Press "Enter" to skip to content

A story of fifty years photography | Patrick Chauvel | TEDxNishtiman


okay this is it’s good to be here in the
Arbela
without having to go to war and it’s a
good sign I don’t have to take pictures
of fighting you’re at peace so that’s
the first good thing about today this is
how it all started for me on the left
you have my father on the right you have
my uncle they were both soldiers during
the Second World War during the
Indochina war and during the Algerian
war and then they became reporters
they’re the ones that told me you must
never forget about or you must talk
about it you must so war because it’s
our biggest enemy and if you don’t know
your enemy you’re gonna lose so my job
is to cover Wars so we can fight war the
right way if you want peace you have to
know war if you ignore war the world
come to you by surprise so my job is to
endlessly tell the story of the wars
some people during the Second World War
in Germany said they didn’t know what
happened maybe it’s true today you can’t
say that because we’re reporters are
everywhere so if you don’t know that
means you didn’t want to know and if you
don’t want to know that means you’re
responsible for it you don’t know so our
job is to make a little noise in the
head of the politicians who declare war
all the time as we say old people
declare war young people die you know
and it’s the same story I started in
Vietnam in 1968 and I said I have the
impression of doing the same pictures
today it’s always the same thing you
have people that are fighting for ideas
and then the ideas changed
and the fight change but it’s still the
same thing I mean on my bag I have
written SSDD same shit different day you
know so this is what creates refugees
refugees come from there they’re trying
to escape all this and then you have the
religion problem this is Beirut
Christians a priest the Palestinian I
mean he’s been fighting for so long his
hand looks like bullets at the end you
know Palestinians have been fighting
forever my first real story was 67 the
Israeli war I still go to Israel that’s
more than 50 years ago it’s ridiculous I
mean it’s a small country why are they
keep can’t they find a solution maybe
somebody doesn’t want a solution you
know and this is Lebanon now one of the
problems in Lebanon see where the
refugees came from Jordan and suddenly
it was too much refugees for the people
to accept it’s a small country and the
army was not strong
so when turmoil started it took over the
whole country and became a civil war
that’s the danger you have to have a
strong country to accept civilians but
to accept refugees like in France we had
the refugees from Algeria and he worked
out really well because they had they
knew how to do agriculture they knew a
lot of things that we didn’t know and so
they brought us their knowledge the
thing with refugees if you have to take
out their qualities and put them inside
your own country otherwise they’re going
to turn around and around and around and
just become refugees like it’ll become
like a name I mean I’m a refugee but
that doesn’t mean anything
you have to from a refugee become
something else like the Vietnamese you
know the Vietnamese they were sent to
different countries they integrated they
first opened restaurants and together
they worked they were integrated in the
system if they stay as refugees they
keep waiting to come back and they don’t
at the end so it makes them like a
ghetto you know that doesn’t work well
this I mean even the cat is running away
so if why would the Lebanese want to
stay if a cat who has seven lives is
running away you know the the tank was
from the Christian army the can’t I
don’t know
so this is the Lebanese war and this is
Haiti the Haitians were fleeing like
hundreds of people risking their lives
to cross the sea to go to Miami that’s
the first time they were allowed to vote
you can see it didn’t work out and so I
decided to go with them on the boat they
were going from to Miami but once we
were on the boat I found out that we
were going probably to London the
direction he was taking so at the end we
sunk the boat sunk
only 14 people survived this is a
Palestinian in Jenin I asked him what’s
the picture behind it’s the wall of his
dining room and he said it was a picture
on his wall he called it the Palestinian
dream Afghanistan now you have this
civilian overlooking the Canadian
soldiers and that night the Taliban sent
a message to the soldiers saying okay
you have the technology you won this
battle you have the watch but I have the
time
this guy was born here he’s going to
stay here the Canadians have already
it’s the British soldier Afghan this is
two generations
I met the old guy fighting the Russians
and that’s his son who is fighting us so
SSDD know this is Libya now we know how
and this is well this is bash Iike there
was not a long time ago he had you know
the offensive
that’s the Kurd army and the Peshmerga
his tank commander has just been killed
so he’s crying but she kept I don’t know
what these Americans were doing there
so these people are here I think 600,000
people are in Erbil what are they going
to do I mean because we were talking I
was talking with different people today
and saying how can we integrate them in
our system but I think the best solution
would be to stop the fighting you know
get the problem at the root you know
they can’t live there anymore this is
when I came back to Paris after several
Wars people didn’t care about what was
happening they say it’s far away so I
made this montage of pictures saying
well look how Paris would look like if
you’re not careful so it was just trying
to show the people that if you won’t
fight the war you have to know exactly
how the war functions in Afghanistan I I
heard like in the wind one night a voice
saying I changed borders I make Kings I
kill kings I put the brother against the
brother the families against the
families I change borders I defy you to
not live without me that’s war it’s been
going on for so long I mean I’m probably
the only guy wants to lose my job I
to the refugee thing look at what
happened in France we have Algerians we
have Moroccans we have African people
all our ancient colonies have come
towards us a lot of them integrated
themselves not all because that’s that’s
life but to think it’s a good thing to
find the qualities of each and use them
and have them help us you know after all
and look at the French team you have
Africans you have Subterraneans you have
Arabs and you have gold walk but they’re
all French and they all their qualities
came together so that was I think we
should all play football you know maybe
we had incredible good football players
who come from muscle you should do you
know give them footballs and see what
happens ok it’s just a joke but still it
can show that you know in America
there’s a guy who wrote a book and he
imagined that there was no more Mexicans
in California and the next morning the
Americans were like going where’s the
Mexican where’s my pizza where’s my
who’s going to look after this and that
the whole country would stop without the
Mexicans you need to have movement in
different cultures to mix it’s
impossible to work otherwise we’re all
from refugee places I mean the French
refugees from everywhere the Americans I
mean when they say when Donald Trump I
this this thing says migrants brought in
America criminality drug and violence
the Indian says I know but we are not
the same here now we’re integrating
people and the worst thing is to be a
refugee in your own country I worked
with the Kurdish reporters that helped
me to work in Mosul you know Eunice
Muhammad is one of them he’s a reporter
he’s here in this room Berzin and we
worked together we went to muscle around
it was strange for Eunice he was himself
a refugee and he went to study in Iran
and then came back to help me and tell
the story of refugees himself it’s like
a circle going on and going on our job
is to try to break that circle you know
really keep on talking about war so it
stops I mean it’s like a flood you know
you have to be careful it’s coming from
everywhere and try to tell the
politicians you know to think before
they do something stupid because look at
the results we have our president that
suddenly decided to go into Libya we can
see the result that went well you know
the Americans come in Iraq and you see
what happened in Iraq you know that you
have people talking about other
countries saying I will put a solution
but they don’t know about the country
George Bush when he was elected didn’t
have a passport they had to make him a
passport how how can he decide to take
care of Iraq he never left Texas you
know so my job is to try to show what’s
happening so people are accountable for
what they do and Plus that never forget
the people all these people I have in my
pictures I remember them
I have their name I call them on the
phone I mean I’m doing wars for 50 years
that’s half a century
and it’s the same story voila that’s it
[Applause] [Music]
Please follow and like us: