
I’d spent the past year and a half
researching the history of tits in the
United States you heard that correctly
TI TS or whichever of these hundred
euphemisms you’d prefer instead tits is
my euphemism of choice because it’s the
most disarming of the group but I would
also vote for the calculator spelling of
boobs which is eight zero zero eight
five for those of you who missed that
portion of seventh-grade math so all
that begs the question why breasts
clearly given our vernacular we live in
a culture that harbors a deep
fascination breasts represent so many
powerful things fertility eternity
maturity femininity sexuality yet
statistically 75% of the women in this
room would admit to being dissatisfied
with that particular body part and if
I’m being perfectly honest until I
started this project I was among that
75% as well here’s why it seems like
that shouldn’t have happened to me
though when I was around three years old
I decided that when I grew up I wanted
two things
well technically three I wanted to
become a writer and I wanted to have
really huge boobs which is why
throughout most of the 90s if there was
a pair of round objects in front of me
they went right up my shirt it’s true
I’m a millennial I’ve always been told
to follow my dreams I’d also been told
that my body was a temple and yet
fast-forward to 10 years later and my
body felt more like a prison I hated
having breasts first of all they were
heavy and they fell into my armpits when
I slept which I did not sign up for
but also I was ashamed of having breasts
because of the attention that it called
to my body and because it seemed to me
that there was only one acceptable
breast shape and you know what I’m
talking about large round perfectly
symmetrical breasts I didn’t have which
is why throughout so many New Year’s
resolutions I continually promised that
I would just learn to accept my body
body acceptance for me was only a dream
and here’s the thing that they don’t
tell you about dreams it’s not enough to
follow them you have to chase them it
wasn’t until I got to graduate school
and fell down this rabbit hole of
information-gathering that I finally
started to acquire the body acceptance
that I’d so wanted and a large part of
that came from gaining a historical
perspective on the body so I’d like to
give you the highlights of 242 years
worth of American breasts I’ve been
calling a tits tree needless to say I’ve
spent a considerable amount of time in
various Columbia libraries looking at it
and one of the richest insights I found
was this in her book the beauty myth
Naomi Wolf wrote how the qualities that
a given period calls beautiful and women
are merely symbols of the female
behavior that period considers desirable
in other words ideal standards of beauty
are less prescriptive of how a woman
should look than how she should behave
and in that sense breasts are a portal
into a much broader set of questions
about American conceptions of feminine
beauty and behavior in viewing these
images I’d like you to notice how
limiting middle and upper-middle class
body ideals especially in women’s
magazines where the bulk of these images
come from really were there very few
women of color represented and very
quickly we start to see the same body
types emerging over and over again and
while this is by no means a
comprehensive history it does chart how
frequently the ideal breasts chain
and the links we’ve gone to conform to
them since the beginnings of American
history our breasts have been flattened
with corsets bound with gauze cinched in
to bust developers and surgically
altered with materials from glass balls
– bees – bees wax goat’s milk and Teflon
these moments in American history prove
it the way we shape our breasts and
bodies is constantly in flux and for the
sake of everyone’s attention span I’m
going to guide us through the tits tree
in 30 year increments in the earliest
years of American history the ideal body
was young and virginal for more youthful
looking breasts a popular medical book
advised older women which probably meant
women around my age to make a plaster
from hemlock which is a poisonous plant
we already knew with deadly because it
was what killed Socrates 2,000 years
before and it gets worse in the
mid-1800s Victorian ideals came to the
fore which equated small features with
virtue so a gaunt pale body with small
breasts implied a higher moral standing
for paler skin women use body lotion
laced with arsenic which in the next
century would be reclaimed by women as a
convenient means of killing one’s
husband towards the end of the 1800s
voluptuously Illustrated Gibson girls
epitomized the rise of the educated
independent women who took a more
visible role in public life but even an
icon is seemingly liberated as she
wasn’t immune to conforming to the ideal
body on the right you’ll notice is a
series ad of a bus developer and I know
what you’re thinking it’s not a toilet
plunger it was actually used to enlarge
the breasts and I’m not sure that it
worked but by the 1920s no one wanted
anyways
a new feminine ideal took hold with a
flapper and while she could now vote
and was liberated from the corsets her
mother and grandmother wore she bound
her breasts in keeping with the era’s
flat-chested androgynous ideal and that
accordion looking contraption on the
right is a bandeau bra which is also
called a flattener after world war ii
the population swelled the economy
swells and guess what else welt
technological innovations led to a new
circular sewing stitch which created the
cone-shaped bullet bra breast mania in
the 50s and 60s was bolstered by another
landmark in women’s health the first
fda-approved oral contraceptive it had
such high estrogen levels that sales of
C cup bras jumped 50 percent but
fortunately women who didn’t have ample
cleavage or take birth control could
still live up to the ideal thanks to
innovations like the inflatable bullet
bra on the right which needs no further
comment we saw some of the bodily ideals
from the 50s
in the eighties but with bigger hair a
booming economy created a market for all
things access and the new feminine ideal
became spelt toned and large breasted
thanks in part to the rise of
supermodels aerobics and breast implants
headlines heralded the triumphant return
of breasts we’re still not sure where
they went and with that came ads for
breast enhancers like these in the pages
of popular women’s magazines again that
is not a toilet plunger so where does
this leave us now I think the two
headlines I’m about to show you
illustrate how quickly American Beauty
ideals shift in the 21st century last
year the New York Post ran this headline
boobs are back still no word on where
not two months later they ran this small
boobs are back sometimes it feels like
there’s no winning when it comes to
women’s media and breasts at its worst
natural breasts get criticized for
looking saggy surgically enhanced
breasts are called out for appearing
unnatural and visible cleavage somehow
translates to a cry for attention 242
years worth of history demonstrates how
often breasts have been treated as a
commodity bull trend instead of a body
part so it seems absurd to hate your
breasts for how they look when we can’t
even agree on what a good pair of
breasts look like in the first place
now I’m not condemning women who augment
their breasts nor am i suggesting that
we abstain from wearing whatever becomes
the equivalent of the bullet bra in 30
years my hope is that we continue to
move towards a more expansive notion of
beauty that doesn’t revolve around taut
skin that defies gravity I’ve looked at
this picture for so long trying to
figure out how to describe the
expression on my face and I realize now
what it is it’s pride when we’re kids we
don’t shoulder any of the body shame
that comes later
most of us barely notice our bodies
unless we scrape the knees couldn’t even
name most body parts let alone tell you
how they should look if I’m lucky enough
to have a daughter I’d want her to know
that having a body can be a challenge
regardless of what you look like I’d
want her to know that body acceptance
like progress itself isn’t linear and
I’d wanted to know that not all women
have large perfect breasts and that
you’re a woman whether you have large
breasts or small breasts or one breast
or no breasts and truthfully I still
don’t know how you go about making your
body into a temple but I’d suggest this
instead
treat your body as you would a historic
building you don’t have to love every
inch of it but you have to respect it
protect it maintain it and understand
its importance we’re living with all of
the privileges women have fought for
centuries to get and are still fighting
for and we can’t control what the ideal
body is today or what it will look like
tomorrow so why would we accept societal
notions of what’s beautiful and what’s
valuable this is a call to not only us
but our friends our sisters our wives
our daughters standards of beauty are
forever changing let’s stop chasing them
thank you [Applause]
researching the history of tits in the
United States you heard that correctly
TI TS or whichever of these hundred
euphemisms you’d prefer instead tits is
my euphemism of choice because it’s the
most disarming of the group but I would
also vote for the calculator spelling of
boobs which is eight zero zero eight
five for those of you who missed that
portion of seventh-grade math so all
that begs the question why breasts
clearly given our vernacular we live in
a culture that harbors a deep
fascination breasts represent so many
powerful things fertility eternity
maturity femininity sexuality yet
statistically 75% of the women in this
room would admit to being dissatisfied
with that particular body part and if
I’m being perfectly honest until I
started this project I was among that
75% as well here’s why it seems like
that shouldn’t have happened to me
though when I was around three years old
I decided that when I grew up I wanted
two things
well technically three I wanted to
become a writer and I wanted to have
really huge boobs which is why
throughout most of the 90s if there was
a pair of round objects in front of me
they went right up my shirt it’s true
I’m a millennial I’ve always been told
to follow my dreams I’d also been told
that my body was a temple and yet
fast-forward to 10 years later and my
body felt more like a prison I hated
having breasts first of all they were
heavy and they fell into my armpits when
I slept which I did not sign up for
but also I was ashamed of having breasts
because of the attention that it called
to my body and because it seemed to me
that there was only one acceptable
breast shape and you know what I’m
talking about large round perfectly
symmetrical breasts I didn’t have which
is why throughout so many New Year’s
resolutions I continually promised that
I would just learn to accept my body
body acceptance for me was only a dream
and here’s the thing that they don’t
tell you about dreams it’s not enough to
follow them you have to chase them it
wasn’t until I got to graduate school
and fell down this rabbit hole of
information-gathering that I finally
started to acquire the body acceptance
that I’d so wanted and a large part of
that came from gaining a historical
perspective on the body so I’d like to
give you the highlights of 242 years
worth of American breasts I’ve been
calling a tits tree needless to say I’ve
spent a considerable amount of time in
various Columbia libraries looking at it
and one of the richest insights I found
was this in her book the beauty myth
Naomi Wolf wrote how the qualities that
a given period calls beautiful and women
are merely symbols of the female
behavior that period considers desirable
in other words ideal standards of beauty
are less prescriptive of how a woman
should look than how she should behave
and in that sense breasts are a portal
into a much broader set of questions
about American conceptions of feminine
beauty and behavior in viewing these
images I’d like you to notice how
limiting middle and upper-middle class
body ideals especially in women’s
magazines where the bulk of these images
come from really were there very few
women of color represented and very
quickly we start to see the same body
types emerging over and over again and
while this is by no means a
comprehensive history it does chart how
frequently the ideal breasts chain
and the links we’ve gone to conform to
them since the beginnings of American
history our breasts have been flattened
with corsets bound with gauze cinched in
to bust developers and surgically
altered with materials from glass balls
– bees – bees wax goat’s milk and Teflon
these moments in American history prove
it the way we shape our breasts and
bodies is constantly in flux and for the
sake of everyone’s attention span I’m
going to guide us through the tits tree
in 30 year increments in the earliest
years of American history the ideal body
was young and virginal for more youthful
looking breasts a popular medical book
advised older women which probably meant
women around my age to make a plaster
from hemlock which is a poisonous plant
we already knew with deadly because it
was what killed Socrates 2,000 years
before and it gets worse in the
mid-1800s Victorian ideals came to the
fore which equated small features with
virtue so a gaunt pale body with small
breasts implied a higher moral standing
for paler skin women use body lotion
laced with arsenic which in the next
century would be reclaimed by women as a
convenient means of killing one’s
husband towards the end of the 1800s
voluptuously Illustrated Gibson girls
epitomized the rise of the educated
independent women who took a more
visible role in public life but even an
icon is seemingly liberated as she
wasn’t immune to conforming to the ideal
body on the right you’ll notice is a
series ad of a bus developer and I know
what you’re thinking it’s not a toilet
plunger it was actually used to enlarge
the breasts and I’m not sure that it
worked but by the 1920s no one wanted
anyways
a new feminine ideal took hold with a
flapper and while she could now vote
and was liberated from the corsets her
mother and grandmother wore she bound
her breasts in keeping with the era’s
flat-chested androgynous ideal and that
accordion looking contraption on the
right is a bandeau bra which is also
called a flattener after world war ii
the population swelled the economy
swells and guess what else welt
technological innovations led to a new
circular sewing stitch which created the
cone-shaped bullet bra breast mania in
the 50s and 60s was bolstered by another
landmark in women’s health the first
fda-approved oral contraceptive it had
such high estrogen levels that sales of
C cup bras jumped 50 percent but
fortunately women who didn’t have ample
cleavage or take birth control could
still live up to the ideal thanks to
innovations like the inflatable bullet
bra on the right which needs no further
comment we saw some of the bodily ideals
from the 50s
in the eighties but with bigger hair a
booming economy created a market for all
things access and the new feminine ideal
became spelt toned and large breasted
thanks in part to the rise of
supermodels aerobics and breast implants
headlines heralded the triumphant return
of breasts we’re still not sure where
they went and with that came ads for
breast enhancers like these in the pages
of popular women’s magazines again that
is not a toilet plunger so where does
this leave us now I think the two
headlines I’m about to show you
illustrate how quickly American Beauty
ideals shift in the 21st century last
year the New York Post ran this headline
boobs are back still no word on where
not two months later they ran this small
boobs are back sometimes it feels like
there’s no winning when it comes to
women’s media and breasts at its worst
natural breasts get criticized for
looking saggy surgically enhanced
breasts are called out for appearing
unnatural and visible cleavage somehow
translates to a cry for attention 242
years worth of history demonstrates how
often breasts have been treated as a
commodity bull trend instead of a body
part so it seems absurd to hate your
breasts for how they look when we can’t
even agree on what a good pair of
breasts look like in the first place
now I’m not condemning women who augment
their breasts nor am i suggesting that
we abstain from wearing whatever becomes
the equivalent of the bullet bra in 30
years my hope is that we continue to
move towards a more expansive notion of
beauty that doesn’t revolve around taut
skin that defies gravity I’ve looked at
this picture for so long trying to
figure out how to describe the
expression on my face and I realize now
what it is it’s pride when we’re kids we
don’t shoulder any of the body shame
that comes later
most of us barely notice our bodies
unless we scrape the knees couldn’t even
name most body parts let alone tell you
how they should look if I’m lucky enough
to have a daughter I’d want her to know
that having a body can be a challenge
regardless of what you look like I’d
want her to know that body acceptance
like progress itself isn’t linear and
I’d wanted to know that not all women
have large perfect breasts and that
you’re a woman whether you have large
breasts or small breasts or one breast
or no breasts and truthfully I still
don’t know how you go about making your
body into a temple but I’d suggest this
instead
treat your body as you would a historic
building you don’t have to love every
inch of it but you have to respect it
protect it maintain it and understand
its importance we’re living with all of
the privileges women have fought for
centuries to get and are still fighting
for and we can’t control what the ideal
body is today or what it will look like
tomorrow so why would we accept societal
notions of what’s beautiful and what’s
valuable this is a call to not only us
but our friends our sisters our wives
our daughters standards of beauty are
forever changing let’s stop chasing them
thank you [Applause]
Please follow and like us: