Press "Enter" to skip to content

Advocating with empathy for immigrant education | Lindsey Bird | TEDxModesto


all of us have our insecurities our
perceived flaws some come and go with
age but others left last a lifetime
I remember learning the meaning of the
word empathy in school and finally
having a name for what I thought was my
greatest weakness the ability to
understand the perspective and feelings
of others to walk in their shoes I think
I saw it as a flaw because of the
intense emotions seeing the world from
the shoes of others stirred inside me
sadness anger occasionally rage over the
years I grew to see empathy as my
Achilles heel the trait that caused
other people to see me as weak or not in
control of my emotions every time my
eyes would well with tears or I’d speak
out an indignation
I’d feel a tinge of shame well it’s
taken me a while but I finally realized
that empathy is not a flaw in fact it
I can honestly say I didn’t see empathy
at least within myself as a positive
thing until just within the last year in
fact at the beginning of my career I saw
it as a curse I started teaching in 2004
and instantly noticed things happening
to the children of others that stirred
that anger and rage I’d lived trying to
suppress students being tracked by
perception rather than ability
opportunities being handed to some and
not even offered to others students of
color and English learners falling
victim to the bigotry of low
expectations for far too many of our
most vulnerable students perception
policies and politics are building walls
as a new teacher part of my assignment
included two sections of English Learner
history filled with students new to the
country and language but blended with
students who’d been in US schools five
years or more many since kindergarten
the only thing these students had in
common was the label English Learner I
did everything I could to meet their
needs but I instantly noticed there was
no strategy that could overcome this
situation that did not involve
compromising rigor or support we needed
systemic change so from that moment I
dedicated my career to English Learner
equity a few years later I pounced at
the opportunity to join a committee
designed to do exactly that research and
implement new programs to better meet
English Learner needs using data
traveling to visit model programs
throughout the state conducting internal
research even working with a prominent
consultant I was honored to be on a path
to show these students and our community
their true potential in the end it was
decided students in US schools five
years or more needed the rigor access
and support to be successful in a
mainstream environment while the
newcomers which were actually only 17%
of English learners at the high school
level at that time needed something
different so the language institute was
born serving all newly arrived immigrant
refugee and asylum seeking teens in our
city by consolidating them to one campus
we were able to design specialized
courses to meet their beginning
linguistic and cultural needs
I was honored and excited to be the
social science teacher in this program
and absolutely could not wait to put our
committees hard work into action well
let’s just say that first year didn’t
exactly go as planned our research had
underestimated the diversity and our
communities newcomer population well we
had anticipated having many Spanish
speakers
we did not consider how many different
countries they would come from other
than Mexico honoring and respecting the
differences in culture and even dialects
became vital amongst our
spanish-speaking students one thing most
students from Mexico Central America and
South America did have in common were
the circumstances which pushed them from
their native country and for many from
the arms of their parents they were not
coming for the opportunity we had
assumed but were escaping danger like
refugees evading war these immigrant and
Asylum seeking teens had seen and
experienced atrocities unimaginable to
most Americans for them the trauma of
their past and for many the reality of
their family separation often needed to
be addressed as urgently as their
education our biggest surprise was that
we had actual refugees students who had
survived war in the Middle East but had
not been considered in our committees
research because their families had yet
to resettle to our community they
arrived with equally urgent yet unique
needs some had been withheld from school
for safety reasons
others awaited resettlement in a
secondary country that did not offer
access to education so most arrived with
significant gaps meeting the needs of
these students was a challenge they had
so many obstacles to overcome they were
learning a language that used a
different alphabet they were processing
what they had seen and experienced and
for many waking up to the reality of how
their new country and community
perceived them their language their
culture their religion you would think
the one thing my all of my students had
in common would be sadness and
frustration but it wasn’t whether it was
a refugee from Iraq an asylum seeker
from El Salvador
an illiterate girl from Angola or a
disabled student from India the one
thing they all had in common was pure
joy while we grappled with trying to
uncover and address their vast and
evolving linguistic cultural emotional
and behavioral needs they reminded me
that empathy might not be such a bad
thing after all in fact it had given us
a shared purpose even though our
histories were so different we were now
walking a path together and along that
path
I witnessed so much more than joy it was
their determination their optimism their
appreciation for things we often take
for granted none of which I would have
realized had I not taken the time to
walk in their shoes and then it hit me
it was confusing empathy with sympathy
that would have been my fatal flaw
empathy had led me to having tea in
their homes trying exotic cultural foods
attending weddings and funerals even
bringing my own family to dinner at the
mosque for Ramadan and the attend
graduation parties in South Modesto
sympathy on the other hand would have
taken me down a path of low expectations
the exact same low expectations I had
vowed to overcome so after taking long
walks in the shoes of our students we
worked hard to adjust teaching
strategies curriculum and course
offerings to better meet their needs as
they rose to the higher bar we were
setting we were able to quickly identify
systemic and cultural barriers standing
in the way of them achieving equity when
compared to their native-born peers for
this journey I walked in the shoes of
their parents some no longer alive many
living abroad
most living locally but with no
knowledge of our language or our school
system all looking at us to open the
door to their child’s American dream it
was their shoes that took me through
challenges so much more difficult than
teaching a traumatized 17 year old the
Roman alphabet some think it’s
unrealistic
in fact many have said maybe even a ploy
for attention but I just cannot shake
the firm belief that the children of
others deserve every opportunity as my
I believe when educators come together
and use empathy and equity as their
secret ingredients magic can happen and
for us magic did happen although very
slowly policies guiding students on age
and enrollment based on rules that were
established without the consideration of
a 17 year old girl enrolling with no
former education because she’d been
denied at the hands of the Taliban or an
aspiring engineer from Cambodia who was
enrolled as a sophomore due to his age
and needed just a little extra time to
get his literacy up so he could attend
his dream school uc-davis these policies
were unintentionally comparing them to
their native-born peers and as a result
oppressing them telling students who’d
often worked twice as hard they had half
the options was just not a compromise we
were willing to make and policy was only
one of the barriers I mentioned words
written to govern a community to
regulate a school system to even create
a positive classroom environment can be
changed to adjust to the people it
serves change comes easier in some
institutions than others but for all it
requires awareness empathy and political
will in other words culture for years my
colleagues and I have been trying to
address the barrier standing in the way
of our students to no avail
we’ve been consistently reminded that
the empathy and equity we’ve poured into
our program doesn’t seem to exist
outside our classroom walls so while we
have patiently waited for culture and
policy to catch up to the endless
opportunity our program has to offer we
started to use the void of actual
newcomer policy to the advantage of some
of our students for example I remember
the first day
of one Iraqi refugee girls school
experience as if it were yesterday she
arrived not knowing a word in English
and even struggled when directions were
translated into her native Arabic she
was visibly overwhelmed but she had this
warrior like spirit that radiated
throughout the classroom we had data
that showed she arrived with a preschool
literacy rate and by the time she was
finished with the first school year only
ten months of formal education she was
reading around third grade the following
year she dove into leadership started
playing tennis and set high goals for
herself so to support her aspirations we
established a graduation plan that was
within the rules and common for
newcomers around the state and the
nation we offered her a fifth year of
high school which for her was really
only a fourth because she’d missed all
of ninth grade so that she could not
only graduate but graduate fully
and she did just that that overwhelmed
refugee that entered my classroom not
knowing the Roman alphabet with gaps in
her education but with the will to
overcome at all through education had
done it this year she started her second
year in college at a school I might have
had some influence on my alma mater
Chico State she was one of many students
who graduated past the traditional age
of 18 but with the academic and cultural
competence to dive directly into a
four-year university in fact since 2014
ninety percent of language institute
graduates have gone on to higher
they’ve enrolled our local community
college CSU’s and UCS across the state
this spring we celebrated our first
private school acceptance a Syrian
refugee who didn’t arrive until October
of her junior year who used the fifth
year to get the literacy and course
requirements she needed to be accepted
at the University of Pacific with a
$40,000 scholarship the United Nations
High Commissioner on refugees was so
impressed with her story they made her
life into an international online
advertisement promoting the value of
I was equally proud of a Language
Institute alumni from Mexico who
recently graduated with his master’s and
education and two teaching credentials
he’s currently teaching in Los Angeles
providing immigrant students just like
him the access and opportunity they need
to also defy their demographics so back
to my internal struggle with empathy
being a superpower or a curse please
don’t get me wrong
ultimately the amazing students of the
Language Institute did the hard work to
achieve such greatness but my colleagues
and I had to fight with the will of
entitled empowered parents unimaginable
battles to open the doors of equity
which made the stories I just told you
even possible and even with such
astonishing accomplishments antiquated
policies were allowing some students to
slip through the cracks
and because we fight for our students as
if they were our own children and we
will not accept anything but equity we
have made both allies and enemies along
the way in this decade-long culture war
we’ve waged we’ve heard some revealing
comments about our community these words
don’t represent the opinion of one or a
few but of a culture a culture that I
hope together we can change words like
it’s a shame your students are taking
resources away from real Americans or
can you please stop celebrating the
success of your students other
immigrants might want to move to our
community
putting an unfair burden on our city or
many students graduate reading and
writing below grade level why should
your students deserve the advantage of
extra time or it’s time your families
stop complaining and start being
grateful for what they have
I have to admit that last one hit me
like a punch in the gut
because I am their family and if their
families have been complaining it’s only
because my colleagues and I have
educated and empowered them to stand up
in fact very rarely were they
complaining directly they were given a
voice by a group of amazing community
advocates many of whom are with us
tonight
that also happened to be gifted with the
trait I have grown to embrace as a
superpower well I’m sad to say the
culture I just quoted is currently
winning effective this school year
policies are being interpreted in a way
that deny our students the opportunity
to access an extra year of high school
whether it be for literacy college
readiness or university eligibility
among other mandates that have rewritten
our philosophy of equal opportunity
empowerment and access literally taking
us back to where we were before the
program began in 2009 what sure feels
like hate I think it’s probably fear
fear of exactly what I’m not exactly
sure but I’m pretty confident it’s based
on the stereotypes that my students
I know what my fear is my fear is that a
community or a country without empathy
remains divided walk one mile in my
student shoes and you will see that
giving them what they need to be
successful doesn’t take away from our
own it defines who we are when our
community or any community comes
together to use empathy to create equity
for the children of others we can defy
demographics and improve quality of life for everyone thank you
Please follow and like us: