Press "Enter" to skip to content

A Feminist Perspective on the Fast Fashion Industry | Jeanine Glöyer | TEDxAUBG


[Music]

[Applause]

we should all be feminists t-shirts like

mine promoting feminist statements are

very sorry t-shirts like mine promoting

feminist statements are a very recent

trend produced by the so-called

fast-fashion industry an industry that

allows more than 80 billion garments to

enter the market every year and whose

workforce is composed by more than 80%

women have you ever wondered how these

women the women that are producing

t-shirts like mine feel about fashion

brands being celebrated for promoting

these messages just as these messages

the rapid growth of the textile industry

has promised emancipation emancipation

not through social movement but through

economic growth

however the only outcomes that can be

observed today are nothing but immense

environmental pollution and horrific

exploitation my name is Shannon and when

I was small I was what you would

probably call a true fashion victim I

love to dress to shop and to discuss the

latest outfit with my friends I just

enjoyed clothes without ever really

thinking where they might come from this

fashion however were thoroughly

shattered when I volunteered in India

about nine years ago I visited textile

factories and I got to know the woman

producing the clothes I loved so much

and all of a sudden the term fashion

victim developed a totally new meaning

to me however today I do not want to

talk to you about the horrible incidents

like the collapse of the textile factory

Rana Plaza because I believe that in

order to truly understand the horrendous

condition the textile industry is in

today we need to rather focus on the way

it emerged and how it developed as you

might guess by now seeing my t-shirt

the question that come

sends me the most than that and the

question that I think sheds light on the

problem in general is why is the vast

majority of people working in the

textile industry woman the first time I

actively wondered about this question

wasn’t when I visited a textile factory

in the South Indian town of Tirupur it

was only a few days later when I was an

urgent need of somebody to repair my

trouser and all everybody who was

engaging in tailoring in whom I was able

to find we’re men how was it possible

that everybody inside the factories as

you can see on the slide was female

while everybody engaging in tailoring

outside of the factories we’re men I was

sure that there must be a specific

reason and in fact there is have you

ever wondered why you can buy a t-shirt

for less than what you would pay for a

beer buying clothes for the incredibly

cheap prices that we are used to today

is a very recent phenomena and has only

been realized through dramatic changes

in the way our clothes are produced let

me take you onto a journey back until

the early 70s when neoliberal capitalism

was on the rise and textile companies

were faced by ever-growing competition

of course trying to survive this

competition textile companies eagerly

trying to reduce their costs of

production and as labor or in other

words workers are the most important

input used for the production of

textiles the easiest way for them to do

so was to search for the most

exploitable worker or in other words the

worker that could be paid least but at

the same time still delivering the same

quantity and quality they needed what

they found we’re women women in

countries like India and China or

Bangladesh countries in which the lack

of labor laws or strong trade unions

enabled these same companies to enforce

in labor conditions characterized by

uncertainty low income and limited to no

social benefits but why women

of course there is no one answer to that

question as it depends highly on the

context however there are a bunch of

commonalities that can be found in areas

marked by this feminine phenomenon let

me go back to the tailor that helped me

repair my trouser whom you can see here

on the slide confused by what I had

observed I asked him was it why I wasn’t

able to find any female tailors outside

the factories he laughed at me and said

that of course I couldn’t find any

female tailors because the job of the

tailor is really complex and needs loads

of skills over which women clearly do

not possess working in the textile

industry or in the textile factories

inside does not require loads of skills

if any because every worker has to

complete only one little step along the

assembly line for example adding the

buttons finishing the side or the arm

seams or as you might be able to see on

the slide

adding the labels so it occurred to me

that one reason I’ve only seen women

inside the textile factories might be

that they were believed to be less

skilled and hence in a weaker position

to demand higher wages a second reason

can be detected when observing the ways

in which pantry our constructors

attribute certain roles to men and

others to women while males identity for

example is closely connected to a man’s

ability to care for and control over his

family woman’s identity in most cases is

closely connected to their role as

housewives if there is a financial need

however for a woman to engage in any

kind of wage labour outside the

household and I can tell you for most

families there is her work her work will

in most cases be depicted as merrily

supplementing that other male family

members but to conclude we can say that

social structures and local discourses

that depict or even cause women to be a

less educated and be not in the position

of having to feed an entire family are

used as a

if ocation for paying women less so um

the let me introduce Shaheen to you

Shaheen is from a small village in Tamil

Nadu at the age of 14 she had to move to

Tirupur the city I was talking about in

the beginning in order to work in one of

its textile factories controlled by

mainly male managers she has to work on

the horrendous circumstances often

exposed to sexual and psychological

abuse she earns hardly enough to finance

her living and has no chance to make any

savings for future investments hands she

depends she remains dependent on her

male family members support and thus is

now captured in not only one sphere of

male domination per household but in two

spheres of male domination the household

and the workplace or said differently

she is captured between patriarchy and

capital a very recent trend so-called

home-based textile production is taking

these structures to a completely new

level labor-intensive processes that you

can see on the picture like embroidery

knitting or rack weaving a more and more

often outsource directly to the

households and again the major targets

of work women like Swan that do oh yeah

that household adversity says it has

loads of advantages for them they for

example do nominally

families they they are not exposed to

any plague illogical of physiological

abuse and the factories and they do not

visit their lives to work in an

insecurity rotten buildings and second

glance however it becomes obvious that

again it isn’t really woman but rather

podge miracle and capitalistic

structures that profit most so Anna in

the picture for example and worked for

an international renown rap producer and

she had to buy all materials in

machineries herself of course unable to

afford those she was more or less forced

to take a loan from her employer and

hands in his depth was unable to

discipline to you over even though she

hardly heard anything

integrating her work into her everyday

duties for example doing some embroidery

world rice was still boiling or in

between cleaning the house in doing the

dishes nobody really realized that she

was actually working so well hidden from

the eyes of labor unions and labor

legislations and even those of society

she was not only stripped of any legal

protection but moreover wasn’t actually

or wasn’t seen as an actual worker as

you might imagine this did not really

improve the situation but rather

reinforced her sub Oh denied position

summed up we can now say that the ones

who profit from outsourcing through the

households are again a textile companies

and be patriarchal structures that are

strengthened rather than challenged by

this nutrient the ones who lose are

again women making their work invisible

excluding them from contractual

relations and hence neglecting the full

integration to the world market further

facilitates their exploitation or said

differently patriarchy and capital from

a perfect symbiosis reinforcing each

other to the disadvantage of women

tired of discussing all these issues on

a theoretical level I founded the fair

fashion label Jyoti fair works in

collaboration with an Indian NGO in 2010

our aim is to produce socially an

environmentally friendly product but do

not only bring joy to our customers but

Morris or most importantly to everybody

involved in their production starting

from the cotton farmer through to the

weavers and the seamstresses today

savanah is no longer working under in

labor conditions marked by exploitation

not only is she

earning a fair wage and enjoys decent

and stable working conditions but also

has she been trained in all steps of the

production as well as in the fields of

administration and management – having

gained these new skills she was able to

become self-confident and moreover to

actively participate in negotiating the

way she wants to work of course

Jyoti cannot influence whether SWANA and

her coworkers are going to use their

skills in order to renegotiate their

position in society as well as in the

household however what Jyoti can do and

what I think all fashion brands should

do is to bright to provide them with the

right basis to do so today we can

proudly present that Sue Anna and many

of her co-workers have been able to

actively change their position and

especially about of their girl children

to the better so Anna and many of her

co-workers for example and Ava were able

to send their girl children to school

Halima one of Savannah’s co-workers just

recently told me that instead of

arranging her oldest daughter’s marriage

she’s now making sure that she can go to

university in order to become straight

strong and self dependent so to conclude

work itself is not the problem

but can actually constitute an important

step on the way to individual liberation

only it isn’t built on structures of

exploitation and oppression so you might

ask yourself but what is my role in all

of that what is my position in what can

I do about all of this even though I do

not believe that we as consumers have

the power to change the entire system I

think that we have a lot of power to

actively and consciously choose the

brands that we want to support with our

money what is for sure is that wearing a

t-shirt like mine that states we should

all be feminists but at the same time

has been produced and through exploiting

women’s oppressed situation does not

help at all which is why I’m going to

try to take it off now without releasing

my microphone ok that worked um so what

I do in my everyday life – yeah go about

this challenge and to – yeah come up to

my own expectations is follow a very

simple sentence once introduced by

Vivienne Westwood buy less choose well

and make it last translated into your

everyday life

this could mean if you feel the urgent

need to buy a new t-shirt and I know

that neat just ask yourself do you

really need the new t-shirt or do you

maybe already have enough in your closet

if you decide that yes you do need a new

one maybe just go to the nearest flea

market or invite your friends over for a

close weapon party if that for any

reason doesn’t work for you go to the

nearest fair trade shop and if there is

none in your time because it’s maybe not

that popular yet in your the place you

live or if you live on the

countryside go to the Internet and our

promise you find t-shirts and every

sizes shapes and colors you can only

imagine that is actually not my last

sight okay problem um so um now that

brought me out of control

but what I wanted to say is that if you

yeah look for these t-shirts I promise

you that you’ll find um yeah them in all

sizes and shapes because fast a fear

fashion today is just as beautiful as

conventionally produced fashion with the

only difference that it will not only

please you and the environment but at

the same time will support its producers

and hands can lead to actual gender equality now

Please follow and like us: