Press "Enter" to skip to content

Capitalism is about to save us all. Here’s how I know. | Matthew Weatherley-White | TEDxBoise


okay so you have an idea and it’s
actually a great idea
and if the stars all line up one day you
might find yourself standing on one of
these big red dots sharing your idea
with hundreds or maybe millions of
perfect strangers but before you do you
will likely want to scrub the Internet
just make sure that your brilliant idea
worth sharing hasn’t already been shared
and so you do and you very likely will
discover that there are already a lot of
smart people in the world who are very
busy thinking about and exploring your
idea which is pretty much what happened
to me and after a few panic fueled
sleepless nights I made an unexpected
discovery that most of the people who
spend their time thinking about and
exploring money and the future of
capitalism tend to orient towards
pessimism why capitalism should operate
differently how it could be more
sustainable more resilient more
inclusive less extractive less
exploitative more just in fact some
people even recommended that we should
be working collectively towards an
entirely new form of economic
organization a replacement for
capitalism now I’d like you to hold that
architecture of failure for a second
because we’re going to take a huge
tangent together detouring
into our collective misunderstanding of
evolution and why that misunderstanding
gives rise to the sense of pessimism
that seems to wrap itself like a giant
squid around so many conversations about
money okay so evolution and we all
understand the basic principles behind
evolution right it’s adaptation now I’m
not an evolutionary geneticist but
I happened to have a conversation with
one a few weeks ago and he encouraged me
to see evolution through a very specific
lens this concept called selective
pressure which is an invisible force
that interacts with the millions of tiny
manifestations of genetic individuality
that we all exhibit to create the
changes that we see in the world sort of
fish feet to fins fins to feet fins to
feet as it were but the problem is that
most people when they think about
evolution they think about it in one of
two ways it’s either a hyper logical
genetic progression or it’s a form of
hand-to-hand combat and neither of these
narratives actually capture that that
essential process and this
misunderstanding matters a lot
well why well I believe it matters
because this misunderstanding shapes the
essential characteristic of modern
capitalism this illusion of a
merit-based system predicated upon a
false analog to warfare now I need to
say something for the record actually
I’m on I’m being filmed so I’m I’m very
much seeing something for the record
[Applause]
while some have argued that we should be
working towards a replacement system I
don’t agree in fact I do not advocate
for a dismantling of capitalism in favor
of some other ism we have all seen
capitalism and the social cultural and
political structures that surround it
offer up surprising solutions to some of
the great challenges that we face clean
energy affordable housing remarkable
medical advances I’ve been a
professional investor for about a
quarter of a century and I have seen
capitalism do this it definitely not all
the time not all the time but often and
over and over so here is a spoiler alert
I have an optimistic capitalist and I’m
gonna say something that might make some
of you in this room a little bit
squirming I think you’re all we’re all
optimistic capitalists what do I mean
when I say that what do I mean when I
say we’re all optimistic capitalists
well we all probably agree that markets
the place where we go to buy and sell
stuff and services generally work pretty
well I mean we’ve been attending them
for centuries trading seashells for
coffee beans and goats for chickens
whatever we had in excess for whatever
we thought we needed I think if they
didn’t work we probably would have
stopped going to them um
we probably also agree that giving
people the opportunity to raise money to
start businesses to hire people to make
things to pay taxes and yes if you fail
it’s a pretty good system I mean even
today’s economic environment in China
looks a lot more like capitalism than
any form of communism that Marx or
angles or mouths might have imagined and
I also bet that we agree that there is a
relationship between work and risk and
reward and although that relationship
seems to have broken down recently that
core idea still holds and that this this
intersection of
markets and capital flow and the
opportunity for reward that’s the basic
framework for capitalism and I doubt
anybody would disagree with that but
where it starts to get complicated it’s
when we try to define our own role
within this capitalist system and it
gets complicated for two reasons first
because when we think about capitalism
and you know let’s admit it to ourselves
we do probably more often than we would
like to admit it gets really abstract so
let’s think about capitalism as an
operating system while it might be
impossible to describe how an iPhone
works I think we all understand the need
for a periodic upgrade and then second
most people tend to think of capitalism
as a static system this fixed framework
and here here’s where we loop back from
this extended detour into evolution
because capitalism evolves
relentlessly it is continually
reflecting and informing our prevailing
social norms I mean it was in our
lifetime that child labor formed an
important part of the global labor pool
it was in our parents lifetime that was
totally cold to dump toxic waste into
our rivers and oceans it was in our
grandparents lifetime that colonialism
prevailed and it was in their
grandparents lifetime that the pursuit
of whales forged the early links and
what we now call a global supply chain
but each one of these practices
generally became extinct and they faded
not because they made no economic sense
it faded because at different times and
for different reasons and with different
degrees of reluctance they became
unacceptable and I believe that the
current form of capitalism ignoring as
it does generally the social and
environmental consequences of its own
operating system will one day
become unacceptable and I think that
future version of capitalism it’s
inevitable and that it’s a lot closer
than we think but why do I think that
like what do I see that makes me so
confident what do I see that makes me so
optimistic consider for a moment the
relationship between a sub oceanic
earthquake and a tsunami the earthquake
will pass almost unnoticed long except
by handful of geophysicists but the
tsunami will race across an entire ocean
to wreak devastation upon landfall
that’s a pretty extreme analogue I get
but I think that dynamic holds in the
evolution of capitalism invisible events
which trigger material measurable
unexpected perhaps even apparently
unrelated changes at some future time so
what are the sub oceanic earthquakes
happening right now that will lead to
the tsunami of change well I could riff
on this for a few hours but I’ll spare
you instead I’m gonna stitch together
six totally unrelated anecdotes which
one presents it as a group I think offer
an unexpected and perhaps even
compelling outline for what the future
of capitalism holds so the first
suboceanic earthquake the Norwegian
sovereign wealth fund and pretty random
what’s the sovereign wealth fund so
think of a sovereign wealth fund like a
giant government-run piggy bank that can
be raided to benefit the citizens of the
country since 1970 Norway has pumped
about 20 billion barrels of oil from the
oceans that lie in its coasts and
they’ve directed a surprising amount of
the revenue from that oil into their
sovereign wealth fund and now that
sovereign wealth fund is worth over a
trillion dollars trillion in other words
oil has made more way very very
prosperous Vickers work gets interesting
six months ago the government of Norway
announced that they would no longer
invest in and would strip all exposure
to oil gas and coal from their portfolio
now there’s a number of reasons that
they could have made this decision and I
wasn’t in the room when they did but
it’s impossible to overstate the
symbolism of this I mean this is like
Bill Gates standing up and saying you
know I’m not gonna invest in technology
anymore
the second suboceanic earthquake the
Pope so historically the Pope shepherded
the church’s mission and the Vatican
Bank steward of the church’s capital and
this arrangement worked pretty well for
I don’t know several thousand years but
recently the separation of church and
Bank is starting to crumble in his most
recent encyclical laudato si the Pope
issued a clarion call for capitalism to
be a more forceful defender and
protector of those in our global economy
who are at least able to protect
themselves and a more active protector
of our environment this is the Pope
talking about money it’s true Pope
Francis makes no investment decisions
but I think it’s fair to say that he has
a fair amount of sway over church
matters third Larry Fink’s letter Larry
think in some circles he’s kind of like
the Pope and he is a CEO of Blackrock
which is the largest asset management
firm in the world so he sits on top of a
pile of money that’s six trillion
dollars tall so he recently wrote a
letter to his fellow CEOs and in this
letter he said if your business does not
have a purpose that contributes
positively to society we will not
support you now it’s hard to predict
exactly how this is going to play out
it’s impossible to know exactly what he
means by that but what is clear is that
he has put the conventional way of doing
business
ignoring the social and environmental
consequences of the operations on notice
and perhaps more critically he has sent
a shock wave through the corporate
boardrooms of the world the fourth
suboceanic earthquake
63 trillion dollars we are standing on
the edge of the greatest wealth transfer
in history as an estimated sixty three
trillion dollars passes from the hands
of primarily aging white men to their
widows children and the charities that
they support so i started advising
families in 1993 and at the time when
the patron of a family passed away he
just started working with his wife or
his children sort of no questions asked
it was a form of professional
inheritance but a recent report by JP
Morgan revealed that 85% of widows and
93% of inheriting children expect to
fire their advisor within three years
the number one reason given because that
advisor either doesn’t understand or
might be actively hostile to the idea
that an investment strategy can’t pursue
more than simply financial gain it might
even seek to contribute positively to
society I’m betting that Larry Fink read
that report this the B corporation
movement so think of a B corporation
like a first cousin to the traditional C
corporations that we all know about but
these businesses use the power of
business for good to certify as a
qualified B corporation requires that
the company meet a rigorous set of
standards related to community
environment employees
and customers so right now there’s about
3,300 give or take
certified be corpse around the world and
the roster includes a list of the usual
suspects Patagonia Ben and Jerry’s
seventh generation I’m even proud to say
that my company is a founding B Corp but
two weeks ago Groupe Danone a publicly
traded French six billion dollar
consumer products company announced that
they had successfully completed their B
Corp certification now remember that a
publicly traded company at the end of
the day owes its allegiance to only one
group its shareholders and its job is to
increase shareholder value so for a
group down on to go through the brain
damage of becoming a certified B Corp
means only one thing that their board
and their executive team believes that
embracing and embedding best practices
and sustainable business management will
lead to higher share prices than if they
didn’t and this is the first time that a
publicly traded company has ever said
this the sixth suboceanic earthquake my
so Carl is he’s a classic Wall Street
banker
he’s been on Wall Street since 1987 and
he is now the CEO of a publicly-traded
solar energy company vevo power a few
months ago Carl told me that in the
markets in which he competes
vivo power is frequently the lowest cost
provider of electricity lower than coal
lower than oil lower than natural gas
and corporate America is paying
attention Google right now generates 100
percent of its electricity needs from
alternative and renewable sources Warren
Buffett perhaps the greatest investor
ever is now the largest owner of wind
power in the country and Walmart is the
largest owner of distributed rooftop
solar power maybe on the planet and none
of these companies would be doing this
if it weren’t profitable so where does
this leave us with a vague sense the
capitalism might be shifting sure with a
little window into the arcane world of
international global finance all right
with a handful of interesting anecdotes
you can haul out at your next cocktail
party that’s my gift to you but you’re
probably sitting there saying to
yourself well why why do I even care we
should all care we should all care
because capitalism now touches every
single person on this planet because the
largest corporations are now larger than
many countries because as government’s
struggle to deliver the kinds of
services that its citizens expect the
private sector is going to step in and
we have to decide what that looks like
can we use the steering power of capital
to force to shape this inevitable
evolution well I think
that those six examples that I just gave
you and there’s many many more are
evidence that this is already happening
in ways that are both surprisingly
simple and like profoundly
transformational this might sound like a
call to become an activist go man the
barricades and there are people who will
do that and I totally applaud them but
capitalism does not require that we all
become activists to dial up the
Selective pressure in fact we don’t even
need to all be pessimists but nor weak
nor can we become complacent because
capitalism needs engagement it needs
participation and needs choices acted
upon it needs us to determine how this
selective pressure will be optimised and
that might be the best way to look at
this because capitalism it’s the most
powerful efficient optimization machine
that man has ever designed and right now
it’s simply optimized for profits and
there’s nothing intrinsically right or
wrong with that so the question is not
is capitalism good or evil the question
is to what end do we seek to optimize in
addition to profits why not
environmental resiliency why not gender
and race inclusion why not opportunity
equality to say that it can’t or worse
that it shouldn’t that reveals a failure
of imagination I think that the Pope and
Larry Fink and group down on and my
brother all offer in their own way proof
the capacity for capitalism to evolve
and the solution is beautifully
inevitably intrinsic to the system
capitalism as a system we must remember
was created by man it wasn’t handed to
us and
tablets carved in stone and so
capitalism can be recalibrated it can be
re-engineered it can be reimagined by by
us so we have to ask ourselves again
that question what aspects of the
current form of capitalism do we wish to
survive to serve future generations
what adaptations do we want to see
embedded in the capitalism and in the
world that we hand to our children a
more regenerative sustainable perhaps
even reflective form of capitalism is
right there I’m telling you is it is
right there waiting for us with the
evolutionary character of capitalism
itself as the capitalist to bring it to life thank you
Please follow and like us: