Press "Enter" to skip to content

Are Museums and Galleries Moving? | Victoria Broackes & Geoffrey Marsh | TEDxCourtauldInstitute


well good afternoon everybody we hope to

give you a few things to think about and

I just wanted to say start starting off

that one of the strange things about

running a department of theater and

performance in a museum is that

obviously theater performance is always

changing in a frenetic pace politically

since we also include contemporary music

museums and galleries move may be a bit

slower but they’re changing as well and

that’s what we’re going to talk about

this morning speak about what we see as

a current movement in museums and

galleries and how that reflects changes

in the experience economy and the rest

of the world so just going to start by

giving some context about this

trajectory and then I’ll give some

examples of how this has come into our

work at the V&A so to start I think at

the moment for those of you I’ve been

unfamiliar with the Museum and gallery

world you could see the the personnel

may be divided into three groups a lot

of younger and particularly more

progressive curators I think in

following Bob Marley up here thinking

about what’s the promised land a

different sort of promised land perhaps

from what traditional museums have been

about thinking about museums as Civic

spaces places for debate much more

animated and engaging with much larger

audiences and I think there’s another

part of the community that wants to keep

museums just as they are that they’re

obviously very popular among certain

groups in society and and then to

perhaps to quote Russell there there’s

some people who prefer not to think

about the issues at all but we’re going

to force you to think about them this

morning so so I think what we really

want to focus on on on this morning

afternoon is the way that more types of

immersive exhibition making in museums

are changing the way not only way that

people use museums and visit them but

the way that the objects in them are

treated in a different way and of course

this is part of a much wider changes

that are going on in the end

Eggman twirled and I just put a few of

them up here and of course some of you

well maybe all of you have been to one

or other these so I’ll put the at the

top there punch-drunk

the theatre company has moved to

creating immersive theater experiences

we don’t go and sit in seats like this

and as people on the stage but the

audience is totally integrated into the

action that’s going around and I’m sure

some of you at least have been to secret

cinema which was established in 2007

which has changed the idea a cinema

going from again just watching the film

to the audience becoming part of the

film dressing up and so on and so forth

and more recently you can see that

moving into all sorts of other areas

particularly kind of gaming being turned

into a physical format with escape rooms

and the Crystal Maze being turned into a

live experience when you can actually go

and perform in your your own version of

a TV show

of course immersion by human beings in

in particular environments is nothing

new and you’ve been to Stonehenge will

know that no one really knows what

happened at Stonehenge Avebury come to

up with ideas and to catch of hulks I

think once said every generation gets a

Stonehenge it deserves but at the moment

there’s a sort of new ideas coming out

but he said she’s quite clear that at

some level it must have been a sort of

experience economy of the prehistoric

period this extraordinary structure that

was created over thousands of years

we’re clearly all sorts of activities

went on and the immersive economy has

you know followed through in religion

particularly over the centuries I think

one of the great turning points though

was the 1933 World Expo in Chicago

there’s a poster out there because on

the right is the man who went there Walt

Disney and he was so impressed by this

great concentration of what government’s

wanted to say about them that he dreamt

up the idea of a different sort of thing

an entertainment World Expo where the

audience instead of just trooping around

having told things by governments and so

forth would actually create a world that

was as much for the visitors as for the

the people and I think this what started

something which we can see increasingly

over the last

we’re in immersion into the kind of

experiences once upon a time was

controlled by the rich and powerful

things like coronations and that sort of

thing and then slowly what’s been coming

up is the idea that we the public have

as much right to decide what goes on as

being told what to do by those in

authority other things that have cropped

up this is a picture of the San

Francisco Exploratorium which opened in

1969 it’s difficult to imagine really

that this was the first Science Center

ever and now there’s literally hundreds

and hundreds of things where you can

immerse yourself in scientific

experiments and so forth and that’s

increasingly crossing over with the huge

development in video gaming over the

last thirty years to create new types of

experiences where the worlds of reality

and imagination cross over now of course

anything that’s changing society’s way

of making money and you can also see in

parallel the development of these sort

of immersive experiences both in retail

these huge mouths mile of America here

but obviously many others much closer to

home and also the development of themed

read themed catering this is a Hard Rock

Cafe founded in 1971 but its idea that

the experience of where you eat food is

almost as important as what you’re

putting in your mouth and then finally

there’s obviously the huge development

of cheap flights it’s difficult to

imagine that the first package holiday

was just over 50 years ago before that

time particularly as country you’re

really limited pretty much to going to

the coast of England and some of the

older ones in the room may remember

you’re only allowed to take fifty pounds

out of the country when you went abroad

when I was a teenager which limited what

you could do even if you did get abroad

but now you’ve got this huge idea of

flights weekend breaks and all the rest

of it which people just think it’s not

normal and coming out of that the sort

of Instagram culture where what you do

comes increasingly an important form of

who you are and this is paralleled by

the development of the technology and so

while music you may think of museums as

just think

things that have old objects in them and

historical art and all the rest of it

increasing if you look back over the

last 50 years you can see how the

changes in technology introductions of

computers or audio-visual materials have

fundamentally changed what you’re being

offered and I think we’re now coming to

a really key turning point because over

the next few years it’s quite clear that

there’s going to be a wave of augmented

reality mixed reality which alongside

virtual reality technology is going to

mean that within the museum world

instead of being limited in a sense by

what you’ve actually got in your

collection does huge potential to mix

together collections from around the

world but most importantly to move from

telling people about this material to

finding actually or audiences actually

want to hear so over the last few years

Vicky and I have been experimenting I

kind of guess when we started doing it

we didn’t actually think we were

experimenting in a series of exhibitions

that she’s going to talk about in a

minute where the key part of the if it

has been that alongside all the exhibits

and all the rest of it people being are

immersed and that’s obviously dependent

on technology and as with any other type

of technology at the moment there’s

always a question of it is it good or

bad so as a thought before Vicky starts

I think one of the my favorite books is

George Orwell’s in 1994 is also one of

David Bowie’s favorite books he wanted

to make a musical about it and so really

one of the key questions I think we’d

both like you to think about is if

museums are moving from just real things

to increasingly mix them up and with

technology is that a good thing is that

a bad thing who’s in control who’s using

that powerful what and finally I think I

just like to say is although the work

that we’ve done with David Bowie and

revolutions exhibition and the Pink

Floyd show that Vicki did people were

quite a lot of people said to me

certainly oh it’s very easy doing all

this with kind of popular culture and

recent things we some of you may know

we’ve recently just had an opera

exhibition hall at the V&A with a sound

experience in showing that you can

actually make immersive experiences

equally with historic subjects

so I think that’s the point on which I

will hand over the clicker the clicker

to me so how far can we go with this the

VNA was founded in 1857 conceived to

bring art and design to everyone but now

as well as being a magnet for artists

and designers it’s a venue for

interaction and as much a place for

entertainment as education so what is

the purpose of a museum today and how do

museums stay appealing in a competitive

marketplace but also maintain their

integrity we need to compete with all

the other attractions London and other

major cities have to offer so we’re

interested in understanding how we can

offer intelligent memorable experiences

and how we can communicate stories and

information in an engaging and

entertaining way increasingly that also

means in an emotional way a moving way

in recent years as mentioned by Jeff

we’ve curated three exhibitions David

Bowie is in 2013 you say you want a

revolution in 2016 and last year the

Pink Floyd exhibition in 2017 these

exhibitions take a broad approach we

don’t just explore music through the

sound or the lyrics or the instruments

we look at the wider social political

and cultural context with objects

spanning all our collection as fashion

film posters books art works and and of

course music I’ll now give you some

examples from each of these exhibitions

about how we brought these subjects to

life in what might previously have been

considered a quite a dry environment in

a museum

so in David Bowie we had the final show

moment conceived to show what an

incredible live performer he was we had

out loud music to replicate the communal

buzz and camaraderie of being at a

[Music]

[Music]

[Applause]

the thing was that in in most of the

exhibition people going around in their

own worlds wearing headphones but in

this bit they took their headphones off

and they listened with everybody else

and we found that in that area people

laughed they danced they sang and some

even cried but we mix this up with more

traditional moments such as when we

displayed the costume that David Bowie

wore for the Saturday Night Live show in

1979 and we put that with a design that

Bowie had sketched himself and we showed

it next to the Sonya Delauney costume

designs for Tristan Zara’s 1923 play the

gasps heart for which Bowie had taken

his inspiration and we also had a

photograph in elections of that original

production so along with Bowie’s own

performances it brought the whole thing

together and shed light on his

inspirations in you say you want a

revolution we had an area where we

wanted to evoke the experience of taking

LSD because LSD was such an important

part of this year in 1967 we were

showing the legendary UFO Club which was

a club in Tottenham Court Road a hotbed

of the underground and the

counterculture in 66 to 67 so to do that

we commissioned a new light show to show

the psychedelic effects of the light

shows that were shown in the club and on

your headphones who would have been

listening to Jefferson airplane’s White

Rabbit and we’d recorded that by Norah

Lee through a swinging microphone

literally swung around a microphone

heads to produce a sort of

disorientating effect that might conjure

something of the effects of LSD but

sometimes emotion can be very simple and

can just be about allowing people the

space to have their own moment with the

music and reflect on a way it makes them

feel we don’t need to tell people what

to feel so in the Pink Floyd exhibition

as an example we had a dark room

dedicated to the dark Dark Side of the

Moon album we simply had a spinning

hologram of a prism in there and the

music the album playing in its

entirety so what these examples show is

that museums have certainly evolved

alongside the experience economy

nowadays we try and turn what was once a

passive experience into an active one

provoking people to experience knowledge

rather than collect it we try and

encourage visitors to make connections

with the ideas not just with the objects

and the tone is much less formal and

educational it’s more of an exchange

where visitors own knowledge it’s just

as important as ours these changes do

seem to reflect a wider change in the

way people are acquiring information in

their daily lives now with social media

it’s more of an interactive process

people are active participants in the

discussion and debate and actually

exhibitions are the perfect embodiment

of our hyperlinked world they’re better

able to engage with multiple ideas sound

and visuals at once in a film or a play

or a book here you can see the bedroom

installation from a David Bowie is show

this was actually 35 separate pieces of

media gathered from inspirations for

Bowie things that he’d watched or film

of him as are projected onto 17 screens

which we then put into an imagined

setting of his bedroom that that’s a

sort of set of his bedroom showing what

he was sort of soaking up in those years

sorry and the exhibition allows the

audience to move at their own pace and

focus on the areas which which mean most

to them now bizarrely when we started

making exhibitions about music we work

really hard to persuade the artists that

they could be brought to life in a

museum and they weren’t sure but now the

industry approaches us music artists now

want to be in exhibitions because

museums are using techniques which are

now so successful at bringing

performances to life that exhibitions

might actually have become a viable

alternative to touring perhaps even a

better option to doing another reunion

show and as mentioned by Jeff we think

the developments in VR and AR could have

a big impact on museum displays in the

future you may have heard that a

hologram of Roy Orbison is about to go

on on tour to do a

series of concerts in the UK in this

preview photo you can see Roy backed by

the Royal Philharmonic Orchestra who are

actually on the stage with him

so to finish the experience economy has

changed what museums do and how they do

it especially when it comes to dynamic

subjects such as performance but also in

other areas like the model in our new

exhibition recently with the VR

experience at the same time we need to

make sure our exhibitions maintain their

integrity because we don’t want to risk

being a commercial vehicle for a music

label or an artist we need to be more

than that and offer something that

visitors don’t get anywhere else by

providing new insights original

scholarship a focus on process alongside

never already seen before objects and it

will be very interesting to see where

these developments take us in the future

not just for exhibitions and museums but

also for performers performances and

even plays without actors thank you very

much

you [Applause]

Please follow and like us: