
then
day as you know
but not to run too fast I’ll talk to you
media therefore means that they do not speak
of the poor, I will certainly speak of them
poor because in some way of proof
he’s talking a lot about it, even if it’s done
a little matera a however of the rich in
relationship to the middle class I will not do the
relation to Italy of which we have
little talked so far
I would like to start with this statement
with this thing that will be written a lot
long ago by an economist who perhaps is
been underestimated but deserve more
relevant to those that have been
recognized as you see wrote this
economist who is called a golden age
in 1984 then 31 years ago according to the
conventional wisdom the middle class e
the glue that he holds together with the company
if this is true then ours
society is draining this writes the
bull contains a clear statement the
middle class and considered the glue
in the society the middle class
considered the glue of the company e
contains an implicit statement that
is that for which the middle class
it is somehow losing ground yes
he referred to the United States among themselves with
this statement of this problem
reduction of shrinkage if
you also want the disappearance in the
more extreme versions of the middle class
many occupy the dead are occupied
the first problem we have however of
define the middle class and then that of
measure it what the middle class is
how much income how much wealth it shares
what does his well-being represent?
how things are going
here we have to consider that the
term middle class has done its own
entry into the panorama of the notions
useful for understanding stratification
of the inequality of the xix
century when the companies were a lot
simplified it was simplifying mine
time
the aristocracy at the top is something that is
he can call the proletariat at the base
arrival this class call it so of
bourgeois entrepreneurs who occupied this
huge space between so two extremes was
quite homogeneous inside
sufficiently different from the other two
the problem of identifying the class
average did not place things are a lot
more complicated
social stratification has become
a complex phenomenon and a recent one
research carried out in great britain
consulting
he was very very high of people he has
led to the conclusion that today
we live in a world with at least seven
social classes from the beginning you see the
middle class well summer the middle class
technique up to precarious or
precarious and making proletariat
extremely difficult to answer
question where the middle class is in
this classification the problem is
complicated by the fact that as it turns out
well from that survey the variables in
basis to which we can consider
part or less of the middle class are
multiple are those of character
income and wealth
there are those that have to do with
the podium degree of education that we
economists that we love human capital but
you are also the kind of profession that
social relations are carried out of which
we have a variable that comes in
in the definition of class and therefore
middle class and also what is coming
called these cultural capital
variables can be combined in ways
very different in complex societies
that we live and create one
relevant complication to be able to
speak in an identified and well
precise middle class this explains
also because they are numerous
interviews that the vast majority
of the many people more than the ones
reason with peaks could be
considered middle class they think of themselves
same as being part of the middle class
let’s see for a moment how they are doing
economists my colleagues tend a
some simplify things then the
throw on the simple we only calculate
the income
obviously it is one
simplification but a simplification
it does not solve all the problems and that there
indeed, it returns many problems in each
case illuminates us a bit having said that
it was variable in front and income
we have solved a few problems we must
then define in terms of income where
is the middle class and here they are compared
various positions one that says the class
average and that which receives an income
which is higher than what it takes
20 percent poorer and lower than
what takes 20 percent more
rich in this idea then the class
average is a definite population and yes
thus expands the 16 depending on which the
income that perceives this
definite population go juice go down
compared to the total a vision
alternative is the one that says we fix
of the posts
income within these posts is there
middle class over there are the poor and
Ricchio how you want to call these
stakes are normally placed on the 25th
percent under 25 percent above
what is the median income ie the
income that divides the distribution into
250 percent and poorer than this
50 percent and richer and more income
this is another criterion in this
case then the stakes are fixed and yes
calculate how many people are inside
the middle class shrinks if less
people stay within this range
There are other criteria that tend in
simplified way to fix anyway
of the stakes trying to see how much
the middle class is far from the rich and
close to the poor
none of these criteria e
satisfactory, however, if we
we applied alitalia in the last twenty years
about years we will find that the middle class
and immovable these calculations that there
I introduce you to say, for example, that the
population share that in 1995 had
an income included in that interval
that I told you is little different from that
that’s in 2012 so apparently
there is mobility as it is apparent
immobility if we use the criterion of
how much income he received 60 percent
intermediate
the fact that it is still obviously not
it means that this represents
correctly the phenomenon of reality
that this indicator is immobile a
part that within this stillness there
they can be segments that move
in a very different way if obviously
also the fact that income is not
indicative of the state of well-being of
this segment of the population there
they are related problems as it is well known
the greater variability of income
there is a growing insecurity
problems that were previously mentioned
also from riccardo of loss of
prestige of some professions o
even of disappearance but anyway if
we use more sophisticated class measures
media based on the concept of
polarization we get to the result
what is the concept of
polarization and then go to check
if those who are down those who
they are very high up and they are more cohesive and
more homogeneous
and within them if this increases
degree of polarization means that yes
empty the center that is to say that the
middle class
loses ground you make more calculations
sophisticated based on this
indicator and it can also be established if
each of us who today occupies a certain
position in the income scale with the
same income which currently doing
due proportion would have occupied
from the same position as yesterday
or a worse position in the
income scale and it turns out that many
would occupy a worse position
so this means that we have a
more sophisticated indicator and more
credible for the retreat of the one who
we can consider it in various ways
middle class
with this exercise we discover
clearly that the distances between that
which we call middle class and the top
and bottom ie the vertex of the part
low have changed and turned away the
the distance from the top has grown and it is
reduced the distance from the bottom
we see some data we have them
already seen before
these are the data of how it has evolved
the bang of a series of countries not
only in the United States of which
we talked so far is too much for one
a hundred of income, that is, as predicted
national share and national radio that
flows one percent richer from the
1980 to today sees that decade later
decade
this share grows almost everywhere
the United States and Great Britain are
on the right are even explosives of
widely in Italy does not pass it
so bad if this is a measure of
the Scandinavian countries are also successful
see sweden there is a deterioration
remarkable
the two countries that somehow
contain this phenomenon are the
France and the Netherlands for reasons that do not exist
I’m here I can not tell you
let us pause, however, on Italy and on
united states for an instructive comparison
these are the odds of income
which was not a percent in 1980 in
2007 in Italy it goes from 6.9 to 9.9
it is a substantial increase almost 50 per
a hundred more that goes to this category
of people in the United States is
enormously more we have done two
calculations to give you an idea of what you are doing
is
here what is the average income
one percent and the average income of
rest of the population
there are 180 and in 2007 these are given
true that is, data are drawn from
investigations we have available
in 1980 the United States income
average of who had been part not for
one hundred more than that 355 thousand dollars in
1900 2007 had become more than one
million dollars so it was
practically tripled in Italy was 94
thousand euros and has become 180 thousand euros
which means that more or less it is
income doubled in the meantime
you see it in the lower part
of the table in the United States is
passed from 43 and 57 with an increase of
32 7 percent in Italy from 13 to 18
with a minimum of 34 of 21 make the accounts
of which of what has increased in
absolute terms the difference between
this average income of the top income
it is however a simple indicator is
to ask how much average income
they wanted to make a single income
percent and it has moved to Italy from
6.8 average incomes for top income
per cent to as much as 10 so this video a
half the distances
obviously in that 99 percent there is not
only the middle class are there too
those who are lower
however this is a very indicator
precise of how they are removed
distances and we do some zooming
from my class of course we can
even going out someone if you remember that
from the middle class you succeed as for
mitigate the severity of the problem
for example, if you remember jordan belfort
who is said to be a former member of the
middle class grew up to two accountants
in a small bayside apartment a
queens to 26 years alive the revenge of
brokerage and began to earn
49 million dollars and angry for
the fact that 49 to less than 52 and therefore
it does not even reach a million
dollars a week this like
you will know you can imagine taken from the tea
wall street a wall street but it is
this image is absolutely realistic
for the many that for the few who succeed
to go out to the side there are many that
the many who regress and remain
we must ask ourselves what the mechanism is
which produces these effects beyond
of things that have already been said
certainly a mechanism is what
will produce domestic produced enterprises
that shift of income from everyone
others to managers this has happened is
happened because inside the
enterprises the power is distributed
otherwise recent studies also of the
monetary fund then of organizations
let’s say they should not have one
particular a particular liking for
the middle class show that where
for example, power has been weakened
of the unions or has changed works the
role of the union occurred one
shift of income towards the part
high in distribution but I do not want to
talk about this also because the first one
from this chart you have already seen
which showed riccardo then a
small doubling of this graphic
the idea is the relationship between how much
earn CEOs and
how much does a worker earn?
American companies from 65 to 2008 speak
of another thing that I want to talk about
public sector in Italy then a
small detail but very relevant
here we find data that we have
elaborated on a relationship between the gain
let’s say about a rich manager
represented load in the sense that
earn a high income p 95 in
this chart is one of a worker
of the average public administration p50
it is one that stood down p25
the red one represents the relationship between
how much earns manager who earns
more and what is lower is
the blue one instead the relationship of
top manager is the middle one you see
that there is a strong trend e
significant to the aggravation of the
sequences within the administration
public where there is a large part of
middle class for many reasons in Italy
within the public sector with
all the professions you can imagine
a second important point is
undervalued but that in my opinion a lot
relevant is how you enter the market
of work and where it is placed when
you enter the labor market
many are placed directly in the
middle class that you enjoy are placed
much below which we have calculated
income wages depend on entry
in three generations and we have seen in the
six years after entering as it is
they went their income so they are three
short invitation to look at the panel
right that refers only to graduates
the most damaged of this from this
phenomenon that I am about to say
the blue line represents income
entry therefore in year zero and the
their growth for the next six years
at the entrance for those born in the 65s 69
the other two lines represent the
same data for those born in 70 74 in 74
79
how you see the difference is
generations are significant and significant
successive graduates enter with a
lowest wage in absolute terms e
have career years 56 years in which the
distances respect how to call them to them
older brothers to their fathers tend
to increase that I want to say that if
someone on the blue line a lot on the
blue line were just middle class
enter the labor market today
many of these are not middle class in
based on the definition we can
give therefore there is a problem
very impressive that affects above all
graduates the same data referred to
lower educational qualifications give one
very minor difference the children of the
middle class are often one graduates
of the assets of the middle class is the
qualification if it is treated in
this way in an era in which however
we speak of human capital as in the
bigger than the really terrible assets
as we often say we talk a lot about
sustainable development has never been done
such a significant damage to the environment
as now we talk a lot about capital
human and it is rather bad in
this era
let’s go briefly to search for
explanations where we can look for them
I emphasized the correlation between the
concentration at the top and the worsening
of the middle class
but this concentration too much to what it is
due
it is primarily due to our opinion
to the distorted competition is not the
market as such
it works like we want to do it
work and therefore the reasons for the
which produce huge incomes
within the markets is the result of
some rules that we give could
keep you long if you have some
minute more on this aspect la
I do not know a single example the
methods through which they come
allowed or not allowed terminated
access barriers to certain
professions are relevant to the
the formation of income is not just one
question then of technology is not
just a question of
globalization the proof lies in the fact
that countries exposed to the same risks as
globalization and financialization
of technological change have
very different inequality means
which have operating rules of the
the second point is very different markets
the business calendar is
changed the distribution of power e
therefore those have become more powerful
who have higher incomes and one
precision multiply their position
the third question was limited to
distribution that is implemented by the
welfare state both on the revenue side
because the taxes have become less
progressive both on the side of ease
of access of many middle class and the
fruition of a series of services of the
web that were previously free or
free that they are now subjected to
evidence of the selectivity means that in
somehow they damage this segment
of the population
an extreme case has already been mentioned by
riccardo is the winner that
it takes all markets in which it is
states only one bidder we see
so that manages to cover 80 90 per
one hundred of the market outfits has nothing to do with it
technology but also centers the way in
which are distributed among those who
participates in the production process i
fruits of the result allowed by the
technology a problem of the rights of
properties we could say and then there is one
another aspect, the decision goes because you
a little while ago the small middle class
patrimonies to small riches if
the rate of return increases with the
wealth inequalities, distances
from the middle class the top increase not
because of course the value is in mind
absolute moment also in terms
related is a small fruit heritage
3 percent
and 10 percent fruit the distance is
they widen what would happen if
continue like this we often talk about
growth as a solution to problems
we did two calculations suppose
miraculously that Italy takes to
grow at the rate of 2 percent and lo
I do for 18 years so for one
unlimited time at the end of these 18
years
suppose we ask ourselves how we are
distributed this fruit of growth
imagining that it is distributed as yes
it is distributed in the country he has known
the aggression of the 90s the years
2000 the United States a non-percent of
two thirds growth to the remaining 99 for
one hundred percent of growth
the outcome would be after 18 years of this
extraordinary growth that at 99 per
a hundred the rest of 99 percent of the
income would grow only by one
they put 15 percent that many want
say 300 euros a month in the meantime the
remaining 1 percent would have seen
grow the radio prize of 130 for
one hundred and with these results yes
it would win in our country alone
about a third of national god terror
it’s a scenario I think enough
dramatic what can be done
you can certainly make interventions
policy is not written in the book of
history that things should go like this
but what an obstacle is a strong obstacle
strong and culture expressed by positions
like this this is the position of
martin feldstein who was a councilor
of reagan that has an enormous diffusion
even in our country
this statement of substance says the
problem is poverty is not the
inequality which means that the
middle class
it will only become a problem when
will have become poor there is someone who
he thinks differently and claims that
this will never happen because the middle
class is too big to fail us there
we trust we do not trust this act of
optimism in any case concludes ray not
a nice question mark
thank you
[Applause]
day as you know
but not to run too fast I’ll talk to you
media therefore means that they do not speak
of the poor, I will certainly speak of them
poor because in some way of proof
he’s talking a lot about it, even if it’s done
a little matera a however of the rich in
relationship to the middle class I will not do the
relation to Italy of which we have
little talked so far
I would like to start with this statement
with this thing that will be written a lot
long ago by an economist who perhaps is
been underestimated but deserve more
relevant to those that have been
recognized as you see wrote this
economist who is called a golden age
in 1984 then 31 years ago according to the
conventional wisdom the middle class e
the glue that he holds together with the company
if this is true then ours
society is draining this writes the
bull contains a clear statement the
middle class and considered the glue
in the society the middle class
considered the glue of the company e
contains an implicit statement that
is that for which the middle class
it is somehow losing ground yes
he referred to the United States among themselves with
this statement of this problem
reduction of shrinkage if
you also want the disappearance in the
more extreme versions of the middle class
many occupy the dead are occupied
the first problem we have however of
define the middle class and then that of
measure it what the middle class is
how much income how much wealth it shares
what does his well-being represent?
how things are going
here we have to consider that the
term middle class has done its own
entry into the panorama of the notions
useful for understanding stratification
of the inequality of the xix
century when the companies were a lot
simplified it was simplifying mine
time
the aristocracy at the top is something that is
he can call the proletariat at the base
arrival this class call it so of
bourgeois entrepreneurs who occupied this
huge space between so two extremes was
quite homogeneous inside
sufficiently different from the other two
the problem of identifying the class
average did not place things are a lot
more complicated
social stratification has become
a complex phenomenon and a recent one
research carried out in great britain
consulting
he was very very high of people he has
led to the conclusion that today
we live in a world with at least seven
social classes from the beginning you see the
middle class well summer the middle class
technique up to precarious or
precarious and making proletariat
extremely difficult to answer
question where the middle class is in
this classification the problem is
complicated by the fact that as it turns out
well from that survey the variables in
basis to which we can consider
part or less of the middle class are
multiple are those of character
income and wealth
there are those that have to do with
the podium degree of education that we
economists that we love human capital but
you are also the kind of profession that
social relations are carried out of which
we have a variable that comes in
in the definition of class and therefore
middle class and also what is coming
called these cultural capital
variables can be combined in ways
very different in complex societies
that we live and create one
relevant complication to be able to
speak in an identified and well
precise middle class this explains
also because they are numerous
interviews that the vast majority
of the many people more than the ones
reason with peaks could be
considered middle class they think of themselves
same as being part of the middle class
let’s see for a moment how they are doing
economists my colleagues tend a
some simplify things then the
throw on the simple we only calculate
the income
obviously it is one
simplification but a simplification
it does not solve all the problems and that there
indeed, it returns many problems in each
case illuminates us a bit having said that
it was variable in front and income
we have solved a few problems we must
then define in terms of income where
is the middle class and here they are compared
various positions one that says the class
average and that which receives an income
which is higher than what it takes
20 percent poorer and lower than
what takes 20 percent more
rich in this idea then the class
average is a definite population and yes
thus expands the 16 depending on which the
income that perceives this
definite population go juice go down
compared to the total a vision
alternative is the one that says we fix
of the posts
income within these posts is there
middle class over there are the poor and
Ricchio how you want to call these
stakes are normally placed on the 25th
percent under 25 percent above
what is the median income ie the
income that divides the distribution into
250 percent and poorer than this
50 percent and richer and more income
this is another criterion in this
case then the stakes are fixed and yes
calculate how many people are inside
the middle class shrinks if less
people stay within this range
There are other criteria that tend in
simplified way to fix anyway
of the stakes trying to see how much
the middle class is far from the rich and
close to the poor
none of these criteria e
satisfactory, however, if we
we applied alitalia in the last twenty years
about years we will find that the middle class
and immovable these calculations that there
I introduce you to say, for example, that the
population share that in 1995 had
an income included in that interval
that I told you is little different from that
that’s in 2012 so apparently
there is mobility as it is apparent
immobility if we use the criterion of
how much income he received 60 percent
intermediate
the fact that it is still obviously not
it means that this represents
correctly the phenomenon of reality
that this indicator is immobile a
part that within this stillness there
they can be segments that move
in a very different way if obviously
also the fact that income is not
indicative of the state of well-being of
this segment of the population there
they are related problems as it is well known
the greater variability of income
there is a growing insecurity
problems that were previously mentioned
also from riccardo of loss of
prestige of some professions o
even of disappearance but anyway if
we use more sophisticated class measures
media based on the concept of
polarization we get to the result
what is the concept of
polarization and then go to check
if those who are down those who
they are very high up and they are more cohesive and
more homogeneous
and within them if this increases
degree of polarization means that yes
empty the center that is to say that the
middle class
loses ground you make more calculations
sophisticated based on this
indicator and it can also be established if
each of us who today occupies a certain
position in the income scale with the
same income which currently doing
due proportion would have occupied
from the same position as yesterday
or a worse position in the
income scale and it turns out that many
would occupy a worse position
so this means that we have a
more sophisticated indicator and more
credible for the retreat of the one who
we can consider it in various ways
middle class
with this exercise we discover
clearly that the distances between that
which we call middle class and the top
and bottom ie the vertex of the part
low have changed and turned away the
the distance from the top has grown and it is
reduced the distance from the bottom
we see some data we have them
already seen before
these are the data of how it has evolved
the bang of a series of countries not
only in the United States of which
we talked so far is too much for one
a hundred of income, that is, as predicted
national share and national radio that
flows one percent richer from the
1980 to today sees that decade later
decade
this share grows almost everywhere
the United States and Great Britain are
on the right are even explosives of
widely in Italy does not pass it
so bad if this is a measure of
the Scandinavian countries are also successful
see sweden there is a deterioration
remarkable
the two countries that somehow
contain this phenomenon are the
France and the Netherlands for reasons that do not exist
I’m here I can not tell you
let us pause, however, on Italy and on
united states for an instructive comparison
these are the odds of income
which was not a percent in 1980 in
2007 in Italy it goes from 6.9 to 9.9
it is a substantial increase almost 50 per
a hundred more that goes to this category
of people in the United States is
enormously more we have done two
calculations to give you an idea of what you are doing
is
here what is the average income
one percent and the average income of
rest of the population
there are 180 and in 2007 these are given
true that is, data are drawn from
investigations we have available
in 1980 the United States income
average of who had been part not for
one hundred more than that 355 thousand dollars in
1900 2007 had become more than one
million dollars so it was
practically tripled in Italy was 94
thousand euros and has become 180 thousand euros
which means that more or less it is
income doubled in the meantime
you see it in the lower part
of the table in the United States is
passed from 43 and 57 with an increase of
32 7 percent in Italy from 13 to 18
with a minimum of 34 of 21 make the accounts
of which of what has increased in
absolute terms the difference between
this average income of the top income
it is however a simple indicator is
to ask how much average income
they wanted to make a single income
percent and it has moved to Italy from
6.8 average incomes for top income
per cent to as much as 10 so this video a
half the distances
obviously in that 99 percent there is not
only the middle class are there too
those who are lower
however this is a very indicator
precise of how they are removed
distances and we do some zooming
from my class of course we can
even going out someone if you remember that
from the middle class you succeed as for
mitigate the severity of the problem
for example, if you remember jordan belfort
who is said to be a former member of the
middle class grew up to two accountants
in a small bayside apartment a
queens to 26 years alive the revenge of
brokerage and began to earn
49 million dollars and angry for
the fact that 49 to less than 52 and therefore
it does not even reach a million
dollars a week this like
you will know you can imagine taken from the tea
wall street a wall street but it is
this image is absolutely realistic
for the many that for the few who succeed
to go out to the side there are many that
the many who regress and remain
we must ask ourselves what the mechanism is
which produces these effects beyond
of things that have already been said
certainly a mechanism is what
will produce domestic produced enterprises
that shift of income from everyone
others to managers this has happened is
happened because inside the
enterprises the power is distributed
otherwise recent studies also of the
monetary fund then of organizations
let’s say they should not have one
particular a particular liking for
the middle class show that where
for example, power has been weakened
of the unions or has changed works the
role of the union occurred one
shift of income towards the part
high in distribution but I do not want to
talk about this also because the first one
from this chart you have already seen
which showed riccardo then a
small doubling of this graphic
the idea is the relationship between how much
earn CEOs and
how much does a worker earn?
American companies from 65 to 2008 speak
of another thing that I want to talk about
public sector in Italy then a
small detail but very relevant
here we find data that we have
elaborated on a relationship between the gain
let’s say about a rich manager
represented load in the sense that
earn a high income p 95 in
this chart is one of a worker
of the average public administration p50
it is one that stood down p25
the red one represents the relationship between
how much earns manager who earns
more and what is lower is
the blue one instead the relationship of
top manager is the middle one you see
that there is a strong trend e
significant to the aggravation of the
sequences within the administration
public where there is a large part of
middle class for many reasons in Italy
within the public sector with
all the professions you can imagine
a second important point is
undervalued but that in my opinion a lot
relevant is how you enter the market
of work and where it is placed when
you enter the labor market
many are placed directly in the
middle class that you enjoy are placed
much below which we have calculated
income wages depend on entry
in three generations and we have seen in the
six years after entering as it is
they went their income so they are three
short invitation to look at the panel
right that refers only to graduates
the most damaged of this from this
phenomenon that I am about to say
the blue line represents income
entry therefore in year zero and the
their growth for the next six years
at the entrance for those born in the 65s 69
the other two lines represent the
same data for those born in 70 74 in 74
79
how you see the difference is
generations are significant and significant
successive graduates enter with a
lowest wage in absolute terms e
have career years 56 years in which the
distances respect how to call them to them
older brothers to their fathers tend
to increase that I want to say that if
someone on the blue line a lot on the
blue line were just middle class
enter the labor market today
many of these are not middle class in
based on the definition we can
give therefore there is a problem
very impressive that affects above all
graduates the same data referred to
lower educational qualifications give one
very minor difference the children of the
middle class are often one graduates
of the assets of the middle class is the
qualification if it is treated in
this way in an era in which however
we speak of human capital as in the
bigger than the really terrible assets
as we often say we talk a lot about
sustainable development has never been done
such a significant damage to the environment
as now we talk a lot about capital
human and it is rather bad in
this era
let’s go briefly to search for
explanations where we can look for them
I emphasized the correlation between the
concentration at the top and the worsening
of the middle class
but this concentration too much to what it is
due
it is primarily due to our opinion
to the distorted competition is not the
market as such
it works like we want to do it
work and therefore the reasons for the
which produce huge incomes
within the markets is the result of
some rules that we give could
keep you long if you have some
minute more on this aspect la
I do not know a single example the
methods through which they come
allowed or not allowed terminated
access barriers to certain
professions are relevant to the
the formation of income is not just one
question then of technology is not
just a question of
globalization the proof lies in the fact
that countries exposed to the same risks as
globalization and financialization
of technological change have
very different inequality means
which have operating rules of the
the second point is very different markets
the business calendar is
changed the distribution of power e
therefore those have become more powerful
who have higher incomes and one
precision multiply their position
the third question was limited to
distribution that is implemented by the
welfare state both on the revenue side
because the taxes have become less
progressive both on the side of ease
of access of many middle class and the
fruition of a series of services of the
web that were previously free or
free that they are now subjected to
evidence of the selectivity means that in
somehow they damage this segment
of the population
an extreme case has already been mentioned by
riccardo is the winner that
it takes all markets in which it is
states only one bidder we see
so that manages to cover 80 90 per
one hundred of the market outfits has nothing to do with it
technology but also centers the way in
which are distributed among those who
participates in the production process i
fruits of the result allowed by the
technology a problem of the rights of
properties we could say and then there is one
another aspect, the decision goes because you
a little while ago the small middle class
patrimonies to small riches if
the rate of return increases with the
wealth inequalities, distances
from the middle class the top increase not
because of course the value is in mind
absolute moment also in terms
related is a small fruit heritage
3 percent
and 10 percent fruit the distance is
they widen what would happen if
continue like this we often talk about
growth as a solution to problems
we did two calculations suppose
miraculously that Italy takes to
grow at the rate of 2 percent and lo
I do for 18 years so for one
unlimited time at the end of these 18
years
suppose we ask ourselves how we are
distributed this fruit of growth
imagining that it is distributed as yes
it is distributed in the country he has known
the aggression of the 90s the years
2000 the United States a non-percent of
two thirds growth to the remaining 99 for
one hundred percent of growth
the outcome would be after 18 years of this
extraordinary growth that at 99 per
a hundred the rest of 99 percent of the
income would grow only by one
they put 15 percent that many want
say 300 euros a month in the meantime the
remaining 1 percent would have seen
grow the radio prize of 130 for
one hundred and with these results yes
it would win in our country alone
about a third of national god terror
it’s a scenario I think enough
dramatic what can be done
you can certainly make interventions
policy is not written in the book of
history that things should go like this
but what an obstacle is a strong obstacle
strong and culture expressed by positions
like this this is the position of
martin feldstein who was a councilor
of reagan that has an enormous diffusion
even in our country
this statement of substance says the
problem is poverty is not the
inequality which means that the
middle class
it will only become a problem when
will have become poor there is someone who
he thinks differently and claims that
this will never happen because the middle
class is too big to fail us there
we trust we do not trust this act of
optimism in any case concludes ray not
a nice question mark
thank you
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: