Press "Enter" to skip to content

Education’s Well-Intentioned People Problem | Tatiana Poladko | TEDxWilmingtonED


if you hear a little bit of an accent as

I speak it is because I’m standing here

speaking a foreign language the fact

that I am on this stage with the ability

to speak English as well as my first

languages Ukrainian and Russian is

certainly a testament to my parents

investments and sacrifices for my

education well and my own hard work but

that’s only a part of a story like the

life-changing outcomes we hope to see

for students in the education system my

linguistic prowess and my life

trajectory were people dependent it took

their investments from and interactions

with the right people to set my life on

I grew up in eastern Ukraine in a mining

city knowing to be the longest city in

Europe

my parents had dreams that I would

experience parts of the world they could

only imagine

so since young age I aspire to travel

abroad to become an exchange student my

parents weren’t bored that is why they

sacrificed all the disposable cash they

had to have me working with an English

language shooter and also put me in as

special school to study foreign

languages but it took a random encounter

with someone determined to expand

opportunity for my goals to actually be

achieved one day on a routine trip to a

market my mother ran into my former

biology teacher after a long

conversation my teacher casually

inquired if I was participating in the

first testing round for the Future

Leaders exchange program a flex program

what first round I mean we knew of the

Flex program but we had no idea how to

engage in the process so the teacher

told my mom that the following day at 8

a.m. in a city 150 miles away from where

we lived

the first test to get selected for the

program would take place not to be

deterred she came home we packed our

things up and tuka hopes on a train ride

that very evening to make sure we were

in time for the test that story had a

happy ending

I did get selected as a finalist in the

program and I did receive the funding to

travel to the United States to spend one

year studying at a public school in

kokomo County in Indiana and even though

the huge corn fields and all the people

was not quite what I expected my travels

abroad to look like that experience as

an exchange student set my life on a

different course it is also they

experience that reminds me of the power

of people in education the well-intended

people who dedicate their lives to

children have power to expand

opportunity for students and to change

their life trajectories in very positive

ways but these same well-intentioned

people also wield a dangerous power we

hate to discuss in our conversations in

education they have ability to close

doors and pick winners and choosers and

the winners and losers and and and and

and kill dreams and her chances that

students will fulfill potential I have

seen this people problem at play

countless times in my work with hundreds

of students over the past decade in 2009

while in graduate school my husband and

I founded team sharp an organization on

a mission to prepare exceptional

african-american and Latino youth to

thrive at our nation’s top colleges and

beyond we knew that this work will be

challenging that it will be status quo

break and work you see it is it is it is

not by accident that low-income students

and students of color are seriously

underrepresented at our nation’s most

selective colleges we anticipated to

have an encounter problems that we

typically will discuss in education

how do we inspire unmotivated students

to work hard and to one better how do we

get parents to be involved and be

partners with us in our work how do we

build students and parents awareness

about higher education how do we close

college readiness gaps and while these

are challenges these are not the most

insidious problems that we encountered

the students we worked with and the

parents were on board so much so that

teacher of scholars spent every Saturday

full-day all throughout the school year

participating in intensive teen sharpe

sessions their parents would participate

also on Saturdays and workshops to

expand their understanding of the

college admissions process during breaks

after school students would join us for

study / losses to catch up on work and

get ahead and these efforts and

sacrifices work as 95% of our schoolers

scholars do get admitted into one of the

top colleges in our country but the

grand challenge that we did not

anticipate was the well-meaning adults

who unbeknownst to them stand in the way

of opportunity one of our earliest

examples was an encounter in

Philadelphia with a high-ranking

official whose job it was to increase

college enrollment rates for children in

Philadelphia

we were in our second year of teen sharp

and spent a lot of time sharing with

parents information about our fledgling

program at that point we only had one

program site and it was located in the

city of Camden in New Jersey just a five

minute ride from Center City

Philadelphia

we learned that there would be a

citywide fair of after-school and

enrichment Pro

grams for Philadelphia families and we

figured that would be a perfect

opportunity for us to connect with

Philadelphia parents and recruit

students so we got in touch with an

event coordinator a high-ranking

official to confirm our participation in

in the event and requesting a table to

be reserved 14 sharp the response that

we received was disheartening but it was

also revealing she was not going to let

us participate in her event simply

because we were not based exactly in the

city here is what she said I think it

would not be a great use of your time to

participate we have a hard time getting

parents to come out to meetings etc so

I’m not sure they would be willing to

come across the bridge for a program for

their kids

most are working parents with little

extra time I hope you understand and

appreciate your consideration so I have

was our simple request to make

information accessible to parents in

Philadelphia at an event in Philadelphia

getting rejected was she really blogging

an opportunity for students because of

her poor understanding of the lengths to

which parents go for their kids well she

was we never were allowed to promote our

program at her event but I’m happy to

share that she was really wrong 50

percent of our families who

participative Emily’s who participate in

our program at that site do come across

the bridge she thought a bridge too far

I want to say I would love to say that

this is an outlier case that these

experiences are rare but they’re not our

students experience this every day we

have seen well-intentioned educators

block a student’s access to advanced

level classes available at their schools

and just like the case with our

Philadelphia encounter the reasons they

provide a seemingly good reasons a study

out of Vanderbilt University shows that

black and Latino students are far less

likely than their peers to get assigned

to gifted and talented programs these

are also the same studies that tell us

that educators of color are more likely

to recommend students of color for

gifted and talented programs that white

educators we have seen well intended

educators label our students deem them

unfit for college while these same

students would thrive in our program and

now attend some of the best universities

research shows that students of color

get labeled for special education at

much higher rates

the boys of colleges

suspended at much higher rates we have

seen good leaders school leaders and

teachers kill a student’s projects and

initiatives to spread the word among

their peers about college axis because

they did not believe our students would

deliver or simply did not deem those

sort of initiatives to be important we

have seen good-hearted but LLL inform

educators provide wrong information to

our students set low expectations and

turn away good opportunities for our

kids I’m sounding an alarm not to malign

such an honorable profession I sound an

alarm because they know that neither I

know any educator is immune to becoming

just that very sort of educator it is

quite possible to love children to want

the best for your students to work hard

to be passionate about what you do and

still stand in the way of opportunity

for students so how do we move forward

in the face of our fell ability as

educators well first we need to

second we need to recognize that as

saintly and sacrificial as we are we too

are often the problem we need to

recognize that all the teaching

techniques and accolades and and

professional status will not insulate us

from inherent biases and perceptions

that contain to work with our students

we need to regularly consider our egos

and our privilege which can stand in a

way of our desire to serve students we

need to be aware of our power to block

to miss inform to close doors and to

kill passions as much as we are aware of

our power to transform we need to move

beyond educating our students with good

intentions to educating them with love

the kind of love and belief and expect

patience that we would instill in our

very own children but we need to do to

tread carefully and with humility given

that precious and daunting responsibility in front of us

Please follow and like us: