Press "Enter" to skip to content

Challenging the status quo of movie making in India | Onir Dhar | TEDxIIMC


when I in first approached me to come

here and talk I was wondering why would

anyone in iron be interested in an

independent filmmaker and struggle of

independent cinema because mostly people

who pass out of here straight whoever is

interested in the entertainment industry

to go straight to the studios it’s me of

the studios to find out how to destroy

us otellini then I k if you learn a

soggy state X so realize okay here a

little bottom at the X independence the

last couple of months also have been

witnessing something else which kind of

was a learning process someone is an ex

I am student again so this last few

months I’m constantly having

interactions with people from i am

called up got in touch with me through

linkedin and then say they listened I

want to meet you and I have some

marketing ideas and how we can bring

value to your firm’s and brand in film

branding and on and I was extremely

skeptical you know I kept on telling him

that listen to the last 10 years I’ve

been making films independently and I

think that you know in film Brad’s

always are looking for happy films you

know and stars that you know mostly

brands are interested in so I don’t know

why your waist you want to waste your

time and my time and he kept on

insisting that no oh you know I’ve

started we have studied your firm’s and

the way you

working and we think that we can bring

in some value addition and finally it’s

told in the test next week when I go

back we meet up and figure it out

meanwhile there was another ex I am

student for quality and he’s handling

some bajaj account marketing account so

I’m really Medicaid whatever saying that

he wants to quit again he got in touch

with me through Facebook and while

active on social network he wants to

quit his job and come and join and

healthy market my next film which comes

and he came down from we had meetings

and I was why would I trust you to

market my films you can table but George

whatever and he said okay show me your

firm and I will you know give your

presentation so immediately sat down

watch the firm he went out for three

hours for some cafes a cloud came back

to the presentation was really nice and

of course we have not really nice and

he’s very very passionate for difference

that is what interested in your them

attend and I told him that okay what is

usually we hired as independent

filmmakers hire people who handle

marketing about 2-3 months before of

injuries were not like studios who have

in-house marketing department and he

says that this I want to quit my job

right now come and join and help you

market this term so

the pedal came I am willing to give it

thought we can work towards it but you

know are you aware of what all your

forgive up you know so he is like God

willing to you know I thought about it

and you know i can come down to Bombay

Bombay is an expensive city to live in

and this is but can you tell me you know

how what kind of expectations I can have

my said nothing you I can feel anything

as an independent filmmaker but if you

are successful in what you are doing

what you think you can do we will always

share a part of what you bring into the

company and an sport has been the basic

key of how you know for the last 11

years have been making films right now

in February and will be releasing by six

apart from the firm’s that you mentioned

I produced a film phenomena which was

directed by a first-time director about

which was released in January on the

best film at mommy and a flaw and been

producing this slowly getting into

producing films which are directed my

first and filmmakers I will go back to

what I’m supposed to talk here about

construction of independence in my life

through to a statement that Sandeep

Ramos easy

he was talking about struggling with

that an odd dreams i think when i was in

class 8 that’s when I saw this holly

with over food I didn’t understand him

from talking but I knew that I wanted to

be a part of that word cinema images

sound and from then on mega morning

Robin Hood tons of which I protect you

once we sniffles of your mana kita I

come from a middle-class background and

I didn’t know how this journey would

happen because there was home from

school or anything in good time but this

was a dream i had with that came in at

some point i doona very big even that

this is something that is I don’t have

an option that was the only drink my

house I didn’t know how to reach it I

thought of doing everything possible to

try and reach time and then clean the

struggle but this trouble has some more

like now reason I think about it

something bad because I’ve end of the

table ebony assistance however because

it is I’ve done what I wanted to have

never never made films which have been

commissioned good bad ugly iphone up or

append a good job but it’s my

responsibility which was shared by a lot

of people or people believe them what I

wanted to do so coming to when I came to

Bombay are entering

to want to make my firm the first

challenge was I always for me what was

important is that to make a film that I

believed in not to become a director not

to become someone who is told it okay we

want this is this is and and that was

never the passion the passion the

driving force was I want to tell the

story that I really believe in and I

will do anything to try and I’m willing

to wait but it has to be that story so

my first thing by Brandon even when I

was trying to make it I was fortunate

that my actors most of the whoever i

went to i needed he willing to work for

the film without any money by then had

worked 10 years in the nursery has an

editor writer music producer our

director working in different aspects of

the round empower myself to work

independently as a filmmaker and

everybody’s you know my team came from

people who believed in the film in the

story that I wanted to tell them we are

all willing to work for free and the

only people who were not willing to

stand by me where actually the studio’s

the powerless in a world of the funding

what is the first one it did fit into a

project now mostly unfortunately when

you know the initial the properties

change everyone happy more than okay now

stories will get priority and my

experience has been always that okay

your story is interesting but who is the

sound and after point I realize that

your story does not back then in want to

like no one believed no one with money

mutants

and finally I just started asking

friends family everybody to chipping and

that’s how I need my first film at the

same time I was extremely fortunate that

why when it came to prostitution which

is something that we don’t have in India

we don’t have an independent

distribution system so even if you can

make your firm how you disapprove there

is no second you know Trista filters

also watching this which show you fun so

I was extremely fortunate that we have

is about them Vega Studios biggest

production offices rather to compassion

for distribution and we got him in all

India over burglaries and I got a kind

of visibility because I want to support

so it kind of I that’s why i like when

if we see the Wikipedia we get nic sugar

independence Inn device independently

produced ERISA builder coming out I

realized that you know though it was

what I thought as funny as i can get you

know the music says that if you watch

this well its of sing to our system

sorry myself people were getting very

moralistic body what the film was

talking about though I felt that you

know people

dress the same and many viewers before

bidding of the cinema Ian okay so it was

perceived as non mainstream and secondly

was a huge setback for me cousin release

the day after the Mumbai terrorist

attacks so nobody went to watch

difference it was a great setback from

you as a philosopher producer and then I

thought that how do i make my next film

that was again as an independent

filmmaker you’re constantly trying to

see what the situations and have to

innovate yourself to find answers and I

thought that I have this different

stories which again no one was willing

to back the poor stories of iron each of

them could have a separate service about

single motherhood childish should use

same-sex love and the Kashmiri Pandit

issue so these four stories and I

thought that the desire and need for me

to me this one is bigger than the

challenges and the fact that identify

and I realized that when lot of people

who would write to me on facebook on

Twitter saying that you interested your

products and how to be do it and I

father okay let me just try mobeen what

worked out because at that time we did

have any platforms in India like

IndieGoGo or any other crowdfunding

platforms of crowd sourcing platforms so

I remember putting up a post on my

facebook account saying that this is the

story of all attended if you believe

that

can give money anything about 5,000

rupees or you can volunteer and work for

the film so I remember still and it will

always be precious the first check that

actually saw it was not habitable 20,000

years ago so the first check that came

to me was 2,000 rupees from his two

little device Inuit I was abused as a

child is a part of my story moon toad

and I want to be a part of this and for

me that was a sign when the Sun would

happen I send my assistant amudha she

running to the bank to deposit money to

the account of the third one hand and

over the next one here that’s been

created to to make the shoot and

terrified about 400 people from 47

cities across the world gave me money a

lot of people were there was I remember

we were shooting in bangalore a lady

sends a bunch of arrogant i mean if

someone else and make our use of people

contributed in terms of working as

assistants are directors music writers

artists selling lunch various things

various we had for me it gave me so much

more confidence about myself that yes

when you’re constantly told by that no

one is interested in

the film’s your me that there was an

audience was helping made my firm’s by

giving me money for the firm Israeli you

know they were supporting and this is

where you know very often disease I want

to question this whole concept of what

is entertainment you know what

entertainment supposed to be getting

over a meeting either the biggest curse

that as a filmmaker who considers

himself to be an artist India is you

know I studied in tropical University

haha and so I went to pawn me to become

a filmmaker after my training I was very

proud that I’m an artist the first word

that and had to drop from my identity is

artist in Bombay because that means you

are a red light when it comes to

economics you know and you realize that

in India sinabung though it’s one of

them you know youngest form of art is

are no information and God cars and not

under our tent function so you know you

don’t get any support as an independent

filmmaker financially or of the list

terms without one of the highest taxed

industries which means for me cuz

drinking flink so it does not matter one

crore firm or a hundred Crawford you

still have to be 50 / forties Piper sink

tax entertainment tax and then fifty

percent after you know I think very few

people know how difficult it is to

recover for the film because for one

hundred rupee ticket about 45 rupees

force for entertainment acts from that

other 50

that slam fifty percent is standing by

the exhibition you know Sopoaga theta

then formed our twenty five percent left

ten fifteen percent moves to the

festival de so what comes to the

producer is really a tiny amount and

what you get for your theater stuff

becomes lesser and nessa every week

because the person page shared of the

theater becomes higher and gather a

quicker you know digital revolution

coming in every one is going to gain

tell you that okay this is the time to

celebrate you can put your phone on

youtube you can have your Netflix Amazon

or true but at the same time as a

filmmaker I feel that you know there’s a

huge difference which between watching

the firm in a theater like this and so

on and watching for your mobile you know

it cannot the also the art creative the

way you imagine a firm which is meant to

be shown on this crew when what is meant

to be shown on the robot can’t be the

same it’s a different form of art and

I’m not looking around for more fun but

that is what cinema maybe that is movie

cinema order to invent some other word

for it tonight it has it’s a different

experience and that’s why you know this

whole thing that also that how we define

the word entertainment entertainment you

know I am constantly told that people

you have such difficult lives and you

know when they come to the theater at

the end of the day you want to be n

sting you have to make them feel happy

you know so as an independent filmmaker

are have you become a commissioned

artist who or a fashion designer as to

cater to a certain taste or to be

someone feelings you know I’ll make

people have been I wanted who are these

people that have to be constantly made

to feel good about themselves and who do

not like to think or want stories of

what may be questions their happiness

all questions a lot of things about then

why is questioning or feeling empathy

for the other is such a bad thing us to

do you know why you know it’s almost

like to me everyone so obsessed with

selfies until they don’t forget out and

I was recently shooting them by when I

was shooting my film I one French a

little bit more and i was very

pleasantly surprised to see the camera

and was constantly clicking others and

this thing happen

sessions when I was watching my own

actors I was seen in constantly you know

vomiting and clicking settings I also do

realize that as an actor as an artist

you need to be looking out you need to

be sharing to you know that’s how you

grow similarly I feel that the act of

sitting in intent on watching a firm

reading the people sharing the same air

the same you know excitement of all

things is such a different experience

why do we have to you know the world

sometimes of e-commerce cash in because

you know big basket ordering everything

on we pass it is so tempting but at the

same time i miss the smile of my

Brussels you know I’m missing what I

heal okay you know this whole petty

monitor is anything I mean maybe I have

hope it’s technically yes the fact that

I you know I have to move to a team art

and buy everything is my gosh guard

where I’m not going to my small Randy

that mean small neighborhood Shah who

would give me that personal touch you

know and what is wrong about that what

is wrong about is walking down 15

minutes to the nearby shop instead of

sitting on your sofa having you know

chips and watching TV you go and

becoming a college potato it’s nice to

interact with people it’s nice to go out

to move shop and buy a book there is a

beauty in it and that’s what I think

they often we tend to forget my

stupid iphone this someone signal so one

of the challenges is financed like I

spoke about is that who is willing to

[Applause]

put their monies behind independent

party because independent thought first

thing that comes as an artist is further

constantly thinking that okay in this

country again I’m talking strictly in

context of India is independent is very

often promulgated and we have a film

certification board which is very very

very progressive with a lot of food and

you constantly young you know films are

I don’t know why targeted you know today

you’re an internet so anything is

available at the same time you will hear

of a fun coming out and says this film

will hurt the sentiments of this

community or this political party or

this you know and I am wondering that

what about the sentiments of the artists

I suppose we are such a tiny segment of

the water’s fine and we don’t matter you

know so you have to care for the part

which religious sentiment you’re working

what is supposed to be you know any

political references then you become an

intl you know so constantly you as an

artist you have to start censoring your

thought because at the end of it you are

not doing you’re not making of them to

have it as a bone or loud it’s supposed

to be a dial or you’re looking for an

audience you want to speak to someone

it’s not a self gratification but if you

know from the beginning that the top of

southern things by not it’ll release it

you know commence ok so I’m sensors so

this I think they make it quick just the

point in a couple of other points of one

is censorship of thought to when it

comes to funding even platform so I have

down howard funding for

for like I am crowdfunding is extremely

practical when it comes to bigger larger

firms we agrees about a crore through

crowdfunding is that in India because

against Inverness not coz Omega I

suddenly I get a letter from say be

saying that what you’re doing is illegal

and so we give me you are you end up

paying about forty seven percent of work

em raised in form of taxes you provide a

very good lawyer and this me so the

whole exercise becomes few times so

finance still remains a very big problem

the second problem is once you make the

firm how do you dispute it medianet

today kills independent cinema because

you know the bigger you are the more

money you spend to get all the front all

the news that you read on you know Bob

metal ions or times of india or ht2 they

are paid for so it does not matter how

small 240 international festivals they

won’t write about it though they keep

you know cryin about the state of cinema

in this country no one will write about

your to do pay for or so media is

contributing in a vase I’ve seen with no

satellite channels when it comes to

telecasting films you are not looking

for the same price as a double but we

told that there is smoke the value for

what you have made this again because of

certain moral policing that happens at

every every stage for independent cinema

and I think that there is something very

sub conscious choice to either make you

part of the system or silence your voice

which responds temper stories that is

pleasing having said that I feel again

what keeps the struggle on is that you

have a dream but it’s worth entire journey and I ended man thankee

Please follow and like us: