
today I’m gonna talk about clean spaces
and three miles so when I travel 20 city
any town or a village always looking out
for signs of development we all are
probably and we see new roads buildings
residential buildings commercial
buildings coming out all the veteran but
within these spaces we find I’ve seen
heaps of garbage lying around you’ve
seen it all and young men and women boys
and girls are sifting through the
garbage sorting them with their bare
hands and they’ve done a great job in
cities of collecting garbage but
transporting them sorting them and
storing them is another story so there
is this landfill in Delhi or gossip or
it’s just 30 minutes away from an city
center and it’s a mountain which is 50
feet tall and it came in the news
recently because last year it wasn’t
five four three days and three times
it was spewing fume and noxious gases
into the already you take two
environment of Delhi and as if that was
not enough a part of it – came down
tumbling like a landslide or a trash
slide in this case and swept away –
motorcyclist in the car into the canal
and a person died this is one of the
four dumping sites for Delhi and three
of them aren’t fell between 40 to 48
meters the put them in on itself and the
restriction on the height is 15 to 20
meters so one of the dumps of only
manages to achieve this once this
reaches the dumping ground it’s again
sorted by boys girls then women and you
can see they have no protection their
hands bare feet no gloves no you know
boots mas etcetera and they are exposed
to some of the worst kinds of face that
a city can’t reduce are the other thing
is below our city millions of liters of
sewage is passing through
hundreds of thousands of meters of swish
pipelines every day
emptying into rivers bonds etc and if
you’re lucky in a sewage treatment plant
ah but it gets stuck because of kind of
stuff that goes into the sewage lines
and someone has to clean it so what does
the municipal cooperation do it hires
manual scavengers to get into the sewer
lines and they just win a loin cloth or
something they have no equipment and
they have to fish out the stuff which is
clogging the lines by hand and this is
one of the most obnoxious materials a
human being can come in contact with and
it is extremely dangerous it produces
gases like methane sulfur dioxide
nitrous oxide carbon monoxide and people
dies to give you an example just in
Mumbai between 2010 and 1600 and 1000
say it is six people died and the
highest number was in 2010 322 and in
2014 alone 93 people like this is just
Mumbai imagine the remaining 5 metros be
level cities C level cities way down in
all the places your sewer lines so this
number easily would cross thousands of
people per year and it seems we are ok
with it is launching the Chandra Anna’s
– you know map the moon and launching
hundred and four satellites in one go
but V have not come up with simple
solutions to cleaning our sewer systems
and why is that
it’s something going on now – in another
problem open defecation which is endemic
and thinking holy magic a shortcut inner
has a problem and let me give you a
context to it in 2015 of all the people
who were defecating in the world in the
open 60% came from India so it was one
of our biggest contributions and that
here again 54% of the noodle households
did not have it all so they could
explain why they were defecating in the
open however the remaining 46% you would
assume were using the toilet right part
if a surveys to be believed the sub is
called squattin sanitation quality
utilization trend found that of all the
people who own a toilet at least 40% of
those households one person in the
household was still desiccating at you
know but it’s not more or at all so
having it all it doesn’t mean you do not
defecate new countries like Bangladesh
Nepal in sub-saharan African countries
Latin America the poorer than us they
have less education than us but they
have much lower levels of open education
so why is this puzzle now
I’m gonna skip this I will completely go
to something else I’m going to talk
about practice of untouchability so what
is that notability so untouchability is
when upper caste Hindus behave in a
particular manner with lower gas
chambers so what is the practice they
would even then they won’t time with
them they would marry them they are not
supposed to enter temples draw water
from certain font font wells hand palms
etc walk certain roads in the village so
that is the practice oh but this was
banned by the Constitution 1955 under
the Andean hand so we’re curious this is
still this practice still continue so we
try to find out
so in 2011-12 survey happened from the
India human development survey and in
that survey the respondent households
were asked two questions the first
question was does any member in your
family practice untouchability yes or no
if they say yes we recorded that if they
said no then a follow-up question with
answers was ask sorry which was that
would it be okay is someone who’s an
untouchable or from
Scheduled Caste would enter your picture
no use your attention again seeking a
yes or no response combining the
responses from these two questions we
found that 30 percent in rural 20
percent in urban and on an average 27
person
all of the country accepted to the
practice of Vantage now you must
remember this is a very sensitive
question is the controversial question
when you put in two people and a face to
face interviews they are more likely to
say no or give a politically correct
answer so these are under estimates this
must be much more than what we have
captured here is the kind of a map which
shows the prevalence of the practice the
dark red areas this is the district
level map the dark red areas show where
more than 50% of household practice
untouchability and as the color
gradation goes down it goes from 40 30
etc so you can see the practices largely
in the northern part of him you know and
there were questions in the parliament
based on this but obviously nothing now
we started thinking that the idea of
cleanliness I am pure I keep myself
clean my house clean but I’m giving some
level of dirt and pollution outside it’s
also similar to the idea of
untouchability I am pure you’re in
impure I’m not going to touch you let
you near me so where are these two
things coming from what is what is the
process going are they linked so the
data said I just mentioned which asks
every household whether the impact is
untouchability or not they also ask them
whether you defecate in the open or not
so that each hours old we had both the
data says so we tried to do some
analysis and what we found
perhaps – so before I go further there
was another puzzle which we could not
understand this was that it stays like a
giraffe in Tamil Nadu which are rich
States the level of open defecation is
very similar into that in states like
Bihar and UV which are not so rich
therefore States however states like in
the Northeast which are poor have very
low levels of open defecation so why was
this was another person
so we did we did some analysis we did
some study and what we found was that
first as peoples income Rises the level
of open defecation goes down however if
you have two groups of households one
group of and they have same level of
income to group house own having same
level of income but one group practices
untouchability another doesn’t practices
content ability we found the group that
practices untouchability also practices
more open defecation similarly as the
level of education in the households
goes up the practice of open defecation
goes down however if you had two groups
of households with same level of
education but one group practicing
untouchable you
untouchability and one not we found the
group practicing untouchability falls so
practiced more open defecation at
village level in a village you have
households maybe none of the households
practice untouchability all of them
practice and agility so the share of
household goes from zero to hundred no
one practices accessibility in every
contract we found that as the share of
households in villages increases that
means the number of households in the
village practice untouchability increase
households practicing open defecation
also interests and finally what we found
was that the practice of OD open
defecation varied across states of india
fifty percent of this variation was
squarely only explained by variation in
the practice of untouchability across
the states
thereafter another 20 percent would
explain by variation the level of
education and after that no matter what
variable we use income of household
poverty levels their access to new raiga
the men’s work participation rate
anything nothing explained so basically
we found really really strong
correlation association between
untouchability and open defecation
so where is this coming from what is the
link why is untouchability practice also
explaining open defecation and what we
found is when the survey was done the
squat surveys people are asked this
question why don’t you have a toilet in
the house they said we have a temple in
the house it’s a it’s a it’s a it’s a
pure spiritually in ritually impure
place how can we have it toilet which is
defiling and polluting in this ritually
polluting in the same household or in
the courtyard so it’s best to go as far
away from the house over to defecate in
a compact that was one another problem
was that the the whu-oh prescribed
toilets which are used all over the
world by people whether you do not have
flush toilets or sewer lines is a double
pin toilet and when one pit is filling
up to the other is empty and when one
fills up the other is open and the the
fecal sludge becomes many or and
everyone who uses this toilet all over
the world removes this as compost and
uses in gardens and fields but in India
this kind of work is not done by casting
news because this is done by a
particular caste of people The
Untouchables of the toilets
now these people are not willing to do
this job anymore they’re leaving the
villages so who will remove this and the
other misconception is that these are
very small these pits and they’ll fill
up very fast whereas they last 4 5 6 7
years people have believed that the last
for one or two years so they they are
afraid that they’ll have to tame them
again and again ah this is a government
official who’s trying to show into the
villager that see this is not a taboo
it’s a completely dry manure and it’s
harmless trying to educate people the
other thing we realized was that open
defecation is associated with
masculinity
if you’re a man if you’re a real man you
can get up in the morning you can go to
feel your limbs were you take your dump
and you come back
and who uses the toilet the children the
old people the dribble so if you are a
variety of man you will defecate of you
so all these things are also playing
there Barton I’ll stop by giving a small
example a story of a student friend who
went to America to study at UCLA and he
wanted to hear an idea that India is
producing millions of tons of manure and
fecal sludge is free penny off for
farming if farmers use it it’s cheaper
and farming becomes viable by that much
amount but when he came back to Kannada
got into his field study he found
farmers won’t touch it they said this is
human fecal matter man will get polluted
by it also if he put it in our crops it
will get into the food and then we’ll
get it was whereas they were perfectly
okay with using counter as menu so so
there’s no a notion of you know biology
or science there it’s just beef so what
about what is my point basically my
point here is that when people defecate
in the open they do not use many of
human manure or they do not worry about
the garbage or practice untouchability
these are based on their belief systems
these are not based on a scientific
notion or a germ theory of disease these
are our ideas and thinking and unless we
change these ideas I think you’re going
to remain backward for a very long time
so it’s I think high time we change
these ideas
take deep introspect and then move
forward thank you [Applause]
and three miles so when I travel 20 city
any town or a village always looking out
for signs of development we all are
probably and we see new roads buildings
residential buildings commercial
buildings coming out all the veteran but
within these spaces we find I’ve seen
heaps of garbage lying around you’ve
seen it all and young men and women boys
and girls are sifting through the
garbage sorting them with their bare
hands and they’ve done a great job in
cities of collecting garbage but
transporting them sorting them and
storing them is another story so there
is this landfill in Delhi or gossip or
it’s just 30 minutes away from an city
center and it’s a mountain which is 50
feet tall and it came in the news
recently because last year it wasn’t
five four three days and three times
it was spewing fume and noxious gases
into the already you take two
environment of Delhi and as if that was
not enough a part of it – came down
tumbling like a landslide or a trash
slide in this case and swept away –
motorcyclist in the car into the canal
and a person died this is one of the
four dumping sites for Delhi and three
of them aren’t fell between 40 to 48
meters the put them in on itself and the
restriction on the height is 15 to 20
meters so one of the dumps of only
manages to achieve this once this
reaches the dumping ground it’s again
sorted by boys girls then women and you
can see they have no protection their
hands bare feet no gloves no you know
boots mas etcetera and they are exposed
to some of the worst kinds of face that
a city can’t reduce are the other thing
is below our city millions of liters of
sewage is passing through
hundreds of thousands of meters of swish
pipelines every day
emptying into rivers bonds etc and if
you’re lucky in a sewage treatment plant
ah but it gets stuck because of kind of
stuff that goes into the sewage lines
and someone has to clean it so what does
the municipal cooperation do it hires
manual scavengers to get into the sewer
lines and they just win a loin cloth or
something they have no equipment and
they have to fish out the stuff which is
clogging the lines by hand and this is
one of the most obnoxious materials a
human being can come in contact with and
it is extremely dangerous it produces
gases like methane sulfur dioxide
nitrous oxide carbon monoxide and people
dies to give you an example just in
Mumbai between 2010 and 1600 and 1000
say it is six people died and the
highest number was in 2010 322 and in
2014 alone 93 people like this is just
Mumbai imagine the remaining 5 metros be
level cities C level cities way down in
all the places your sewer lines so this
number easily would cross thousands of
people per year and it seems we are ok
with it is launching the Chandra Anna’s
– you know map the moon and launching
hundred and four satellites in one go
but V have not come up with simple
solutions to cleaning our sewer systems
and why is that
it’s something going on now – in another
problem open defecation which is endemic
and thinking holy magic a shortcut inner
has a problem and let me give you a
context to it in 2015 of all the people
who were defecating in the world in the
open 60% came from India so it was one
of our biggest contributions and that
here again 54% of the noodle households
did not have it all so they could
explain why they were defecating in the
open however the remaining 46% you would
assume were using the toilet right part
if a surveys to be believed the sub is
called squattin sanitation quality
utilization trend found that of all the
people who own a toilet at least 40% of
those households one person in the
household was still desiccating at you
know but it’s not more or at all so
having it all it doesn’t mean you do not
defecate new countries like Bangladesh
Nepal in sub-saharan African countries
Latin America the poorer than us they
have less education than us but they
have much lower levels of open education
so why is this puzzle now
I’m gonna skip this I will completely go
to something else I’m going to talk
about practice of untouchability so what
is that notability so untouchability is
when upper caste Hindus behave in a
particular manner with lower gas
chambers so what is the practice they
would even then they won’t time with
them they would marry them they are not
supposed to enter temples draw water
from certain font font wells hand palms
etc walk certain roads in the village so
that is the practice oh but this was
banned by the Constitution 1955 under
the Andean hand so we’re curious this is
still this practice still continue so we
try to find out
so in 2011-12 survey happened from the
India human development survey and in
that survey the respondent households
were asked two questions the first
question was does any member in your
family practice untouchability yes or no
if they say yes we recorded that if they
said no then a follow-up question with
answers was ask sorry which was that
would it be okay is someone who’s an
untouchable or from
Scheduled Caste would enter your picture
no use your attention again seeking a
yes or no response combining the
responses from these two questions we
found that 30 percent in rural 20
percent in urban and on an average 27
person
all of the country accepted to the
practice of Vantage now you must
remember this is a very sensitive
question is the controversial question
when you put in two people and a face to
face interviews they are more likely to
say no or give a politically correct
answer so these are under estimates this
must be much more than what we have
captured here is the kind of a map which
shows the prevalence of the practice the
dark red areas this is the district
level map the dark red areas show where
more than 50% of household practice
untouchability and as the color
gradation goes down it goes from 40 30
etc so you can see the practices largely
in the northern part of him you know and
there were questions in the parliament
based on this but obviously nothing now
we started thinking that the idea of
cleanliness I am pure I keep myself
clean my house clean but I’m giving some
level of dirt and pollution outside it’s
also similar to the idea of
untouchability I am pure you’re in
impure I’m not going to touch you let
you near me so where are these two
things coming from what is what is the
process going are they linked so the
data said I just mentioned which asks
every household whether the impact is
untouchability or not they also ask them
whether you defecate in the open or not
so that each hours old we had both the
data says so we tried to do some
analysis and what we found
perhaps – so before I go further there
was another puzzle which we could not
understand this was that it stays like a
giraffe in Tamil Nadu which are rich
States the level of open defecation is
very similar into that in states like
Bihar and UV which are not so rich
therefore States however states like in
the Northeast which are poor have very
low levels of open defecation so why was
this was another person
so we did we did some analysis we did
some study and what we found was that
first as peoples income Rises the level
of open defecation goes down however if
you have two groups of households one
group of and they have same level of
income to group house own having same
level of income but one group practices
untouchability another doesn’t practices
content ability we found the group that
practices untouchability also practices
more open defecation similarly as the
level of education in the households
goes up the practice of open defecation
goes down however if you had two groups
of households with same level of
education but one group practicing
untouchable you
untouchability and one not we found the
group practicing untouchability falls so
practiced more open defecation at
village level in a village you have
households maybe none of the households
practice untouchability all of them
practice and agility so the share of
household goes from zero to hundred no
one practices accessibility in every
contract we found that as the share of
households in villages increases that
means the number of households in the
village practice untouchability increase
households practicing open defecation
also interests and finally what we found
was that the practice of OD open
defecation varied across states of india
fifty percent of this variation was
squarely only explained by variation in
the practice of untouchability across
the states
thereafter another 20 percent would
explain by variation the level of
education and after that no matter what
variable we use income of household
poverty levels their access to new raiga
the men’s work participation rate
anything nothing explained so basically
we found really really strong
correlation association between
untouchability and open defecation
so where is this coming from what is the
link why is untouchability practice also
explaining open defecation and what we
found is when the survey was done the
squat surveys people are asked this
question why don’t you have a toilet in
the house they said we have a temple in
the house it’s a it’s a it’s a it’s a
pure spiritually in ritually impure
place how can we have it toilet which is
defiling and polluting in this ritually
polluting in the same household or in
the courtyard so it’s best to go as far
away from the house over to defecate in
a compact that was one another problem
was that the the whu-oh prescribed
toilets which are used all over the
world by people whether you do not have
flush toilets or sewer lines is a double
pin toilet and when one pit is filling
up to the other is empty and when one
fills up the other is open and the the
fecal sludge becomes many or and
everyone who uses this toilet all over
the world removes this as compost and
uses in gardens and fields but in India
this kind of work is not done by casting
news because this is done by a
particular caste of people The
Untouchables of the toilets
now these people are not willing to do
this job anymore they’re leaving the
villages so who will remove this and the
other misconception is that these are
very small these pits and they’ll fill
up very fast whereas they last 4 5 6 7
years people have believed that the last
for one or two years so they they are
afraid that they’ll have to tame them
again and again ah this is a government
official who’s trying to show into the
villager that see this is not a taboo
it’s a completely dry manure and it’s
harmless trying to educate people the
other thing we realized was that open
defecation is associated with
masculinity
if you’re a man if you’re a real man you
can get up in the morning you can go to
feel your limbs were you take your dump
and you come back
and who uses the toilet the children the
old people the dribble so if you are a
variety of man you will defecate of you
so all these things are also playing
there Barton I’ll stop by giving a small
example a story of a student friend who
went to America to study at UCLA and he
wanted to hear an idea that India is
producing millions of tons of manure and
fecal sludge is free penny off for
farming if farmers use it it’s cheaper
and farming becomes viable by that much
amount but when he came back to Kannada
got into his field study he found
farmers won’t touch it they said this is
human fecal matter man will get polluted
by it also if he put it in our crops it
will get into the food and then we’ll
get it was whereas they were perfectly
okay with using counter as menu so so
there’s no a notion of you know biology
or science there it’s just beef so what
about what is my point basically my
point here is that when people defecate
in the open they do not use many of
human manure or they do not worry about
the garbage or practice untouchability
these are based on their belief systems
these are not based on a scientific
notion or a germ theory of disease these
are our ideas and thinking and unless we
change these ideas I think you’re going
to remain backward for a very long time
so it’s I think high time we change
these ideas
take deep introspect and then move
forward thank you [Applause]
Please follow and like us: