
I’m gonna take you on a 50-year journey
this morning which is appropriate as I
sit somewhere in my 50s honey insisting
in my early 50s and in that sense that
50 year journey around this particular
topic I want to consider takes us back
to 1966 I’m going to route 66 I’m going
to 1966 and in 66 I’m going to the great
Robbins report on higher education and
in 66 Robbins was asked to look at what
is higher education before and I’m going
to ask you that question in terms of
what is a university for or how do you
create the university or what is the
university about and how does innovating
and integrating and educating link to
what a university is for and challenge
you in terms of your concepts of
university and what it is we’re trying
to achieve here in Bolton in this great
University so let’s go back to 66 let’s
take ourselves just 50 years 51 in fact
years back to when Lord Robbins was
asked to define the essence of a
university in the United Kingdom and
Robbins said that universities were
about they were about the creation and
the preservation and the dissemination
of something what was that something
well of course that something was
knowledge so it was about creating it
was about preserving and it was about
disseminating knowledge and a university
therefore and the new great white tile
universities the white heat technology
universities of the 60s were developed
the the the Bradford’s and the York’s
and the keels and the Warwick’s were all
created to create preserve and
disseminate knowledge creating research
creating knowledge of course was around
the actual fundamental blue skies
thinking of research what is what is new
creative initiative what let’s think the
unthinkable let’s do what I’m going to
ask you to do today and think the
unthinkable and indeed challenge Robbins
from 66 to something new today
indeed the motive for going forward for
universities today may well be
innovate integrate and educate as
opposed to create preserve and
disseminate knowledge so let’s have a
look at what Robbins was saying what he
was saying was that in creation of
knowledge what he was saying was that
blue skies research innovative new
thinking of the essence in some ways of
the PhD the contribution of new things
new ideas new information new
interpretations new ways of applying
things and then we move on a course to
once you’ve created it you have to
preserve it and you can preserve it in a
number of ways but the obvious
preservation of it is committing it to
writing to committing it to learner to
scholar journals and books and and
ultimately that will come to the
preservation moment but in terms of the
the sorry I’m on preservation on tech
patrick the the preservation of
knowledge is providing a repository of
that knowledge whether it be written or
archiving archiving that knowledge or
internetting that knowledge today and
then of course the dissemination of
knowledge comes to the end of the
spectrum that we sit out today that
often universities are judged on which
is around around teaching and
disseminating that knowledge publishing
and getting it out there having
committed it to record in terms of
preserving it publishing and getting it
out there but also teaching students and
making sure that students are well aware
of that knowledge that’s been created
now is that enough
you know Robin’s was the seminal work on
universities but is it enough today then
you then have to move across to ask
about how those new universities did in
society
and how they developed and you have to
look at someone called Burton Clarke at
UCLA Los Angeles who started to look in
the 80s at the work of those
universities that developed in the 60s
and started to look at the most
successful universities in in Europe in
fact in his particular study and ask
what was it about those universities
that have made them successful and how
were they measured as being successful
and of course we then into that great
debate of the University League table
valid or not relevant or not measuring
the right things or not what is a
university for we’re on that league
table does the creation of knowledge
come well perhaps it comes in the
research element where does the
preservation of knowledge come well
perhaps
in the academic infrastructure and where
does the dissemination ala jump become
well perhaps that comes in the the
teaching the view of the student quality
of teaching so perhaps those tables do
in that sense start to span the the
knowledge of robbins but of course along
came higher education limited warwick
limited was the classic example of it
challenged by the academics in the late
70s and early 80’s has been too
commercial too highly focused on making
a university for-profit a university for
business a university for industry
because there was no mention in that
early description of business or
industry and then you had these
universities reaching out to companies
saying we can do applied research we
could do in company research we can do
income generation we can even ultimately
whizz forward a few years and start to
charge fees for the things that we sell
has to say our courses and those are
therefore a remarkable corruption wasn’t
there in this process of this purist
idea of an organization for the purposes
of creating and preserving disseminating
knowledge and today’s position or a
position that moves a few years on into
the 1890s when people like Warwick and
York was starting to say albeit a
slightly divergent way in those two
universities they were starting to say
well actually this is about connecting
to business and industry applying it
it’s about employability no mention in
Robbins’s notion of employability or
usefulness you know no reference to the
idea that a university might actually be
some use to the student who might go to
it who might then ultimately succeed in
employment and add to national wealth
and add to wealth creation but know what
you had is a situation where you’ve got
this purist idea and I’ll come back to
why knowledge perhaps isn’t the right
thing to be focusing on in what is a
university for what is higher education
for in a minute notice that knowledge
might not be the thing that we want to
focus on for a university I’ll give you
some thought for the day I want to in
terms of perhaps it isn’t about
knowledge at all maybe it’s about the
application of that knowledge maybe it’s
about actually wisdom is about judgment
it’s about interpretation it’s about
understanding it’s about application
knowledge itself certainly information
itself is out there and awful
now in the Internet it’s available all
times remember when Robbins was writing
information was not freely available
knowledge was not actually as freely
available as it is today this is being
live-streamed no doubt all over the
world and contributing to an
understanding of issues perhaps but it
wasn’t freely available in the Robbins
era in the 66 in the inner 60s and so
you have this situation where the
question arises now is is a university
for something else today rather than
what it was when it started because
knowledge is available anywhere the
Internet is the university that Robbins
was considering where new knowledge was
created and it’s and it’s preserved and
it’s disseminated so the internet became
the world’s university in that sense so
what does the universities become well
they become areas perhaps where people
do things that we’re talking about today
they they innovate and they integrate
and the educate because they’re a place
they’re a space and the place and in
that sense the university isn’t what
Robbins described at all but it’s
actually a place and a space for
innovation and for creativity and for
the development of challenge of new
ideas so actually TEDx is dead center we
are actually right on the red spot in
terms of being at the right place for
universities now the students involved
in the development of this provision
about what universities might well be
seen to be for for the next 50 years and
of course they then apply that knowledge
and apply that research and apply that
understanding innovation creativity to a
context which is about wealth creation
and that wealth creation then spreads
across you’ll not be surprised as an
economist argue that wealth creation is
critical to the development of society
to development of humanity to
development of resource acquisition and
exploitation for the whole of the the
the benefit of the population of the
world so what a university is for then
well maybe they’re for more than
knowledge may be there for more than
wisdom maybe they’re about really
pushing the boundaries of interpretive
understanding maybe they’re about
challenge
they must be surely about about
challenge and they must be or are they
institutions are they places are these
spaces or are the institutions we had a
situation where Burton Clarke was saying
but the way that universities the great
universities
developed in this country of in the last
50 years Warrick is 50 years old it’s
one of the most successful universities
by most people’s measure from start up
in the 60s to 50 years old last years
it’s so perfect fifty year journey and
of course wilful institution building
took place there to create an
institution and here in Bolton were
engaging in willful institution building
it’s neither accidental nor incidental
but about creating a strong institution
to enable those people participating
that institution to grow to develop to
innovate to integrate and by our process
to educate in terms of that
interpretation of knowledge and
understanding but willful institutions
in places require the development of
place so what I’m saying here about the
university that we’re in is that we’re
trying to develop an institution that
does the things that I’ve described in
terms of innovation and creativity and
education but also does it in a way that
creates a sense of place a sense of town
a tense of a sense of gown the
connectivity between where we are we are
not in a vacuum we are not dropped in
the middle of field like Warrick was
we’re actually right in the center of a
community of community who don’t
understand what a university is they
haven’t had one before fifteen years ago
this town didn’t have a university this
town had an institute of higher
education that was bursting to become a
university but wasn’t one and therefore
you have to work on this process is my
approach of linking the town with the
gown to create an environment a space
and a place where people understand that
we’re more than about creating knowledge
we’re about connecting with communities
were about integrating with a society
that we’re in we’re about shaping and
changing that society we are going to
make Bolton and Greater Manchester
different by what we do the things that
you our students and our communities are
engaging will massively change this
community why should you believe that
can you believe that well it took them
eight hundred years but look at
Cambridge the town or city of Cambridge
wouldn’t be anything without its
University imagine Cambridge or Oxford
without their universities
and I’m going to suggest you if you take
this fifty years on from now imagine
Bolton without it’s University as we
move into them on Crescent no not
surprising I take this as a really good
advertising opportunity for the strategy
of the university but not often that
people listen to me around here so I
take this is an advertising opportunity
will have LeMond Crescent by the Town
Hall we just acquired it the student
village developing behind it the
creation of spaces flexible spaces for
the community and students to live
together to create cafe culture to
create that drop-in situation where an
innovative small high-tech or innovative
creative company can have a studio and
then drop in downstairs to cafe culture
and talk with students or own courses
and then a campus that is resourced with
high-tech facilities new buildings new
facilities and equipment that enables
students to access the best available
the national new Motorsports sent to the
stem center the the dental technologies
facilities the facilities that we offer
in terms of Bolton one and the Health
provision and so on and so on to create
niche based provision of the very
highest quality because of course an
institution can’t be everything to
everybody and do everything well it has
to specialize but in that specialization
runs one common theme which is about
educate in this university educate being
the teaching intensive agenda informed
by Robbins’s traditional notion of
research but not driven by Robbins’s
original notion of research you see for
Robins you couldn’t be a university
unless you’re creating knowledge and
then preserved it and disseminated it
for us the argument today 50 years on
will be maybe we can be a university by
being teaching intensive by focusing on
educating focusing on creativity
focusing on innovation focusing on the
topics of this particular conference and
using that as the driving central thread
or force that holds together the
community that will change the society
that we operate in here in Bolton
because people can understand the
tangible requirement of a university
teaches students and we do it rather
well the Complete University Guide
yesterday said that we were 36 in the UK
out of 100
twenty-nine universities for our student
satisfaction particularly with teaching
36 we actually sat side by side because
I think 35th on that with the same score
oddly enough why they were 35th and we
were 36 with the same score I don’t
understand but and we had to be and they
had a C that’s to say they were
Cambridge and we were Bolton so there we
sit side by side with an 800 year old
University Bolton and Cambridge with the
same score for satisfaction with the
student experience in teaching and
that’s taken they make hundred years
what have they been doing and it’s taken
us about ten or twelve in terms of our
university to get to that position where
our students are highly satisfied with
what they receive but of course on the
league table around research we’re well
down because we’re not a Robin’s
University we’re not a
research-intensive we’re not about
creating knowledge we’re about applying
we’re about integrating that information
innovating with that information and
educating with that information the very
theme of this particular conference so
how do I want to bring this this set of
thoughts together I want to suggest to
you that you want to think about what is
a university of today is a university
today about knowledge or is it about
place is it about people is it about
applicability and if it is about those
things where does knowledge sit in this
is Robins outmoded and in terms of
building and developing university is it
wrong for those research intensive to
remain research intensive are they
barking up the long wrong long-term
strategic tree have Cambridge and Oxford
missed the very point they research
intensive Russell groups who were
hanging on to some historic notion of
the past and is that why London School
of Economics in King’s College London in
the bottom ten in the country for
student perception of their views of
teaching because they’ve lost the plot
in a modern world whereas institutions
like ours are right on the money
were on the message around what it is to
be a modern forward-looking creative
willfully built institution linking the
town and the gown together in a way that
creates space for students to do what
students can do best
to create to innovate and on our part to
educate so I’ll leave you with that
thought about what is a university for
is it about that traditional notion or
is it about something different are we
doing the right thing in a tempting
willful institution-building are we
doing the right thing turning our face
against those research-intensive you
know in 25 years or 50 years will
someone be standing here saying you know
what universities are about is about
teaching it’s about educating it’s about
innovating it’s about using the
knowledge that’s freely and widely
available across the internet why cry
and try and create more knowledge in a
local pocket when there’s far more world
knowledge and information available you
can draw on and innovate and integrate
rather than just simply create so I
conclude with the thought that Robins
perhaps of his time was right but times
have changed times have moved on and
that a modern creative university is
something completely different to the
notion of Oxford and Cambridge the
dinosaurs that are waiting to die thank
you for listening
you
this morning which is appropriate as I
sit somewhere in my 50s honey insisting
in my early 50s and in that sense that
50 year journey around this particular
topic I want to consider takes us back
to 1966 I’m going to route 66 I’m going
to 1966 and in 66 I’m going to the great
Robbins report on higher education and
in 66 Robbins was asked to look at what
is higher education before and I’m going
to ask you that question in terms of
what is a university for or how do you
create the university or what is the
university about and how does innovating
and integrating and educating link to
what a university is for and challenge
you in terms of your concepts of
university and what it is we’re trying
to achieve here in Bolton in this great
University so let’s go back to 66 let’s
take ourselves just 50 years 51 in fact
years back to when Lord Robbins was
asked to define the essence of a
university in the United Kingdom and
Robbins said that universities were
about they were about the creation and
the preservation and the dissemination
of something what was that something
well of course that something was
knowledge so it was about creating it
was about preserving and it was about
disseminating knowledge and a university
therefore and the new great white tile
universities the white heat technology
universities of the 60s were developed
the the the Bradford’s and the York’s
and the keels and the Warwick’s were all
created to create preserve and
disseminate knowledge creating research
creating knowledge of course was around
the actual fundamental blue skies
thinking of research what is what is new
creative initiative what let’s think the
unthinkable let’s do what I’m going to
ask you to do today and think the
unthinkable and indeed challenge Robbins
from 66 to something new today
indeed the motive for going forward for
universities today may well be
innovate integrate and educate as
opposed to create preserve and
disseminate knowledge so let’s have a
look at what Robbins was saying what he
was saying was that in creation of
knowledge what he was saying was that
blue skies research innovative new
thinking of the essence in some ways of
the PhD the contribution of new things
new ideas new information new
interpretations new ways of applying
things and then we move on a course to
once you’ve created it you have to
preserve it and you can preserve it in a
number of ways but the obvious
preservation of it is committing it to
writing to committing it to learner to
scholar journals and books and and
ultimately that will come to the
preservation moment but in terms of the
the sorry I’m on preservation on tech
patrick the the preservation of
knowledge is providing a repository of
that knowledge whether it be written or
archiving archiving that knowledge or
internetting that knowledge today and
then of course the dissemination of
knowledge comes to the end of the
spectrum that we sit out today that
often universities are judged on which
is around around teaching and
disseminating that knowledge publishing
and getting it out there having
committed it to record in terms of
preserving it publishing and getting it
out there but also teaching students and
making sure that students are well aware
of that knowledge that’s been created
now is that enough
you know Robin’s was the seminal work on
universities but is it enough today then
you then have to move across to ask
about how those new universities did in
society
and how they developed and you have to
look at someone called Burton Clarke at
UCLA Los Angeles who started to look in
the 80s at the work of those
universities that developed in the 60s
and started to look at the most
successful universities in in Europe in
fact in his particular study and ask
what was it about those universities
that have made them successful and how
were they measured as being successful
and of course we then into that great
debate of the University League table
valid or not relevant or not measuring
the right things or not what is a
university for we’re on that league
table does the creation of knowledge
come well perhaps it comes in the
research element where does the
preservation of knowledge come well
perhaps
in the academic infrastructure and where
does the dissemination ala jump become
well perhaps that comes in the the
teaching the view of the student quality
of teaching so perhaps those tables do
in that sense start to span the the
knowledge of robbins but of course along
came higher education limited warwick
limited was the classic example of it
challenged by the academics in the late
70s and early 80’s has been too
commercial too highly focused on making
a university for-profit a university for
business a university for industry
because there was no mention in that
early description of business or
industry and then you had these
universities reaching out to companies
saying we can do applied research we
could do in company research we can do
income generation we can even ultimately
whizz forward a few years and start to
charge fees for the things that we sell
has to say our courses and those are
therefore a remarkable corruption wasn’t
there in this process of this purist
idea of an organization for the purposes
of creating and preserving disseminating
knowledge and today’s position or a
position that moves a few years on into
the 1890s when people like Warwick and
York was starting to say albeit a
slightly divergent way in those two
universities they were starting to say
well actually this is about connecting
to business and industry applying it
it’s about employability no mention in
Robbins’s notion of employability or
usefulness you know no reference to the
idea that a university might actually be
some use to the student who might go to
it who might then ultimately succeed in
employment and add to national wealth
and add to wealth creation but know what
you had is a situation where you’ve got
this purist idea and I’ll come back to
why knowledge perhaps isn’t the right
thing to be focusing on in what is a
university for what is higher education
for in a minute notice that knowledge
might not be the thing that we want to
focus on for a university I’ll give you
some thought for the day I want to in
terms of perhaps it isn’t about
knowledge at all maybe it’s about the
application of that knowledge maybe it’s
about actually wisdom is about judgment
it’s about interpretation it’s about
understanding it’s about application
knowledge itself certainly information
itself is out there and awful
now in the Internet it’s available all
times remember when Robbins was writing
information was not freely available
knowledge was not actually as freely
available as it is today this is being
live-streamed no doubt all over the
world and contributing to an
understanding of issues perhaps but it
wasn’t freely available in the Robbins
era in the 66 in the inner 60s and so
you have this situation where the
question arises now is is a university
for something else today rather than
what it was when it started because
knowledge is available anywhere the
Internet is the university that Robbins
was considering where new knowledge was
created and it’s and it’s preserved and
it’s disseminated so the internet became
the world’s university in that sense so
what does the universities become well
they become areas perhaps where people
do things that we’re talking about today
they they innovate and they integrate
and the educate because they’re a place
they’re a space and the place and in
that sense the university isn’t what
Robbins described at all but it’s
actually a place and a space for
innovation and for creativity and for
the development of challenge of new
ideas so actually TEDx is dead center we
are actually right on the red spot in
terms of being at the right place for
universities now the students involved
in the development of this provision
about what universities might well be
seen to be for for the next 50 years and
of course they then apply that knowledge
and apply that research and apply that
understanding innovation creativity to a
context which is about wealth creation
and that wealth creation then spreads
across you’ll not be surprised as an
economist argue that wealth creation is
critical to the development of society
to development of humanity to
development of resource acquisition and
exploitation for the whole of the the
the benefit of the population of the
world so what a university is for then
well maybe they’re for more than
knowledge may be there for more than
wisdom maybe they’re about really
pushing the boundaries of interpretive
understanding maybe they’re about
challenge
they must be surely about about
challenge and they must be or are they
institutions are they places are these
spaces or are the institutions we had a
situation where Burton Clarke was saying
but the way that universities the great
universities
developed in this country of in the last
50 years Warrick is 50 years old it’s
one of the most successful universities
by most people’s measure from start up
in the 60s to 50 years old last years
it’s so perfect fifty year journey and
of course wilful institution building
took place there to create an
institution and here in Bolton were
engaging in willful institution building
it’s neither accidental nor incidental
but about creating a strong institution
to enable those people participating
that institution to grow to develop to
innovate to integrate and by our process
to educate in terms of that
interpretation of knowledge and
understanding but willful institutions
in places require the development of
place so what I’m saying here about the
university that we’re in is that we’re
trying to develop an institution that
does the things that I’ve described in
terms of innovation and creativity and
education but also does it in a way that
creates a sense of place a sense of town
a tense of a sense of gown the
connectivity between where we are we are
not in a vacuum we are not dropped in
the middle of field like Warrick was
we’re actually right in the center of a
community of community who don’t
understand what a university is they
haven’t had one before fifteen years ago
this town didn’t have a university this
town had an institute of higher
education that was bursting to become a
university but wasn’t one and therefore
you have to work on this process is my
approach of linking the town with the
gown to create an environment a space
and a place where people understand that
we’re more than about creating knowledge
we’re about connecting with communities
were about integrating with a society
that we’re in we’re about shaping and
changing that society we are going to
make Bolton and Greater Manchester
different by what we do the things that
you our students and our communities are
engaging will massively change this
community why should you believe that
can you believe that well it took them
eight hundred years but look at
Cambridge the town or city of Cambridge
wouldn’t be anything without its
University imagine Cambridge or Oxford
without their universities
and I’m going to suggest you if you take
this fifty years on from now imagine
Bolton without it’s University as we
move into them on Crescent no not
surprising I take this as a really good
advertising opportunity for the strategy
of the university but not often that
people listen to me around here so I
take this is an advertising opportunity
will have LeMond Crescent by the Town
Hall we just acquired it the student
village developing behind it the
creation of spaces flexible spaces for
the community and students to live
together to create cafe culture to
create that drop-in situation where an
innovative small high-tech or innovative
creative company can have a studio and
then drop in downstairs to cafe culture
and talk with students or own courses
and then a campus that is resourced with
high-tech facilities new buildings new
facilities and equipment that enables
students to access the best available
the national new Motorsports sent to the
stem center the the dental technologies
facilities the facilities that we offer
in terms of Bolton one and the Health
provision and so on and so on to create
niche based provision of the very
highest quality because of course an
institution can’t be everything to
everybody and do everything well it has
to specialize but in that specialization
runs one common theme which is about
educate in this university educate being
the teaching intensive agenda informed
by Robbins’s traditional notion of
research but not driven by Robbins’s
original notion of research you see for
Robins you couldn’t be a university
unless you’re creating knowledge and
then preserved it and disseminated it
for us the argument today 50 years on
will be maybe we can be a university by
being teaching intensive by focusing on
educating focusing on creativity
focusing on innovation focusing on the
topics of this particular conference and
using that as the driving central thread
or force that holds together the
community that will change the society
that we operate in here in Bolton
because people can understand the
tangible requirement of a university
teaches students and we do it rather
well the Complete University Guide
yesterday said that we were 36 in the UK
out of 100
twenty-nine universities for our student
satisfaction particularly with teaching
36 we actually sat side by side because
I think 35th on that with the same score
oddly enough why they were 35th and we
were 36 with the same score I don’t
understand but and we had to be and they
had a C that’s to say they were
Cambridge and we were Bolton so there we
sit side by side with an 800 year old
University Bolton and Cambridge with the
same score for satisfaction with the
student experience in teaching and
that’s taken they make hundred years
what have they been doing and it’s taken
us about ten or twelve in terms of our
university to get to that position where
our students are highly satisfied with
what they receive but of course on the
league table around research we’re well
down because we’re not a Robin’s
University we’re not a
research-intensive we’re not about
creating knowledge we’re about applying
we’re about integrating that information
innovating with that information and
educating with that information the very
theme of this particular conference so
how do I want to bring this this set of
thoughts together I want to suggest to
you that you want to think about what is
a university of today is a university
today about knowledge or is it about
place is it about people is it about
applicability and if it is about those
things where does knowledge sit in this
is Robins outmoded and in terms of
building and developing university is it
wrong for those research intensive to
remain research intensive are they
barking up the long wrong long-term
strategic tree have Cambridge and Oxford
missed the very point they research
intensive Russell groups who were
hanging on to some historic notion of
the past and is that why London School
of Economics in King’s College London in
the bottom ten in the country for
student perception of their views of
teaching because they’ve lost the plot
in a modern world whereas institutions
like ours are right on the money
were on the message around what it is to
be a modern forward-looking creative
willfully built institution linking the
town and the gown together in a way that
creates space for students to do what
students can do best
to create to innovate and on our part to
educate so I’ll leave you with that
thought about what is a university for
is it about that traditional notion or
is it about something different are we
doing the right thing in a tempting
willful institution-building are we
doing the right thing turning our face
against those research-intensive you
know in 25 years or 50 years will
someone be standing here saying you know
what universities are about is about
teaching it’s about educating it’s about
innovating it’s about using the
knowledge that’s freely and widely
available across the internet why cry
and try and create more knowledge in a
local pocket when there’s far more world
knowledge and information available you
can draw on and innovate and integrate
rather than just simply create so I
conclude with the thought that Robins
perhaps of his time was right but times
have changed times have moved on and
that a modern creative university is
something completely different to the
notion of Oxford and Cambridge the
dinosaurs that are waiting to die thank
you for listening
you
Please follow and like us: