Press "Enter" to skip to content

A (Copyright-Free) Exploration of Animation | Asher Silverglade | TEDxCMU


I spent my childhood watching cartoons
yes all of it and you know I’ve never
really regretted that I had a wonderful
time and I learned a lot in the process
but as people tend to do with things as
I got older I kind of outgrew it I
stopped watching them in exchange for
other totally different stuff until a
couple summers ago I was staying with an
aunt and uncle in Ohio for an internship
and one day my cousin’s they’re like
three and five came up to me like hey
Asher do you want to watch Tom and Jerry
with us and I was just like yes I want
to watch Tom and Jerry with you so we’re
sitting on the couch watching Tom and
Jerry it’s like my old favorite and I’m
like really excited for a couple of
seconds and then I see what’s actually
going on on screen so to anyone unaware
Tom and Jerry are a cartoon cat and
mouse and they don’t get along very well
they drop anvils on each other pianos
they like dynamite all the classic
cartoon violins kind of stuff the show I
saw wasn’t doing that they were talking
to each other they were friends like
what happened that’s not what I grew up
with so I started doing some research
and it turns out this kind of transition
isn’t really an uncommon thing with
modern cartoons so if you go back to
like the dawn of early animation with
stuff like Betty Boop in the 1930s it
was totally a normal thing for
characters to just die and go to hell in
the middle of an episode that it was the
olden days I was just something people
did I guess and that stayed in style
until right when I was a kid like I saw
a ton of shows that did that totally
normally Hercules cow and chicken
Courage the Cowardly Dog the grim
adventures of Billy & Mandy Tom and
Jerry ren and stimpy the looney tunes
just to name a few stop till like the
1940s early 50s that you get what you
really think of as cartoon violence
that’s people lighting dynamite on each
other the anvil drop like the kind of
thing you think about and for close to
50 years it just didn’t go out of style
like it was funny that whole time and
yeah people stopped and questioned it
should we be showing this to kids
but it never really stopped until I was
a younger kid and now you’d think things
would get kind of maybe a little more
sensitive over time more caring just the
opposite so to anyone who knows Rocko’s
Modern Life yeah there’s an episode in
which the main character briefly works
at a sex line for copyright reasons I
can’t show the actual screenshot but it
looks just like that I promise you
there’s an episode of Courage the
Cowardly Dog that’s all about I kid you
not
a young woman running away from her
abusive boyfriend to run off with her
lesbian lover I didn’t believe it either
I had to rewatch the episode I still
don’t really believe it and as much as I
tried to recreate that one with stock
photos I just couldn’t and if you go
back to the Tom and Jerry episode and
Jerry thing there’s an episode where the
whole plot is Tom being sent to hell but
more on that later
so my question became how do you get
away with that like if you think I’m
being too harsh I had seen all of this
before I knew how to read and that
wasn’t an uncommon thing either it turns
out the answer was a little simpler than
you might think
it’s just that kids don’t always know
what’s going on like if you show him a
red man with horns surrounded by fire
they don’t know who that is show a
character talking on a phone saying Oh
baby oh baby oh baby they don’t know
what he’s doing violence didn’t fit into
that for me though you show someone
punching someone else dropping an anvil
another heavy object everyone knows
what’s going on and I don’t know if you
guys know this but kids are very very
impressionable I’m not sure if you know
this little tidbit but if you do drop an
anvil on someone it will kill them so
how do you get away with that you show
so many violent things you show it it’s
funny and you never show any
consequences or do you let’s go back to
that Tom and Jerry episode I mentioned
the one where Tom goes to hell so the
plot of the episode is Tom and Jerry are
up to their usual fan
against the cat in the mouse are chasing
each other around when Tom gets a piano
dropped on him
for about the dozens time except in this
episode it actually kills him which is
kind of your first clue you’re not in
for a normal episode you see him go up a
stairway to heaven and go up to a cat
version of Saint Peter at the gate who
says to him hold on buddy you can’t come
in here you’ve been torturing this mouse
the last 40 episodes Tom does get an
exception though he’s given a little
slip of paper that reads quite simply I
forgive everything and if you can get
Jerry to sign it it’ll all be okay
it’d be like it never happened you can
go to heaven it’s all good and he can’t
do it Jerry doesn’t forgive him in time
and as promised you see Tom go into hell
into a burning cauldron with devil
characters everywhere like zero holding
back on that and it turns out this kind
of thing isn’t really uncommon there’s
an episode of Popeye in which he’s
actually put on trial for assault yeah
it’s funny watching him eat spinach and
beat people up but it almost got him a
life sentence like I really can’t
overstate how shocking that kind of
episode is like there’s nothing serious
about Tom and Jerry it’s a cat and a
mouse fighting and yet they take
everything and throw it out just to show
you the consequences of what they’re
doing now before I go on I do want to
address one little thing about violent
cartoons namely in relation to kids so
the thing is kids have parents and if
the kids are watching violent cartoons
the parents are able to step in and say
hey you know I don’t really like what
you’re watching can we change the
channel and aside from that networks
also take very good care of what they do
and do not show and the big example I
have of that is Ren & Stimpy season two
episode two man’s best friend otherwise
known as the banned episode I think you
can kind of see where I’m going with
this so when I asked Viacom if I could
use the episode they banned from airing
in a TED talk they weren’t very friendly
about it so I’d like to give special
thanks to some of the brothers of Alpha
Epsilon Pi for helping to reenact this
so the general class would Brendan
Stimpy is you have these two dogs Ren
and Stimpy Ren’s kind of smart Stimpy
not so much and in this episode they
decide they want to get adopted they
want to be pet dogs so they go off and
they get adopted by this guy named
George licker you know this is gonna go
fantastic things don’t go so great
George tries to teach them a bunch of
tricks
now Stimpy is very good he gets the hang
of it right from the get-go rant not so
much he’s not very good at what he’s
asked to do he doesn’t get a lot of
treats so at the end of the episode
George decides he wants them to be
defense dogs but before they can learn
to defend they have to learn to attack
do you see where this might go wrong
he’s standing there with an oar we
didn’t have oars handy ready to beat the
holy hell out of him and he does even if
I had copyright permissions for this I
don’t think I’d be able to show the
whole clip during the beating George
gets battered bruised very very
graphically his eye pops out of his head
and the whole time Ren keeps going
eventually he falls unconscious and Ren
keeps hitting him and the whole time
Stimpy’s they’re begging him Ren stop
what are you doing – what friend replies
very curtly shut up you’re next and that
whole scene ends with this iconic and
honestly terrifying scene of Ren
standing over George’s unconscious body
laughing now I know that was kind of a
comical recreation of it but I assure
you in episode it was horrifying so
after all that what happens does Ren get
yelled at does he not get any treats
does he get kicked out well no
Ren does what he’s asked to do so he
gets a treat they all do and the episode
ends with the three of them dancing
happily for the camera and that’s it
that’s the end of the episode no
consequences nothing further it ends
then and there when Nickelodeon saw this
they were furious they said we can’t air
this you’re insane
and fired the current showrunner of Ren
& Stimpy the guy who had created the
show himself well what did he do so
wrong well the trick is he didn’t show
any of the consequences of the violence
whereas the alt whereas a lot of the
older cartoons the good ones showed Thom
going to hell Popeye on trial when
they’re violent about things this one
didn’t it showed them getting rewarded
now I think I know what you’re all
thinking right now you know after I love
hearing you babble about your favorite
cartoons but what does this have to do
with me well I’m glad you asked and I’m
getting there
the meantime it’s time to look into our
mystery box oh it’s an apple now this
Apple has been poisoned ignore the fact
that it looks tasty and that I bought it
this morning poisoned let’s see have to
stay in the room with all of you but I
have to leave how can I stop anyone from
dying I see two options one I could take
it explain the Apple and tell you hey it
looks great but it’s not don’t eat it or
I could maybe try to hide it and just
hope no one ends up finding the damn
thing I think it’s human nature to take
the second option which is what a lot of
the newer cartoons do rather than talk
about violence something controversial
they’re willing to simply hide it and
not talk about it and it’s around now
that I feel like you should be realizing
that maybe this wasn’t really about
cartoons I think it’s a natural habit of
people to not talk about things that
they find uncomfortable it’s easier that
way and in a lot of ways it just makes
life a little smoother but you don’t get
any
out of that in fact you lose a lot I’m
here today to encourage all of you to
talk about things that make you
uncomfortable have a look around because
you will find that there are a lot of
ideas that have already been hidden from
you very effectively and if you’re brave
about it approach them as they are and
have a good look you just might find
that they aren’t really so scary and so
dangerous after all well I’ve never been
so nervous eating a banana or maybe not
maybe I’m just a guy who watched too
many cartoons on Netflix last night and
then decided to give a TED talk I leave
that much completely and totally up to
you
but I encourage you talk about what
makes you uncomfortable watch an old
cartoon look for the hidden fruit and
have a great day
thank you [Applause]
Please follow and like us: