Press "Enter" to skip to content

Beyond the Headlines: Mass Media and the Alteration of Risk Perception | Madeline MacLean | TEDxMSU


[Applause]
Newtown Connecticut Orlando Florida
Tucson Arizona Aurora Colorado San
Bernardino California Charleston South
Carolina there’s a reason these cities
are so familiar to us a reason many of
you will recognize these names most
people know these cities not for their
landmarks or for their population sizes
but for the tragic events that have
taken place here the shootings in movie
theaters schools nightclubs these have
all happened within the last few years
and these events stand out in our minds
for the tragedy and shock that we felt
as a nation these six events ruled the
news for weeks after they happened you
couldn’t turn on the TV or radio without
hearing new developments in the story
yes we know these six cities but what
about the rest these are all the mass
shootings that have taken place in our
nation between 2009 and 2015
133 events of the same nature as those
six that we are so familiar with so why
do we not know about these in my
freshman year here at Michigan State I
joined the first year of a promising new
program called the social science
scholars thanks to this incredible
program I’ve had many opportunities as
an undergrad that before I was able to
only dream of one of those was pairing
with dr. April zio Lee a professor in
the school of criminal justice to do
research in my first year
our research focused on the
newsworthiness of mass shootings in
other words what factors impact the
coverage of a mass shooting why are some
widely reported on while others are not
first of all it’s important to
understand how we conducted this
research we defined mass shooting as the
FBI defines it a single event carried
out by a person or group of people armed
with firearms which results in the death
of four more victims this is important
because you may see articles on the web
every now and then that proclaim four
hundred mass shootings in 2016 and
they’re not wrong per se but you do have
to look at how those articles define a
mass shooting often they will say an
event constitutes a mass shooting if
four more victims are injured not killed
well not technically incorrect this
distinction does tend to widen the net
considerably
we measured newsworthiness in two ways
number of stories and word count in
those stories we looked only a broadcast
from major national news networks and
when we had other numbers we looked at
correlations significance bivariate
regression x’ multivariate regression x’
all those fun statistics but if you’re
like me and math isn’t your forte
don’t worry I’ll explain the results and
the connections we found so on that note
what makes a mass shooting newsworthy
first of all the old dodge of if it
bleeds it leads is truer than ever we
found that both word count and story
count increased for each additional
death or injury in a shooting in the end
the number of fatalities proved the most
significant factor out of all the ones
we looked at so as deaths go up word
count and story count increased steeply
also if it took place in public it was
more likely to be reported on a public
setting would look something like a
movie theater or school now these
factors make sense when looking at the
shootings we all know so well high
victim counts both in deaths and
injuries and public settings such as
churches or nightclubs but what are we
missing here what shootings are
deemed worthy of media attention and why
not first of all we found a couple of
factors that didn’t make any difference
at all one of those factors was if the
shooter obtained the firearm illegally
and the other was if the shooter
committed suicide after the crime but
more importantly we found two factors
that made a shooting less likely to be
reported on one was if it happened in a
private setting and the other is what we
call iph or intimate partner homicide
this is when a spouse girlfriend
boyfriends partner ex or anyone else
intimately involved with the shooter is
one of the victims oftentimes this
includes killing other family members
and most often the others killed in the
shooting are the children the
relationship when a shooting included
iph or took place in the home it was far
less likely to be reported on as much or
at all according to every town for gun
safety fifty-seven percent of gun
violence victims are intimate partners
or family members the majority of people
affected are close to the shooter
emotionally the media portrays mass
shootings as a stranger killing other
strangers when in reality that’s the
minority of cases our own study found
that over 60 percent of the mass
shootings that we examined were never
reported on at all the majority of these
included intimate partner homicide when
looking at our other results on how
intimate partner homicide in a shooting
means that it will probably not be
reported on the research suggests that
iph is less interesting to the public or
not seen as news this may be because iph
is less relatable no one wants to
believe their partner is capable of such
a things so people would rather read
about the random deaths of innocents
some may even say that the intimate
partners of the shooters were complicit
in their fate
that they should have taken more
countermeasures or shouldn’t have been
involved with the shooter in the first
place so what’s the point here
how does this impact our lives the media
disproportionately reports on certain
types of mass shootings not only do we
know this simply by looking at the map
of the 133 recent mass shootings but
also by looking at the numbers such as
the results from our research for
example even though most mass shootings
take place in private the vast majority
of shootings we hear about on the news
take place in public even though most
mass shootings include intimate partner
homicide those are very rarely discussed
in the media and although we all know
the horrific shooting that took place at
Sandy Hook Elementary we don’t usually
hear about the kids harmed in their own
homes which often happens in cases of
intimate partner homicide the media is
misrepresenting these shootings and our
perception is altered because of it we
fear getting shot by a stranger in a
movie theater or school or church in
reality we should statistically be
fearing the guns in our own homes
handled by our family and our partners
after 9/11 the frequency of car
accidents in the u.s. skyrocketed more
people were on the roads because no one
wanted to fly even though such an attack
was hugely unlikely to happen again why
is this the answer is simple our
perceptions of risk are based on what we
see and if we see a stranger shooting at
strangers in a public place when we turn
on the TV that’s what we’re going to see
as most likely to happen to us when
looking at mass shootings and many other
things in our world no one piece can
give us the whole story Adam Lanza the
man responsible for Sandy Hook is not
representative of all
and pulse nightclub is not
representative of all mass shootings
these are complex people and events each
deserves to be looked at in depth yet at
the same time we have to look at the big
picture how do all 133 of these events
fit together what are the patterns and
how can we change them we must take care
that our perceptions are not altered
irreparably never look at something and
see one picture challenge it these
things don’t happen in a vacuum
there is always context and it’s our
responsibility to see that context even
two sides to every story is
oversimplifying every piece of every
mosaic is multifaceted when we look
closely we must think critically about
these statistics so few people are
informed on these facts and if we all
had better numbers and not just what we
see on the news we would be able to
focus more intelligently on solving the
violence problems we face we talk about
stopping another new town another
Orlando another Aurora but what about
another Indianapolis or another Tyrone
another Wichita douglasville Morgantown
springfield one of the 133 others we
must stop focusing on only a few of the
pieces and see the big picture failure
to think critically about any given
topic will result in standing still in
this case especially that is one thing
that we cannot be satisfied with if we
expect to make our nation safer we must
apply these findings to our policies we
can have all the knowledge and research
in the world but nothing will improve if
we cannot use them to make a difference
as German writer Johann Wolfgang von get
to once said knowing is not enough we
must apply willing is not enough we must
do people from every viewpoint will find
it easier to come together if we have
all of the proper and up-to-date
information
when we start focusing on only a few
events and think critically about the
pieces and the big picture they create
perhaps one day we can go from this to
this to this maybe even to this thank
you
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: