
lately it’s not so easy to know is it if
you did a good decision how do you know
that it was a good one did it feel right
can you give us excellent reasons for
the decision are you happy about the
outcome whether and how we can know that
a decision is a good one is what I want
to talk about today but in order to do
so I think we have to start with an
example with a decision to start the
discussion with and I’m going to take
the opportunity to use one of my
favorite decisions it’s courtesy of the
Cambridge University Library who has
kindly enough for digitalized and made
pictures of almost every note that
Charles Darwin ever scribbled down and
here’s one particularly nice note it’s
written in 1838 just a few weeks before
he proposed to his cousin and the two
head is here it’s a bit hard to read but
on the left you see the question and
arguments for marriage and on the right
you instead see arguments against
marriage now it’s a bit hard to read and
I won’t read it all out you but among
the arguments for marriage we find
things such as companion and friend in
old age who will feel interested in one
object to be beloved and played with
better than a dog anyhow on the side
with arguments against marriage we
instead find things such as freedom to
go where one liked choice of society and
little of it conversation of clever men
at clubs not forced to visit relatives
and to bend in every trifle now as you
may see at the end of this note his
conclusion was to marry says merry merry
merry QD and I actually particularly
liked his last reason for reaching this
conclusion where he says my god it’s
intolerable to think of spending ones
whole life like a nutria be working
working working and nothing after all no
no won’t do so he got married and the
few autobiographies I’ve read about
Darwin indicate that the marriage was
happy I guess
we can’t ask him any more does that mean
that this was a good decision it’s kind
of hard to say isn’t it in order to
truly evaluate this decision it seems as
if we would have to know what would have
happened if he had not married his
cousin what if he had married someone
else what if he had refrained from
marriage and written five other books
that revolutionized natural science what
if he all of a sudden changed a career
and became something that we never heard
of we don’t know what would have
happened had he not married in the
Wedgwood so how do we know that the
decision he made was a good one I’m not
really sure it’s so easy to answer that
question and that’s what I want to talk
to you about today regardless of this
difficulty yeah there is a large amount
of books and papers and Internet classes
and help yourself tapes and you name it
telling us what good decisions are and
how to make them parts of this research
is excellent I’m not saying that there’s
anything wrong with this but an
interesting question to ask is of course
how do they know what a good decision is
how can they evaluate what good
decision-making is and here there seems
to be two different types of answers to
this question one answer comes from what
I will call the prohibitory camp for
people that are very cautious and they
will tell us that good decisions are
decisions that help us avoid specific
pitfalls that are particularly bad for
us the other group of people i will say
will become to this we are part of the
success oriented a view towards decision
making and they say something like well
you know use the type of decision style
that general will give get you what you
want so these are two quite different
approaches to how good decisions should
be made now when it comes to the
precautionary or prohibitory camp the
people who tell us that good
decision-making is basically about
trying to avoid certain very severe
pitfalls we get a very structured and
very well worked through idea of how you
should proceed in your
making in order to avoid certain really
dangerous thinks so what are these
things that we should be so scared of
the most famous one is something that is
usually called a money pump but I will
translate that to a porcelain pump in my
example since we are after all in the
business of hole-making in this talk it seems so