Press "Enter" to skip to content

Combating Fake News | Anthony Cormier | TEDxFSU


hi how are you I’m Anthony
I am i work for BuzzFeed news in New
York City I do not make listicles or cat
videos but we uh we appreciate that you
come and view them because I pays my
bills I want to start very broadly right
we’re here to talk about fake news but
we’re not gonna talk about a couple of
things today you could find me in the
hallway after we can talk we’re not
gonna talk about Donald Trump we’re not
gonna talk about Russia we’re not gonna
about that dang BuzzFeed dossier
what we are going to talk about is the
fact that I am in the fight of my life I
have been a journalist for 15 years and
what I and my colleagues are facing at
the moment is a new phenomenon that I
hope you will help us win because the
guy you see up here right now is real
news I’ve dedicated my life to this I
care about it I’ve gone to bed with a
pit in my stomach every day for the last
15 years worried that I got everything
right and what you’re seeing is news
that’s not right news that’s
particularly meant to dis inform it’s
being used as a weapon to change their
minds I don’t care if you’re a liberal I
don’t care if you’re conservative okay
if you’re down the middle what I do care
about is our democracy I care about an
informed Republic so let’s sort of take
a step back and understand what real
news is and what fake things is big news
used to exist in the supermarket
checkout line you’d see a a tabloid
where Hillary Clinton gave birth to an
alien baby or Elvis Presley was spotted
at a coffee shop in Peoria Illinois
it’s invest of my knowledge neither of
those things are true what you’re seeing
now our websites blaring that Melania
Trump is a high-end escort or that
Hillary Clinton ran a pedophile ring at
a Washington DC pizza parlor neither of
those things are true the difference is
is that the news is now packaged to look
like mine these packaged to look like
real news and secondly it’s being used
as a weapon to dis inform you it’s being
used as a way to get you to move to one
side or the other liberals I know that
you’re out here and you’re probably
thinking that all it is is just a
conservative matter ah y’all are just as
guilty to Breitbart is just as bad as
we’re all story
Milo is just as
as occupied ends so I’m sorry to inform
you that but but it is so I want to sort
of walk through why it perhaps has
become so so prevalent I know there are
two things that have happened in past 10
to 20 years
number one Americans have stopped
trusting their institutions perhaps
rightfully so we no longer trust our
government we no longer trust our
churches our houses of worship our media
that’s our fault someone that’s the
government’s fault so that’s the
church’s fault
but when we did that when we stopped
having trust in objective verifiable
truths we opened the floodgates for the
for the manipulators we’ve all sort of
gone to our corners right we’re over
here and all we want to do is watch Fox
News and we’re over here and all we care
about is Rachel Maddow and so we have
this whole suite of media outlets that
are catering to your interests there are
only sort of pushing you toward
therefore their objective goal they’re
their ends and in the meantime while
this was happening while there’s this
great partisan divide between the buffed
and the right Americans also stopped
paying for their news that that
according to the Nieman lab there are
half as many American reporters at daily
newspapers as there were in 1990 I have
sat in newsrooms and very sombrely
watched as one person after another has
been walked into the HR building and
come out with tears in their eyes first
goes the ovet writer second ghost city
hall then goes to the cops reporter and
then goes a guy in sports and then goes
to the copy desk and then the newsroom
is bereft of anyone there so those are
left are doing more than ever so I can’t
do enterprise stories anymore I can’t do
deep dive investigations anymore this
becomes a problem right and in that void
again comes Breitbart and Raw Story and
Milo and so we understand sort of maybe
what it is once then perhaps why it’s so
prevalent and now maybe we can talk a
little bit about why it’s so dangerous
it should be obvious but perhaps it’s
not an informed Republic is a strong
Republic facts matter I am here on the
campus of Florida State University where
it is your goal
to do research to find new truths to do
peer-reviewed studies you guys are here
to do truth we’re in the same boat I’m
do the same thing as Y all right so what
happens is and it’s not a recent
phenomena but we’re dis informed we
don’t know what we’re voting for we
don’t know who we’re voting for we don’t
know how to stop this we don’t know what
to believe it I don’t blame you I
actually in fact I blame oats
I blame me it’s my fault actually some
of my faults my publisher fault but
that’s another different story so you
you’ve gone and made decisions and you
don’t have a full sort of bouquet of
facts behind you right and so I want to
hopefully leave you with that idea of
how to combat this and we’ll start very
simply by saying you should all take out
your Facebook your phones right now and
check out your Facebook Likes and you
should start scrubbing things you should
get them out of your life you should
take a look at what you like because
that’s what the algorithms are putting
in front of your face right if you like
Milo or if you like I’m picking on
occupied and I’m picking on them but
there are very many of them if you like
that Facebook is learning to feed you
more of that right if you like
hamburgers hamburgers all the time if
you like cheese fries you’re gonna get
cheese buddies all the time you like
fake news about pedophile rings at comet
pizza in Washington DC which is by the
way completely not true you’re going to
get more of that so that’s the very
first step that you can take you can
sort of understand what’s entering your
world then learn how to exercise it I
hope that you’ll all sort of leave here
and go and do that the second thing you
can do and this is same las’
self-promotion is you can start paying
for your news again that would be an
awesome thing to do because news isn’t
free I have a daughter here in the room
actually and she’s in college and
college in case you guys have more it’s
not free nobody got to send them there
and I get this is a little bit shameless
but I want to sort of impart on you one
thing that real journalists are your
neighbors we coach your little eight
games we bring home scanners we we stay
bleh we miss parent-teacher conferences
because we’re at a fire or to see Hawley
I just hope that you’ll leave here
understand it as much as you may hate
the liberal media or you may hate the
conservative media you may hate the
what’s the word for it the lamestream
media the cannot lane but that’s neither
here nor there we’re real human beings
digging for truth
day after day and no matter what you
think of us for you no matter what you
do you voted for
we’re folks who care about this we
dedicated our entire lives to it I
started on the loading docks of the
Panama City News Herald that was my
first job after I left Florida State not
a sprawling the megalopolis it’s a small
town in a small paper but I learned how
to do this I learned what mattered and I
want to say to you the difference
fundamentally between what you’re seeing
on some of these fake sites and what we
do is that mistakes happen I make
mistakes all the time
I once this is a terrible story I’m
gonna admit it but whatever I killed the
guy in print he was a trapeze artist he
had fallen
tragically off of the trapeze I was in
Sarasota Florida as a huge circus town
was a big news event well I call the
hospital do my due diligence the dudes
not dead his sister told me he’s dead
the doctor said he was dead what they
failed to tell me was that oh he was
just actually on life support so I
reported in the paper the next day that
this guy had died his family when they
read it on the front page wasn’t very
happy mmm
eventually you’ll die I did what I told
my editor anyway even if it’s 40 years
from now didn’t really go over well but
here’s the fundamental difference right
here’s what Breitbart doesn’t do here’s
what occupy Dems doesn’t do they don’t
run a correction they don’t only I did
so my editors my newspaper they care
about getting it right our
accountability is our tradecraft if you
don’t believe me what have I got left
right so one final thing that will
differentiate for you guys how to
identify good news not could you excuse
me frankly fake news and really you
take some steps beyond paying for your
news and beyond figuring out how
Facebook is responding this and we
should say that Facebook and Google have
taken active measures and they should be
applauded for sort of ferreting some of
this stuff out right they’ve not fully
gone all the way but they do deserve
praise for what they’ve done so far
there’s some things you can do when you
read a news story you can look at it and
tell me if it has a byline
right can you identify the author
because if you can that’s a usually
pretty good sign that somebody cares
enough to put their name on it does the
site have editors does the employ fact
checkers are the quotes actually
directly taken from an individual did I
talk to you and get your name and quote
you if I did you can be a pretty good
bet that like I’m a decent journalist
that I know I’m doing unless they took
it from somewhere else right if they
took another quote and they repackaged
it and put it in different context what
do you do with that right how do you
know that came words from another step
you can do is you can sort of trust your
gut if it seems fake it probably is like
Elvis is probably dead hate to break it
to you Hillary Clinton did not as far as
I know have an alien baby Melania Trump
is not a high-end escort I mean these
are these are things that you should be
able to look at and understand whether
or not they’re true and then finally I
have a very interesting way for you guys
to try to tell the difference so these
are two websites
what’s one you raise your hand if you
think the one crime in Italy I gave you
the answer clearly the Seattle Tribune
is the fake one and the Seattle Times is
the real one but they are very difficult
down to the gutters the white space on
the sides of the page to the clear
Seattle at the top right different for
you to know so you open up your facebook
you’re super busy you’re doing your
homework you take care your kids you’re
running to plays how are you supposed to
know really quickly which one is real
and which one is not so it’s difficult
the Seattle Tribune actually is fake and
their ass and find prints on the page it
suggests that it is a entertainment site
in the Seattle Times is one of the
finest American newspapers and all land
it’s winner of multiple Pulitzer Prizes
and does amazing incredible reporting
and like so many other newspapers
Bendu round after round with a budget
cuts means people like me we’re out of
jobs though I’m so grateful for this
chance because like I said earlier this
is the fight of my life I don’t know if
we’re gonna win I could tell you i’ma
fight like hell for it I’m hoping that
you will help I don’t care if you agree
with me I don’t care if you are
politically aligned with me or with your
neighbor just leave here understanding
that there are a group of journalists in
America that are digging for objective
truths they care about this they go to
sleep like I said every night with a pit
in their stomach hoping to god that we
called every source that we were checked
every fact that I spelled every name
right because there’s nothing wrong
nothing worse rather than misspelling
the name of a high school volleyball
player I’m telling you you will get a
phone call from grandma the next day
saying you you misspelled Katy Katy wise
to the Katy Katy ie which is horrible
because Brenda wants to cut that thing
out put it right but that’s what we do
and I have misspelled Katy innumerable
times I haven’t I’ve gotten my facts
wrong I’ve gotten things completely
botched up and screwed around and turned
upside down but I’m here because I
actually care about and I try really
hard and so do my colleagues no matter
what you do I just hope that you will
help us fight back appreciate your time
thank you so much
you
Please follow and like us: