Press "Enter" to skip to content

Being a Designer in an Engineer’s World | MaryBeth Privatera | TEDxUCincinnati


I’m here to tell you the tale of the two

worlds that I live in one that’s rooted

in art and the other one that’s rooted

in science it’s really the tale about

culture and about how our professional

cultures interact with one in one

another but first let me tell you a

little bit about my background

you see I started out college when I was

three years old do you think I’m

brilliant right but let me tell you how

I managed it I thought about this in the

womb and I planned it out I thought how

can I get there really here’s what it

was my dad was a barber and my mother

went to nursing school and we couldn’t

afford babysitting so what did we do I

went along to nursing school with my

mother and I would go to nursing school

with her and I would look at her books

and I would sit there and she gave me a

pile of paper and she said honey just

sit there and draw I’m like okay mom I

got this so I would sit there and I

would draw and I would look through her

nursing books and I would go oh oh wow

oh wow and then she surrounded me with

national Geographics which is even more

interesting as a young child because

then you’re like oh wow the world it’s

very interesting right and so I sat

there and I drew and I drew and my

parents no matter what I asked for they

would give it to me and I would go to my

grandmother’s house for babysitting

again and they’d say here’s a tissue box

it’s okay

it’s tissue box what can I do with that

I take tissues I’d wad it up into a ball

they take another tissue over the top of

it tie it with string and I’d hang it up

put a face on it and I’d made ghosts

ghosts that hung in the window and this

love of being able to take my hands and

build things it progressed so that in

middle school I actually started to make

pom-pom animals now I’m a little bit

older than a lot of you in the audience

this isn’t the time when you could go

buy pom poms and you could go buy the

little googly eyes you could put it all

together put it in there and then you

make this like a little product no what

I was doing is taking yarn wrapping

around my hands tying it and not making

my own pom poms making my hats to go on

the top of the animals then I went

around the neighborhood and I sold them

I made $85 I was very very proud of

myself and that started off my journey

as a product designer and I went to my

dad said you have to go to college I

said okay I’ll go to college he said but

you can’t do that art thing you got to

make a living and I like but I like to

draw like no no you have to make a

living I’m gonna really like science but

that really wasn’t my calling because I

really like to draw so I went to design

school and in design school I had to do

things like design a lawnmower and I had

to design an Indy 500 car at one time

and I was like you know stop feeling it

really not feeling that wallsconce

no matter how much I try that wall

sconce is there its shine and light it’s

doing its job but I’m not really feeling

that wall sconce and we have this great

thing called the co-op program so I went

on this job and I remember I showed up

to the job interview and I forgot my

resume and I had an a so it was there

they’re like do you have your resume I

was like I said it mail didn’t you get

it and I said I really just want to

learn that’s what I want to do and the

company was a medical device company and

it was here I said ah I found what I

love I get to do science in design

that’s fantastic so I learned how to

take science and apply it to my design

and I learned that through medical

devices I get the opportunity to explore

and learn from so many wonderful people

and then I get to come back and I get to

design now you may ask yourself what is

a medical device and what is that well

medical devices are required for life to

exist as we know it it could be

something as complex as an LVAD system

that keeps you alive while you await

heart surgery or can be an everyday item

like your eyeglasses a toothbrush or

even your Fitbit it can just make it

just improve health and well-being so

that’s very very diverse in fact in the

federal registry the definition of a

medical device

two and a half paragraphs long in Europe

it’s also two and a half paragraphs long

but they have a caveat if you

call it a medical device it is a medical

device now what I learned in design

school is that design is really really

fun it’s a complex process it lives at

the crossroads of technology innovation

culture and environment all wrapped up

together and what’s important when we

design is that we know who we’re

designing for what’s the purpose or the

need and what’s the underlying value

that we’re going to bring the best thing

about designing a medical device is the

fact that you’re going to actually help

people not that a wall sconce doesn’t

help people because we need to see our

lighting as we go to the movie theater

but this impacts their life in a

meaningful way

so in 2004 I took a leap I took a

commitment and I started to only design

medical devices and in this role I’ve

had the opportunity to learn from so

many wonderful people I’ve had the

opportunity to design devices that truly

do impact patient care on a daily basis

I’ve had the opportunity to join a

clinical department to have a rare

glimpse the inside of how clinical

Department practices the life of a

physician the life of a nurse I’ve had

the opportunity to participate fully in

the medical device industry and to help

form some of its standards and in order

to develop a medical device you’re

always with standards you see the

reality of our world is that we have all

of these rules and expectations and

that’s the result of our culture and the

culture in which we live is formed from

all of our shared understandings our

values our attitudes our beliefs our

underlying assumptions and I can be

broken down into micro culture such as

the micro culture of your family that

says you’re going to go to college and

you’re going to have to go to the

nursing school with your mother all of

that forms that culture and it breaks it

down even further into micro cultures

into individual companies and individual

professions so in my role I get to

interface directly with engineers with

marketing professionals with regulatory

professionals and most importantly the

practice of medicine

let me come back over here to my design

side because I’m not quite done

explaining that design process when we

design a medical device we have all of

these wonderful things that we have to

meet you see we have a regulating

agencies that say in order to design a

device you’re going to need to be 100%

100% of the time which means that we

have to go and we have to research what

our clinical practitioners are doing and

then translate that back to design and

we have to test it in a rigorous manner

that involves risk and harm and we have

to prove that our device is safe it’s

effective it’s easy to use this is

mandated through several rules and

several laws that we have it’s also

mandated that we do good design do it

right the first time and our regulating

agencies tell us that we have to

collaborate we have to understand prior

to proposing a solution this is good we

like those rules think about that as a

patient I absolutely want to have that

medical device to work now let me jump

over here to the side of the practice of

medicine these people that practice

medicine and making a commitment of long

hours of training to make sure that the

care that they deliver to us is 100

percent 100 percent of the time they

wake up every day trying to do their

best making sure that they’re trying to

meet all of their patient needs but they

have external influences too and they

have rules and expectations that they

live within those rules and expectations

one of them is patient privacy that’s a

law it doesn’t go away I’m talking about

HIPAA hip is the rule that protects our

privacy and make sure that none of our

values are public out there but it’s

impacted medicine has been both

significant and large and small ways for

example let me share with you what I’ve

witnessed I’ve witnessed health care

providers need to change phones it’s

kind of odd right

why would HIPAA cause them to change

phones well the reality is they just

didn’t have enough security on it and

patient information was coming to their

phone the patient information coming to

their phone in the wrong hands is a

problem another way when you go to the

emergency room

you used to be able to see on a board

that would have your name you could

follow a patient you could track it this

is where my grandma is I know my

grandma’s in room 3 I could see that

well you can’t now you need to know

grandma’s number so it’s changed that

impact there at one time attendings were

able to residents were able to text

images to their attendings to seek

advice that’s no longer the case unless

everybody has the right security because

if we don’t follow HIPAA this of the

penalties are severe now you’d think

that the rules and these expectations

are something that we may like we may

not like the reality is we like those

rules they keep us safe they keep us

protected so I argue that the same rules

that protect us are the ones that may

actually limit us in design over here we

think about being really creative we

think about alternative realities over

here they have no time to do that over

here I’ve got to be 100% 100% of the

time when I’m in my design world if I

have a problem I have the ability to

just walk away to think about it for a

little while

and then come back to it when I have a

solution that’s not the case if I’m a

surgeon I actually have to solve the

problem right there but struggles me to

this conclusion the reality is all

people are creative he’s got a problem

to solve he’s gonna solve it right there

they’ve got a problem to solve they’re

gonna take a little bit more time there

are three types of people in the world

there’s side liners they’re innovators

and there’s naysayers the innovators

they take it they take a strong love of

what they’re going to do they take it

they’ll adopt technology immediately but

bring it in they’ll act on it side

liners people that wait for it they hold

back and naysayers the people that

always say no in design were rarely

the naysayers we’re always like hey what

do I have over here we find all free

types and depending upon their level of

conservativeness their level of ability

of acceptance they will adopt things

immediately and bring it into their

practice see I believe that the cultures

in our individual professions influence

each other every day both in positive

and negative ways and the rules that say

I have to collaborate come in to clash

with some of the rules that say I have

to limit access I have to protect

patient privacy and the reality is

between the two of these each individual

profession is set up for its own success

and hasn’t really realized the fact that

we impact each other both positively and

negatively as we go through our daily

lives and we are interacting with one

another how we take into that

information and we use it to form

ourselves and we give it to another

profession means that it will either

limit our ability or keep our keep keep

going I had a beautiful speech just

really good and I just threw it out

thank you I appreciate that

[Applause]

the reality is is that rules and

expectations the ones that were given to

me by my dad that said you will go to

college you will have a job the rules

and expectations of that are found on

health care providers they all form the

culture in which we live and we have a

responsibility to assess where those

rules happen why they’re here ask why

we’re doing what it is we’re doing how

we can learn from one another and how we

can move forward the reality is is that

rules and expectations happen every day

new devices new processes new theories

are going to happen and they’re going to

happen by those who are risk takers by

those who you perceive to be crazy or

even an outlier you might have to put

your credibility on the line you might

have to be one that says maybe my

colleagues don’t think that I am really

valid or good and Ed for every rule and

for every expectation there is an

exception it’s name is creativity thank you

Please follow and like us: