Press "Enter" to skip to content

Change is opportunity | Ben Franz-Knight | TEDxEastsidePrep


I’m gonna take you through one thread of

a journey that’s 40 years and 74 million

dollars but first I’m gonna set a little

bit of background so you get the full

context so in 1907 the Pike Place Market

was established and it was about the

price of onions right farmers were not

getting a fair price from the

wholesalers and consumers were paying

too much so the City of Seattle

established a farmers market right on

Pike Place and it went really really

well

until the 50s and suburbanization and

the market was slated for demolition

they were gonna tear it completely down

replace it with high-rises bowling

alleys and movie theaters and there was

a note a local movement led by Victor

Steinbrueck this gentleman right here

and remember that name Steinbrueck and

they saved the market so in the early

70s they put in place this very quirky

governance structure to manage the Pike

Place Market I’m the director of the PDA

the preservation and Development

Authority we owned most of the property

in the historic district I answer to a

12 member council lots of politics we

have about 15 buildings have over 100

employees and how many of you are

familiar with commercial leasing any of

you you know the location location

location premise right that’s the most

valuable thing right after that when you

look at your lease document the most

valuable thing is what you can use that

space for when I took this job I turn to

our forum lease turn to the use

provision and it said see historic

Commission approval so we owned all the

property but we can make no decisions

about how it’s used that lies in the

hands of yet another governing body the

historic Commission and it goes much

deeper than that they dictate what light

bulbs we use what paint colors and what

bricks right intentional separation of

powers to ensure that the Pike Place

Market PDA as the landlord does not

default to pure economics as the highest

and best use that we are constantly

working to preserve the history of our

city

there’s also the constituency they

appoint four of my bosses you have the

Merchants Association there’s actually

two there was a fissure in the 90s and

so one split often formed another one

you have the de style tenants

association there’s a whole ordinance

that governs how we assign tablespace

throughout the market on the north end

every single day and then you have

friends of the market which is the

organization that was established by

Victor Steinbrueck throughout that we

have 250 small businesses over 220

craftspeople 84 farmers and hundreds of

residents that live throughout the

market and pretty much everywhere one

story above Pike Place is an apartment

and most of those apartments are for

low-income seniors we also have a host

of social services a medical clinic a

Senior Center a food bank and a

preschool and to piggy banks they raise

a lot of money for these social services

in fact they raised a lot more once we

put a sign up above rachel under the

clock and sign that said what rachel

does of course we forgot to get historic

Commission approval so they told us to

take that sign down we had 30 days until

the hearing so we did a comparison of

the money we raised the 30 days prior to

the sign went up and the 30 days that

the sign was up we raised twice as much

money we presented that to historic

Commission after 15 minutes of

deliberation they decided it was okay

for us to leave the sign as those who

made a few modifications and we have 10

million visitors a year so it’s with

this backdrop that we had a tremendous

opportunity and also a real concern

we’re constantly watching the world

changing around us and trying to figure

out how to respond so the viaduct is

coming down how many of you still

question that Bertha is literally 200

yards from completion the viaduct is

going to come down and the City of

Seattle came up with a grand vision for

a great new waterfront when the viaduct

gets torn down they hired a New York

designer James corner brilliant designer

involved in the High Line in New York

and he came up with a plan we’re going

to take the grand waterfront we’re gonna

run it

right up over a parcel that we call pc-1

north at the time and I’ll tell you

about that in just a moment and right

across what’s known as Victor

Steinbrueck Park and we’re gonna redo

all of it so you can imagine this was a

pretty significant threat to the market

this is Steinbrueck Park also known as

native Park named after Victor pretty

important guy for us

this is pc1 north this is the last

parcel in the historic district that

we’ve been trying to develop for 40

years since the market was saved in the

1970s so tremendous opportunity but how

do you mobilize a community that’s

focused on preservation and protection

to move toward change first there’s

timing and we got really lucky

demolition the viaduct waterfront plan

there was City funding we were an

incredible financial position my

predecessor was a wizard of an

accountant and she ensured that the PDA

had adequate resources it was prepared

for a future and we had a long-standing

effort to develop this site so the first

thing I did was dove in and looked at

our history and this may sound illogical

but that actually allowed us to move

very fast these are the pages from the

1974 urban renewal plan and they talked

about the priority uses for pc1 north we

want parking we want commercial we want

residential space and it eliminated a

good six to 12 months of Seattle process

because we had agreed to this in the 70s

and we reaffirmed it in the 80s and we

looked at it again in the 90s and I

pulled all those out and showed

everybody we need to move now to a

concept design so just a quick review of

the site and remember this right here

this is a cabin and this is the outhouse

1909 1973 this is when the market was

saved there was a building on this site

it was called the Municipal Market it’s

where Bavarian meat started 1974 the

building caught fire we also weren’t

wearing seatbelts

we threw the empty beer cans in the back

of the station wagon and we stood on

after the building was torn down that’s

how it’s at until June of 2015 you have

to constantly assess your risk any time

you’re taking on a project and we as a

preservation and historic district are

tremendously risk-averse so I showed you

all of the input all of the community

members lots of voices in this process

lots of governance lots of bureaucracy

you’d think that would be enough

underneath this site is a Burlington

Northern train tunnel that runs from the

south side to the north side on a

diagonal it was hand dug in the early

1900s it is the main north-south line

for Burlington Northern we couldn’t stop

it we couldn’t break it but we had to

get as close as we could to get our

parking in that helps support the

project we had tunnel monitoring

equipment in the tunnel for nine months

and it was only once the final grade and

the final slab for the garage was poured

and cured that Burlington Northern

finally said you’re good why is that

important up until that point they could

have stopped us at any juncture in the

project this was a known risk then

there’s a community process you have to

plan and you have to listen so the first

four images are the first draft from

Miller Hall I’m credible architect did a

fantastic job for us everybody found a

reason to hate all four of those options

so we had a meeting and this was a

really important meeting we were going

to decide how to move forward with

design on this project we had 64 people

in attendance we had four television

stations several print reporters and a

radio station and the council debated

this in front of the entire community

and we settled on option B B and with an

amendment B B+ that allowed us to get

one extra story of housing and this was

the beginning of over 200 public

meetings that’s where this was the main

item

the agenda a main topic of discussion

followed by 24 briefings of the historic

Commission that last briefing where I

got their approval was 2 hours and 45

minutes the last 15 minutes how many of

you heard of the charms and get your

name on a charm and hangs on the fence

I’ll show you an image in a moment they

spent the last 15 minutes measuring the

font size of the donor recognition on

the charm and one condition of approval

was that the font size couldn’t be

higher than a quarter inch give or take

a 16th so tremendous public process no

Chuck we did this all including the

public and why is that important every

member of the public that engaged in

this project and was a regular attendee

at our meetings can see something in

this that was their idea the angle of

this roof that preserves views from the

West End of the market where the day’s

dollars set up today the glass garage

doors that preserve the views the

commercial Hall that echoes components

of the market today heavy timber

construction a celebration of the

producer we have a chocolate maker a

biscuit maker a brewery and a Spanish

seafood restaurant that’s going to smoke

and cure fish access and and portals

through right the markets about

discovery so in this project you can see

that sense of discovery you can see the

destination you want to go and their

surprises and a residential building

that has units for forty low-income

seniors we’ve moved in 22 people 12 of

them were currently we’re homeless right

before they moved into this space and

even here the architect came and

presented the final design for the

interiors of the residential to our

council the council chair turned to me

and said Ben what did Howard think who’s

Howard Howard’s a very large man very

loud man in an electric wheelchair

that lives in one of our low-income

senior units and he has attended every

single meeting for five years Howard got

to choose the color palette for the

interior of the residence and why is all

that important in the community process

when we presented this whole project to

the City Council to get approval for

thirty four million dollars in city

funding we got a unanimous vote because

we

embraced the entire community they

understood the risks they understood

what the opportunity was and more

importantly they had ownership because

they could see their ideas the last

thing we did was made sure we didn’t

wait for Bertha we designed this to

build while the viaduct was still in

place so just about two years ago we

started construction right here and we

went fast

we started excavating we were making

great progress and then I took Peter

Steinbrueck on a tour of the site

Victor’s son former council member we

were walking through and he said hey Ben

do you find any bottles any old stuff in

the mud oh yeah let’s go to the

construction trail let me show you what

we found

he takes some pictures he goes home he

posted on Facebook 48 hours later I get

a call from the State Office of

archaeology saying mr. Franz night it

appears that you have missed a permit

step now I have my historic preservation

permit from the Office of Historic

Preservation which is in the same

building as the Office of archaeology

and the same Department in Olympia they

don’t talk to each other have you found

anything on the site she says well you

know we found a few things I’ve been

told by our our archaeologist this

mostly you know it’s mostly garbage I

hear a fist hit the desk mr. Franz night

this is not garbage this is our state’s

history and I immediately realize I am

in big trouble

what do you need us to do I am so sorry

we have missed a step you need to get

archeologists on site monitoring every

bit of soil immediately starting

tomorrow at 8 a.m. we will be on-site in

one week fantastic

I get archaeologists on-site 8 hours

later they can cover a shell midden they

uncover shoes they start finding

artifacts remember the photo from 1907

early 1900s the cabin and the outhouse

right here they find a little 4 by 4

foot wooden box I’ve been given this

presentation with the image from the

early 1900’s quite a few times they

can’t figure out what it is I’ll be

right back hold on I go print out a

slide indeed it’s the Privy

it’s the outhouse we have found the base

of the outhouse that’s in the middle of

that photo the archaeologists get

incredibly excited why because if you

drop something in the Privy you didn’t

go after it they tend to be artifact

rich so we found over 2,000 artifacts I

think the favorite one is this doll head

right out right here rolled out of the

dirt on Halloween and terrified the

archaeologists they took it back they

did their research they found out it’s a

German ceramic doll and the model name

is indeed Bertha so we found Bertha so

you want to move fast right when you are

trying to change something you’re trying

to get somewhere but you can’t be

reckless now you can’t be reckless when

you run into an obstacle you have to

understand it you have to correct it and

then you can move forward again so this

was the site in January of 2016

incredibly complicated infrastructure

going over the top of the Burlington

Northern train tunnel everybody is

watching so this is being constructed in

a fishbowl when the archaeologists taped

off an area with yellow tapes

everybody’s like there was a murderer on

site no no they found bones we don’t

know if they’re human yet it turns out

they were cow bones it’s fine

interestingly on the archeology note we

discovered there were two populations

living on this site in the early 1900s

one was a group of squatters on the

north end of the site and the

archaeologists could tell because they

had poor cuts of meat the other group of

workers were the engineers for the

Burlington Northern train tunnel it was

one of the greatest engineering feats of

the day and they were feeding them

incredibly well and they had the finest

cuts of meat pretty interesting

discovery so this was the site in 2016

this is the site just in January of this

year in the end of February we started

moving people into the residential

building just this morning we got

approval from the fire marshal for

temporary occupancy of the garage in the

commercial space so 40 units of

housing 300 parking spaces 10,000 square

feet of commercial space and then an

amazing new Plaza right here that

extends off the DeSimone bridge and

celebrates the incredible views going

down to the south and has a connection

that provides for the future of the

waterfront so just earlier this week I

was sitting in a room with all the

waterfront partners folks from the

aquarium City of Seattle city leaders

that started this vision for the new

central waterfront that we responded to

four years ago they can’t wait to stand

with us on June 29th with the mayor cut

the ribbon and celebrate this project as

the catalyst for ensuring that the

central waterfront vision gets realized

we went from responding to change and to

a threat to becoming a catalyst for

realizing a great vision for our city so

with change comes great opportunity and a few challenges thank you

Please follow and like us: