Press "Enter" to skip to content

And Yet it Moves: Challenging Our Assumptions | Sarah Bloom Raskin | TEDxCharlottesville


and yet it moves Galileo

responded staring across the courtroom

at Pope Paul v who had brought the

weight of the Italian Inquisition down

on Galileo for contradicting what was

then a widely held belief that the earth

was fixed and everything rotated around

it well today we think of Galileo as the

father of the Scientific Revolution but

we forget that in the sixteenth century

Galileo was a heretic during his trial

when his accusers claimed that the earth

was fixed and everything revolved around

it Galileo said no it moves he

contradicted the strong precedent of the

day and yet in spite of what the learned

people were saying in spite of what the

texts were teaching Galileo had a

different view he had observed with his

own eyes something completely different

using his telescope he looked out to the

same sky that generations of people had

looked at before but he saw something

completely different and seeing what he

saw he produced for us a groundbreaking

truth that we are not the center of the

universe and for that he spent the rest

of his life under house arrest now how

do we embrace this Galilean spirit in

our own lives I think about it from one

dimension which is the dimension of the

economic policymaker

now of course economic policymaking is

rooted in a deep respect for facts and

analysis and the way it typically works

is that data is collected data is

aggregated data is analyzed theories are

produced and policy options are derived

from what that analysis looks like the

stream moves pretty steadily from data

to aggregation of data to facts to

analysis to policy options and in this

way economic theories are produced over

time the data changes new data points

emerge and yet these theories are still

in place and being looked at the same

way now the behavioral economists call

this confirmation bias right and this is

the phenomenon by which new data points

are emerging but it’s only the existing

theories that become the cornerstone of

what we believe signs may be pointing a

different way but we toss them aside if

we have confirmation bias because we

believe that they are not supporting the

theories that we hold this of course has

big consequences for economic

policymakers because if we don’t pull in

the new data points the signs along the

path what are we doing in terms of

optimizing our policy prescriptions so

we think about I’m thinking about how to

combat this confirmation bias what can

we do to avoid it well we start by

taking on a disposition of observing

more around us and

experiencing data in a way perhaps that

were not that accustomed to a new way a

way in which we actually attempt to

immerse ourselves in the problems at

hand now think about it traditional data

has a very hard time quantifying the

human toll of say a financial crisis for

example how do we quantify the stress

involved in losing a home how do we

quantify the anxiety that’s produced in

looking for a new job how do we quantify

the pressure that you feel in figuring

out which debts you’re going to pay off

first the importance of embracing though

these unquantifiable datasets it’s

absolutely imperative if we’re going to

create policy options that work for

people now of course everybody in this

room you know does different things

people are creating and designing

products services policies creations

that impact human people that is the

point but as we do this effort what is

it that we’re choosing to bring in to

our observation set to actually create

optimal products services policies for

others well I think about it

from a couple of angles and here are a

couple of anecdotes that come to mind

for me so it’s 2008 and it is the midst

of the mortgage crisis people are losing

homes people are being laid off

businesses aren’t hiring there’s a

general stay

of of confusion of despair confidence is

low but the general feeling is that

we’re going to get over this crisis that

it’s a contained event a self-contained

event well I’m driving to Baltimore

because at that time I’m the

commissioner of financial regulation for

the state of Maryland and I find when

I’m driving this particular route I

always pass a certain intersection and I

never get through the green light I’m

always stuck for whatever reason at the

red light and when I get stuck there one

day in I notice telephone poles and I’m

the telephone poles I see a couple of

those signs and I think oh that’s

interesting I do not sure I saw those

signs yesterday but I definitely see

three signs today and these are signs

like you know 1-800 need help 1-800 need

cash 1-800 cellhouse those kinds of

signs anyway the next day driving again

to Baltimore passing the same

intersection stopped at the same red

light and I look around and actually the

three signs have become six signs there

are now six signs on these poles and I

think that’s really interesting but

again the same exact character of the

signs next day the number of signs

increases by the end of the week the

telephone poles are completely blanketed

with these signs

and I’m thinking what does this mean

what does this mean about whether or not

our financial crisis is going to be

contained and what it meant and what I

took from it to mean was that there was

a general sense that systems weren’t

working for people that the usual

mechanisms by which people would be able

to recover from our crisis actually

we’re not operating well and people were

turning to places that actually

generally don’t do them any good at all

but needed a place where they could

start to understand how to restructure

their mortgage how to actually talk to

their banker

how it should get themselves back on

their feet after having lost a job

another example so it’s 2012 and I’m

again in my car this time I’m driving to

the Federal Reserve Board in Washington

and as I am driving they’re thinking

through actually our aggregate data sets

which produce for us a sense of

unemployment figures statistics about

labor market mobility and typically

we’re feeling like the number of jobs is

increasing and this is a good thing we

are moving through the crisis the number

of jobs is increasing that as a good

thing people have more spending power

people firms are hiring and I’m feeling

actually ok but as I’m driving in I pass

another sign it’s not one of these 1-800

signs this time it’s a sign that says

job fair this way and it’s a sign that I

think you know I’m gonna go check out

this job fair and see what it’s all

about and so I follow the signs and they

leave me to our local Community College

which in fact is having a job fair right

in its cafeteria so I get out of my car

go into the cafeteria and start to you

know start to scope out the jobs that

are being offered at this particular

fair and thinking I’m gonna use this as

a good opportunity to actually you know

count count different kinds of jobs well

immediately I see that the jobs being

offered actually fall into particular

buckets there’s a whole host of booths

that are set up to offer people jobs as

restaurant workers it’s another set of

booths being set up or that are set up

for offering people jobs in the military

and there’s a third set of booths that

seem to be focused on swimming pools

turns out that there was seem to be high

demand for lifeguards and didn’t think

of you know being a lifeguard required

a college degree but hey there were

three these were the kinds of jobs that

I thought I saw being offered and I I

thought this is this is not a

particularly great sign that these are

the jobs being offered and I decide I’m

gonna leave the job fair and start to

start to walk out and as I do something

catches my eye which is a sign on a

booth that says IT jobs jobs of the

future and I thought yes of course this

is really the kind of job that I would

imagine would be a job that would be

sustaining a job that is a career a job

that actually people are looking for I

approached the booth and actually the

woman a woman comes out from behind the

booth and says are you looking for a job

and I said well yes I guess I guess I am

and she said okay well are you ready to

submit your resume to our database and I

said your database the way you apply for

a job is she said you put your resume

into our database and we’ll contact you

if we’re able to make a match and I said

make a match she said yeah well the

resume that you put into the database

gets screened by an algorithm and we

determine whether the features of your

resume will match a government contract

that we’re pursuing I thought wow I mean

this really isn’t what I thought the

labor market was looking like I said oh

do I then have the opportunity to put my

resume into many different databases and

she said oh no can’t do that one

database you choose one database because

you’re gonna sign to sign up you know a

binding letter of intent that you have

only applied to one database and and you

will wait to hear and I said oh well he

told me a little bit about the salary

and she said well it’s not an annual

salary we pay by the hour and I said

benefits she said well the benefits you

know folded into what we pay by the hour

so this turned out to be an important

set of signals to me these signals were

signals that actually more than the

quantity of jobs mattered for our

aggregate data set it’s the quality of

the jobs and there was also a light that

was that that I I saw enhanced in this

experience which of course was this

notion of discouraged workers workers

who realized that the job market is too

burdensome to actually try to navigate

or that the jobs themselves were really

not worth pursuing in terms of being

able to move back into the labor force

so again an example of seeing something

that enhanced the dataset enhanced the

way in which we are looking at what

typically our theories so data

aggregation actually presents a set of

challenges for policy makers and it’s

Galileo really who reminds us of the

power of observation and the power of

bringing in new data to enhance the

development of theory and then the

ultimate policy decision making in this

way the routine is actually

revolutionary so you know today for

example here we all are in this

beautiful space being able to think big

thoughts from diverse fields in a

multidisciplinary open way challenging

new questions but when we leave here

when we step outside this beautiful

space and look to the sky

or look around us what data points will

we absorb what data points will we

choose to challenge our own deeply held assumptions and beliefs thank you

Please follow and like us: