Press "Enter" to skip to content

A Prosecutor’s View: From Bureaucrat to Reformer | Josev Brewer | TEDxGreenville


[Music]

I think the kids apparently up to and

including the tender age of meg Pearson

call it a humble brag but the last time

I gave a TED talk I look like this I’ll

give everyone four guesses as to what

the subject my talk was a my years a

real-life mrs. Doubtfire be the art and

science of not bathing ever see 50

shades of my premature gray or D duck

calls so a tremendous amount has changed

since this photograph personally and

professionally not just the length and

volume of the gray I’ve made some really

tremendous or really significant

personal mistakes I’ve also made some

great choices most notably I still

practice law just no longer with the

federal court I’m an Assistant United

States Attorney and I prosecute

violations of federal criminal law but

and I cannot emphasize this enough today

I’m merely illustrative in the state and

throughout the country there Assistant

United States Attorney’s who are better

more able much much longer tenured and

clearly capable of a whole lot more

basic personal hygiene than myself and

so I think it’s important probably

useful to start with a brief civics

lesson you all might recall from your

government class or not we have two

parallel systems state and federal both

with their own laws and jurisdictions

some of which overlap and some of which

are distinct the Department of Justice

is the law enforcement agency of the

executive branch of the federal

government which is the law enforcement

branch of our federal government the US

Attorney’s of the prosecutorial arm the

prosecutors for the Department of

Justice but in each of the respective

states so in the state we have one u.s.

attorney miss Beth Drake and then under

her various Assistant United States

Attorney’s like myself at the state

level or on your television you would

know them as solicitors or district

attorneys all this to say I’m an example

not necessarily representative of but an

example of many many more so do you need

to pause here real briefly for a quick

legal disclaimer certainly none of y’all

thought you were going to escape today

without some limitation of Liability but

everything I say is in my personal

capacity

my own personal view not any official a

particular view of the Department of

Justice the administration or any of

constituent members now by virtue of

your tenants here today you have

consented to a permanent lifelong

wiretap and on your way out a very very

deep body cavity search so it’s it’s not

any sort of news the recent and mostly

bipartisan attention given to the issue

of mass incarceration 1973 there are

roughly 200,000 prisoners in this

country as a 2015 there were 2.3 million

prisoners in this country we have four

percent of the world’s population but we

house 20% of the world’s prison

population this phenomenon has been

dubbed mass or over incarceration and as

I refer to the problem in criminal

justice a that’s the issue to which I’m

referring the symbol written work

redirecting much the public’s attention

on this issue is by a former federal

prosecutor Michelle Alexander called the

new Jim Crow there’s been a recent

documentary the 13th which powerfully

depicts this predicament has been a

number of TED talks already specifically

in the space Brian Stevenson the equal

justice initiative adam fossa

massachusetts state prosecutor and our

very own TEDx curator caroline caldwell

richmond and all these are necessary

reading for my talk although it’s not my

intent to revisit the underlying problem

it cannot be emphasized enough 2.3

million prisoners in our country rather

i’d like to pick up on this important

story and add some additional value in

perspective especially at this very

critical important political and

cultural time in our US history and so

i’d like to do three things first and

primarily i’d like to make the case that

real systemic systemic change is almost

always an inside job the societal

institutions themselves must be willing

to change either by force or feeling in

commiseration the revolution must be

reciprocated from the seat of power

second i’d like to do a little

show-and-tell about what federal

prosecutors are actually doing to

improve your criminal justice system and

third for all these reasons beg your

political and civic patience and calm as

to the first bureaucrats are

revolutionaries too we typically think

about societal change as revolutionary

in a function of the rebel and the

change

in the reformer King Gandhi the boys X

Snowden we think about militant

resistance versus nonviolent protests

cyber attacks

Selma bridge Standing Rock WikiLeaks

Anonymous we think about the people

versus the power Public Enemy bring the

noise fight the power class conflict we

think about those without any authority

versus those with authority we think

about this very moment in US history UC

Berkeley women’s marches Twitter

bullying Ferguson black lives matter we

think about the community vs. the cops

versus law enforcement versus the system

along with others I’d like to suggest

today that our reform and our revolution

can be community plus the cops plus law

enforcement in parallel with the system

indeed history suggests that it must

King marched and judges ordered Rosa sat

Johnson and Kennedy signed for every

revolutionary and community activist

along the picket line there was some

bureaucrat or sue or elected official on

the inside I think the greatest example

of a system revolutionaries Mandela

himself know persecuted reformer I would

suggest today in history has ever sees

so much power after suffering so much

persecution and declined so much

retribution and yet when he was released

from prison he worked within the

existing political system invite his

political enemies to the table

participated in the writing of a

constitution and used and delivered

reform through the vehicle in the

mechanism of democracy when he could

have burnt when he could have and maybe

even should have burned it all to the

ground the criminal justice system is

like an essential but massive naval

vessel out at sea not the Department of

Justice as a bureaucracy but literally

the entire systemic process it’s got

some wear and tear most people agree

that it’s off-course to one extent or

another has some barnacles maybe some

old technology and revolutionaries and

community activists have literally been

hanging off of its hull

scraping tediously individual barnacles

one at a time

maybe trying to paddle against its

powerful engines some even hope that

they can pirate the ship Caroline

Caldwell Richmond but it’s too big to

move by external force the crew itself

has to be a part of the redirection

where community entities and groups can

focus on one or two parts typically to

extreme frustration and consternation of

the criminal justice problem maybe early

childhood education or job placement for

individuals after they returned from

prisoner a prosecutor is actually

uniquely positioned to impact an

interface with individuals all along

what is called the sequential intercept

model or the whole ship so to speak the

sequential intercept model Maps a

continuum of five points of intervention

with citizens and individuals who

violate the law the first intercept is

prevention in law enforcement before

anybody ever violates the law can we

intervene in their lives and make some

sort of difference the second intercept

is detention at the moment where there’s

reason to believe someone has violated

the law

can we still intervene in their lives

and make a difference the third

intercept is courts in jail after

someone has admitted or it’s been proven

that they violated the law can we

intervene their lives and make a

meaningful difference

the fourth intercept is re-entering

after someone’s paid the consequences

for violating the law can we intervene

in their lives and make a difference in

finally community support can we

intervene their lives and make sure that

they never violate the law again which

is to return full circle to the first

intercept prevention in law enforcement

with some irony there is no entity

better equipped to impact it each point

along this continuum than law

enforcement not community activists

about educators church leaders not the

media where they can impact again often

great frustration at one or two points a

prosecutor can impact not completely but

in part at each point indeed in

rendering Community Safety which is our

mandate is our solemn obligation to make

exactly that kind of difference all on

the way in the words of my legal mentor

the Honorable Bruce ëhow Hendricks this

is not new in his ancient as part of our

common law heritage Heritage’s federal

prosecutors our duty is to the citizen

law abiding or not

to be aware of the use of power and have

the courage not to use power so your

federal prosecutors are in your schools

talking with students about bullying and

gun violence and the tremendous opioid

epidemic last year in the state 25,000

students were reached with those

messages your federal prosecutors are in

the community with state probationers

offering social services to incentivize

the to stay out of trouble and avoid

violating the log in your federal

prosecutors are in mosques and you with

religious communities have been the

target the victim of hate crime

discrimination in the court room your

federal prosecutors are charging more

proportionally and ighting nonviolent

offenders more carefully and where

appropriate looking for alternatives

incarceration like drug courts veterans

courts mental health courts and pretrial

diversion and six years of operation the

federal drug court in this state which

is one of the first most nationally

recognized of its kind has saved over

three and a half million dollars in

taxpayer savings by helping over 50

defendants maintain sobriety and avoid

lengthy prison sentences but even once a

defendant is sentenced the courtroom is

not the end of the intervention your

federal prosecutors are behind the fence

in juvenile facilities and state prisons

and Frederick tional institutions

talking with prisoners about their

release considering clemency petitioners

hosting job fairs helping with

identification and documentation

necessary for a successful return home

in the last 12 months over 800

individuals in the state have been

reached with those resources in this

state the point of the day is not system

players or federal prosecutors are the

most important or the only reformers and

revolutionaries and although as a

middle-aged white male government

bureaucrat I certainly almost

cartoonishly embody him I am NOT here to

shell for the man from the Civil War to

the civil rights movements in terms of

reform activists have said the most

important blood in US history but just

us a leadership has a critical motto it

says those closest to the problem or

closest to the solution but they are

furthest from the reach

sources and the power so today we need a

model of change in expectation about

revolution that all along this continuum

bring system resources to the problem

solver victims of the problem historical

victims of the problem alongside

historical keepers of a problem those

without authority with those in

authority and so no matter what you fear

see on your television these are the

faces of some of the individuals who

serve your country committed to better

and more complete justice in the

courtroom and in the classroom from

youth to post incarceration there’s no

more important time for the federal

prosecutor to seize their full and quasi

judicial responsibilities as curators of

Community Safety and criminal process to

be system players that honor the system

even as they seek to improve it here the

revolution in the streets make it the

standard operating procedure on the

shelves so without taking a poll realize

today that the composition of this room

is more likely system player in your

respective spheres of influence that

reformer more rule-follower than it is

revolutionary so the question is how you

be a part of bringing your system

resources to those without any

[Applause]

[Music]

you [Music]

Please follow and like us: