Press "Enter" to skip to content

Confronting Chronic Disease and Refusing To Give Up | Susannah Meadows | TEDxNashville


[Music]
[Applause]
when my son Shepard was three years old
he started walking with a limp by the
time he was diagnosed with juvenile
idiopathic arthritis a month later he
was having trouble getting out of bed
we saw the top doctors in New York City
and they told us that while there was no
cure for what Shepherd had there were
medicines that could treat his symptoms
and that if we didn’t give Shepherd
these drugs he could become disabled and
of course he’d still be in pain so we
started him on powerful immune
suppressants but these drugs come with
worrying risks including lymphoma and
liver disease
they also made Shepherd feel sick and
they did little for his arthritis pain
he would lie on the couch for several
days after taking his pills It was as if
he had the flu every week but this was
our only option unless it wasn’t I heard
about another mom whose son recovered
from arthritis six weeks after she
stopped feeding him food with gluten and
dairy in it and gave him probiotics
omega-3s and other supplements when I
first heard about what she did I
dismissed it as frou-frou alternative
medicine I figured that it couldn’t work
or doctors would know about it but when
you watch a little guy lie there on the
couch it’s pretty tough to accept that
that’s how it’s gonna be evidence or not
the other moms plan wasn’t risky so we
decided to try it we couldn’t not try it
one morning six weeks into our
experiment I went into shepherds room to
help him out of bed as I’d been doing he
sprang up himself and said mommy my
knees don’t hurt anymore
now we have no way of knowing what made
Shepard better it’s possible the
medication kicked in late but they’re
compelling reasons to believe that it
was the diet a couple times Shepard
accidentally had bread and as arthritis
pain returned immediately and when I dug
into the medical literature myself I
found several studies suggesting that
the diet we gave Shepard could have a
positive impact on autoimmune arthritis
researchers have since told me that
inflammation in the body can be linked
to inflammation in the gut and that that
can originate with a food intolerance or
a decimated gut bacteria population
perhaps from taking antibiotics and
we’re learning more every day about how
critical is population our microbiome is
– our overall health
we eventually took Shepard off the drugs
which we are never expected to be able
to do and still his arthritis did not
come back he’s now a happy wisecracking
10 year old he likes drawing comic
strips he’s in the running club and he
doesn’t remember what arthritis felt
like so the thing that may very well
have saved him came from another mom
which got me thinking that the answer to
an illness may lie beyond the knowledge
of even the best doctors and that if
something hasn’t been proven to work it
doesn’t mean that it won’t
no one has all the answers which seems
really obvious to me now but I think it
can be hard to recognize in the realm of
Medicine or doctors expertise is always
going to be greater than our own I came
to believe that if you are facing a
difficult health problem or any problem
you have a choice to keep going when
others say that you can’t in addition to
being a stubborn parent
I’m a journalist so after Shepard
recovered I went looking for stories of
people who faced daunting medical
challenges and refused to give up
what I found became my book the other
side of impossible I met a woman with MS
who was using a wheelchair available
medications could no longer help her so
she decided to help herself she read
through medical studies and came up with
a plan that involved eating 12 cups a
day of fruits and vegetables within the
year she was riding a bike again the
mother of a boy with life-threatening
food allergies refused to accept that
there was no treatment for her son so
she moved across the country with three
children and two dogs to pursue an
experimental therapy that addressed the
anxiety that haunts so many children
with food allergies a year later that
boy was eating everything I met a little
girl who’s starting at the age of three
months old was knocked down by
unrelenting seizures the family tried
everything
Western medicine could offer and
everything outside of it nothing worked
the girl’s seizures kept getting worse
but her mom wouldn’t give up a full
decade into their wrenching ordeal they
went to see yet another neurologist that
doctor suggested they do an MRI the scan
revealed a brain tumor the tumor was
removed and that girl has not had a
seizure since so it’s not about
alternative medicine versus Western
medicine
I actually think those categories are
useless it’s about whatever works and
persevering until you get there medicine
is medicine
we can’t know if others will be helped
by these therapies until we study them
and actually some of that work is now
underway the therapy for food allergies
has been so successful anecdotally that
Boston Children’s Hospital is now
looking into it but what’s remarkable
about the people I met is that they
believe they get better before science
at
them the way or as I had lucked into
hearing about this thing that maybe
would work and that we tried out of
desperation they were determined to
solve the unsolvable they had an
extraordinary talent for hope because of
course you wouldn’t persist without that
I came to think of them as the
indomitable z’
which I realized sounds like they should
be wearing capes and perhaps they should
when I started my research a couple of
them had not had any luck yet
which is why I wanted to write about
them I wanted to show a range of
outcomes because that’s how it is when
you experiment I remember when I met
Annie the mother of the girl with
seizures she was still struggling and I
didn’t have hope for her and then she
proved me wrong when they finally
vanquished those seizures another woman
I met who had severe rheumatoid
arthritis was handicapped by a painful
limp when I met her and then she too
over the course of two years improved
dramatically well we can’t draw
conclusions from such a small sample I
wonder can perseverance itself have an
impact on whether we recover or not if
you think just about Annie and her
little girl how different their story
would be now if Annie had given up even
five years into it I reached out to dr.
Jeffery roediger a psychiatrist on the
Faculty of Harvard Medical School and
asked him if he thought perseverance
that bullheaded push for an answer
could influence our health and he said
yes he said that the mind was a major
reason why people got better and he told
me about a couple small but rigorous
studies looking at people with cancer
and he said that the will to survive the
strength and commitment to one’s health
seemed to be a major reason why some
people recovered or live longer than
they were expected to
that’s the kind of mindset that the
indomitable had they not only sought
healing they expected it and that’s
exactly the right condition for bringing
about the placebo effect
we know from medical studies that the
placebo effect real healing is likely to
happen just about any time you pursue
recovery with confidence researchers
who’ve looked at the placebo effect have
seen patients with Parkinsons disease
autoimmune disease anxiety and pain get
better when their only medicine is
belief we understand so little about how
and why this comes about and we really
should be studying it more so how do you
come by perseverance and its partner
hope when it’s more reasonable to assume
that you won’t get better because to me
what’s as incredible is coming back from
a disease that’s considered flat-out
irreversible is thinking you can in the
first place we don’t have the science
yet to be able to say we’re perseverance
comes from and how we can all get it but
there is a study that offers some
intriguing clues years ago at the
University of Colorado a group of rats
was subjected to tiny shocks to their
tails when they were adolescents which
sounds a little bit like high school to
some of the rats were able to turn the
shock off by manipulating a little wheel
other rats had no means of doing so they
were helpless then the scientists
followed the rats for the rest of their
lives
luckily rats don’t live very long and
what they found was that the rats that
had control over the shocks were and
these are their words the scientists not
the rats the rats were inoculated for
life against helplessness
so when faced with difficulty later on
they didn’t give up so what the study
suggests is that our early life
experiences may come into play if we
later hit a brick wall that was not my
experience when Shepard got sick I took
our doctors word for it that we would be
dealing with this for the rest of his
life
I wasn’t hopeful and I didn’t go looking
to experiment but now if someone in my
family got sick with an impossible
illness I would know to get to work I
know I’m not helpless that we aren’t we
have some control and an enormous amount
of choice in terms of what kinds of
therapies we pursue so I’d make a long
list of doctors and I wouldn’t stop
there because what the indomitable
taught me is that perseverance can work
I remember talking to Annie his daughter
had the seizures back when they were
still having a tough time and I said how
is it that you can keep going when
you’ve had so many setbacks and she said
because she’s not better yet and I asked
the son of the MS patient what it was
that drove his mom and he said courage
is knowing you’re licked and doing it
anyway and I asked the woman who
developed the allergy therapy someone by
the way who has no medical background
and I said what be do you think that you
could figure this thing out
when the researchers who’ve dedicated
their lives to it still haven’t been
able to you know what she said she said
that’s not how I think I think what do I
want to do thanks [Applause]
Please follow and like us: