Press "Enter" to skip to content

Beautiful Game Theory, Beautiful Economics | Ignacio Palacios-Huerta | TEDxUDeusto


I get the phone call from a son of mine
he asks me what I do have all the
penalty kicks
of all the places with Manchester United
I say yes okay would you be willing to
work a little bit for Chelsea and say
okay how come I said well it happens
that my good friends with averin grant
Aaron grant is the coach that replaced
Mourinho and as you know these guys are
playing in two three weeks time the
Champions League final I say okay that’s
interesting
could you do the test that you typically
do with this data and tell us what
happens yes I can do that I’ll be
pleased to do that so okay I get the
data I work for a couple of weeks and I
write the report which I sent to my
friend a famous mathematician that works
in Israel and in New York I send the
same report to the coach the coach on
Monday says well this is absolutely
fantastic hopefully we are not going to
need it
hopefully we’ll beat Manchester United
in the first 90 minutes but if it
happens that we got waxer time and into
a shootout this will be very very useful
okay so guess what Champions League
final they end up 1-1 they go to extra
time they continue 1-1 as a penalty
shootout okay now my reports tested for
certain aspects that should happen if
rational players play this game okay if
they play correctly there should be very
little arbitrage opportunities there if
they don’t actually should you should
systematically at least in a statistical
sense take advantage of certain players
it happens that they were two players in
manchester united that had a very strong
bias the first one was the goalkeeper
when the sir
when the star had not a perfect but the
very strong tendency
to move to the right hand side when
facing the right footed kicker and
towards the left when facing the left
footed kicker the second player who was
Cristina Ronaldo he was almost perfect
except if he stopped in the run-up to
the ball if he did that it was almost
certain that he will kick to right okay
so this is exactly what happened in the
third penalty kick just of course
knowing what when the serve was doing my
jealousy players score all of the
penalty kicks and in the penalty kick my
goalkeeper bit a sec I stopped Cristiano
Ronaldo so in the fifth penalty I was in
a position to win myself the Champions
League final for Chelsea with some data
and some math unfortunately in the fifth
penalty John Terry is left as predicted
when the servant to the right totally
unpredictable John Terry except he
kicked to the left and just barely miss
hit the post and went out there he went
my chance to win the Champions League
final then there was a six penalty and
in the service penalty America totally
disregarded the advice of a date
he kicked to the right which is as we
knew what when the star tends to do
against right footed players when they
stop the ball
Manchester United won the Champions
League final so at this point you may
think how on earth a professor in
economics at the wood school has 11,000
penalty kicks is this guy not working
let’s do any research at all only
watches football
let’s do any teaching how on earth are
this guy the answer has to do with with
Galileo I have lots of products because
it is very good at the same as Galileo
Galilei had very good data from apples
that he dropped from the PISA tower or a
few years later Sir Isaac Newton most of
all data from apples so apples and
stones provided very good
for these guys to test theories that
were of interest to them not because
they care not because they care about
penalty kicks sorry about not because I
care about penalty kicks about any type
of fear they care about about nothing
Helen day that they care about the laws
of gravity and yet the weight of an
apples and stones worse terrific to test
for the first time some theories that
were important to physics economics
actually economics is a social science
but is not characterized by the subject
matter it is characterized as Gary
Becker says by the approach that we take
to things whether it’s in sociological
questions political science questions
and topological questions any type of
questions okay because it is applicable
to any type of human behavior it means
that any type of human behavior could be
potentially very useful to test theories
the same as apples and stones data was
very good to test theories for this
famous scientist so what type of
theories can you test with penalty kick
data if you watch the movie A Beautiful
Mind it turns out John Nash got a Nobel
Prize 1994 then they made a movie but
there was a subset of his theories that
had remained untested for many years
those are the theories that involve
mixing among optimal strategies and it
had remain untested because it’s very
hard it is very hard typically the real
world is very dirty you have 20 bankers
30 frames 100 countries a bunch of
individuals playing you have many
strategies available to them it’s very
hard to find good data like with apples
and stones okay but the penalty kick is
ideal only true agents and always in the
same position so some of these theories
had remained untested it occurred to me
that this type of it was a deal after
some math you solve for the Nash
equilibrium and it turns out that it has
some predictions football players to do
something ok they should do the
goalkeepers to the left and right the
same reports as 40 to 50
the kickers would lose 3861 and actually
somehow miraculously football peas do
that not all of them but most of them do
that which is kind of shocking you would
think how on earth food or players that
never came to a university like this
don’t even have high school follow these
laws for the same reason that apples and
scones do not know the laws of gravity
and yet they follow these laws of
gravity and you can check as a group as
once you have one thousand parody but
you can check individually you can check
you can check Messi do this you can
check it
Aldo will keep us Casillas anybody and
she will in fact people are behaving as
and as would predict in fact they do but
not always as as I noted earlier with
van der Sar and Ronaldo now so this is
an instance that it doesn’t take the
economic approach to human behavior in
this direction is the other way around
any type of human hero could be useful
so it’s not what economics can do for
football is the other way around is what
superconn is for economics
like what apples and stones can do for
you okay so this is the first message I
wanted to convey today the second is the
moral standard report which is still is
very rare today in a in academic
research which is what an economist can
do for any type of to human behavior why
not for sports maybe you have seen the
movie Moneyball Moneyball is a movie
that is fantastic in the following sense
it revolutionized in the last 15 years
the sports industry in the US and where
is touching now the European industry
why this guy hired an economist
economist with some data some
methodologies start analyzing behavior
and somehow was able to assess much
better to identify much better talent
that just with instincts okay
as a result there was some biases and
arbitrage opportunities that he took
advantage of so let me give you three
examples see examples of how an
economist and made contributions to
Sports example number one you may
remember in 2002 a psychologist for the
first time and some of my friend site
for the last time they gave a novel
price to a psychologist
okay to Danny Kahneman okay for his
contributions detecting biases he did
that in money biases some biases are
very important not all of them some of
them and they disturb the Nobel Prize it
is very hard to find conclusive evidence
even if we suspect that various force
that move the apples from the tree to
list or even we suspect that we humans
are biases very hard to actually
document clearly the sources under bias
will go back to penalties actually and
to my surprise not single pellet is
paternity shootouts like in the Chelsea
Manchester United people think that
people say even today that it is a
lottery everybody has the same chances
five kicks each a 50-50 lottery the
world lottery remembers reminds us of a
50-50 well if you look at the data and
it takes a long time to collect lots of
data because of the nice offices dekappa
born we need lots of data turns out that
it is not a fifty-fifty load it is a
60/40 load okay who begins who follows
is rondalee data me by coin so it’s
perfectly identified the source of of
this asymmetry okay some DEA team is
given an arbitrarily a greater chance to
believe in and another team is will be
given a greater chance to be login why
because presumably this living lag in
asymmetry effects performance it is
probably better to be living and to be
lagging and trying to play catch-up so
this is an economist looking a later
this week could identify by us in a very
clean set
what does can we do as an economist act
we can fix the wires or attempt to fix
the virus these days the current order
is let’s say that there are two teams a
and B first kicks a and B then a and B a
B a B but if the order a B gives
advantage to anybody
let’s say a big is an advantage to a
what should we do in the next pair of
penalties we should reverse the
advantage to try to compensate for what
happened the first pair by the way what
happened even but it is both a comes
goes to be the same we should reverse in
the next pair to compensate any
advantage given to anybody by reversing
the order in the next pair we were
compensating any type of robot it’s
invalid by the way if there was no
advantage in the order a B by reversal
we’re doing nothing so it is a win-win
proposition to actually change the earth
and then let’s repeat a b.p a a BB a a
BB a do you know any sport that uses
this structure first one then two two
two two
until a team or an agent or a player
wins of course tennis tennis uses that
structure
presumably they realized long time ago
that leaving serving gives you a great
attention we lived in a little affects
performance so I don’t know if you
notice but three weeks ago even though
in the Spanish media was not seen a lot
three weeks ago
must a third FIFA announced and it was
covered in England in Germany in France
in the US big time FIFA announced that
they are implementing this system they
are going to be moving from the a.b a.b
a.b to a tennis tiebreak okay so this is
something else that al economies can do
identify by us and try to correct the
bias if we think like an economist very
difficult sometimes these things don’t
happen every year every decade but
is doable second example closer to us
let’s see what an economist would think
we have to move 36,000 people season
ticket holders so she owes from the old
sentiments to the new San Mames
everybody thinks is going to be better
off okay it’s a better Stadium
well I’m plus by the way I want to be
seated with my friends and family around
me by the way the guy sitting right by
me it’s also wants to be seated with his
friends and family around him impossible
it’s impossible so here we have to
devise a system oh by the way we are
going to buy or sell seats in the new
stadium we are going to allocate seats
in the stadium so we are not going to
use prices or contracts or we are not
going to allow trading it’s impossible
no prices no contract no trading we just
have to think of an allocation turns out
that this problem is identical in a
mathematical structure to what I will
Ross Nobel Prize in Economics in 2012
has studied he resisted in many problems
where you have too much donors and
recipients ok donors for kidneys you
have too much hospitals too Restless you
have too much public house in among
different different type of people
without using prices because we don’t
want to trade kidneys we don’t try to
trade organs ok so we have to allocate
it as close as possible to market
efficiency ok this is this is a the type
of recess that got another price to Alby
in a few years ago using it by the way
using this type of algorithms with
device and algorithm of people from one
extreme to the other out of this 36,000
people we got 60 complaints less than 2
per thousand ok
these much others work very well to
solve an important problem in this in
this in this company in this club third
and final example
coming back to San mamés a technical
quest acting acoustic economist could
solve we are going to play for one
season in a u-shaped stadium you
remember the was the only stadium was
the new student being built and for one
season
it was a u-shape question has this as
semantic a stadium impact performance if
it does we have to take advantage of
that study if it does and choose
accordingly now we studied for a couple
of weeks maybe around 100 hours data
from a single stadium Rayo Vallecano
that also has a new shape to estimate
whether or not potentially a u-shape
asymmetry in destiny my impact
performance what we found was very
interesting
we found that always attacking in the
first half towards the goal that does
not have any people could create around
1.5 to 2 points per season what did we
need studious econometrics that people
we use we studied in economics courses
now is that a lot is that a very little
we don’t know but athletic produces
points had more or less 1 million per
point the budget is around 65 million
euros for the first team a good season
is around 60 to 65 points
ok so attacking and we’d by the way we
managed to attack almost 90 percent of
the games the first half against de
Gaulle without people and the second
half against the goal with peep they
call with people is worth around 2
million euros and by the way that system
will reach the final so we reached the
Champions League for the first time in
the last 15 years so these are instances
of both ways economics what the
economists can do for football and what
football can do for economics what
sports can do for economics what
economics can do for sports
beautiful game theory beautiful
economics thank you very much
[Applause]
[Music]
Please follow and like us: