Press "Enter" to skip to content

Changing Media | Helen Belcher | TEDxCorsham


[Music]
I was nearly 40 when I understood what
it meant for me to be trans I and others
in my family while I was growing up had
known or suspected at least for many
years but there’s a difference between
knowing and understanding rather like
the difference between GCSEs and
a-levels GCSEs test what you know while
a levels should test what you understand
to mangle an oft-quoted example
knowledge is knowing that tomato is a
fruit which is often used in salads
however if you understand what a tomato
is you won’t use it in a fruit salad and
I say that because it shows that even if
you know something or are something it
can quite take quite some length of time
before you understand it or at least
understand that it applies to you we
often need help to gain that
understanding the last 20 years seems to
have seen an explosion in the number of
trans people we see around us and
probably even more so in the last five
years
part of that is down to trans people’s
growing confidence a society and
government policies and law have become
more accepting of us but part is because
more people now have the information
that they need to understand that trans
might just might apply to them we’re
still talking about a very small
percentage of people the information
comes from a variety of sources some
from personal contact but most of it
falls under the umbrella term of media
of course 20 years ago we didn’t have
social
Facebook Twitter and so on there were
some rudimentary internet forums but
there wasn’t the math sharing of
information correct or otherwise that we
see now and it’s meant that up until
fairly recently we relied on traditional
media newspapers radio television to
help us understand the world up until
around 1970 press coverage of trans
people was factual straight-laced
reporting of the worst of the south this
very strange thing has happened a bit
dry but no real judgement readers were
left to draw their own conclusions
authorities coped often quietly and
without fuss and then two things
happened
despite expert legal and medical advice
socialite April Ashley had her marriage
to an heir to the Guinness fortune
annulled the judicial ruling was if
you’re born male you must always be
legally male after a tortuous court case
Ashley didn’t have the energy to appeal
and so legal precedent was set she ran
off to France and interestingly enough a
month later a French Court allowed a
trans woman to marry a man on the
grounds that she was obviously female
the ashley decision in the UK removed
access of trans people to administrative
procedures that we had used for many
years and so began a long process of
legal challenges usually by trans women
wanting to marry the man of their dreams
a couple of years later in 1972 jan
morris who had been the press reporter
on so Edmund Hillary’s
successful team who conquered Everest in
1953 Jan was intrusively grilled about
her transition on national television
the media narrative up until this point
factual had started to change the
occasional court victory and they were
initially very few indeed was reported
again largely factually however during
the 80s 90s trans people became subjects
of fascination starting with 1979 s
George to Julia are also called a change
of sexes a BBC series which followed a
trans woman from the very early stages
of explaining herself and her decision
to her family all the way through to the
operating theatre and ending with
channel fours Eurotrash where trans
people were positioned of one of her
panoply of weird exotic sexualized
people the media coverage transformed
into what I would call zoo television a
David Attenborough narration wouldn’t
have been out of place in large parts of
it felt a bit trapped behind glass the
better programs focused on the medical
and surgical narrative the stereotype of
the burly bricklayer going into surgery
and emerging as some kind of glamazon
was born the butterfly effect reality is
mostly far less prosaic and zoo
television continues to this day right
now this week ITV is broadcasting a
series called transformation Street the
repeated focus on surgeries as if those
are all that defines a trans person
causes increasing out region within
trans communities yet broadcasters still
do
it press coverage was also mutating it
was becoming more hostile and by the
time the Leveson inquiry was called in
2012 sufficient evidence had been
mustered that suggested press coverage
fell into three broad categories that
transpeople are fraudulent
but trans people are undeserving and
that trans people are deviant all of
these meant that trans people were
entitled to be ridiculed we were a
paradox despite there being so many of
us that we were unnecessarily hoovering
up vast amounts of scarce NHS resources
there were also so few of us then why
was the NHS bothering to treat us at all
now in 2012 channel 4 broadcast the
series called
my transsexual summer despite the awful
title this series was genuinely
different from anything that had gone
before as it followed trans people’s
lived stories and while the first of the
four programs did the surgery thing the
other three looked at the very real
difficulties trans people had in getting
jobs or housing and also how their close
families dealt with transition that
series and the shift in coverage that it
promised probably wouldn’t have been
like it was without the input of a group
called trans media watch rewinding few
years 2009 ITV broadcast an episode of a
comedy called moving wallpaper which
featured a trans character and it became
very quickly clear that this character
only existed to be the target of comedy
in the 27 minute program there was a
transphobic joke every 90
seconds Ofcom received numerous
complaints well into the hundreds and
they dismissed them all a number of us
about 40 of us then appealed and Ofcom
dismissed the appeal so we appealed
again and this time Ofcom decided to
invite some of us in on the
understanding that we stopped appealing
they recognized they didn’t actually
understand the problem that we were
explaining so five of us including me
sat with some senior Ofcom managers and
complaints handlers and discussed what
being trans meant what societal
pressures we faced the types of media
coverage and the effect it had on us and
we started that meeting with a
three-minute montage of hateful coverage
which had been broadcast over the
previous 12 months it had a massive
effect as Ofcom introduced us to a
couple of other very key people in
broadcasting and trans media watch was
born in two years later I was sitting in
the blue chair giving Evert the
charities evidence to the Leveson
inquiry detailing their abuses the
British press were visiting on trans
people and their families the other
thing which very quickly became clear
not just at Ofcom but at channel 4 the
BBC the Press Complaints Commission and
many other media organizations was that
media coverage was not generally driven
by malice but by ignorance our mission
was to encourage the British media to
report trans issues with accuracy
dignity and respect but that meant
encouraging time-pressured journalists
and editors to invest time thinking and
learning about our issues
so although we started in protest we
quickly became a
ooop who engaged to educate and it also
meant that we had to learn quickly about
media I’m an IT person I knew hardly
anything about media in 2009 and now I
know only too well the pressures on
journalists editorial structures how
good press releases are structured
complaints processes and so on
others can judge whether actually
understand any of that however recently
there are some people those in the media
and those with access to the media who
do now intend to set the clock back we
see that very clearly now where parts of
the press have learnt how to bypass the
editors code to make sure they can
publish hateful transphobic pieces
without coming under official censure
where possible they now write about
trans people as a generic group rather
than naming any specific individual they
cite spurious surveys to support stories
they scream free speech every time they
are challenged which is a gross
misrepresentation of what free speech
actually is so the national media
coverage has changed as has the national
conversation around trans people and
I’ve had a part to play in that that
media narrative is continuing to change
and the battle is to ensure that trans
people can continue to influence that
process so what made trans media watch
effective and this is the bit that I
hope can apply to everybody and we’d
like to give people something to take
away with them at our heart was a core
team of five volunteers all of whom
would dedicate it passion
it and driven to make change research
does seem to show that five is a very
good number as it coalesce as well and
it enables people to make decisions
effectively beyond five you get too many
possible combinations of interactions to
communicate effectively with five people
it is very rare that three or more of
you have no energy left so there’s
always energy in the group to drive
itself forwards and interestingly for me
it was the second time I’d been in the
core group of five volunteers and the
second time I’d seen the same kind of
effects we also had a variety of skills
only one of us was a media professional
at the start although another became a
fairly well-known trans celebrity or
personality all five of us were
University educated but more importantly
all five of us contributed ideas and all
five of us saw a common purpose in
educating the media so my conclusion is
that five people with a common passion
can change our environment obviously you
need more than five to carry out
everything but a core of five is
incredibly powerful and I’d like to end
by dedicating this particular talk to my
mother-in-law Kathy was someone who also
knew the difference between knowing and
understanding the importance of doing
your bit for society and engaging in
educating and we said goodbye to her
on Wednesday thank you
you
[Applause]
you
Please follow and like us: