
[Music]
hi there so I have a question it’s
actually the same question I’ve had for
the last 25 years do media have the
power to make peace so in order to
address that question I’m gonna make
five points and conclude with my new
vision so typically when I ask people
this question
they say the answer is yes and what
they’ll do is they’ll point to examples
from media meeting mass communication
and more broadly also interpersonal
communication and they’ll give me an
example of some TV episode they saw or
maybe a post they read in social media
or a speech they heard in which someone
advocated for peace and based on that
they’ll say yes media have the power to
make peace but here’s the thing there’s
actually no conclusive evidence to that
effect and the reason for that is
there’s been very little research
conducted to try to answer that question
and most of the research that actually
exists is not what is called assessment
and evaluation research that is research
that directly tries to determine whether
what you came across say in a social
media post if that’s influencing your
attitudes beliefs or peace relevant
behaviors what I mean by that is that in
order to determine if media actually
have an impact on peace you need to know
is it impacting someone in such a way
that they are it’s causing them to hate
their enemies less is it causing them to
have different political beliefs about
who is responsible in a conflict or most
importantly is it changing their
behavior say to join a protest or if
Peace Accords are in process to vote
differently than they would have had
they not interacted with that peace
message so as I said I’ve been interest
in this question for the last 25 years
around that time in the 1990s I had been
working as a practitioner for a number
of media organizations conflict
management organizations as well as for
the United Nations
we’re essentially I was running these
kinds of piece media interventions
now what became apparent to me is that
these kinds of interventions they’ve
existed since the 1940s so today they’ve
existed now for 90 years but scholars
weren’t actually interested in assessing
and evaluating them until about the turn
of the century which was 20 years ago
that means we have a knowledge gap of 70
years and that’s why we don’t have
actual research to answer this question
and now even among the little bit of
research that exists the assessment
evaluation research that exists most of
that focuses on peacebuilding not
peacemaking namely whether message
messages can foster friendship not
whether they can change people’s
political beliefs and the thing is
political beliefs are essential to
change political beliefs about core
issues surrounding inequitable resource
distribution and perceptions about that
if political beliefs are not changed
peace cannot be made so therein is the
issue why the first point that I’m
making that there hasn’t been any
conclusive evidence to answer that
question whether media make peace the
second point I want to make is that
there is evidence from analogous
research about health media campaigns
that suggests media interventions can
have no impact at all meaning if you’re
running them you’re just throwing money
down the drain so scholars who’ve
studied smoking secession campaigns have
effectively shown that telling someone
who smokes that smoking is bad for them
has no impact on their behaviors because
news flash everyone who smokes already
knows it’s bad for them so if you
actually want to get them to quit you
have to adopt a new strategy so that’s
the second point media intervention may
not have any impact the third point is
that there’s also evidence from
analogous assessment and evaluation
research about humanitarian
interventions that suggests you can
actually create more harm than good so
research that was conducted around the
time
of the Rwandan genocide showed that very
well-meaning aid practitioners actually
inadvertently aided the genocide so what
they did is they intervened into Rwanda
and they supplied resources to Hutus who
already had more resources and also had
reasons tied to rwanda x’ precursor
colonial history to enact revenge
against Tutsis so what happened those
eight practitioners who were trying to
foster socio-economic development
instead inadvertently he aided a
genocide so it’s because of vexing
concerns like this that I felt we really
need to answer this question do media
have the power to make peace right we
have no conclusive evidence about that
question there’s analogous evidence that
you can have no impact that you’re just
throwing throwing money down the drain
and you can create more harm than good
that’s why in the late 90s I decided to
become a scholar and as I saw no one was
answering this question it became
apparent to me that I guess I needed to
if I wanted to know the answer and felt
really passionate about it so at that
time I started to advocate a
sub-discipline that I call peace
communication that’s dedicated to
precisely procuring assessment
evaluation evidence to answer this
question now in order to try to answer
this question I conducted a major study
I started that in 2001 until 2011 so
it’s been ten years but really the bulk
of it I conducted from 2004 to 2006 with
a follow-up in 2011 so what I did is I
picked an intervention that I felt was
the best design intervention in
existence at that time because naturally
there’s a most to learn from it and the
reason why it was the best design
intervention my opinion is that it was
unusually the only one that actually
incorporated any kind of assessment
evaluation behavior change evidence
namely from analogous research the
second thing about this intervention is
that it was targeted to children now
children typically make up anywhere from
1/2 to the majority of conflict zone
based populations
so it’s them rather than adults who
really experience daily life in a
conflict so for these reasons I felt
this intervention offered the best you
know the most to learn from and so I
proceeded to conduct an assessment
evaluation of it now what is this
intervention well it’s actually a
version of Sesame Street that was
targeted to Israeli and Palestinian
children now for you to understand the
study and what I learned from it let me
first tell you a little bit about these
media interventions of these Sesame
Street’s so number one Israeli and
Palestinian Sesame Street was produced
by four production teams an Israeli team
a Palestinian team and American team in
its first season in its second season it
also brought on a Jordanian production
team now as a Peace Media intervention
it transpired over two seasons so I
study those two seasons in combination
the second point to know about these
sesame streets is that unlike all other
sesame streets around the world it
operated on two streets rather than one
meaning on a Palestinian and an Israeli
Street so these sesame street’s
basically envisioned the end result of
the Oslo Accords between Israelis and
Palestinians that sought to achieve what
was known in the nomenclature as a
two-state solution namely where a
Palestinian state would exist side by
side and peace with an Israeli state so
Sesame Street created a two Street
solution and the set design therefore
envisioned the resolution of the
conflict right there was no conflict
peace had been made which obviously in
reality it hadn’t been made and as I’m
sure all of you know the
israeli-palestinian conflict has still
not been resolved but that is the vision
they wanted to give to the children the
third point to know about it is that it
operated in both Arabic and Hebrew and
fourthly like all other sesame streets
around the world it sought to instill
early childhood development skills in
its audience like reading writing
arithmetic basic social skills but what
it added there was also an area called
mutual respect and that’s where it
focused on peace building now to portray
peace building what they did and you
could see here on the screen on the left
side
some examples of the characters from
Disraeli Sesame Street on the right side
some examples of the characters from
Palestinian Street a Palestinian Sesame
Street what they did is they essentially
created characters who are non
stereotypical representations of
Israelis and Palestinians and scripted
them in as all good-natured human beings
and then they would show them
interacting with one another where
Israelis would go visit the Palestinian
Street and Palestinians would go visit
the Israeli Street and they would
interact together peacefully to model
that for the audience of the hope that
they would emulate that so as I said I
conducted a study of this and I want to
know what the audience took away from it
so in order to do that I lived in
several Israeli and Palestinian
communities where I conducted what
scholars call an ethnography in order to
make sense of these children’s daily
lives amid conflict I would then go to
the children’s homes I would interact
with them and their families I would
then interview the children to try to
make sense of how they made sense of the
conflict and then I would show them a
mock episode of the program and watch
alongside them after that I would then
ask some questions to figure out what it
is they took away from the program so I
would use this toolkit like game board
or this game board to help facilitate
our conversation and as part of that I
also gave the children the opportunity
to respond not just verbally but through
drawing form and this is all something
typical that scholars do when they
conduct research with children this age
who in my study were 5 to 8 now in order
to make sense of what they understood
about the series as I mentioned
beforehand I first asked them what they
understood about the conflict and how
they perceive their partners to conflict
so to view that I would start out first
of all by asking the Palestinian
children can you tell me who or what is
a Jewish Israeli now that’s not really a
term that’s used locally so they
couldn’t really answer that so I’d say
how about someone who’s Jewish and they
would say yes someone who is Jewish is a
member of an army
in other words they were the way they
defined someone who was Jewish was for
example not as a member of a nation not
as a member of a religious group not
even as a people but rather you know
dimensionally only as members of an army
they would then proceed to draw this
kind of image of an adult dressed in a
khaki colored military uniform when I
asked the Jewish Israeli children the
same question namely can you tell me who
or what is a Palestinian he would
respond blankly they just didn’t respond
and I’m thinking what’s going on here
like why don’t you know what a
Palestinian is so I didn’t I encouraged
them and I’d say are you sure you don’t
know and then they would say oh yeah you
mean a terrorist yeah I know what a
Palestinian is and I would say okay so
in their case they define Palestinians
not for example as a nation not an
ethnic group and not even a people they
instead to find them you know
dimensionally as terrorists so both of
them as you could see have very negative
stereotypes of one another now when I
went on and I’m sorry when I they asked
the Jewish Israeli children to draw
their stereotype they drew this kind of
image of an adult clad in a ski cap
which was their representation of a
terrorist now when I went on to ask them
about the interpretation of the show I
would ask first the Palestinian children
to tell me what it is they saw on the
show for example did they see anyone
Jewish in it so the Palestinian children
would tell me no I didn’t see anyone
dressed in military uniform therefore
there were no Jews in Sesame Street I
would then ask the Jewish Israeli
children the same question did you see
any Palestinians in the show and they
would say no in their case the answer
they provided they would start out by
telling me you know this is an Israeli
show despite what I told you earlier
that the series was actually produced by
4 production teams they assumed it was
only Israeli made and by that they
specifically met Jewish Israeli and then
they would go on to answer my question
and they’d answer in a way which they
thought
the answer was obvious and even my
question was stupid where they would say
this so you know it’s an israeli-made
production and obviously Israelis care
about us so they’re not gonna put
someone on the show who would harm us so
they’re not gonna put a terrorist on da
so no there were no Palestinians in the
show so this brings me to my fourth
point audiences interpret information in
a myriad of ways their attitudes or
beliefs will not necessarily be affected
or their peace relevant behaviors so
pointing to say a speech you heard on TV
as evidence that media can make peace
isn’t because audiences interpret things
in all kinds of ways as you just heard
now what happened here for the
Palestinian children what they saw on
Sesame Street
these non stereotypical portrayals of
good-natured Jewish Israelis just did
not square with their stereotypes of
someone who’s quote-unquote Jewish right
they’re the particular stereotype they
evinced it also didn’t square with their
intertwined political beliefs that we
also discuss in which they told me who
they felt was responsible for the
destruction around them there and who is
responsible for their freedoms and self
autonomy or rather lack thereof as they
explained it to me likewise for the
Jewish Israeli children the portrayal
the non stereotypical portrayal of
Palestinians on Sesame Street didn’t
square with their stereotypes nor did it
square with their intertwined political
beliefs about who they felt was
responsible for the conflict so this is
what ultimately happened now I can go on
and say a lot about why this happened I
can also talk about the recommendations
that I make for the improvement not just
of Israeli and Palestinian Sesame Street
but peace media interventions around the
world and that’s something I talk about
in a book that I’ve just written and one
of the things I’d note is that peace
media interventions cannot be effective
unless all parties took conflicts
definition of peace is included and that
might be typically either justice
equality or security if all those
definite
for peace or not encoded into an
invention it will not have an impact on
all parties to conflict now rather than
get into greater detail about that what
I want to do right now in my remaining
time is get to my fourth point which is
to return to my original question do
media have the power to impact peace
well after this study and everything I
know today my answer to that is not
necessarily at least as so far as we
know today what I do know is that if
evidence-based practice is generated we
would know much more and this is where I
get to my new vision that I want to
conclude with what if a new organization
were created that encouraged
evidence-based practice what if it
encouraged more scholars to conduct the
needed assessment evaluation evidence or
research to determine whether media can
impact peace and what if that
organization paired them with scholars
to generate evidence-based practice if
that happened one of two things would
occur either we would know conclusively
that media do not have the power to
impact peace in which case I would say
we shouldn’t run these programs anymore
that’s money thrown down the drain or we
would learn that these programs can be
effective and we would actually improve
them now none of that concur without
support
that’s where policymakers and donors
come in if policymakers signal their
support for this kind of effort that
would go a long way in increasing the
probability that piece media
interventions would be successful if
donors helped fund it that would also
obviously increase the effect now
typically the organizations that run
these interventions media and conflict
management organizations are
not-for-profit organizations they like
scholars don’t have money for this on
the other hand for-profit media
organizations like high-tech companies
do as do other donors who are already
funding these efforts so if they
provided the funding we might see this
kind of organization
now I’m not suggesting they provide more
funding than they’re already providing
what I’m suggesting is that they create
a new funding model instead of
continuing to fund scholars and
practitioners separately if they made
funding contingent on them working
together we might see a change we might
see the generation of evidence-based
practice now I’ve been dreaming about
creating an organization like this for
years but it’s not something I can do
alone so if this is something that
resonates with you I would love to hear
from you thank you
[Applause]
hi there so I have a question it’s
actually the same question I’ve had for
the last 25 years do media have the
power to make peace so in order to
address that question I’m gonna make
five points and conclude with my new
vision so typically when I ask people
this question
they say the answer is yes and what
they’ll do is they’ll point to examples
from media meeting mass communication
and more broadly also interpersonal
communication and they’ll give me an
example of some TV episode they saw or
maybe a post they read in social media
or a speech they heard in which someone
advocated for peace and based on that
they’ll say yes media have the power to
make peace but here’s the thing there’s
actually no conclusive evidence to that
effect and the reason for that is
there’s been very little research
conducted to try to answer that question
and most of the research that actually
exists is not what is called assessment
and evaluation research that is research
that directly tries to determine whether
what you came across say in a social
media post if that’s influencing your
attitudes beliefs or peace relevant
behaviors what I mean by that is that in
order to determine if media actually
have an impact on peace you need to know
is it impacting someone in such a way
that they are it’s causing them to hate
their enemies less is it causing them to
have different political beliefs about
who is responsible in a conflict or most
importantly is it changing their
behavior say to join a protest or if
Peace Accords are in process to vote
differently than they would have had
they not interacted with that peace
message so as I said I’ve been interest
in this question for the last 25 years
around that time in the 1990s I had been
working as a practitioner for a number
of media organizations conflict
management organizations as well as for
the United Nations
we’re essentially I was running these
kinds of piece media interventions
now what became apparent to me is that
these kinds of interventions they’ve
existed since the 1940s so today they’ve
existed now for 90 years but scholars
weren’t actually interested in assessing
and evaluating them until about the turn
of the century which was 20 years ago
that means we have a knowledge gap of 70
years and that’s why we don’t have
actual research to answer this question
and now even among the little bit of
research that exists the assessment
evaluation research that exists most of
that focuses on peacebuilding not
peacemaking namely whether message
messages can foster friendship not
whether they can change people’s
political beliefs and the thing is
political beliefs are essential to
change political beliefs about core
issues surrounding inequitable resource
distribution and perceptions about that
if political beliefs are not changed
peace cannot be made so therein is the
issue why the first point that I’m
making that there hasn’t been any
conclusive evidence to answer that
question whether media make peace the
second point I want to make is that
there is evidence from analogous
research about health media campaigns
that suggests media interventions can
have no impact at all meaning if you’re
running them you’re just throwing money
down the drain so scholars who’ve
studied smoking secession campaigns have
effectively shown that telling someone
who smokes that smoking is bad for them
has no impact on their behaviors because
news flash everyone who smokes already
knows it’s bad for them so if you
actually want to get them to quit you
have to adopt a new strategy so that’s
the second point media intervention may
not have any impact the third point is
that there’s also evidence from
analogous assessment and evaluation
research about humanitarian
interventions that suggests you can
actually create more harm than good so
research that was conducted around the
time
of the Rwandan genocide showed that very
well-meaning aid practitioners actually
inadvertently aided the genocide so what
they did is they intervened into Rwanda
and they supplied resources to Hutus who
already had more resources and also had
reasons tied to rwanda x’ precursor
colonial history to enact revenge
against Tutsis so what happened those
eight practitioners who were trying to
foster socio-economic development
instead inadvertently he aided a
genocide so it’s because of vexing
concerns like this that I felt we really
need to answer this question do media
have the power to make peace right we
have no conclusive evidence about that
question there’s analogous evidence that
you can have no impact that you’re just
throwing throwing money down the drain
and you can create more harm than good
that’s why in the late 90s I decided to
become a scholar and as I saw no one was
answering this question it became
apparent to me that I guess I needed to
if I wanted to know the answer and felt
really passionate about it so at that
time I started to advocate a
sub-discipline that I call peace
communication that’s dedicated to
precisely procuring assessment
evaluation evidence to answer this
question now in order to try to answer
this question I conducted a major study
I started that in 2001 until 2011 so
it’s been ten years but really the bulk
of it I conducted from 2004 to 2006 with
a follow-up in 2011 so what I did is I
picked an intervention that I felt was
the best design intervention in
existence at that time because naturally
there’s a most to learn from it and the
reason why it was the best design
intervention my opinion is that it was
unusually the only one that actually
incorporated any kind of assessment
evaluation behavior change evidence
namely from analogous research the
second thing about this intervention is
that it was targeted to children now
children typically make up anywhere from
1/2 to the majority of conflict zone
based populations
so it’s them rather than adults who
really experience daily life in a
conflict so for these reasons I felt
this intervention offered the best you
know the most to learn from and so I
proceeded to conduct an assessment
evaluation of it now what is this
intervention well it’s actually a
version of Sesame Street that was
targeted to Israeli and Palestinian
children now for you to understand the
study and what I learned from it let me
first tell you a little bit about these
media interventions of these Sesame
Street’s so number one Israeli and
Palestinian Sesame Street was produced
by four production teams an Israeli team
a Palestinian team and American team in
its first season in its second season it
also brought on a Jordanian production
team now as a Peace Media intervention
it transpired over two seasons so I
study those two seasons in combination
the second point to know about these
sesame streets is that unlike all other
sesame streets around the world it
operated on two streets rather than one
meaning on a Palestinian and an Israeli
Street so these sesame street’s
basically envisioned the end result of
the Oslo Accords between Israelis and
Palestinians that sought to achieve what
was known in the nomenclature as a
two-state solution namely where a
Palestinian state would exist side by
side and peace with an Israeli state so
Sesame Street created a two Street
solution and the set design therefore
envisioned the resolution of the
conflict right there was no conflict
peace had been made which obviously in
reality it hadn’t been made and as I’m
sure all of you know the
israeli-palestinian conflict has still
not been resolved but that is the vision
they wanted to give to the children the
third point to know about it is that it
operated in both Arabic and Hebrew and
fourthly like all other sesame streets
around the world it sought to instill
early childhood development skills in
its audience like reading writing
arithmetic basic social skills but what
it added there was also an area called
mutual respect and that’s where it
focused on peace building now to portray
peace building what they did and you
could see here on the screen on the left
side
some examples of the characters from
Disraeli Sesame Street on the right side
some examples of the characters from
Palestinian Street a Palestinian Sesame
Street what they did is they essentially
created characters who are non
stereotypical representations of
Israelis and Palestinians and scripted
them in as all good-natured human beings
and then they would show them
interacting with one another where
Israelis would go visit the Palestinian
Street and Palestinians would go visit
the Israeli Street and they would
interact together peacefully to model
that for the audience of the hope that
they would emulate that so as I said I
conducted a study of this and I want to
know what the audience took away from it
so in order to do that I lived in
several Israeli and Palestinian
communities where I conducted what
scholars call an ethnography in order to
make sense of these children’s daily
lives amid conflict I would then go to
the children’s homes I would interact
with them and their families I would
then interview the children to try to
make sense of how they made sense of the
conflict and then I would show them a
mock episode of the program and watch
alongside them after that I would then
ask some questions to figure out what it
is they took away from the program so I
would use this toolkit like game board
or this game board to help facilitate
our conversation and as part of that I
also gave the children the opportunity
to respond not just verbally but through
drawing form and this is all something
typical that scholars do when they
conduct research with children this age
who in my study were 5 to 8 now in order
to make sense of what they understood
about the series as I mentioned
beforehand I first asked them what they
understood about the conflict and how
they perceive their partners to conflict
so to view that I would start out first
of all by asking the Palestinian
children can you tell me who or what is
a Jewish Israeli now that’s not really a
term that’s used locally so they
couldn’t really answer that so I’d say
how about someone who’s Jewish and they
would say yes someone who is Jewish is a
member of an army
in other words they were the way they
defined someone who was Jewish was for
example not as a member of a nation not
as a member of a religious group not
even as a people but rather you know
dimensionally only as members of an army
they would then proceed to draw this
kind of image of an adult dressed in a
khaki colored military uniform when I
asked the Jewish Israeli children the
same question namely can you tell me who
or what is a Palestinian he would
respond blankly they just didn’t respond
and I’m thinking what’s going on here
like why don’t you know what a
Palestinian is so I didn’t I encouraged
them and I’d say are you sure you don’t
know and then they would say oh yeah you
mean a terrorist yeah I know what a
Palestinian is and I would say okay so
in their case they define Palestinians
not for example as a nation not an
ethnic group and not even a people they
instead to find them you know
dimensionally as terrorists so both of
them as you could see have very negative
stereotypes of one another now when I
went on and I’m sorry when I they asked
the Jewish Israeli children to draw
their stereotype they drew this kind of
image of an adult clad in a ski cap
which was their representation of a
terrorist now when I went on to ask them
about the interpretation of the show I
would ask first the Palestinian children
to tell me what it is they saw on the
show for example did they see anyone
Jewish in it so the Palestinian children
would tell me no I didn’t see anyone
dressed in military uniform therefore
there were no Jews in Sesame Street I
would then ask the Jewish Israeli
children the same question did you see
any Palestinians in the show and they
would say no in their case the answer
they provided they would start out by
telling me you know this is an Israeli
show despite what I told you earlier
that the series was actually produced by
4 production teams they assumed it was
only Israeli made and by that they
specifically met Jewish Israeli and then
they would go on to answer my question
and they’d answer in a way which they
thought
the answer was obvious and even my
question was stupid where they would say
this so you know it’s an israeli-made
production and obviously Israelis care
about us so they’re not gonna put
someone on the show who would harm us so
they’re not gonna put a terrorist on da
so no there were no Palestinians in the
show so this brings me to my fourth
point audiences interpret information in
a myriad of ways their attitudes or
beliefs will not necessarily be affected
or their peace relevant behaviors so
pointing to say a speech you heard on TV
as evidence that media can make peace
isn’t because audiences interpret things
in all kinds of ways as you just heard
now what happened here for the
Palestinian children what they saw on
Sesame Street
these non stereotypical portrayals of
good-natured Jewish Israelis just did
not square with their stereotypes of
someone who’s quote-unquote Jewish right
they’re the particular stereotype they
evinced it also didn’t square with their
intertwined political beliefs that we
also discuss in which they told me who
they felt was responsible for the
destruction around them there and who is
responsible for their freedoms and self
autonomy or rather lack thereof as they
explained it to me likewise for the
Jewish Israeli children the portrayal
the non stereotypical portrayal of
Palestinians on Sesame Street didn’t
square with their stereotypes nor did it
square with their intertwined political
beliefs about who they felt was
responsible for the conflict so this is
what ultimately happened now I can go on
and say a lot about why this happened I
can also talk about the recommendations
that I make for the improvement not just
of Israeli and Palestinian Sesame Street
but peace media interventions around the
world and that’s something I talk about
in a book that I’ve just written and one
of the things I’d note is that peace
media interventions cannot be effective
unless all parties took conflicts
definition of peace is included and that
might be typically either justice
equality or security if all those
definite
for peace or not encoded into an
invention it will not have an impact on
all parties to conflict now rather than
get into greater detail about that what
I want to do right now in my remaining
time is get to my fourth point which is
to return to my original question do
media have the power to impact peace
well after this study and everything I
know today my answer to that is not
necessarily at least as so far as we
know today what I do know is that if
evidence-based practice is generated we
would know much more and this is where I
get to my new vision that I want to
conclude with what if a new organization
were created that encouraged
evidence-based practice what if it
encouraged more scholars to conduct the
needed assessment evaluation evidence or
research to determine whether media can
impact peace and what if that
organization paired them with scholars
to generate evidence-based practice if
that happened one of two things would
occur either we would know conclusively
that media do not have the power to
impact peace in which case I would say
we shouldn’t run these programs anymore
that’s money thrown down the drain or we
would learn that these programs can be
effective and we would actually improve
them now none of that concur without
support
that’s where policymakers and donors
come in if policymakers signal their
support for this kind of effort that
would go a long way in increasing the
probability that piece media
interventions would be successful if
donors helped fund it that would also
obviously increase the effect now
typically the organizations that run
these interventions media and conflict
management organizations are
not-for-profit organizations they like
scholars don’t have money for this on
the other hand for-profit media
organizations like high-tech companies
do as do other donors who are already
funding these efforts so if they
provided the funding we might see this
kind of organization
now I’m not suggesting they provide more
funding than they’re already providing
what I’m suggesting is that they create
a new funding model instead of
continuing to fund scholars and
practitioners separately if they made
funding contingent on them working
together we might see a change we might
see the generation of evidence-based
practice now I’ve been dreaming about
creating an organization like this for
years but it’s not something I can do
alone so if this is something that
resonates with you I would love to hear
from you thank you
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: