Press "Enter" to skip to content

Calling in, not Calling out | Meliha Grbic | TEDxYouth@IdahoFalls


all right hello everyone so to begin I

want you all to visualize a Muslim think

about their face their clothing and

their personal beliefs now look at me am

i what you envisioned my name is Malika

my name is an Arabic name a very old

Bedouin name meaning beautiful although

my name is Arabic and I was raised in

Idaho I was actually born in Germany to

Bosnian Muslim refugees the plurality of

these cultural influences in my life has

created unique areas of interest and one

of these interests is learning languages

I know English and Bosnian fluently and

from a young age I started learning

Arabic but on my voyage for language

acquisition I actually found myself in

Amman Jordan last summer how were prior

to accepting the scholarship to study

several my friends and family members

urge me to think critically about my

decision to go abroad they were

concerned about my safety as an American

girl and Middle East has been publicized

as an unsafe region for several years

now however I know a lot about Islam and

I know a lot about chronic history as

well I was optimistic about my future

experiences in Jordan I’m Muslim and

most the people that I would be meeting

were Muslim also certainly I would have

an upper hand over my fellow travelers

certainly I would be able to better

empathize and understand this new

culture so I decided to accept my

scholarship to study through the

national language initiative for youth

commonly known as Miss Lee in Amman

after I had landed in amin we had an

orientation and my program coordinator

discussed several necessary safety

topics these include culture shock

sexual harassment

taxi etiquette so from that orientation

and subsequent taxi rides I clearly

remember the significance of the taxi

meter it was imperative that the taxi

driver turn on the meter as soon as we

entered the car lest they abuse our

foreign naivety and over charges on my

first ride I forgot to ask about the

meter and the driver charged me three

dinar for one deny ride which is about

one and a half USD i paid him but I was

a little bitter about the situation I

had been taking advantage of and so if I

fast forward to my last week in on mon I

had grown comfortable with the language

and the culture and I didn’t really fear

a confrontation with taxi drivers

anymore I wanted to be I wanted to see

my friend one more time before I left

for the u.s. so I left and I went

outside to the streets the traffic was

atrocious but after about 30 minutes

attacks he finally pulled up as I

entered I did standard protocol I asked

him about the taxi meter immediately and

he didn’t respond I didn’t turn it on I

wasn’t sure if he had heard me or not so

I repeated the question again can you

please turn on your meter this time he

looked at me through his your rear-view

mirror but still didn’t do anything at

this point I was getting a little

anxious and started to doubt my

pronunciation he was preoccupied traffic

but I felt the need to clarify myself

once more please turn on the meter sir I

said again in Arabic this time he looked

at me and he was a little irritated he

said why are you asking about the meter

I’m trying to make sure we get into

traffic safely I was a little shocked

and I started to explain myself but he

interrupted and he’s like not all taxi

drivers are thieves I apologized I I was

surprised by my own reaction but then he

interrupted me again and said don’t

apologize just now that I’m giving you

so that caused me to sit in silence and

reflection the rest of this taxi ride I

was really disappointed in myself in my

own reaction to the situation I thought

that I had the capacity to understand

and to empathize with his new culture I

thought that my knowledge and faith as a

Muslim would help me with this empathy

and this understanding but I had

completely succumbed to be self

defensive behaviors that were

unproductive and I misjudged the

situation it was an incredible wake-up

call the taxi driver taught me that

although we shared a similar religion we

definitely did not share some old

similar cultures Islam is very important

to the Middle East but having knowledge

of religion is not enough to understand

and navigate a new culture confidently I

understand Islam and it’s Bosnian

context but had never had prolonged

interaction with the Middle Eastern and

more specifically Jordanian Muslim

before the taxi driver also taught me

that I me to examine my misconceptions

and assumptions about different groups

of people I had been so focused and so

sure of my compassion and empathy

towards Muslims that I unknowingly

discriminated against another group taxi

drivers I in this way the self defensive

behavior was very unproductive and I

found that my naivety and myself

defensive behavior is a product that

characterizes many empathetic and

open-minded people I’ve shared this

experience to you to demonstrate the

rather unappealing and inappropriate

behavior even I as a Muslim and someone

with a lot of cultural background has

demonstrated it’s really easy to succumb

to self-defense behavior abroad you’re

in an in comfortable situation

everything

new but it’s also pretty easy to come

across here at home amongst her peers

and citizens and so this actually leads

me into another story and it’s

drastically different from my taxi

driver story it has to do with an

Islamic artist and I had the ability to

talk to her one day after class she was

explaining the basic premises of Islamic

art which among geometric patterns and

shapes and repeating colors and unique

mediums is focused on a hadith by

prophet muhammad peace be upon him and

hadith is a word action a phrase that

Prophet Muhammad said or day and this

particular Bahia deeth which is an

illusion militant Yash Raj Mel means

indeed Allah is beautiful and he loves

beauty and as she was explaining that

this is a major premise of Islamic art

she turned to me and she said yes

maleeha even your name it means

beautiful and all of a lost creations

are beautiful her words really resonated

with me and stuck with me because I

understood her I I respected her and

despite our cultural and geographic and

physical differences I felt that I could

really empathize with her and this

situation is especially significant to

me in my experience of Jordan because it

really humanized Jordanian people and

Muslims although I had learned to

respect Jordanian culture long before I

had left I this situation really

clarified the difference between respect

and empathy as I stood there watching

her and I understood her hopes and her

dreams and her ideas I realized it

wasn’t because of this religious bond we

shared but rather because I truly

decided to listen to her and understand

her and the more I listened to her the

more she reminded me of my friends back

home these two experiences are some of

the many that have shaped my experience

in Jordan and forced me to address some

of my own self defensive and

otherwise inconsiderate behaviour that I

unknowingly used and so just a quick

hand raised how many of you like think

of yourselves as open-minded as

empathetic people I know I do yeah so

before I set foot in Jordan I had a

certain naivety that characterizes a lot

of empathetic and open-minded people but

that’s why I think it’s especially

important to address these self

defensive behaviors because they affect

the open and closed minded alike I would

like to share a quote with you today and

it’s from John Knowles book a separate

peace all of them constructed at

infinite costume themselves these

national lines across the frontier for

this enemy they thought they saw if he

ever attacked that way if he was indeed

the enemy many Westerners are afraid of

Middle Eastern cultures beliefs and

ideas they fear Syrian refugees and

perpetuate discrimination against them

out of self-defense out of this

perceived threat and although we may

perceive ourselves to be open-minded and

different from them applying theoretical

ideals to real life is really difficult

equality fairness and open-mindedness

don’t transfer very easily even so I

think we should continue to try to be

open minded and understanding because I

don’t want to avoid the Middle East out

of fear I don’t believe in that enemy

across the frontier and I don’t want to

build mojno lines or walls I want to

embrace the beauty in the Middle East

and I want to promote negative

stereotypes against Muslims and really

create engagement between Middle Eastern

and Western citizens however I will

admit that mistakes will be made and it

is in these mistakes that we must grow

and reflects together so as we pursue

our own interests and discover new

perspectives and explore our true

passions and dreams we must remember to

you analyze and examine our own

defensive behaviors it’s time to stop

calling out our Syrian Middle Eastern

Jordanian and Muslim neighbors it’s time

to stop calling each other out in the

name of righteousness instead let’s

start calling each other in to

discussions to spaces and into our

America thank you [Applause]

Please follow and like us: