Press "Enter" to skip to content

Changing the Game in Musical Theatre | Joe Deer | TEDxDayton


[Music]

there was an earthquake in Manhattan

about a year ago did you hear about it

they called it Hamilton and overnight

everything changed the author lin-manuel

Miranda was hailed as a genius and even

people who don’t like musicals were

spending a month’s rent to try to get a

ticket why

what makes Hamilton the next big thing

in the musical theater for those of you

who haven’t seen it

Hamilton is the story of our founding

fathers told with a hip hop score and a

cast of mostly non-white young actors

sounds logical right I think a lot about

the musical theatre so when something

comes along that changes the game like

Hamilton I want to know why so let’s put

it in perspective most musicals even the

most successful musicals you’ve seen

typically follow one of those

well-established forms

think of shows like lemierre’s ER habla

or wicked or even rent each of those

follows the well-established pattern but

at an incredibly high level however

there’s the difference between

commercial success and changing the game

that only happens about once a

generation and that was the case with

Hamilton these game-changing musicals

seem revolutionary but I’ve got news for

you revolution in art is almost always

evolution

so those startling features that were so

attracted to in these shows have usually

been around in one form or another

before they just never been used this

way or this well in my line of work we

talk a lot about revolutionary musicals

and you might be surprised that many of

those shows we now think of as the most

traditional were actually as fresh for

their audiences as Hamilton is for us

today

think about Oklahoma that great

granddaddy of all the traditional

musicals it rocked its audience to the

core when it brought concert dance on to

the musical stage and it rejected the

old leggy showgirls Ziegfeld spectacle

to tell the humble story of a Ranch Hand

who wanted to marry the farmers niece

and start a family of their own in a

brand new state or showboat which took

the dramatic conventions of opera and

wolf together no less than five popular

music forms to tell the story of racism

in America between the end of the Civil

War in 1927 when that show was first

produced or hair which finally got rock

music and youth culture onto the

Broadway stage each of those shows took

some element of popular or high culture

and brought it into the musical theater

but you know something none of them was

the first to try to do so in fact even

Hamilton isn’t the first show to bring

rap and hip-hop on to the Broadway stage

anybody ever remember holler if you hear

me or on your toes or always you each of

those shows tried these innovations

first but with game-changing in the

musical theater it’s about how you do it

and how well you do it writing a musical

a successful musical of any kind is very

difficult because the musical theater

has a huge amount of expectations and

obligations that it brings with it think

of Phantom of the Opera one of the most

successful musicals of the last 50 years

phantom tells the compelling story of

familiar characters with catchy music

and dance and spectacular design and it

does it in a way that isn’t so

intellectual or preachy that it chases

the audience away but it still gives us

that high-calorie emotional boost we

love with drama romance

and at least a touch of humor and it

does it with broad appeal across all

generations and cultures not just for

theater geeks like me so give it all

that it’s no wonder that most producers

and creators don’t want to try something

new if it ain’t broke don’t fix it right

but every once in a great while someone

does come along who truly advances the

forum and that was the case with

Hamilton so how do we know when we’re

seeing a game-changing musical

well first a game-changing musical has

to be contemporary

it must look sound move and feel like

today it doesn’t have to be set today

but it has to be of today second a

game-changing musical must reflect the

burning social issue of its time

Hamilton is about the assimilation of

marginalized immigrants into the

mainstream of society and their positive

impact on the destiny of that society

that’s our burning social moment hair is

about the way the counterculture of the

1960s rejected the old post-world War

two

order to bring a new set of values for

us to live by on the town is about the

vitality of America’s best and brightest

young men as they celebrate what might

be the last 24 hours of freedom they’ll

ever know before they head into the jaws

of death in Europe to defend freedom and

democracy in America every one of those

shows held up a mirror to its society

finally to be a game-changing musical a

show must create a form that matches the

subject and this is where Hamilton gets

it so right everyone involved in that

show from the writer

lin-manuel Miranda to the director and

choreographer the designers and

orchestrators all of them conspired to

create a

vital new form really an amalgamation of

existing forms that satisfies all those

expectations we have for commercial

success but still manages to move the

ball down the field in a way we feel

we’ve never seen before they took a

story we thought we knew and infused it

with the music and dance and visual

aesthetic of hip hop culture the true

heartbeat of America today they did it

in a way that every middle-aged

businessman every college kid and

everybody from virtually any ethnic or

cultural background could identify with

and be excited by and feel that they saw

themselves represented on that stage and

they did it really really well that’s

why Hamilton is such a game changer now

unless you’re a theater lover like me

you you might wonder why does any of

this matter well here’s why because the

musical theater is bigger than just

entertainment musicals are an idealized

view of the world they’re also an

aspirational vision of what we hope to

become so every one of those shows I

talked about captures its national

moment in that time capsule and tells us

about where we’re heading when we look

at Hamilton maybe it’s not so crazy that

we’re telling the story of America’s

past with a score that sounds like

America’s present in a cast that looks

like America’s future for now we can

relish everything that Hamilton does so

well we know that other people are going

to pick up that form and maybe even

refine it but at some point even

Hamilton and those shows that it spawns

will be the old thing and when they are

you can bet that some creative young

woman is going to fight her way up

through the crowd to tell her musical

story of America

next future and changed the game again

[Applause]

[Music] you

Please follow and like us: