Press "Enter" to skip to content

Are You Not Entertained? Cicero And Modern Political Arena | Glenn Ruse | TEDxPSU


always remember what city this is what

you seek who you are as you go down to

the Forum every day think to yourself I

am a new man

I seek the consulship this is Rome

anyone who’s ever taken an ancient

history class knows Marcus Cicero anyone

who’s ever studied Latin probably hates

him he’s known for his large body of

works all marked with his signature

quick wit and sharp tongue and

incredibly difficult Latin but what

history often overlooks however is the

fact that Marcus Cicero was a Noah’s

homo which is Latin for a new or a

strange man and new men in Rome were men

whose families hadn’t reached the

highest levels of political office for

the average Roman this really didn’t

affect you you could be successful in

many fields but if you had political

ambitions being an outsider being a new

man proved to be a really difficult

hurdle to overcome

Cicero did not have the political

capital that comes with claiming a

famous ancestor he didn’t have the large

network of patrons and clients that his

opponents families had been cultivating

in some cases for generations and

centuries and simply put his name wasn’t

widely known throughout the Republic

nevertheless and 64 BCE Cicero was

elected to the consulship the highest

position in Rome unanimously by the

Roman tribes he used his mastery of

language his power the power of his

speech and his ability to reach and mold

the support of the people to overcome

his position as a as an outsider and

earn his place in Roman society now I

know regardless of your political

leanings just the mention of an outsider

candidate or an anti-establishment

candidate will bring back recent

memories the 2016 presidential election

was marked by the impact and success of

these outsider candidates

on the Democratic side Bernie Sanders

started his movement and built a

revolution from a simple almost

laughable grassroots message in the

Republican camp Donald Trump now

president Trump made huge waves with 140

character statements and he built and

energized a large movement with his huge

rallies

both men were up against the political

leaders of their parties but each were

able to reach success with the base by

using a similar strategy to Cicero’s for

classicists like myself 2016 was the

year that reminded us that we not only

have inherited the ideals of democracy

and a republic

we’ve also inherited the political

tactics and schemes that politicians

like Cicero perfected over 2,000 years

ago despite the fact that Cicero enjoyed

really relished in talking about himself

and writing about himself he really did

not leave behind a great description of

his campaign strategy the best source

for this is actually a letter written to

him by his younger brother Quintus the

first piece of advice in this letter to

his brother was actually the quote from

the beginning of this talk always

remember what city this is what you seek

who you are every every step taken as a

candidate must be taken with the

constant awareness of your position as

an outsider every action done must be

carefully calculated to counterbalance

the stigma of your position this makes

it all the more difficult for senator

Sanders and now president Trump because

of the sheer amount of exposure there is

for modern political candidates

especially in the age of social media

like Facebook Instagram Twitter every

action they take is instantly shared

around the world every post they make on

Facebook every tweet they send out

regardless of time of day is instantly

viewed and scrutinized by more than just

their followers as an outsider this

means that a unified message

a unified message is not only necessary

but if you don’t have a unified message

you’d better be very good at spinning

bad publicity clintus told his brother

not to leave rome his constant presence

in the city would do more for him than a

single speech could Cicero knew from

personal experience that as an outsider

the people need to see you to connect to

you and he learned this the hard way

when he first ran for office his first

position in the Roman Republic was as

Christ er the lowest rung of magistrate

in Sicily he ran won the position and

left for office with the full support of

the people incredibly proud of himself

and when he returned he expected a warm

welcome as he stepped back on the shores

of Italy the people many of them didn’t

even realize he’d been gone he was so

frustrated and his pride was hurt so he

hurried back to Rome and reconsolidated

Andrey established himself in order to

move forward politically this is where

social media makes a difference for

modern political candidates live tweets

infographics Instagram posts snapchat

stories they all make it seem as if the

candidates are constantly present even

if they’re only in a specific area or

town Donald Trump already had a

well-established

public image especially on Twitter when

he made his announcement he hit the

ground running with his hashtag make

America great again Donald Trump used

his Twitter account to dominate the news

cycle for months

before placing a single ad it was a

Trump appeared to be everywhere at once

his Twitter feed was a not of message

lines and controversial tweets were

embedded and surrounded by constant

updates from the field policy statements

and infographics and memes and retweets

in this way the fishbowl effect for

outsiders was dazzled by his busy image

and any political enemies or even the

media themselves would have to sift

through his timeline and through all of

these posts in order to piece together

his policies and plans and report on him

Bernie Sanders on the other hand did not

have a well-established public image his

biggest moment in the national spotlight

before he ran for office for president

came in 2010 whenever he filibustered in

the filibuster against tax breaks for

the wealthy for eight hours

his biggest grassroots support on social

media came on reddit in the first six

months of the campaign there were over

80 Sanders specific subreddits or

discussion pages on the site it was

grassroots efforts like this on social

media that helped spread his message and

fueled his campaign throughout the

primary reaching the people is only the

first step however the second and most

crucial step is invigorating and

energizing the people that you’re

talking to for a politician this comes

mainly from your oratory and rhetoric

which it’s something that Quintus really

did not need to advise his brother on

Cicero’s first entrance into the public

eye came in the law-courts the Roman

legal system set up a little different

than the modern-day the cases were heard

in the forum and they were open to the

public

large crowds of people would come to

hear the advocates usually young men but

sometimes older experienced senators

would advocate in the courts they would

come to listen to their power of

language and their their mastery of

oratory it was almost a competition

almost a reality show

Cicero showed his his political

ambitions early on because he took on

large huge cases high-profile cases his

first case that really caught the

attention of everyone was the

prosecution of a man named varies

various had been the governor of Sicily

and he was being accused of a long list

of crimes including defiling temples

embezzling state funds and stealing

private property Cicero prepared several

days worth of speeches against Barry’s

but he only needed one to win after a

long day of hearing witnesses Cicero

ended his speech with the worst

accusation brought against Barry’s

namely killing a Roman citizen without a

trial the people that were surrounding

him and listening to this speech were so

roused and so angered by Cicero’s

description in very great detail of the

execution of this Roman citizen that

varies for fear of his own life fled the

forum and went into voluntary exile

essentially forfeiting his case and

admitting guilt Cicero was lifted up and

carried out of the forum by the people

in one fell swoop Cicero had not only

secured his position as one of the best

speakers in Rome at a very young age but

he had also earned his position as one

both senator Sanders and President Trump

are incredibly skilled at inciting

emotion in their audiences Bernie

Sanders message did not change from day

one his message resonated so well with

his audiences that whenever he would

recite his tag lines or his statistics

at both debates and in his rallies his

followers would chant them along with

him his refusal to use attack ads or go

negative in many of his speeches meant

that his rallies were issues based and

any coverage of them or him would have

to focus on those issues

Donald Trump on the other hand in a very

different strategy Donald Trump’s

speeches were almost improvised they

jumped from theme to topic almost

without a moment’s notice his speeches

are filled with unfinished thoughts and

tangents but that didn’t matter his

supporters fed off of the atmosphere of

the rally and the tone of the speech

itself Donald Trump is not the best

order but he is incredibly skilled at

not only inciting emotion but molding

that emotion in the crowds listening to

him his speeches were fueled by the

restlessness anxiety and fear of the

people listening and he built off of

that he capitalized on it he promised

that when he got into office he would

change everything in Washington he would

drain the swamp and make America great

again there by placing themselves

against the established candidates these

these candidates were able to reach

voters who had previously not felt

engaged by politicians these voters felt

and still feel as if they’re Outsiders

watching their country with no say and

no real ability to control what’s going

on

just like Cicero this the power behind

their success came from the supporters

that they had energized now there’s one

more important parallel with Cicero that

we’re currently watching unfold namely

the way Cicero reacted to the results

when Cicero’s elected consul a senator

named Cataline plotted against the

Senate the Republic and Cicero himself

Cicero uncovered and discovered the plot

and laid out all of the details to the

people of Rome in a series of speeches

the result of which was Cataline was

driven out of the city the plot was

foiled and Cicero was seen as a hero

there was the people in the Senate were

so so relieved by sand and so relieved

by the the loss of danger and so elated

with Cicero’s role in saving the saving

Rome that they gave him the title Potter

patriae which is Latin for father of the

country and this was an honorific that

hadn’t been given for over 300 years

Cicero true to form refused to let

anyone forget that he was given the

title Potter patriae and that he saved

the Republic and that he uncovered the

plot and that on his last day in office

the people lifted him up and carried him

on their shoulders from the forum to his

home on the Palatine Hill as if a

general returning home in triumph Cicero

had to do this as an outsider who had

earned his place in society he had to

legitimize his position in history he

needed to focus on his legacy and remind

people that he earned his place he broke

through as an outsider even though it

increased the animosity and brought

Donald Trump’s reaction to the results

have been interesting four months after

the election Donald Trump was fixated on

the numbers and the size of his victory

this trends not going to stop he has to

do this as an outsider in the moment in

which he won the moment his opponent

conceded he had to immediately begin

legitimizing himself and proving that he

deserves to be there and fixating on his

legacy his campaign promises may not

come to fruition if that’s not what’s

going to matter to Donald Trump now

Donald Trump will be focused on his

legacy and its overall position in

American history as annoying as he was

in victory Cicero was at his best when

faced with defeat and dire circumstances

after the assassination of Julius Caesar

Cicero found himself to be one of the

last living members of the Senate his

the people and his fellow senators were

looking to him for his views on how to

proceed everything had changed

Cicero took this newfound power and he

used it he attacked the supporters of

Caesar he railed against them in a

series of speeches particularly their

leader Mark Antony the power of his

words increased the animosity between

Mark Antony and the Senate and the

people and actually later the future

emperor Augustus the this animosity

increased so much that it actually

stopped Anthony from really passing any

of any of his platforms or beliefs the

mastery of Cicero’s language and his

ability to reach the people especially

at this point in his life brought him to

a prominence that he hadn’t reached

since decades before the day after the

election senator Sanders saw a surge in

support and people looking to him for

his views as the initial shock of the

results began to fade the media and the

Democratic Party began to realize that

Bernie Sanders was still talking and

more importantly his supporters were

still listening and acting just as he

did during the election he accepted

every invitation to take part in

interviews and town halls more people

are hearing his message than ever before

and he was not stopping his position as

an outsider may have kept him from the

mainstream of his party but as in the

case of Marcus Cicero and Donald Trump

this is a powerful position to be in so

what can we pull from this parallel what

can we learn from their example in a

time when our country is more divided

than ever before with no real hope of

reuniting in the near future what can we

do we’re Outsiders what can we

accomplish but see that’s the trick so

were they

Marcus Cicero fought his way to

prominence and earned his place in Rome

despite his position as an outsider

senator Bernie Sanders he came out of

near obscurity

brought life and vigorous debate to the

political arena Donald J Trump defied

every expectation and with his massive

support base earned his place at the

head of the table

if 2016 taught us anything it’s the fact

that an outsider with a powerful voice

and a resonating message is a powerful

force to bear we just need to remember

Quinta Cicero’s first piece of advice to

his brother always remember what city

this is what you seek who you are as you

leave this conference and you go out

into your individual futures I want you

to remind yourselves I am an outsider I

seek to make a difference this is

America

thank you [Applause]

Please follow and like us: