Curie brothers in the 19th century
now what happens in a piece of ellipse
piezoelectric crystal is that when you
excited with the voltage it creates a
mechanical wave or a pressure wave
pretty much like what is created by a
tapping finger and when you apply
pressure across it pressure on it it
creates a voltage now sound waves like
light waves can be bent differently by
different materials in fact that’s the
reason why we can at all may call to
images of the internal organs of the
body because different tissue types have
different acoustic impedance a–‘s and
that’s how reflection from them creates
an image now what happens is that these
images get created and then long long
back about 50 60 years back the sort of
piezoelectric membranes were concave
shaped and that’s what radiated
ultrasound and when the sound waves came
back from reflected echoes they once
again converged the focus and that’s how
images would be made in the last few
decades things have changed because of
digital signal processing and
application-specific integrated circuits
so now focusing can be done by applying
time delays to waves that emanate from
these tiny crystals that dot the sort of
the surface of the probe so that’s how
modern ultrasound machines image through
convergence few years back I had the
chance to be you know spend hours
watching some of these machines taking
scans of yet to be born babies so what
the doctors do as many of you may have
seen is place the probe on the belly of
an expectant mother and look at the
features to see whether they are
developing normally mothers come in
different sizes and so do the features
as they grow they also move and they
kick around and most of these machines
produce ultrasound images that are in
two dimension and clinical guidelines
kind of prescribed that you image
certain standard standard scan planes in
two dimension because you need to look
at the anatomical structure and make
certain biometric measurements using a
mouse like caliper that is on the screen
on the machine which the user uses now a
small movement of the ultrasound probe
actually shifts the fee
of you quite sharply in ultrasound and
as I said these objects sometimes move
so it is actually quite difficult and it
takes time and effort to bring up the
standard scan plane so the question is
how do new users of ultrasound learn to
do this so figure this out we conducted
an experiment in our lab where we had
some new users whom we asked whom we
taught how to use the ultrasound machine
and the probe and we were we asked them
to scan an object which you see on the
left hand side that’s like an object
called a phantom this particular object
is a fatal phantom because it has the
features of about twenty week fetus what
you see and these phantoms are actually
made of materials that mimic tissue
properties so you can actually test our
to sound systems work with them what you
see on the right is the standard one of
the standard planes of the head of the
this fatal phantom which looks pretty
much like the head of a real phantom
real fetus at that kind of age and this
is something that is stand by an expert
users so this image is actually pretty
good and it meets this clinical kind of
standards so what we did was we thought
these new users how to scan and then we
shorten this image and ask them to bring
it up so what do they bring up so they
were asked to scan seven times over the
course of a few weeks and each time they
scanned for images each so what do they
bring up let’s see this is what they
bring up you can see that there is a
fair amount of variability in the
brightness and in the background and in
the force so they kind of sometimes the
heads are a bit tilted and so on and the
left panel represents one user and the
right panel represents the second user
and you can see that there’s a fair
amount of variability now what happens
is after this round obsessions the
expert now goes and gives feedback to
these people and tells them how to scan
better and they go back to stand again
and the scan seven times again over a
period of time force can see each each
time and there’s only one difference
this time in front of them is a
reference image that is scanned by the
expert and this is what the images look
now well I have looked at them over and
over again and I think they perceptually
look much more clear we can look at the
last one and you can see this one they
look perceptually far more clear and
more consistent but if you look closer
you will find that there is still some
differences in the background and the
pose that’s the tilt of the head so what
happened was it the feedback was it the
reference image that changed the fact
that these people are learning to sort
of the scan better or was it their will
or was it an improvement of their skill
or is it that human beings are just
designed to learn over time and if we
did this experiment with hundred new
users would we find the same pattern of
learning so this experience sort of
jostled my memory you know when I was a
child I had these illustrated books on
how the solar system came about and how
the earth was formed and then it was
warm and then it cold and there was so
much water and the life sprung and we
evolved from a simple bacterium to a
homo sapien and in my mind was imprinted
these two images by the way these are
sort of these are scanned pages of that
book of mine like yours back and you can
see that the image that was imprinted in
my mind was actually these hands and
feet of a chimpanzee and us and so when
I think about it and I think of images
and I’d like you to think of images too
now these images are formed by sort of
convergence that is
designed they are designed for their
come about because of design convergence
that we manufacture and that’s all
because of laws of physics what about us
we our actions are they the result of
design or chance and then finally to go
back to what triggered the stock right
so what triggered this talk I think I
think was the theme of this event where
parallels intersect and what is the
probability you think what are the odds
that we would all be gathered on the
Saturday morning converged here talking
about convergence so I think compared to
the world of physics the world of living
in the world of living convergence is a
bit more of a chance than design thank you