Press "Enter" to skip to content

An Optimistic View on Cancer | Erika Newman | TEDxUofM


what comes to mind when you hear the

word cancer what lives in your head

about cancer is it fear if so fear of

what chemotherapy surgery radiation hair

loss pain does it make you think about

loved ones a parent a partner a sibling

do you think about children unborn

children children dying death and dying

from cancer it makes me think about

these children these children are all

sisters and brothers or first cousins

and all of their fathers several of

their mothers and many of them died of

cancer the team girl in the middle is my

mother my mother and two of her brothers

were diagnosed with cancer and died so

when I think about cancer I think about

my mother and my uncles and the

destruction of a family by cancer this

also comes to mind when I think about

cancer my background is that I’m a

pediatric surgeon and my passion my

clinical niche is caring for kids with

cancer in the most technical sense I

remove tumors from the chest and abdomen

of small babies and children so when I

think about cancer I think of the

disruption that it causes to the lives

of my patients and their families and

all those things that you are feeling I

feel them to sadness anger fear but

those are not my only reactions to the

word cancer I am mostly inspired when I

hear that word I am overcome with an

enormous sense of ambition and intention

it is a trigger word for me it incites

me I think it is because of my family

history with this disease and it is also

because of this child this is an x-ray

of a ten year old who developed a cough

that didn’t go away and after multiple

visits to and from emergency departments

an emergency room doctor obtained this

chest x-ray it shows a space occupying

mass in the right chest it’s

neuroblastoma the most common cancer

outside of the brain and children it is

a cancer of the nervous tissue

apparently in the adrenal gland or

nervous tissue of the neck chest abdomen

or pelvis and as a senior trainee in

pediatric surgery I was consciously this

patient and his mother and when we

explained to his mother that in order to

give him his best shot at survival we

needed to try to remove the mass but in

doing so we could harm his lungs his

heart and the major blood vessels to and

from his brain his mother was overcome

with grief when we made it to the

operating room just as we were about to

make the opening incision my mentor

looked up to me and said this tumor is

coming out today let’s go it was us

against the most natural of disasters an

anatomic catastrophe invading the

delicate organs of a small child

threatening his hope for a future we

were awakened and inspired by a survival

and by his life and seven hours later

there was out of his chest and on its

way to the pathologist for review we

then had the privilege of going out to

the waiting room and celebrating with

his mother that we have removed the

tumor in its entirety without any damage

to any normal structures this time his

mother was overcome with joy the next

morning our young patient had many

questions for us when could he eat when

would the tubes come out what about

school what about basketball could

friends visit and then in a most

composed and courageous way he looked

right at me and said what causes

neuroblastoma and why do I have it and

is there a cure those questions changed

me they changed me because we had no

answers we don’t know what causes this

cancer and to look into the hopeful eyes

of a ten-year-old and saying in all of

modern medicine no you are not cured

it’s deeply troubling and I couldn’t do

it and in that quiet moment of questions

in chaos the dream was shaped I could

see it I could feel it among all the

patients and all the problems this was

it there was something special about

this problem something about this cave

that grabs me and wouldn’t let go you

see what he had just taught us was yeah

we could diagnose the complex problem

perform an elegant operation safely but

there remained the fact that cancer

would recur and neuroblastoma was likely

still lurking in his blood vessels and

in his lymph nodes that fact we didn’t

change not with our surgery and not with

chemotherapy therefore his direct

questions and his curiosity had just

reminded us this was not enough it was

not enough because he was not cured and

in our conversations with him what

happened and maybe this has happened to

you too I realized that in order to

stand in this full space this full space

of healing we really needed to be open

to what was in fact an evolution we had

to flat-out accept the challenge receive

the directive to not just stay on the

field but

take up the battle in that moment and

probably many others prior to that led

to this my goal and my dream is to cure

cancer my team and I have set out to

make discoveries and to develop a cancer

treatment that will obtain curative

outcomes for children with neuroblastoma

I accept responsibility and

accountability for this problem it is a

part of me I think about it when i wake

up in the morning and i think about it

before i go to sleep at night the

message from that young patient was this

why aren’t we aspiring for the

extraordinary and couldn’t we at least

try isn’t that all we can do is take

clues from our personal and professional

experiences and allow them to move us to

inspire us maybe it is about freeing

ourselves in those magical moments and

allowing the disruption in the chaos to

set our goals to drive us to our purpose

I did that for neuroblastoma and when I

did that you know what I found that it

is the absolute perfect cancer to study

poised for a curative discovery here’s

an example of why cancer is no longer a

secret because the entire human genome

has been mapped we know what normal

looks like and we also know what the

cancer genome looks like so cancer

researchers have been discovering all

the DNA mutations that turn a normal

cell into a tumor cell there has never

been a more exciting time to study

cancer and what is even more compelling

about neuroblastoma which is why we need

to do this work right now is that unlike

most cancers only a few DNA alterations

have been discovered in neuroblastoma

tumors even more exciting the presence

of these DNA alterations are the single

most

predictor as to whether or not children

with neuroblastoma would die could this

mean that if we understand how DNA

alterations leads to chemotherapy

resistance could that be a clue and

carry neuroblastoma DNA is the heart of

a tumor cell we know that mutations

happen when DNA damage occurs DNA damage

from normal metabolic processes UV light

and chemotherapy chemotherapy causes DNA

damage in DNA strand breaks and the cell

responds by either repairing its DNA or

instructing selda could it be that the

road or the answer or perhaps even our

hypothesis is that a tumor cell gains

resistance by repairing its own DNA we

already know that resistant tumors the

ones that relapse somehow figure out a

way to patch up their DNA so our lab is

interested in these very special tumor

cells the ones that can recognize the

broken DNA and a fish efficiently put

the ends back together again we think

this allows the tumor to grow imagine if

that is the missing puzzle tumor cells

with a special ability to repair their

own DNA imagine further that we could

block that process if we are right

perhaps children no longer dying of

neuroblastoma and if we are wrong then

we are positioned to be guided to the

next question to do this we have

assembled an interdisciplinary

multidisciplinary team and we have rally

believers in our work and last summer we

wrote to the federal government about

the DNA repair capacity of neuroblastoma

that happens in the form of an ro1 grant

the pinnacle of one’s academic career we

spent days and hours scrutinizing each

experiment

analyzing each data piece crafting each

word to carefully convince the NIH that

our idea was the next best step to

understanding the curates in

neuroblastoma on this first submission

they didn’t accept our grants but you

know I think that it’s because I know

that I have been uniquely guided to do

this work we immediately start to

strategize how we would send the grant

right back we would address each

weakness one by one and how really all

we needed to do was a few more

experiments learn a few more techniques

but the one thing we knew is that we

weren’t giving up so I think the message

in all of this is multifold our personal

and our professional experiences they

shape our dreams they lead us to our

destiny our challenge is to be open to

the clues the quiet nudge that moves us

to our life’s purpose and when that

happens is our fight in the battle

unshakable unyielding because we know

that we have been brilliantly guided to

this place and then that one magical

moment preceded by many magical moments

will be that one critical milestone on

our journey with the extraordinary thank you for your time

Please follow and like us: