
[Music]
so I’d like to start off today by
showing you a brief video clip it shows
several police officers in New York
applying a chokehold to Eric garner and
many of you may have seen this clip
before but if you haven’t I do caution
you it may be somewhat disturbing so
let’s go to the video but this is also
I’m minding my business please just
leave me alone I told you the last time
please leave me alone don’t touch me
put your hand behind okay to put that
video shows the power of anyone armed
with nothing but a smartphone today to
expose police seemingly abusing their
positions of authority and guess what
you only know about the illegal
chokehold placed on Eric garner because
a bystander in New York happened to film
it need more evidence of the power of
the smartphone as a tool for
accountability consider a video taken at
April 2015 by a barber named Faden
Santana as he happened to walk to work
one morning in South Carolina the video
that Santana took shows police officer
Michael Slager fakely fatally shooting
in the back multiple times and unarmed
and fleeing Walter Scott now the video
that Santana took became key evidence in
the murder trial against Officer Slager
it ended in a hung jury in December 2016
but here’s an important point in one
that I want to come back to later
Santana merely observed Officer Slager
he did not interfere and
non-interference in turn is key for
helping to deescalate tensions between
police and the communities that they
serve the smart phone in brief should be
a tool for accountability not for
interference now none of this is
particularly new people have been
filming police for many years now think
about the video taken by George holiday
some twenty five-plus years ago from his
Los Angeles apartment balcony it showed
several Los Angeles police officers
beating Rodney King with batons
following a high-speed chase now that
video sparked both civil and criminal
trials against the officers involved and
ultimately led to riots in the city of
Los Angeles now much has changed since
then with regard to technology back then
it was the handheld camcorder and today
it’s it’s just a smartphone but nothing
has changed about the impact that these
videos have on the criminal justice
system and all of this today takes place
within a much larger conversation one
about police and community relations
today police find themselves working
under a microscope they have some
several shootings of African Americans
helped to spark the black lives matter
movement and thus today anyone armed
with a smartphone could help hold police
accountable for their actions and yet
just as significantly videos can also
help police
now how so you might wonder how might
that be that a video could help a police
officer well imagine an officer was
falsely accused of abusing a suspect a
video could show what really happened a
video in turn could clear the officer of
any wrongdoing and yet unfortunately
we’ve seen several incidents where
citizens have had their smartphone
seized and smashed simply because they
were recording an officer from a public
sidewalk in yet on the other hand
sometimes police rightfully worry that
those filming them will interfere with
the often dangerous and deadly work that
it is being an officer so what’s the
solution the solution is for both sides
police and citizens to know and
understand their rights when it comes to
filming police in public spaces and this
leads to the big picture question is
there a constitutional right to film
police in public spaces such as parks
sidewalks and streets and that’s a
question that I’ve studied now for
several years and what I found is that
it’s a two-sided issue and I want to
tell you today about both sides first
citizens must respect police and not
interfere with their jobs and yet on the
other hand police must respect the First
Amendment a basic civil right now I’m a
First Amendment advocate and I have been
for years at least since the time I was
editor of my high school newspaper but I
do understand one thing
and that is if there is to be a First
Amendment right to film police that it
cannot be an absolute right what does
that mean not in absolute right that the
right must be subject to some
limitations particularly when safety
concerns are involved so here’s what I
found from my research the right to film
police in public places flows from the
First Amendment to the United States
Constitution the First Amendment
protects free speech and Free Press
against government censorship so how is
the First Amendment going to be relevant
here
well first of all videos are a form of
speech and second police are members of
the government therefore the First
Amendment is relevant but ultimately it
is up to the United States Supreme Court
the nation’s highest court to tell us
what those words in the First Amendment
mean Congress shall make no law
abridging freedom of speech or the press
well unfortunately and perhaps
surprisingly the United States Supreme
Court has never actually considered a
case directly involving the right to
film police in public now I said that
might seem surprising but it’s really
not and that’s because the law always
lags behind technology consider it a
tech lag as it were as they say the
wheels of justice often grind slowly so
without any guidance from the United
States Supreme Court lower courts across
the nation have been left us sorted out
for themselves and while some have
reached different answers and some
frankly haven’t even addressed the issue
at all the growing consensus seems to be
this that there is a First Amendment
right to film police in public places
like parts but it is subject to what
courts call reasonable restrictions in
other words it’s not an absolute right
there’s some caveats and exceptions to
it and this actually makes sense with
much of free speech law the First
Amendment doesn’t give you blanket
protection to say anything you want
anytime in any location you can’t after
all falsely shout fire in a crowded
theater but back to what that term
reasonable restrictions means
unfortunately it’s a gray cloudy German
and the only thing really certain is
that citizens cannot interfere with
police when doing their job and that’s a
point that I raised earlier with regard
to the video that Faden Santana took of
the shooting of Walter Scott
Santana merely observed he did not
interfere so what constitutes then
reasonable restrictions what courts tend
to weigh several factors first they
consider the dangerousness of the
situation the interaction between the
officer and the suspect involved and
second they also tend to consider safety
factors public safety and citizen safety
and suspect safety but what does all
this really mean in the real world well
what it really means is that both sides
both citizens and police need to respect
and to understand their rights and if
they did so I think a lot of things
would happen in particular the tensions
between communities and police today
that exists might go down so what are
then some real steps some concrete steps
that both citizens and police can take
to help lessen those tensions that I
just mentioned well first let’s talk
about citizens citizens must not
interfere with police when filming them
in second they shouldn’t stand too close
now unfortunately how close is too close
is a gray area standing 25 feet back may
be perfectly permissible but just five
feet back less than two yards maybe not
so exercise some common sense when
filming in terms of how close you come
second people need to think about
whether it’s night or day and whether
one officer is surrounded by a hostile
crowd of dozens that’s a basic
consideration of officer safety and
third citizens need to understand that
courts do consider some types of
interactions between police and suspects
to be inherently dangerous so for
instance traffic stops are considered to
be inherently dangerous interactions
thus when filming a traffic stop don’t
come too close and fourth and finally if
you’re recording a police officer
don’t yell yelling only escalates
tensions take the high ground and record
as a neutral observer again the
smartphone should be a tool for
accountability not for interference now
what about police what can they do well
several things first they need to
understand that when they work in a
public space they have no reasonable
expectation of privacy and second they
also need to understand that indeed the
vast majority of courts have held that
there is a First Amendment right to film
police in public spaces subject to those
reasonable restrictions and third if
they believe that someone who is filming
them is standing too close they should
order them to stand back rather than
seizing their phone or worse yet
grabbing it and smashing it to the
ground again de-escalating tensions is
key on both sides of the equation so
ultimately the bottom line is that both
police and citizens need to take each
other’s perspectives in doing so they
need to understand that there is a First
Amendment right to film police but it
has its limits
and in particular it ends when observing
crosses the fine line into interfering
if both sides knew and did this I think
several things would happen one tensions
between police and communities would
de-escalate police accountability would
increase and finally the First Amendment
would be safeguarded so the final lesson
then is this know your rights exercise
your rights but know their limits the
line between observing and interfering
is a fine one thank
so I’d like to start off today by
showing you a brief video clip it shows
several police officers in New York
applying a chokehold to Eric garner and
many of you may have seen this clip
before but if you haven’t I do caution
you it may be somewhat disturbing so
let’s go to the video but this is also
I’m minding my business please just
leave me alone I told you the last time
please leave me alone don’t touch me
put your hand behind okay to put that
video shows the power of anyone armed
with nothing but a smartphone today to
expose police seemingly abusing their
positions of authority and guess what
you only know about the illegal
chokehold placed on Eric garner because
a bystander in New York happened to film
it need more evidence of the power of
the smartphone as a tool for
accountability consider a video taken at
April 2015 by a barber named Faden
Santana as he happened to walk to work
one morning in South Carolina the video
that Santana took shows police officer
Michael Slager fakely fatally shooting
in the back multiple times and unarmed
and fleeing Walter Scott now the video
that Santana took became key evidence in
the murder trial against Officer Slager
it ended in a hung jury in December 2016
but here’s an important point in one
that I want to come back to later
Santana merely observed Officer Slager
he did not interfere and
non-interference in turn is key for
helping to deescalate tensions between
police and the communities that they
serve the smart phone in brief should be
a tool for accountability not for
interference now none of this is
particularly new people have been
filming police for many years now think
about the video taken by George holiday
some twenty five-plus years ago from his
Los Angeles apartment balcony it showed
several Los Angeles police officers
beating Rodney King with batons
following a high-speed chase now that
video sparked both civil and criminal
trials against the officers involved and
ultimately led to riots in the city of
Los Angeles now much has changed since
then with regard to technology back then
it was the handheld camcorder and today
it’s it’s just a smartphone but nothing
has changed about the impact that these
videos have on the criminal justice
system and all of this today takes place
within a much larger conversation one
about police and community relations
today police find themselves working
under a microscope they have some
several shootings of African Americans
helped to spark the black lives matter
movement and thus today anyone armed
with a smartphone could help hold police
accountable for their actions and yet
just as significantly videos can also
help police
now how so you might wonder how might
that be that a video could help a police
officer well imagine an officer was
falsely accused of abusing a suspect a
video could show what really happened a
video in turn could clear the officer of
any wrongdoing and yet unfortunately
we’ve seen several incidents where
citizens have had their smartphone
seized and smashed simply because they
were recording an officer from a public
sidewalk in yet on the other hand
sometimes police rightfully worry that
those filming them will interfere with
the often dangerous and deadly work that
it is being an officer so what’s the
solution the solution is for both sides
police and citizens to know and
understand their rights when it comes to
filming police in public spaces and this
leads to the big picture question is
there a constitutional right to film
police in public spaces such as parks
sidewalks and streets and that’s a
question that I’ve studied now for
several years and what I found is that
it’s a two-sided issue and I want to
tell you today about both sides first
citizens must respect police and not
interfere with their jobs and yet on the
other hand police must respect the First
Amendment a basic civil right now I’m a
First Amendment advocate and I have been
for years at least since the time I was
editor of my high school newspaper but I
do understand one thing
and that is if there is to be a First
Amendment right to film police that it
cannot be an absolute right what does
that mean not in absolute right that the
right must be subject to some
limitations particularly when safety
concerns are involved so here’s what I
found from my research the right to film
police in public places flows from the
First Amendment to the United States
Constitution the First Amendment
protects free speech and Free Press
against government censorship so how is
the First Amendment going to be relevant
here
well first of all videos are a form of
speech and second police are members of
the government therefore the First
Amendment is relevant but ultimately it
is up to the United States Supreme Court
the nation’s highest court to tell us
what those words in the First Amendment
mean Congress shall make no law
abridging freedom of speech or the press
well unfortunately and perhaps
surprisingly the United States Supreme
Court has never actually considered a
case directly involving the right to
film police in public now I said that
might seem surprising but it’s really
not and that’s because the law always
lags behind technology consider it a
tech lag as it were as they say the
wheels of justice often grind slowly so
without any guidance from the United
States Supreme Court lower courts across
the nation have been left us sorted out
for themselves and while some have
reached different answers and some
frankly haven’t even addressed the issue
at all the growing consensus seems to be
this that there is a First Amendment
right to film police in public places
like parts but it is subject to what
courts call reasonable restrictions in
other words it’s not an absolute right
there’s some caveats and exceptions to
it and this actually makes sense with
much of free speech law the First
Amendment doesn’t give you blanket
protection to say anything you want
anytime in any location you can’t after
all falsely shout fire in a crowded
theater but back to what that term
reasonable restrictions means
unfortunately it’s a gray cloudy German
and the only thing really certain is
that citizens cannot interfere with
police when doing their job and that’s a
point that I raised earlier with regard
to the video that Faden Santana took of
the shooting of Walter Scott
Santana merely observed he did not
interfere so what constitutes then
reasonable restrictions what courts tend
to weigh several factors first they
consider the dangerousness of the
situation the interaction between the
officer and the suspect involved and
second they also tend to consider safety
factors public safety and citizen safety
and suspect safety but what does all
this really mean in the real world well
what it really means is that both sides
both citizens and police need to respect
and to understand their rights and if
they did so I think a lot of things
would happen in particular the tensions
between communities and police today
that exists might go down so what are
then some real steps some concrete steps
that both citizens and police can take
to help lessen those tensions that I
just mentioned well first let’s talk
about citizens citizens must not
interfere with police when filming them
in second they shouldn’t stand too close
now unfortunately how close is too close
is a gray area standing 25 feet back may
be perfectly permissible but just five
feet back less than two yards maybe not
so exercise some common sense when
filming in terms of how close you come
second people need to think about
whether it’s night or day and whether
one officer is surrounded by a hostile
crowd of dozens that’s a basic
consideration of officer safety and
third citizens need to understand that
courts do consider some types of
interactions between police and suspects
to be inherently dangerous so for
instance traffic stops are considered to
be inherently dangerous interactions
thus when filming a traffic stop don’t
come too close and fourth and finally if
you’re recording a police officer
don’t yell yelling only escalates
tensions take the high ground and record
as a neutral observer again the
smartphone should be a tool for
accountability not for interference now
what about police what can they do well
several things first they need to
understand that when they work in a
public space they have no reasonable
expectation of privacy and second they
also need to understand that indeed the
vast majority of courts have held that
there is a First Amendment right to film
police in public spaces subject to those
reasonable restrictions and third if
they believe that someone who is filming
them is standing too close they should
order them to stand back rather than
seizing their phone or worse yet
grabbing it and smashing it to the
ground again de-escalating tensions is
key on both sides of the equation so
ultimately the bottom line is that both
police and citizens need to take each
other’s perspectives in doing so they
need to understand that there is a First
Amendment right to film police but it
has its limits
and in particular it ends when observing
crosses the fine line into interfering
if both sides knew and did this I think
several things would happen one tensions
between police and communities would
de-escalate police accountability would
increase and finally the First Amendment
would be safeguarded so the final lesson
then is this know your rights exercise
your rights but know their limits the
line between observing and interfering
is a fine one thank
Please follow and like us: