Press "Enter" to skip to content

Accountability – the heartbeat of Governance | Jay P Desai | TEDxBocconiUMumbai


many years ago one evening my wife and a

close friend were going out for dinner

to the Taj at about 8:30 and they were

all sort of set to go out my 13 year old

son grabbed his mother and said mama

you cannot go you stay home with me for

dinner and he was very persistent so she

called the Taj and canceled the

reservation and it was just as well

because it turned out to be a

life-saving decision because it was the

evening of 26/11 when terror descended

onto Mumbai including at the hotel where

my wife were having dinner and as I was

watching the television that evening I

started to think why is it that this can

occur so easily in our country why is

there a failure of the process on so

many occasions and in fact you might

remember that those few days across

Mumbai and across the country Factory

there was a lot of protests there were

people marching protesting against the

poor governance against poor

accountability against poor public

administration and I think the the

feeling I got is that yes I do have the

right to complain and protest but I also

felt that I had an obligation as a

citizen to try to do something to

improve the governance process I was not

sure what a few days later a close

friend of mine was in a flight with me

to go up he had escaped from the Taj

early that morning the night after

terrorist attacks unhurt Pereira

harrowing experience so when I asked him

now that you’ve sort of survived that

incident how does it change your life

and he said a very interesting thing is

that I want to understand

what can I do as the ordinary citizen to

improve accountability in our country

and with that question he launched me

unknowingly onto a three and a half year

journey to understand governance and

accountability in our country being a

biologist by training I knew nothing

about political science but I felt if I

can’t characterize what accountability

was at least I should feel that I’ve

done something as an ordinary citizen to

help improve the public understanding of

accountability so here’s what I found in

my journey industry half years and by

accident the research ultimately became

a book but during that process many more

incidences of poor governance were

visible you all remember the

Commonwealth Games scam you may also

remember the coal scam the telecom scan

and I started to think that India is now

probably at its most critical juncture

in its post-independence history because

it was not the Taj under siege but I

thought it was accountability which was

under siege and through that process I

could see that well there were people I

talked to did not have a clear

understanding of what accountability

meant and so my journey was to try to

increase that understanding what I

learned is that governance is the heart

of any country but accountability is its

heartbeat without accountability you

cannot have good governance and if you

explore governance and you try to study

it

it’s qualitatively and quantitatively

measurable you can measure governance

it’s much more difficult to measure

accountability you can only measure it

through intangible understanding of the

mechanisms of accountability and I then

started looking at the system using my

biology background from a systems

perspective and I realized that this is

very complex

[Music]

governments as a system interacts with

the political system with the social

system with the economic system so if

you change something in one of those

systems there could be a positive or

negative in fact on the other system so

it’s systems dynamics at play and that’s

important because obviously governance

will then have an impact on many other

areas in the wage which country operates

so I ask the question is India too young

a democracy to really expect good

governance we’ve been around democracy

for maybe 65 years around that time now

it’s 70 years and when I did an analysis

of a large number of countries looking

at on one axis at the age of the

democracy on the x-axis and the quality

of governance and the y-axis I found an

interesting shape if you look at the

graph you will see that somewhere where

India is around 65 70 years you find

that India is way below other countries

of similar democratic age

India’s governance level is not as good

as other countries which are around 65

70 years old so there’s a lot of

catch-up that we need to do then I asked

the question how does governance impact

the competitiveness of a country and

when I did the correlation between a

global competitiveness index and

governance

I found the correlation to be 0.8 3

which means it’s extremely high

essentially good governance and being

competitive as a country move in exactly

the same direction we don’t know what

causes what but they move in the same

direction so if you are a country which

has good governance there is a good

chance to be very competitive if you

have poor governance you will not be

competitive what impact does governance

have on the human condition so I looked

at the Human Development Index and I

actually found the correlation once

again to be extremely high those

countries that have good governance tend

to have tend to have very good

human development indicators the social

condition the human condition is in good

shape

in those countries where governance is

weak the human condition is also weak so

therefore it impacts with social systems

also I also was wondering how does the

social hierarchy that exists in India

impact governance now social hierarchy

is the inequity in power and wealth

between individuals India as you know

has a very high social hierarchy which

means if I’m at the bottom of the pool

in terms of equity how can I ever

extract accountability or expect good

governance from a public official who is

supposedly at a higher level in power

and wealth and that correlation really

worried me because it’s inversely

correlated the greater your social

hierarchy the worse your governance will

be in India is those countries where

hierarchies is extremely high and that’s

developed over 2,000 years there’s a lot

of discussion today about the shadow

economy India is about maybe 25 percent

of its economy is shadowkhan maybe more

but the correlation again is very strong

if you have a large shadow economy you

are likely to have poor governance so

any attempt to reduce the shadow economy

is actually going to help improve

it is also discussion about digital

evolution now if you look at this graph

it shows you that those countries that

are digitally evolved you compare them

to the quality of governance the

correlation is almost point-9 which

means those countries that employ a

large number of digital transactions are

quite likely to have much better

governance so there is something to be

said for pushing you know digital usage

across the country so that’s definite so

if you look at accountability like I

said accountability is the heartbeat of

good governance accountability is more

measured on the basis of mechanisms or

continuity there are two kinds one which

concerns everybody in this room which is

what we call external accountability

it’s the pressure that citizens civil

society and media exerts on the

government institutions the other is the

internal countability which government

organizations have within from our

research I concluded that the most

important thing to shift any system or

any country from its equilibrium is

external pressure from outside

[Music]

implement internal changes from within

the government are much more difficult

they’re their own political

considerations it takes much more time

so the external pressure the people like

us apply which we also applied during

those years when there was an

anti-corruption movement in India to

remember and I think that has a dramatic

impact on the country’s decision to push

its accountability up and to push its

governance up from my work I found that

there are six broad things that any

country can do to improve its

accountability and therefore improve its

governance and for India for example

information which you provide which the

government provides in terms of being

transparent is very critical being

impartial that is impartial in terms of

selection of public officials focus on

implementation not just on how much

money are you allocating to your scheme

but really what was the outcome of the

allocation infrastructure so improving

essentially the infrastructure of the

courts the judiciary is absolutely

critical and independence even public

officials within the government need to

give be given freedom to make sure

they’re independent of interference from

the political executive but I think the

most important thing really is the last

one that is involvement that is

involvement of people like you and me in

the political process not only when we

would but also in the intervening period

and so if there is if there are ordinary

citizen if you’re a student if you’re a

working in a corporation what can you do

to improve accountability that was the

question that my friend who escaped from

the Taj asked me

so there are six things you can do so

first of all three five things first we

can provide your time spend a few hours

a week a few hours on weekends helping

civil society organizations who are very

well organized and already doing their

bit to improve governance in the country

you could provide your media support

which is if your access to media through

social media or regular media you can

provide that support to them we can also

provide your intellectual capability so

if you are a company if you’re a college

you have great intellectual resources

available to you and civil society

organizations don’t have access to that

so if you increase their institutional

capacity to push the governance

initiative that makes a big difference

infrastructure college like this or if

you’re working in a company classrooms

on weekends or you know in the evenings

or office space on weekends and if you

give that to a civil society

organization to simply come in and work

that helps them tremendously to fight

their battle and lastly of course can

provide monetary support but these are

the five things which which you as

ordinary citizens can do to help improve

accountability in our country so let me

walk you through the journey of

accountability over the last ten years

since 2008 we actually felt that

accountability was dropping because why

was that the case because the external

accountability pressured the citizens

were putting on the government

resolutions were enormous

so coupled with the media coupled with

civil society we were putting a lot of

pressure on the government and therefore

more scam grouping is exposed if we had

not put that pressure those scams would

not have been exposed as a result our

perception was that accountability is is

dropping continuously corruption and

governance India is becoming worse and

worse but that pressure resulted frankly

in 2014 in a complete change of

administration in a country and if I

remember the platform in which the new

government came in was claimed to be

that of providing great governance it

was the pressure that we put that

actually caused that over the last few

years I believe that accountable ease

began to improve there is much greater

pressure much greater transparency an

accomplice has become to include I think

that today we’re a much better position

than we were way back in 2008 and I feel

that in the next five or seven years

accountability continue to improve but

it can only improve if people like you

and me do orbit is no point complaining

we have an obligation as citizens of

India to do something to try and improve

the quality of governance I think is

important to remember the words of the

father of the nation if you want to make

some change you’ve got to be part of

that change process there’s no point

just saying that things should improve

it’s not going to improve unless you are

actively involved and I think that if we

all do that as ordinary citizens whether

you’re a student whether you’re in a

company I think we will ultimately make

sure that India meets its tryst with

destiny thank you you

Please follow and like us: