
[Music]
that’s that’s we it’s weirdly sort of
appropriate to finish the fabulous day
that we’ve had with a talk about death
and dying about you and me and the
inevitability of our own passing but
actually this is not so much a talk
about our stopping it’s more about us
starting and how by embracing the
mystery of our life and our dear and by
coming to terms with our own mortality
we can live a fuller life full of
purpose and full of love this is a
photograph of my parents it’s only a
wedding day in 1952 and Tel Aviv and
Israel both of my parents lost their
parents and most of their families in
the Holocaust
my mother survived her child and a
schvitz and the death march that
followed and my father five years
fighting with the Polish army based out
of London I know for them and I suspect
for you and I know for myself that I
came to this place to this world imbued
with the spirit of my ancestors and in
everything that I do and in each moment
of time I add to my own present in my
future and that when it’s my turn to go
if I am lucky it will be those that love
me my children perhaps I hope who will
carry me into their future and perhaps
that’s the best we can hope for when I
was thinking about this talk I didn’t
think so much about the future I thought
much more about the past and in
particular some of the enduring truths
and far katoki of our First Nations and
many of you will be familiar with this
Mason jerries model of health and
wellness for Marty too far a top afar
it’s a holistic model that encompasses
much more than just physical well-being
it includes the well-being of the family
the mind and importantly the spirit and
other another talkie Hey aha
Tamia Nui o T ow hey Tonya Tonya Tonya –
hey tangata what’s the most important
thing in the world it is people it is
people it is people and one more camera
can worry that that we walk into the
future
facing backwards or as søren
kierkegaard said we understand backwards
but we are forced to live our life
forwards that sense that the future is
somewhat unwritten and that no there are
clues to it from our past these kinds of
things have been quite helpful to me and
my sort of no journey through medicine
and I think they might be helpful for us
to consider as we go through this talk
which is I think more about living than
dying to tell you the truth now when I
was incredibly young I thought I would
live forever I didn’t talk about death
or dying much I didn’t consider it nor
Elna Sand suffering and in fact if I was
ever to be threatened by something like
that as it happened for my ancestors and
the time of the ancient Pharaoh’s the
Angel of Death would pass over my house
and I would be spared actually I don’t
believe that anymore my first encounter
with the death and dying process though
came at medical school when I was a
student and I still remember the
profound sense of disbelief that I had
when I looked down at those tiny dark
nuclei inside those cancer cells so far
away at the end of that microscope and
my sense of disbelief that they could
bring us down and that terrible process
that is that the progressive weight loss
and fatigue that inexorable turning up
of our toes until we die oh my god Here
I am at the late afternoon of my medical
career and I still actually don’t
understand how that happens but I’ve
come to realize that I don’t need to
understand that I just need to accept
that it does another photograph of my
parents at 1986 this time taken in the
back garden of my home in London my
father died in Wellington four years
after this photograph was taken he was
77 years old I was 34 and just recently
returned to New Zealand was working at
Auckland Hospital before I moved to
Middlemore where I now work although my
father’s death was not unexpected it
rocked me in all sorts of different ways
first of all that sense of disbelief
that he was he was dead and could be
gone forever a terrible sense of guilt
because I could have been a better son
to him a sense of sadness for not
knowing more about his extraordinary
life and that nagging regret for all
those things left unsaid but perhaps
mostly and perhaps selfishly the thing
that really struck me was that this was
the first time I had to really face up
the ephemeral nature of life and start
coming to terms with my own mortality
the sight of my father’s body in that
funeral home that soon after became a
car yard still haunts me that look on
his face and death one he never had in
life the funeral he had in the freezing
rain at Makkah bar on the south coast of
Wellington the calming effect of our
ritual the singing of the Kaddish the
horror of the drip drip drip of the rain
into that puddle in the corner of his
grave the thud of the red clay on the
coffin those things stayed with me for
months and for years until I could turn
away from my fear of death and start to
concentrate on living a purposeful life
we are all of us a speck in this planet
in this universe we exist for a
millisecond in a vast expanse of time
and if the past has anything to go by
time will continue into a future that we
barely can foresee or comprehend into
that continuance many of us have come
and all of us will go
because life is zero-sum game if there’s
one thing we are good at us human beings
we’re good at dying we hit that target
100% of the time so if we come we will
go you know and as sad as that might be
and as much as our loved ones try to
hold on to us in time too we will
eventually become increasingly lost from
them
and that pattern will continue and
continue until we are a species no more
perhaps because we have no habitable
place
now I am an intensive care doctor I work
with the living although many of my
patients are skirting their own death I
work with their families and I work with
their friends and invariably these
people face their situation were the
strength and resilience and a dignity
that is absolutely outstanding but too
often I see the same sense of of regret
sadness and disbelief that I felt at the
death of my father the ICU is a crucible
a place where there’s a great swirl of
emotion and intensity deep reflection
the ebb and flow of all sorts of
different things conflict and resolution
and we are there with these people
a temporary gift and their lives to
guide them to help them to understand to
judge their pace to each them forward
and whether their loved one lives or
dies our role is to keep them together
to make them better to help them to know
and for that and for them to go away
knowing and to live a good and
purposeful life so there are so many
stories it’s really hard to know where
to begin
last week a young woman going about her
everyday work suddenly looked pained put
a hand up to her head and drop to the
ground deeply unconscious the cause a
cerebral hemorrhage from an undiagnosed
aneurysm by the time she reached
hospital she had fixed and dilated
pupils eighteen hours later she was
declared brain dead the next morning her
lungs her heart her liver and her
kidneys were being transplanted into
five complete strangers in a moment
people’s lives are turned upside down
and inside out families and friends are
changed forever
the longest day and night of their lives
a journey that is so deep these families
are really magnificent and we are there
alongside them and together we see the
light as clear as it can ever be and
it’s their affirmation of life in the
face of the darkness of death
these moments are so profound
they are indescribable and to be a
witness to that kind of stuff is just
awesome intensive care doctors are often
called to assess critically ill patients
at all times of the day and night people
that we’ve never met before and
increasingly now the frail and the
elderly when when I was a young doctor I
felt under enormous pressure to
intervene the families were there their
friends all waiting expecting the doctor
to come to make sense of the situation
their own and to make things better
and when I was young it was really tough
you know I just felt they wanted me to
do stuff and I did stuff so I intervened
I did things I pulled the trigger on all
those things that I was trained to do
but I know better now and circumstances
like that I spend much more time taking
stock of talking to those families
listening to them to learn and
understand more about that patient the
life that they have and what they value
and when you do that in every case the
right treatment path emerges and
invariably it’s to do less rather than
to do more a while back I spent quite a
bit of time working and saw more where I
met my friend Mary now Mary came into
the hospital with a life-threatening
infection was close to death according
to her daughter Mary was already quite
frail she was 78 and in the younger life
though she had met she had run and
looked after the family business
now managed by the daughter it was a
small hotel down by the port and our
pier was quite nice views over the
harbour to watch the ships from the
second floor balconies and in her
younger days Mary would scoot up those
stairs and do the things that she needed
to do but as she got older she started
to take the elevator but in the last 18
months or so Mary was pretty well
confined to the front disc but Mary
enjoyed her life and according to a
daughter she knew how to life and really
importantly she knew how she wanted to
so we had a discussion and we decided
that we would take Mary up to the little
ICU there and we did really simple
things as well as we possibly could
we gave her oxygen we gave her fluids we
gave us some antibiotics a few drugs
here and there and we fine-tuned things
always trying to keep an eye on her
comfort making sure she was comfortable
and we decided to wait and see and see
which way she turned 24 hours later
she’s a little bit better 48 hours later
she was in a chair ten days later shoes
at home and here she is on the day of
her 80th birthday two years later
working with the frail and the elderly
is one of the great challenges for
modern medicine it’s more about the art
than it is about the science it’s about
how do we customize all that we know and
all that we can do to the individual
needs of that really difficult group
it’s about treating softly on that line
between treatment and torture and
invariably it’s about doing less rather
than more as robust and strong as we are
here today with our lives so full and so
much already achieved and so much more
to look forward to in the future
it’s hard to believe that one day we’ll
be gone not just for a holiday or
ducking out for a smoke or a cup of
coffee I mean gone for good
there are lots of people who just can’t
get their heads around that and they put
their their sort of eggs and the
afterlife basket now I I don’t think
that’s such a smart move because I think
that just reduces the intensity of their
lives and they’re here and now what is
the time now at some to five plus six on
the 28th of October 2017
I reckon by now a hundred and seven
billion people have come and gone from
this place you would have thought that
if there was an afterlife we would have
heard about it
think about this all of those letters
emails and texts stacked up against the
post office door on death side you would
have thought that one of them would have
made it through the crack from the
darkness to the life a letter from a
dead mother to a grieving child from a
dead child to a grieving mother but no I
don’t believe there’s ever been a
postcard and I’ve not heard from my
mother my mother who wanted to know
everything about me all of the time
David she would say are you happy David
will you be home for dinner would you
like me to put some food aside for you
do you still like a filter fish if there
was one thing that could transcend death
surely it would be the anxiety of my
mother but no no not a word so it seems
to me that life is very much about the
here and now it’s about earthly minds
and our earthly bodies living on this
our heavenly earth here’s my mother this
photo on the 3rd of May 2009 that’s her
80th birthday and it’s taken at the
Wellesley club in McGuinness E Street
and Wellington she died two years later
I was with her during her final illness
and looked after her at her home in
Wellington for the last couple of months
of her of that of that terrible cancer
she hung on as survivors do unwilling to
give up until in a moment of surrender
death came for her my mother like people
so close to death maintained a radiance
and a warmth all the way to the end and
suddenly it was gone his spirit they
stated 20 grams of Earth took off like a
bird a little while later her body was
cremated and awhile later
her ashes were interred in my father’s
grave and Nakada the spirit of my mother
and the spirit of my father live on in
me I know that and I can feel that now
you might say I am a man of science but
I am also not because I’m just like you
and none of us are immune from the
mystery of death it will always
overwhelm anything that we pretend to
know
I had a patient once who had a
near-death experience she described it
to me like this
the colors were really really bright my
eyesight was sharp I looked down on my
battered body and I heard a voice and it
said it’s not your time so I went back
death is such a mystery a child on a
ghost train the one the one big thing we
will have to face one by one and all
alone 22 years passed between the death
of my father and the death of my mother
and during that time I was forced to
grow up I learned a lot about life and I
learned a bit about death for me life is
about us it’s about you it’s about me
it’s about us together it’s about how we
value each other and how we look after
each other it’s also about how we look
after the environment that sustains us
we come into this world and viewed but
with the spirits of our ancestors and
everything that we do and in each moment
we add to our presence and to our future
and if we are lucky will be our children
who all those who love us that will
carry us into theirs so the question for
each of us is this how will I choose to
live and make the most of my one unique
precious life thank you
[Applause]
you
[Music]
that’s that’s we it’s weirdly sort of
appropriate to finish the fabulous day
that we’ve had with a talk about death
and dying about you and me and the
inevitability of our own passing but
actually this is not so much a talk
about our stopping it’s more about us
starting and how by embracing the
mystery of our life and our dear and by
coming to terms with our own mortality
we can live a fuller life full of
purpose and full of love this is a
photograph of my parents it’s only a
wedding day in 1952 and Tel Aviv and
Israel both of my parents lost their
parents and most of their families in
the Holocaust
my mother survived her child and a
schvitz and the death march that
followed and my father five years
fighting with the Polish army based out
of London I know for them and I suspect
for you and I know for myself that I
came to this place to this world imbued
with the spirit of my ancestors and in
everything that I do and in each moment
of time I add to my own present in my
future and that when it’s my turn to go
if I am lucky it will be those that love
me my children perhaps I hope who will
carry me into their future and perhaps
that’s the best we can hope for when I
was thinking about this talk I didn’t
think so much about the future I thought
much more about the past and in
particular some of the enduring truths
and far katoki of our First Nations and
many of you will be familiar with this
Mason jerries model of health and
wellness for Marty too far a top afar
it’s a holistic model that encompasses
much more than just physical well-being
it includes the well-being of the family
the mind and importantly the spirit and
other another talkie Hey aha
Tamia Nui o T ow hey Tonya Tonya Tonya –
hey tangata what’s the most important
thing in the world it is people it is
people it is people and one more camera
can worry that that we walk into the
future
facing backwards or as søren
kierkegaard said we understand backwards
but we are forced to live our life
forwards that sense that the future is
somewhat unwritten and that no there are
clues to it from our past these kinds of
things have been quite helpful to me and
my sort of no journey through medicine
and I think they might be helpful for us
to consider as we go through this talk
which is I think more about living than
dying to tell you the truth now when I
was incredibly young I thought I would
live forever I didn’t talk about death
or dying much I didn’t consider it nor
Elna Sand suffering and in fact if I was
ever to be threatened by something like
that as it happened for my ancestors and
the time of the ancient Pharaoh’s the
Angel of Death would pass over my house
and I would be spared actually I don’t
believe that anymore my first encounter
with the death and dying process though
came at medical school when I was a
student and I still remember the
profound sense of disbelief that I had
when I looked down at those tiny dark
nuclei inside those cancer cells so far
away at the end of that microscope and
my sense of disbelief that they could
bring us down and that terrible process
that is that the progressive weight loss
and fatigue that inexorable turning up
of our toes until we die oh my god Here
I am at the late afternoon of my medical
career and I still actually don’t
understand how that happens but I’ve
come to realize that I don’t need to
understand that I just need to accept
that it does another photograph of my
parents at 1986 this time taken in the
back garden of my home in London my
father died in Wellington four years
after this photograph was taken he was
77 years old I was 34 and just recently
returned to New Zealand was working at
Auckland Hospital before I moved to
Middlemore where I now work although my
father’s death was not unexpected it
rocked me in all sorts of different ways
first of all that sense of disbelief
that he was he was dead and could be
gone forever a terrible sense of guilt
because I could have been a better son
to him a sense of sadness for not
knowing more about his extraordinary
life and that nagging regret for all
those things left unsaid but perhaps
mostly and perhaps selfishly the thing
that really struck me was that this was
the first time I had to really face up
the ephemeral nature of life and start
coming to terms with my own mortality
the sight of my father’s body in that
funeral home that soon after became a
car yard still haunts me that look on
his face and death one he never had in
life the funeral he had in the freezing
rain at Makkah bar on the south coast of
Wellington the calming effect of our
ritual the singing of the Kaddish the
horror of the drip drip drip of the rain
into that puddle in the corner of his
grave the thud of the red clay on the
coffin those things stayed with me for
months and for years until I could turn
away from my fear of death and start to
concentrate on living a purposeful life
we are all of us a speck in this planet
in this universe we exist for a
millisecond in a vast expanse of time
and if the past has anything to go by
time will continue into a future that we
barely can foresee or comprehend into
that continuance many of us have come
and all of us will go
because life is zero-sum game if there’s
one thing we are good at us human beings
we’re good at dying we hit that target
100% of the time so if we come we will
go you know and as sad as that might be
and as much as our loved ones try to
hold on to us in time too we will
eventually become increasingly lost from
them
and that pattern will continue and
continue until we are a species no more
perhaps because we have no habitable
place
now I am an intensive care doctor I work
with the living although many of my
patients are skirting their own death I
work with their families and I work with
their friends and invariably these
people face their situation were the
strength and resilience and a dignity
that is absolutely outstanding but too
often I see the same sense of of regret
sadness and disbelief that I felt at the
death of my father the ICU is a crucible
a place where there’s a great swirl of
emotion and intensity deep reflection
the ebb and flow of all sorts of
different things conflict and resolution
and we are there with these people
a temporary gift and their lives to
guide them to help them to understand to
judge their pace to each them forward
and whether their loved one lives or
dies our role is to keep them together
to make them better to help them to know
and for that and for them to go away
knowing and to live a good and
purposeful life so there are so many
stories it’s really hard to know where
to begin
last week a young woman going about her
everyday work suddenly looked pained put
a hand up to her head and drop to the
ground deeply unconscious the cause a
cerebral hemorrhage from an undiagnosed
aneurysm by the time she reached
hospital she had fixed and dilated
pupils eighteen hours later she was
declared brain dead the next morning her
lungs her heart her liver and her
kidneys were being transplanted into
five complete strangers in a moment
people’s lives are turned upside down
and inside out families and friends are
changed forever
the longest day and night of their lives
a journey that is so deep these families
are really magnificent and we are there
alongside them and together we see the
light as clear as it can ever be and
it’s their affirmation of life in the
face of the darkness of death
these moments are so profound
they are indescribable and to be a
witness to that kind of stuff is just
awesome intensive care doctors are often
called to assess critically ill patients
at all times of the day and night people
that we’ve never met before and
increasingly now the frail and the
elderly when when I was a young doctor I
felt under enormous pressure to
intervene the families were there their
friends all waiting expecting the doctor
to come to make sense of the situation
their own and to make things better
and when I was young it was really tough
you know I just felt they wanted me to
do stuff and I did stuff so I intervened
I did things I pulled the trigger on all
those things that I was trained to do
but I know better now and circumstances
like that I spend much more time taking
stock of talking to those families
listening to them to learn and
understand more about that patient the
life that they have and what they value
and when you do that in every case the
right treatment path emerges and
invariably it’s to do less rather than
to do more a while back I spent quite a
bit of time working and saw more where I
met my friend Mary now Mary came into
the hospital with a life-threatening
infection was close to death according
to her daughter Mary was already quite
frail she was 78 and in the younger life
though she had met she had run and
looked after the family business
now managed by the daughter it was a
small hotel down by the port and our
pier was quite nice views over the
harbour to watch the ships from the
second floor balconies and in her
younger days Mary would scoot up those
stairs and do the things that she needed
to do but as she got older she started
to take the elevator but in the last 18
months or so Mary was pretty well
confined to the front disc but Mary
enjoyed her life and according to a
daughter she knew how to life and really
importantly she knew how she wanted to
so we had a discussion and we decided
that we would take Mary up to the little
ICU there and we did really simple
things as well as we possibly could
we gave her oxygen we gave her fluids we
gave us some antibiotics a few drugs
here and there and we fine-tuned things
always trying to keep an eye on her
comfort making sure she was comfortable
and we decided to wait and see and see
which way she turned 24 hours later
she’s a little bit better 48 hours later
she was in a chair ten days later shoes
at home and here she is on the day of
her 80th birthday two years later
working with the frail and the elderly
is one of the great challenges for
modern medicine it’s more about the art
than it is about the science it’s about
how do we customize all that we know and
all that we can do to the individual
needs of that really difficult group
it’s about treating softly on that line
between treatment and torture and
invariably it’s about doing less rather
than more as robust and strong as we are
here today with our lives so full and so
much already achieved and so much more
to look forward to in the future
it’s hard to believe that one day we’ll
be gone not just for a holiday or
ducking out for a smoke or a cup of
coffee I mean gone for good
there are lots of people who just can’t
get their heads around that and they put
their their sort of eggs and the
afterlife basket now I I don’t think
that’s such a smart move because I think
that just reduces the intensity of their
lives and they’re here and now what is
the time now at some to five plus six on
the 28th of October 2017
I reckon by now a hundred and seven
billion people have come and gone from
this place you would have thought that
if there was an afterlife we would have
heard about it
think about this all of those letters
emails and texts stacked up against the
post office door on death side you would
have thought that one of them would have
made it through the crack from the
darkness to the life a letter from a
dead mother to a grieving child from a
dead child to a grieving mother but no I
don’t believe there’s ever been a
postcard and I’ve not heard from my
mother my mother who wanted to know
everything about me all of the time
David she would say are you happy David
will you be home for dinner would you
like me to put some food aside for you
do you still like a filter fish if there
was one thing that could transcend death
surely it would be the anxiety of my
mother but no no not a word so it seems
to me that life is very much about the
here and now it’s about earthly minds
and our earthly bodies living on this
our heavenly earth here’s my mother this
photo on the 3rd of May 2009 that’s her
80th birthday and it’s taken at the
Wellesley club in McGuinness E Street
and Wellington she died two years later
I was with her during her final illness
and looked after her at her home in
Wellington for the last couple of months
of her of that of that terrible cancer
she hung on as survivors do unwilling to
give up until in a moment of surrender
death came for her my mother like people
so close to death maintained a radiance
and a warmth all the way to the end and
suddenly it was gone his spirit they
stated 20 grams of Earth took off like a
bird a little while later her body was
cremated and awhile later
her ashes were interred in my father’s
grave and Nakada the spirit of my mother
and the spirit of my father live on in
me I know that and I can feel that now
you might say I am a man of science but
I am also not because I’m just like you
and none of us are immune from the
mystery of death it will always
overwhelm anything that we pretend to
know
I had a patient once who had a
near-death experience she described it
to me like this
the colors were really really bright my
eyesight was sharp I looked down on my
battered body and I heard a voice and it
said it’s not your time so I went back
death is such a mystery a child on a
ghost train the one the one big thing we
will have to face one by one and all
alone 22 years passed between the death
of my father and the death of my mother
and during that time I was forced to
grow up I learned a lot about life and I
learned a bit about death for me life is
about us it’s about you it’s about me
it’s about us together it’s about how we
value each other and how we look after
each other it’s also about how we look
after the environment that sustains us
we come into this world and viewed but
with the spirits of our ancestors and
everything that we do and in each moment
we add to our presence and to our future
and if we are lucky will be our children
who all those who love us that will
carry us into theirs so the question for
each of us is this how will I choose to
live and make the most of my one unique
precious life thank you
[Applause]
you
[Music]
Please follow and like us: