
you
thank you very much I’m Dimitri zangulus
and I’m an economist us sound like a
confession I’m afraid it is we we are
the world is about to undergo a
revolution our economies are about to
become decarbonized and I’m going to
argue that economists have failed to
predict the scale of this revolution the
degree to which we are going to
transition to a low-carbon economy I’m
going to argue that economists not only
get the future wrong but economists make
the future wrong to the extent that we
are believed we become part of the
problem to understand this we have to
understand a little bit about the
underlying problem of climate change
greenhouse gases which cause climate
change sit in the atmosphere for decades
in some cases hundreds of years this
means it’s the stock of greenhouse gases
that causes climate change not the
annual flow not the annual emissions so
if you want to control the temperature
you have to stabilize the stock it
doesn’t matter whether you want to
control it to two degrees which is where
our world leaders at what our world
leaders agreed to in Paris a couple of
years ago four degrees or six degrees or
toast degrees you have to bring
emissions the annual flow close to zero
to stabilize the stock or we can either
do this the easy way by managing that
transition or we can do this the hard
way by generating such a hostile climate
it severely compromised as humanity’s
ability to exist on the planet so well
let’s say we were to try and meet the
globally agreed target of two degrees
how much more carbon could we squeeze
into the atmosphere without breaching
that ceiling and that’s what the little
blue circle shows on this chart these
are just scaled circles and what you see
in the black circle is the amount of
readily accessible fossil fuel reserves
coal oil gas that you can extract easily
from the ground most of that if we’re to
meet the two-degree target has to stay
in the ground or if we burn it we have
to capture the tarp that the carbon this
is revolutionary the economy of the
world will very quickly shift from
fossil fuels to renewables and energy
efficiency and I hope to explain why
this is going to touch all of us this
isn’t just the fossil fuel companies
gonna feel this so an obvious question
then at this stage is given that we’ve
got to make such a large transformation
how much is it gonna cost well that’s
easy this is where economists come in
they can tell you the answer and there
it is
don’t try and read out okay you’re not
gonna make any more sense out of it than
I am
bizarrely enough this is the summary
table and the summary for policy makers
from the international panel of climate
change the most authority Vande
respected body in the field of climate
economics and climate studies and what
it says is that in 2100 the cost of
meeting a two-degree target every year
is going to be of the order of two point
nine to eleven point four percent of GDP
so there you have it thank you wait a
minute this is just this is nonsense
right I mean alarm bells should begin to
ring when you see the Comedie decimal
place you know we struggle to predict
GDP to three years ahead let alone 80
plus years ahead yeah this is a period
of a which the world economy will have
expanded by between 300 and 900 percent
so already
something’s not right but this just
doesn’t pass the sniff test let’s think
about what we’re saying here right this
is a scenario where from tomorrow we all
aim to meet the two-degree target we put
the best minds in the world all most
creative innovators are best
entrepreneurs we spend billions maybe
trillions of dollars and investments in
these renewables and we have a perfect
policy framework with a single global
carbon price and yet it’s still expect
more expensive in every single scenario
to employ people in far-flung parts of
the world to dig this stuff up to put
these fossil fuels on ships in pipes on
trains transport them halfway around the
world earn them in 19th century
technology and in most cases lose much
if not most of that energy on the grid
and that apparently is going to be
cheaper than actually extracting this
stuff for free from the wind from the
Sun and from the oceans it just doesn’t
pass the sniff test ok there’ll be
difficult bits for sure in buildings in
industry and land use and forestry it’s
going to be very difficult to squeeze
carbon out of those sectors but
transport and energy it really isn’t
that much of a challenge economists get
this wrong all the time they fail to
understand the rate of deployment that
we see in these renewable technologies
this is a chart from the International
Energy Agency one of the most respected
organizations in this field the red line
shows the actual rate of deployment and
electrical capacity the other lines show
you the forecasts at the ia put out they
no just get it wrong in one year or two
years or three years they get it wrong
year after year after year after year I
mean yeah you all know Einstein’s
definition of madness right it’s
repeating the same thing and expecting
different results well that’s what
they’re doing unfortunately this is a
disaster because one of the key elements
of technological revolutions is what is
called learning by doing when you learn
through deployment you learn to make
your innovations better you experiment
with them you learn through good
practice you engineer them better and so
on and the costs come down and the
productivity and efficiency of the
product goes up the ia understand
learning by doing but like most
economists they’ve really misunderstood
the amount of doing and this is a
disaster because you miss out this this
charts a little busy but what it shows
are two of the leading renewable
technologies solar photovoltaic on the
left and wind power on the right the
cost of solar photovoltaic have come
down by a factor of five in as many
years now wind is a more mature
technology but the cost of wind power
have also haft over the same period both
are now what’s called close to grid
parity that is they are fully
competitive with oil the coal and with
gas okay the wind doesn’t always blow
the Sun doesn’t always shine so we need
some kind of storage to bridge the
intermittency well the good news is that
solar that lithium-ion battery costs
have also fallen by about 40 percent
over the same period with very
encouraging and exciting new innovations
in battery storage on the way it’s not
just energy most big auto manufacturers
have now stopped spending money on
research and development in the
combustion engine they’ve got narrow
research budgets it’s almost all going
into electric vehicles the combustion
engine is over the era of the combustion
engine car has finished this is a
revolution it is a transformation why do
economists get it so wrong why don’t
they understand how quickly we are
deploying these things well the answers
reasonably simple they miss out the key
linkages between investment innovation
behaviors and cultures these feedback
mechanisms that means that when a
revolution happens it can happen a lot
faster than you otherwise predicted and
as a result they overestimate the costs
of the Revolution and they underestimate
its scale let me give you an example
many of you will have been to Copenhagen
or to Amsterdam and you go there and you
ask you know you see that everybody
cycles and you ask people why do all
cycle and they will usually tell you
something along the lines of well we
have fantastic cycling infrastructure
and you look around and true enough they
do and then you might follow up and ask
well how comes you have such great
cycling infrastructure this point they
start to look at you as if you’re a bit
thick and they say well everybody here
cycles well all right it doesn’t really
matter which came first the chicken or
the egg you can tell a similar story
with renewable vehicles if you want to
buy a renewable vehicle you want to know
that there’s electric charging points
and not petrol stations but if you want
somebody to build electric charging
points and not petrol stations you need
to know that there’s enough people
driving electric vehicles you’ve got
these network effects you need to tap
into but expectations are what drives
this change in both cases expectations
really matter economists tend to miss
this out social psychologists on the
other hand have known for years that if
you want to solve complex coordination
problems like climate change you need to
manage and understand expectations likes
and dislikes are not fixed
they are influenceable social norms
they’re not fixed they’re influenceable
technologies they’re not fixed they’re
influenceable and they all feed off each
other in this fantastic spiral this has
been a problem for some times for
economists and it’s something that we
really need to understand imagine for
example that you’re a mayor or aura or
or a politician or a business leader and
you’re thinking of investing heavily or
pushing for policies to invest heavily
in renewables and energy efficiency and
you think everybody else is going to do
this if you if sorry and you actually
think nobody else is gonna do this right
so you expect the technology cost to
stay high you expect the financing to be
niche and you don’t see any huge market
now say all things remain the same but
actually you now expect everybody else
is going to move into this very rapidly
it’s the best thing since sliced bread
every one of their dog wants a piece of
it suddenly you expect the technologies
cost to come down very quickly the
financing will become mainstream and you
see these fantastic new market
opportunities so you invest and so does
everybody else and the very process of
investing generates the deployment that
brings the cost down that makes it more
attractive you start this virtuous site
spiral you reach this tipping point and
that’s and note that nothing has changed
to accept people’s expectations in both
scenarios it’s psychology it’s in the
head and this is what economists tend to
miss out and that’s exactly what we’ve
seen happening on the world political
stage over the last ten years some of
you will remember ten years ago the
Copenhagen conference on climate change
which raised hopes and aspirations of an
ambitious deal but it failed why did it
fail because at the time the language
was about cost it was about burden
sharing it was about sacrifice it was
about everyone pulling their weight to
save the planet
of course what you’ve got was distrust
everyone wanted to free ride on the
actions of others people waited for
other people to move and you got a rates
to the bottom and no deal or at least
not an ambitious deal emerged why in the
clock forward eight years to Paris and
we have that ambitious deal and what’s
more it’s voluntary and that deal is
based on an understanding that there are
opportunities and let me explain why
that is what for a start we’ve seen the
technology costs come down and that
changes the equation commercially quite
substantially we’ve also begun to
understand that there are substantial
gains from energy efficiency by
definition that saves you money but
there are other benefits as well
pollution the World Health Organization
and the World Bank together estimate
that the cost of pollution through death
through ill health through hours lost
out of work in a country like China
amounts to something like 12% of annual
GDP twelve percent I mean that is
literally metaphorically eye-watering
excuse the pun in the European Union
it’s of the order of five to seven
percent these are not trivial numbers if
we dedicated that amount of resources
every year to solving climate change
we’d probably have this licked in a
matter of decades but it doesn’t stop
there once the private sector and
businesses got a whiff of
the opportunities associated with this
kind of change they also began to see
reason to act and reason to invest don’t
squint too hard at this what you need to
are the only thing you need to note here
is the figure of six million this is a
an advert that went out in the financial
times just prior to the Paris agreement
in 2015 and it says six million
companies around the world want an
ambitious climate deal at the conference
in Paris that December this is six
million companies seeing opportunity and
money and profit these are new lobbies
new voices to counter the existing
lobbies in fossil fuels they will have
influence on political systems that will
change policies that will change
investments and it’s no surprise well
trade in renewable sectors has outpaced
world trade in other sectors by double
since the financial crash sustainable
sectors have outperformed the market by
about ten percent over the same period
whereas those sectors that are deeply
entrenched in fossil fuels have lagged
the S&P 500 by in some cases a very
large margin this is a commercial
opportunity and it’s commercial
opportunities together with things like
pollution but it’s mostly the commercial
opportunities of fabricating
manufacturing exporting this kind of kit
in solar in wind and other sectors but
led the Chinese to agree a comprehensive
landmark deal with the Americans the
year prior to Paris and now you see what
we’re going to this right we’ve got
China moving with ambitious
decarbonization we’ve got the u.s.
cutting emissions and we’ve got Europe
cutting emissions that’s three-quarters
of the world the rest of the world just
has to pay attention because this is
going to happen this is where the new
markets are and it’s no surprise
therefore that a year later you had this
ambitious and comprehensive deal in
Paris to try and limit temperatures to
two degrees with an aspiration to keep
them below one and a half now I saw
quite a few of you or I sense quite a
few of you straining there were that
picture of a bomb and you’re kind of
thinking under your residence right look
at it now actually Donald Trump is
another example of why the momentum is
unstoppable ten years ago if the US had
failed show leadership on this the
Indians the Chinese and others would
have said well you know what you’re one
of the richest countries one of the
biggest emitters if you’re not
to be paying for this when we’re
certainly not gonna handicap our
economies to pay for this and the whole
process would have stopped we’ve not
seen that this time it’s been very
different
the US has talked about backpedaling
China India Europe and the rest of the
world I said well fine we’re gonna we’re
gonna move on regardless with our
voluntary agreements why because they no
longer see this is of course they see it
as an opportunity they see this as a
chance to steal a march on the American
competitors who are hamstringing
themselves by slowing down and creating
the new technologies and new goods and
services for the fastest-growing market
in the world all of this stuff all of
this expectations all of these feedbacks
these tipping points these understanding
that you can invest in physical assets
and that changes mindsets it changes
cultures it changes institutions is what
economists tend to miss out and so they
they overestimate the cost of this
revolution and like I said already they
tend to underestimate the scale now
don’t get me wrong
economic models have a very important
role to play they enforce a discipline
on the modeler to be very clear on their
assumptions they impose some degree of
internal consistency and they’re good
descriptions of the workings of the
economy and so they act as very good
sources of simulations for risks in an
as if world what if things develop like
this how might the world looked like but
they useless at forecasting because all
they tell you is the prior assumptions
of the forecaster who makes the
assumptions on the things you care about
like I said at the beginning there’s
plenty that economists can do to help in
this story we can look at the risks we
can try and help in assessing how much
money should be put into research and
development into deployment we can try
and format formulate the standards and
regulations we can help design our
cities to make them more efficient but
economists really need to learn the
lesson but if they’re to stay relevant
to this most important story they have
to spend a lot less time trying to
predict the future and a lot more time
helping design it thank you
you
thank you very much I’m Dimitri zangulus
and I’m an economist us sound like a
confession I’m afraid it is we we are
the world is about to undergo a
revolution our economies are about to
become decarbonized and I’m going to
argue that economists have failed to
predict the scale of this revolution the
degree to which we are going to
transition to a low-carbon economy I’m
going to argue that economists not only
get the future wrong but economists make
the future wrong to the extent that we
are believed we become part of the
problem to understand this we have to
understand a little bit about the
underlying problem of climate change
greenhouse gases which cause climate
change sit in the atmosphere for decades
in some cases hundreds of years this
means it’s the stock of greenhouse gases
that causes climate change not the
annual flow not the annual emissions so
if you want to control the temperature
you have to stabilize the stock it
doesn’t matter whether you want to
control it to two degrees which is where
our world leaders at what our world
leaders agreed to in Paris a couple of
years ago four degrees or six degrees or
toast degrees you have to bring
emissions the annual flow close to zero
to stabilize the stock or we can either
do this the easy way by managing that
transition or we can do this the hard
way by generating such a hostile climate
it severely compromised as humanity’s
ability to exist on the planet so well
let’s say we were to try and meet the
globally agreed target of two degrees
how much more carbon could we squeeze
into the atmosphere without breaching
that ceiling and that’s what the little
blue circle shows on this chart these
are just scaled circles and what you see
in the black circle is the amount of
readily accessible fossil fuel reserves
coal oil gas that you can extract easily
from the ground most of that if we’re to
meet the two-degree target has to stay
in the ground or if we burn it we have
to capture the tarp that the carbon this
is revolutionary the economy of the
world will very quickly shift from
fossil fuels to renewables and energy
efficiency and I hope to explain why
this is going to touch all of us this
isn’t just the fossil fuel companies
gonna feel this so an obvious question
then at this stage is given that we’ve
got to make such a large transformation
how much is it gonna cost well that’s
easy this is where economists come in
they can tell you the answer and there
it is
don’t try and read out okay you’re not
gonna make any more sense out of it than
I am
bizarrely enough this is the summary
table and the summary for policy makers
from the international panel of climate
change the most authority Vande
respected body in the field of climate
economics and climate studies and what
it says is that in 2100 the cost of
meeting a two-degree target every year
is going to be of the order of two point
nine to eleven point four percent of GDP
so there you have it thank you wait a
minute this is just this is nonsense
right I mean alarm bells should begin to
ring when you see the Comedie decimal
place you know we struggle to predict
GDP to three years ahead let alone 80
plus years ahead yeah this is a period
of a which the world economy will have
expanded by between 300 and 900 percent
so already
something’s not right but this just
doesn’t pass the sniff test let’s think
about what we’re saying here right this
is a scenario where from tomorrow we all
aim to meet the two-degree target we put
the best minds in the world all most
creative innovators are best
entrepreneurs we spend billions maybe
trillions of dollars and investments in
these renewables and we have a perfect
policy framework with a single global
carbon price and yet it’s still expect
more expensive in every single scenario
to employ people in far-flung parts of
the world to dig this stuff up to put
these fossil fuels on ships in pipes on
trains transport them halfway around the
world earn them in 19th century
technology and in most cases lose much
if not most of that energy on the grid
and that apparently is going to be
cheaper than actually extracting this
stuff for free from the wind from the
Sun and from the oceans it just doesn’t
pass the sniff test ok there’ll be
difficult bits for sure in buildings in
industry and land use and forestry it’s
going to be very difficult to squeeze
carbon out of those sectors but
transport and energy it really isn’t
that much of a challenge economists get
this wrong all the time they fail to
understand the rate of deployment that
we see in these renewable technologies
this is a chart from the International
Energy Agency one of the most respected
organizations in this field the red line
shows the actual rate of deployment and
electrical capacity the other lines show
you the forecasts at the ia put out they
no just get it wrong in one year or two
years or three years they get it wrong
year after year after year after year I
mean yeah you all know Einstein’s
definition of madness right it’s
repeating the same thing and expecting
different results well that’s what
they’re doing unfortunately this is a
disaster because one of the key elements
of technological revolutions is what is
called learning by doing when you learn
through deployment you learn to make
your innovations better you experiment
with them you learn through good
practice you engineer them better and so
on and the costs come down and the
productivity and efficiency of the
product goes up the ia understand
learning by doing but like most
economists they’ve really misunderstood
the amount of doing and this is a
disaster because you miss out this this
charts a little busy but what it shows
are two of the leading renewable
technologies solar photovoltaic on the
left and wind power on the right the
cost of solar photovoltaic have come
down by a factor of five in as many
years now wind is a more mature
technology but the cost of wind power
have also haft over the same period both
are now what’s called close to grid
parity that is they are fully
competitive with oil the coal and with
gas okay the wind doesn’t always blow
the Sun doesn’t always shine so we need
some kind of storage to bridge the
intermittency well the good news is that
solar that lithium-ion battery costs
have also fallen by about 40 percent
over the same period with very
encouraging and exciting new innovations
in battery storage on the way it’s not
just energy most big auto manufacturers
have now stopped spending money on
research and development in the
combustion engine they’ve got narrow
research budgets it’s almost all going
into electric vehicles the combustion
engine is over the era of the combustion
engine car has finished this is a
revolution it is a transformation why do
economists get it so wrong why don’t
they understand how quickly we are
deploying these things well the answers
reasonably simple they miss out the key
linkages between investment innovation
behaviors and cultures these feedback
mechanisms that means that when a
revolution happens it can happen a lot
faster than you otherwise predicted and
as a result they overestimate the costs
of the Revolution and they underestimate
its scale let me give you an example
many of you will have been to Copenhagen
or to Amsterdam and you go there and you
ask you know you see that everybody
cycles and you ask people why do all
cycle and they will usually tell you
something along the lines of well we
have fantastic cycling infrastructure
and you look around and true enough they
do and then you might follow up and ask
well how comes you have such great
cycling infrastructure this point they
start to look at you as if you’re a bit
thick and they say well everybody here
cycles well all right it doesn’t really
matter which came first the chicken or
the egg you can tell a similar story
with renewable vehicles if you want to
buy a renewable vehicle you want to know
that there’s electric charging points
and not petrol stations but if you want
somebody to build electric charging
points and not petrol stations you need
to know that there’s enough people
driving electric vehicles you’ve got
these network effects you need to tap
into but expectations are what drives
this change in both cases expectations
really matter economists tend to miss
this out social psychologists on the
other hand have known for years that if
you want to solve complex coordination
problems like climate change you need to
manage and understand expectations likes
and dislikes are not fixed
they are influenceable social norms
they’re not fixed they’re influenceable
technologies they’re not fixed they’re
influenceable and they all feed off each
other in this fantastic spiral this has
been a problem for some times for
economists and it’s something that we
really need to understand imagine for
example that you’re a mayor or aura or
or a politician or a business leader and
you’re thinking of investing heavily or
pushing for policies to invest heavily
in renewables and energy efficiency and
you think everybody else is going to do
this if you if sorry and you actually
think nobody else is gonna do this right
so you expect the technology cost to
stay high you expect the financing to be
niche and you don’t see any huge market
now say all things remain the same but
actually you now expect everybody else
is going to move into this very rapidly
it’s the best thing since sliced bread
every one of their dog wants a piece of
it suddenly you expect the technologies
cost to come down very quickly the
financing will become mainstream and you
see these fantastic new market
opportunities so you invest and so does
everybody else and the very process of
investing generates the deployment that
brings the cost down that makes it more
attractive you start this virtuous site
spiral you reach this tipping point and
that’s and note that nothing has changed
to accept people’s expectations in both
scenarios it’s psychology it’s in the
head and this is what economists tend to
miss out and that’s exactly what we’ve
seen happening on the world political
stage over the last ten years some of
you will remember ten years ago the
Copenhagen conference on climate change
which raised hopes and aspirations of an
ambitious deal but it failed why did it
fail because at the time the language
was about cost it was about burden
sharing it was about sacrifice it was
about everyone pulling their weight to
save the planet
of course what you’ve got was distrust
everyone wanted to free ride on the
actions of others people waited for
other people to move and you got a rates
to the bottom and no deal or at least
not an ambitious deal emerged why in the
clock forward eight years to Paris and
we have that ambitious deal and what’s
more it’s voluntary and that deal is
based on an understanding that there are
opportunities and let me explain why
that is what for a start we’ve seen the
technology costs come down and that
changes the equation commercially quite
substantially we’ve also begun to
understand that there are substantial
gains from energy efficiency by
definition that saves you money but
there are other benefits as well
pollution the World Health Organization
and the World Bank together estimate
that the cost of pollution through death
through ill health through hours lost
out of work in a country like China
amounts to something like 12% of annual
GDP twelve percent I mean that is
literally metaphorically eye-watering
excuse the pun in the European Union
it’s of the order of five to seven
percent these are not trivial numbers if
we dedicated that amount of resources
every year to solving climate change
we’d probably have this licked in a
matter of decades but it doesn’t stop
there once the private sector and
businesses got a whiff of
the opportunities associated with this
kind of change they also began to see
reason to act and reason to invest don’t
squint too hard at this what you need to
are the only thing you need to note here
is the figure of six million this is a
an advert that went out in the financial
times just prior to the Paris agreement
in 2015 and it says six million
companies around the world want an
ambitious climate deal at the conference
in Paris that December this is six
million companies seeing opportunity and
money and profit these are new lobbies
new voices to counter the existing
lobbies in fossil fuels they will have
influence on political systems that will
change policies that will change
investments and it’s no surprise well
trade in renewable sectors has outpaced
world trade in other sectors by double
since the financial crash sustainable
sectors have outperformed the market by
about ten percent over the same period
whereas those sectors that are deeply
entrenched in fossil fuels have lagged
the S&P 500 by in some cases a very
large margin this is a commercial
opportunity and it’s commercial
opportunities together with things like
pollution but it’s mostly the commercial
opportunities of fabricating
manufacturing exporting this kind of kit
in solar in wind and other sectors but
led the Chinese to agree a comprehensive
landmark deal with the Americans the
year prior to Paris and now you see what
we’re going to this right we’ve got
China moving with ambitious
decarbonization we’ve got the u.s.
cutting emissions and we’ve got Europe
cutting emissions that’s three-quarters
of the world the rest of the world just
has to pay attention because this is
going to happen this is where the new
markets are and it’s no surprise
therefore that a year later you had this
ambitious and comprehensive deal in
Paris to try and limit temperatures to
two degrees with an aspiration to keep
them below one and a half now I saw
quite a few of you or I sense quite a
few of you straining there were that
picture of a bomb and you’re kind of
thinking under your residence right look
at it now actually Donald Trump is
another example of why the momentum is
unstoppable ten years ago if the US had
failed show leadership on this the
Indians the Chinese and others would
have said well you know what you’re one
of the richest countries one of the
biggest emitters if you’re not
to be paying for this when we’re
certainly not gonna handicap our
economies to pay for this and the whole
process would have stopped we’ve not
seen that this time it’s been very
different
the US has talked about backpedaling
China India Europe and the rest of the
world I said well fine we’re gonna we’re
gonna move on regardless with our
voluntary agreements why because they no
longer see this is of course they see it
as an opportunity they see this as a
chance to steal a march on the American
competitors who are hamstringing
themselves by slowing down and creating
the new technologies and new goods and
services for the fastest-growing market
in the world all of this stuff all of
this expectations all of these feedbacks
these tipping points these understanding
that you can invest in physical assets
and that changes mindsets it changes
cultures it changes institutions is what
economists tend to miss out and so they
they overestimate the cost of this
revolution and like I said already they
tend to underestimate the scale now
don’t get me wrong
economic models have a very important
role to play they enforce a discipline
on the modeler to be very clear on their
assumptions they impose some degree of
internal consistency and they’re good
descriptions of the workings of the
economy and so they act as very good
sources of simulations for risks in an
as if world what if things develop like
this how might the world looked like but
they useless at forecasting because all
they tell you is the prior assumptions
of the forecaster who makes the
assumptions on the things you care about
like I said at the beginning there’s
plenty that economists can do to help in
this story we can look at the risks we
can try and help in assessing how much
money should be put into research and
development into deployment we can try
and format formulate the standards and
regulations we can help design our
cities to make them more efficient but
economists really need to learn the
lesson but if they’re to stay relevant
to this most important story they have
to spend a lot less time trying to
predict the future and a lot more time
helping design it thank you
you
Please follow and like us: