
I’ve ever looked down at your phone or
computer and then immediately gotten
distracted and forgot why you did so
quick show of hands be honest yes okay
everybody that used to be my job it was
my job to take you out of your world and
bring you into mine because once we have
your attention we’re very good at
keeping it and the longer we can keep it
the longer we can sell advertising
against it and it was around doing this
that I realized the entire industry of
the technique of the attention economy
was working exactly this way but there
was this boundless competition to steal
your time and as much of it as possible
and I realize that as architects of our
digital world we need to be better
because we can be and we can see that
these systems have been designed with
intricacy so that companies can keep our
attention indefinitely I don’t want to
keep crushing these freaking candies I
don’t want these alerts to completely
command me I don’t care if that panda
bear is dancing well maybe with a hula
hoop okay this is fantastic I have to
share this with my 10 friends and ten
thousand strangers caption who wants to
throw a panda rager great let me go back
about my life for God’s sakes I’m trying
to right swipe my wife ha it’s been 30
seconds in just 2 Facebook Likes or is
that just to for which I’ve been
notified let me go back and check inside
and see whose likes it tried to hide
they don’t show them all I wonder why
this pandas dancing and another video
plays after automatically this one of a
gopher that stage turns dramatically
it’s like my attention is kept
systematically raptured by algorithms
that know exactly what I want or not
what I want just what I’ll watch and the
people behind this intelligent design
genuinely want to better our lives but
their bonuses just so happen to be tied
to keeping time
on site exceptionally high and now even
my news apps have been gamified and what
am I not gonna click that one simple sex
tip guaranteed to blow her mind when we
talk about the dangers of advertising
we’re often talking about body image in
the messaging itself and I think it’s
the wrong problem I want to talk about
this about the primary business model of
the attention economy in which the more
of your time we can steal the more money
we make with absolutely no limit and you
might be thinking you know who cares so
what if all of these companies if I’m
sorry so what if all of these companies
of Facebook Twitter Instagram snapchat
the entire news industry every gaming
company even meditation apps have to
compete for our attention who cares
people have been doing that forever
right and I have to compete to give us
the best stuff and in practice yes but
in reality unfortunately no this isn’t a
new problem the problem is that we’ve
gotten so good at it as we’ve carried
around these devices in our pockets and
we’ve gotten so good at perfecting the
tactics to steal and hold as much of
your time as possible that is starting
to be a threat to our new system it’s
starting to be a threat to our way of
life and so that begs the question of
how well really do these companies know
us and so there was a study recently by
Michael Kaczynski at a Stanford out of
Stanford University and he found that a
with just 10 Facebook Likes if we just
knew 10 pages you’ve liked he could tell
aspects of your personality better than
the average co-worker with 150 he knew
you better than your mom with 300 better
than your average spouse and these are
just pages you’ve liked this is not
everything you’ve ever clicked on
hovered over and how long you’ve clicked
on it and how long you’ve hovered over
it everything you’ve shared how long
you’ve spent stalking your ex
girlfriends and boyfriends on Facebook
and Instagram all of that data is what
Facebook has but wasn’t available to him
and yet he was still able to know us
better than our spouses he essentially
concluded that our smartphone is a vast
psychological question
that we are constantly filling out both
consciously and unconsciously when we
hear the sort of stuff we think okay
like whatever they know us really well
like that’s fine they’re not making me
do anything I don’t want to do but I’d
like to argue today that as humans we
are persuadable there are some things
that just work at getting and keeping
our attention that we wouldn’t have done
otherwise and you know we think we can’t
be fooled but there are some things that
just work there are some ways in which
we are just de siiva Belov the attention
economy companies that are stealing that
are fighting for our time when I know us
so well when they live in our pockets
when they profit off of our time and
they’re willing to do whatever it
whatever works to get it what world does
that create and we’ll start to see that
what like what works isn’t necessarily
what’s good or what we actually want
there’s a difference between what I want
and what I’ll watch so what works to
keep you engaged in scrolling if you
spend the most time on Facebook when
you’re angry and lonely then that
algorithm as its optimizing to keep you
there for as long as possible is
optimizing to keep you angry and lonely
and it’s not because there’s someone
evil at Facebook sitting behind a screen
saying AHA I want to ruin your emotions
no these people are doing their jobs and
they’re doing it really well at keeping
you on their site but the consequence is
our emotional state and I want to show
you a quick video that just sort of
gives you a sense that we’re not really
the customer in these ecosystems or the
product and I think this shows that
quite well
[Music]
make them laugh cry Wow and by that’s
what the algorithms are optimized for
they don’t inherently care about us of
course the people at Facebook want to
make us happy in some regard but we’re
not the primary shareholder the
advertisers are and what works starts –
then you’re very fundamentally change
the stories that we tell so we know as
we’re posting on Facebook we’re all as
advertisers we’re measuring as news
organizations we’re measuring what’s
effective what is working in this system
right now and we start to see ah that
anger is really doing quite well and
then you know pretty much every article
we see on Facebook as some version of
this headline right this is why you
should be angry click here to feel right
about why you’re angry that’s pretty
much where it’s become because that
works and we start to do what works but
is that news similarly what works has
absolutely nothing to do with truth
people are making ten thousand dollars a
month just straight up making things up
and putting them in front of people who
are willing to believe them who would
like that confirms their suspicions it
confirms their bias it’s a very
profitable industry I don’t know if
you’ve seen one of these articles of the
Pope endorses Bernie Sanders or the Pope
endorses Donald Trump the Pope does not
endorse presidential candidates but you
know they’re they’re convincing they’re
convincing because they’re in front of
people who are very willing to believe
them and when it happens when it works
it happens a lot over the months leading
up to the election there was more fake
news from fake news sites than
mainstream news sites and – granted what
counts as mainstream news is up for
debate I’m willing to concede that for
sure but the amount of information being
created and shared from a straight up
did this happen or did this not happen
standpoint is staggering and once this
happens it’s very hard to undo there’s a
very real cost because the lie can
travel halfway around the world while
the truth is putting on its shoes by the
time any sort of correction is issued by
the time people get any sort of right
information it’s too late if it even
does reach them in the first place
and just a quick side one another
persuasive tactics for making people
believe something is to put it on a
black background with someone’s face in
front of it there’s absolutely no
evidence that Mark Twain said this quote
but I found that online I didn’t make
that just people put things in front of
things that make it work on to a
separate Mark Twain quote it’s easier to
fool people than convince them they’ve
been fooled this is part of why this is
such a challenge it’s because once
people are in these zones once they
believe what they believe it’s so hard
to bring people out of that
indoctrination and you may have guessed
it this time but also not Mark Twain and
unfortunately it’s not just fake news
real organizations real supposedly
prestigious news organizations are
subject to all of the same factors and
they have to resort to this exaggeration
to playing into bias to stirring up fear
and outrage because it works and they
know if they don’t do it their
competitors will so they have to they
feel like they have to be in this game
of stealing our time and starting to
really break that system two examples
here one from the New York Times
apologies one from the New York Times
and one from Fox New York Times came out
with this article talking about how
murder rates are rising sharply in many
US cities
it was later Nate Silver who’s a uh
who’s a statistician really criticized
them sharply for presenting misleading
statistics but it creates fear it’s a
very clickable this article will do what
will do better than its tame counterpart
and then on the right suspect in Quebec
mask terror attack was a moroccan origin
there was an attack who was not Moroccan
but if he is Moroccan that does better
and to that audience that is something
that works that is a more profitable
headline than its alternative and so
finally what works also creates
different realities this one is one of
the most sort of dear to my heart I
think is is a challenge and that I asked
two friends Ali and Taylor to Google how
many refugees committed crimes in Europe
and they pretty much got two different
answers to that question they asked the
question to Google Ali on the left
receiving articles that say uh 56% of
Syrian refugees committed severe crimes
200,000 crimes committed in Germany in
the last year these are very misleading
statistics and then on the right Taylor
is getting information about how
refugees are not dangerous and how there
have been no attacks in the u.s. they
put the same question into Google they
get a different output these people are
essentially living in two different
worlds
they have different versions of what
reality is
because personalization is yet another
tactic that works it keeps us engaged in
spending more time but is this really
what we want out of our news out of our
information out of our Internet and it’s
not just Google here it’s Facebook it’s
all the people we’ve been talking about
are dabbling in personalization in one
way or another because it works and if
they don’t their competitors will and
that’s why this advertising model is so
dangerous and so we have this idea that
the Internet is free right we have that
all these free services and it’s so
wonderful but what’s the real cost of
free what is the real cost of getting of
all of our information without paying
for it
because I’d like to argue that it’s
siloed realities it’s not being able to
trust news or each other because we’re
getting our information from news so
then how do we know who we can trust
there and this war of distraction of
having to fight off thousands of people
whose job it is to break down our self
control because it’s their job to get
our time and it ultimately creates this
angry polarized population this place
that we’re in now it’s created a world
where the best engineers and developers
they have to use their talents to
manipulate our emotions and steal our
time it’s created a world where news
organizations can’t afford to value
truth to the extent which is necessary
for democracy to function it’s created a
world where we’re constantly fighting
for control of our own minds against
this persuasion and we have different
versions of what reality is I’d like to
argue that’s a very expensive cost for
all of these free services and so how do
we fix this luckily we have three
companies that really have are uniquely
positioned with prime opportunity to do
so
but step one is that we have to separate
profits from how we spend our time the
game can’t be how do we take up as much
of your time as possible because this is
the cost of doing that but what if we
maximize something else what if we
maximize things that really mattered to
us what if we imagine a world that
doesn’t compete for your attention but
instead competes to help you thrive
that’s hard to imagine exactly what that
would look like so I want to give a
couple examples you have you know you
have someone making minimum wage trying
to provide for their family imagine if
all sorts of companies we’re competing
doing what works to help them accomplish
that where the goal weren’t about how do
we steal as much of your time but how do
we help you do something that truly
matters to you
what if dating apps weren’t measuring
their success and how many swipes we had
what if they were measuring what works
to help us find meaningful relationships
or whatever you’re looking for
what if news organizations weren’t
competing for our time and clicks weird
having didn’t have to compete to the
base instincts to the race to the bottom
of our brainstem what if instead they
were competing to do what works to
inform us about the world around us to
tell us what matters not just what’s
scary starts to get into the questions
of ikon what is news why do we have news
we’ve come a long way from that
similarly what if this algorithm that
knows us so well on Facebook better than
we know ourselves in some senses what if
it we’re doing everything that works to
help give us what matters to us doing
everything that works to help us spend
time spend time with the people we care
about Facebook could take us all on like
the greatest night out of our lives it
knows so much about our surroundings and
knows so much about us I could just get
it take me on an adventure button it’ll
be awesome
and similarly when you go to Facebook
for news as too many of us do it can
start to think about that same question
what is news for what are we actually
optimizing for what works to inform this
person not just keep them and the
challenge here as many of you are
probably thinking is well okay how do
these
companies make their money but it’s not
as it’s not as bad as you think Facebook
makes about what dollar sixty one per
person per month that’s a dollar two
quarters a dime and a penny that’s the
cost of a lot of this world that we’re
living in if we start to be willing to
pay for services that truly bring us
value and I’m not recommending we pay
for Facebook now I don’t want to do that
but if companies do start to offer us
real products that are enhancing the
world that we live in and measuring
their success based on how well it
affects our lives we’re going to be need
to what we’re going to need to be
willing to pay for that and as customers
we’re on the hook for that as well but
it helps us stop being the product and
start being the customer and so we have
to fix this quickly because every day
that we don’t we’re being driven further
and further apart we’re getting more and
more polarized this is a critical issue
but we can do it we can stop maximizing
time spent we can get that off of the
table as the metric that matters the
most and we can start basing things on
human values we can change from time
spent to time well-spent architects of
our digital world you have more data
information and control over our
attention the tools to tweak our
emotions or return to your experience
but is that what we should do or should
you build digital tools so advanced they
can actually enhance the world outside
the device in our hands
can we add so much value that it lets us
put our phones back in our pants as fast
as we possibly can
not time sucking time giving innovation
that’s what it means to be truly
technologically advanced the future is
not all screens its humanity enhanced
thank you [Applause]
computer and then immediately gotten
distracted and forgot why you did so
quick show of hands be honest yes okay
everybody that used to be my job it was
my job to take you out of your world and
bring you into mine because once we have
your attention we’re very good at
keeping it and the longer we can keep it
the longer we can sell advertising
against it and it was around doing this
that I realized the entire industry of
the technique of the attention economy
was working exactly this way but there
was this boundless competition to steal
your time and as much of it as possible
and I realize that as architects of our
digital world we need to be better
because we can be and we can see that
these systems have been designed with
intricacy so that companies can keep our
attention indefinitely I don’t want to
keep crushing these freaking candies I
don’t want these alerts to completely
command me I don’t care if that panda
bear is dancing well maybe with a hula
hoop okay this is fantastic I have to
share this with my 10 friends and ten
thousand strangers caption who wants to
throw a panda rager great let me go back
about my life for God’s sakes I’m trying
to right swipe my wife ha it’s been 30
seconds in just 2 Facebook Likes or is
that just to for which I’ve been
notified let me go back and check inside
and see whose likes it tried to hide
they don’t show them all I wonder why
this pandas dancing and another video
plays after automatically this one of a
gopher that stage turns dramatically
it’s like my attention is kept
systematically raptured by algorithms
that know exactly what I want or not
what I want just what I’ll watch and the
people behind this intelligent design
genuinely want to better our lives but
their bonuses just so happen to be tied
to keeping time
on site exceptionally high and now even
my news apps have been gamified and what
am I not gonna click that one simple sex
tip guaranteed to blow her mind when we
talk about the dangers of advertising
we’re often talking about body image in
the messaging itself and I think it’s
the wrong problem I want to talk about
this about the primary business model of
the attention economy in which the more
of your time we can steal the more money
we make with absolutely no limit and you
might be thinking you know who cares so
what if all of these companies if I’m
sorry so what if all of these companies
of Facebook Twitter Instagram snapchat
the entire news industry every gaming
company even meditation apps have to
compete for our attention who cares
people have been doing that forever
right and I have to compete to give us
the best stuff and in practice yes but
in reality unfortunately no this isn’t a
new problem the problem is that we’ve
gotten so good at it as we’ve carried
around these devices in our pockets and
we’ve gotten so good at perfecting the
tactics to steal and hold as much of
your time as possible that is starting
to be a threat to our new system it’s
starting to be a threat to our way of
life and so that begs the question of
how well really do these companies know
us and so there was a study recently by
Michael Kaczynski at a Stanford out of
Stanford University and he found that a
with just 10 Facebook Likes if we just
knew 10 pages you’ve liked he could tell
aspects of your personality better than
the average co-worker with 150 he knew
you better than your mom with 300 better
than your average spouse and these are
just pages you’ve liked this is not
everything you’ve ever clicked on
hovered over and how long you’ve clicked
on it and how long you’ve hovered over
it everything you’ve shared how long
you’ve spent stalking your ex
girlfriends and boyfriends on Facebook
and Instagram all of that data is what
Facebook has but wasn’t available to him
and yet he was still able to know us
better than our spouses he essentially
concluded that our smartphone is a vast
psychological question
that we are constantly filling out both
consciously and unconsciously when we
hear the sort of stuff we think okay
like whatever they know us really well
like that’s fine they’re not making me
do anything I don’t want to do but I’d
like to argue today that as humans we
are persuadable there are some things
that just work at getting and keeping
our attention that we wouldn’t have done
otherwise and you know we think we can’t
be fooled but there are some things that
just work there are some ways in which
we are just de siiva Belov the attention
economy companies that are stealing that
are fighting for our time when I know us
so well when they live in our pockets
when they profit off of our time and
they’re willing to do whatever it
whatever works to get it what world does
that create and we’ll start to see that
what like what works isn’t necessarily
what’s good or what we actually want
there’s a difference between what I want
and what I’ll watch so what works to
keep you engaged in scrolling if you
spend the most time on Facebook when
you’re angry and lonely then that
algorithm as its optimizing to keep you
there for as long as possible is
optimizing to keep you angry and lonely
and it’s not because there’s someone
evil at Facebook sitting behind a screen
saying AHA I want to ruin your emotions
no these people are doing their jobs and
they’re doing it really well at keeping
you on their site but the consequence is
our emotional state and I want to show
you a quick video that just sort of
gives you a sense that we’re not really
the customer in these ecosystems or the
product and I think this shows that
quite well
[Music]
make them laugh cry Wow and by that’s
what the algorithms are optimized for
they don’t inherently care about us of
course the people at Facebook want to
make us happy in some regard but we’re
not the primary shareholder the
advertisers are and what works starts –
then you’re very fundamentally change
the stories that we tell so we know as
we’re posting on Facebook we’re all as
advertisers we’re measuring as news
organizations we’re measuring what’s
effective what is working in this system
right now and we start to see ah that
anger is really doing quite well and
then you know pretty much every article
we see on Facebook as some version of
this headline right this is why you
should be angry click here to feel right
about why you’re angry that’s pretty
much where it’s become because that
works and we start to do what works but
is that news similarly what works has
absolutely nothing to do with truth
people are making ten thousand dollars a
month just straight up making things up
and putting them in front of people who
are willing to believe them who would
like that confirms their suspicions it
confirms their bias it’s a very
profitable industry I don’t know if
you’ve seen one of these articles of the
Pope endorses Bernie Sanders or the Pope
endorses Donald Trump the Pope does not
endorse presidential candidates but you
know they’re they’re convincing they’re
convincing because they’re in front of
people who are very willing to believe
them and when it happens when it works
it happens a lot over the months leading
up to the election there was more fake
news from fake news sites than
mainstream news sites and – granted what
counts as mainstream news is up for
debate I’m willing to concede that for
sure but the amount of information being
created and shared from a straight up
did this happen or did this not happen
standpoint is staggering and once this
happens it’s very hard to undo there’s a
very real cost because the lie can
travel halfway around the world while
the truth is putting on its shoes by the
time any sort of correction is issued by
the time people get any sort of right
information it’s too late if it even
does reach them in the first place
and just a quick side one another
persuasive tactics for making people
believe something is to put it on a
black background with someone’s face in
front of it there’s absolutely no
evidence that Mark Twain said this quote
but I found that online I didn’t make
that just people put things in front of
things that make it work on to a
separate Mark Twain quote it’s easier to
fool people than convince them they’ve
been fooled this is part of why this is
such a challenge it’s because once
people are in these zones once they
believe what they believe it’s so hard
to bring people out of that
indoctrination and you may have guessed
it this time but also not Mark Twain and
unfortunately it’s not just fake news
real organizations real supposedly
prestigious news organizations are
subject to all of the same factors and
they have to resort to this exaggeration
to playing into bias to stirring up fear
and outrage because it works and they
know if they don’t do it their
competitors will so they have to they
feel like they have to be in this game
of stealing our time and starting to
really break that system two examples
here one from the New York Times
apologies one from the New York Times
and one from Fox New York Times came out
with this article talking about how
murder rates are rising sharply in many
US cities
it was later Nate Silver who’s a uh
who’s a statistician really criticized
them sharply for presenting misleading
statistics but it creates fear it’s a
very clickable this article will do what
will do better than its tame counterpart
and then on the right suspect in Quebec
mask terror attack was a moroccan origin
there was an attack who was not Moroccan
but if he is Moroccan that does better
and to that audience that is something
that works that is a more profitable
headline than its alternative and so
finally what works also creates
different realities this one is one of
the most sort of dear to my heart I
think is is a challenge and that I asked
two friends Ali and Taylor to Google how
many refugees committed crimes in Europe
and they pretty much got two different
answers to that question they asked the
question to Google Ali on the left
receiving articles that say uh 56% of
Syrian refugees committed severe crimes
200,000 crimes committed in Germany in
the last year these are very misleading
statistics and then on the right Taylor
is getting information about how
refugees are not dangerous and how there
have been no attacks in the u.s. they
put the same question into Google they
get a different output these people are
essentially living in two different
worlds
they have different versions of what
reality is
because personalization is yet another
tactic that works it keeps us engaged in
spending more time but is this really
what we want out of our news out of our
information out of our Internet and it’s
not just Google here it’s Facebook it’s
all the people we’ve been talking about
are dabbling in personalization in one
way or another because it works and if
they don’t their competitors will and
that’s why this advertising model is so
dangerous and so we have this idea that
the Internet is free right we have that
all these free services and it’s so
wonderful but what’s the real cost of
free what is the real cost of getting of
all of our information without paying
for it
because I’d like to argue that it’s
siloed realities it’s not being able to
trust news or each other because we’re
getting our information from news so
then how do we know who we can trust
there and this war of distraction of
having to fight off thousands of people
whose job it is to break down our self
control because it’s their job to get
our time and it ultimately creates this
angry polarized population this place
that we’re in now it’s created a world
where the best engineers and developers
they have to use their talents to
manipulate our emotions and steal our
time it’s created a world where news
organizations can’t afford to value
truth to the extent which is necessary
for democracy to function it’s created a
world where we’re constantly fighting
for control of our own minds against
this persuasion and we have different
versions of what reality is I’d like to
argue that’s a very expensive cost for
all of these free services and so how do
we fix this luckily we have three
companies that really have are uniquely
positioned with prime opportunity to do
so
but step one is that we have to separate
profits from how we spend our time the
game can’t be how do we take up as much
of your time as possible because this is
the cost of doing that but what if we
maximize something else what if we
maximize things that really mattered to
us what if we imagine a world that
doesn’t compete for your attention but
instead competes to help you thrive
that’s hard to imagine exactly what that
would look like so I want to give a
couple examples you have you know you
have someone making minimum wage trying
to provide for their family imagine if
all sorts of companies we’re competing
doing what works to help them accomplish
that where the goal weren’t about how do
we steal as much of your time but how do
we help you do something that truly
matters to you
what if dating apps weren’t measuring
their success and how many swipes we had
what if they were measuring what works
to help us find meaningful relationships
or whatever you’re looking for
what if news organizations weren’t
competing for our time and clicks weird
having didn’t have to compete to the
base instincts to the race to the bottom
of our brainstem what if instead they
were competing to do what works to
inform us about the world around us to
tell us what matters not just what’s
scary starts to get into the questions
of ikon what is news why do we have news
we’ve come a long way from that
similarly what if this algorithm that
knows us so well on Facebook better than
we know ourselves in some senses what if
it we’re doing everything that works to
help give us what matters to us doing
everything that works to help us spend
time spend time with the people we care
about Facebook could take us all on like
the greatest night out of our lives it
knows so much about our surroundings and
knows so much about us I could just get
it take me on an adventure button it’ll
be awesome
and similarly when you go to Facebook
for news as too many of us do it can
start to think about that same question
what is news for what are we actually
optimizing for what works to inform this
person not just keep them and the
challenge here as many of you are
probably thinking is well okay how do
these
companies make their money but it’s not
as it’s not as bad as you think Facebook
makes about what dollar sixty one per
person per month that’s a dollar two
quarters a dime and a penny that’s the
cost of a lot of this world that we’re
living in if we start to be willing to
pay for services that truly bring us
value and I’m not recommending we pay
for Facebook now I don’t want to do that
but if companies do start to offer us
real products that are enhancing the
world that we live in and measuring
their success based on how well it
affects our lives we’re going to be need
to what we’re going to need to be
willing to pay for that and as customers
we’re on the hook for that as well but
it helps us stop being the product and
start being the customer and so we have
to fix this quickly because every day
that we don’t we’re being driven further
and further apart we’re getting more and
more polarized this is a critical issue
but we can do it we can stop maximizing
time spent we can get that off of the
table as the metric that matters the
most and we can start basing things on
human values we can change from time
spent to time well-spent architects of
our digital world you have more data
information and control over our
attention the tools to tweak our
emotions or return to your experience
but is that what we should do or should
you build digital tools so advanced they
can actually enhance the world outside
the device in our hands
can we add so much value that it lets us
put our phones back in our pants as fast
as we possibly can
not time sucking time giving innovation
that’s what it means to be truly
technologically advanced the future is
not all screens its humanity enhanced
thank you [Applause]
Please follow and like us: