
[Applause]
for all of our history as a species
we’ve contrasted two types of system
ordered systems and chaotic systems and
other systems have huge value for
Humanity it gives us legal structure at
the present level in operating theaters
it means we can rely on the fact that
they’ll count out the surgical
instruments as they counted them in and
you won’t have to be operated on for a
second time as I get older I find that
sort of process of increasing importance
order is hugely valuable to human beings
on a negative side a fear of chaos has
been used to impose order unnecessarily
and destroy creative creativity and to
destroy freedom the reality is over the
last 40 or 50 years we’ve taken an
engineering focus on society and
engineering metaphor
and we’ve actually compounded order with
excessive outcome based measurement if
you actually look at the whole history
of last 40 or 50 years everything has to
have a target everything has to have a
defined outcome and it has to be a
number yeah whether it’s kpi’s number of
published papers or whatever else the
reality is all of the scientific
evidence says that when human beings are
pursuing explicit targets
it destroys intrinsic motivation there
is no evidence to contradict that and
where do we most need intrinsic
motivation in health and education and
where do we impose the worst targets in
health and education so we need to start
to think differently about this and we
need to move away from a primitive
dichotomy in which we can trust one
highly structured system with an
absolutely chaotic system into something
more sophisticated now there is actually
a third type of system which exists in
nature it’s a complex adaptive system
it’s a system defined not by its
structure by it by its connectivity in a
complex system everything is connected
with everything else but many of the
connections
cannot be known we talk about dark
constraints a reference to cosmology and
dark matter we can see the impact of a
constraint but we don’t know what the
constraint is we see there are boundary
conditions which aren’t defined we see
connections making things novel or
different in different ways the Internet
is an example of a complex system
humanity is a complex adaptive system
now understanding these and
understanding how we manage them is
critical and it’s not about control it’s
about understanding the connections
about change in the linkages the best
way I’ve ever learned to define the
difference between the three types of
system ordered systems complex systems
and chaotic systems is to start to think
about how we would use those approaches
to manage a day-to-day problem so
imagine if you can that tomorrow you
have to organize a party for a bunch of
nine-year-old children everybody can
imagine that yeah and you’re making the
mistake of holding it in your own house
you learn not to do this as you actually
have more than one child all right the
advantage of community centers is they
have fire hoses fire hose is a very
useful for clean up after a party and
they’re occasionally necessary for crowd
control draw in the party itself so
let’s imagine how we would organize a
party based on what assumption we make
about the type of system if we assume
that the system is chaotic then it means
the children are acting without
constraint their behavior is random so
they’re probably discovered drugs and
alcohol and go on a personal experience
of self-discovery your house may burn
down in the process but it was socially
constructed in the first place so why
are you worried about it I have a friend
in California who did try this once
yeah he’s never going to do it again the
recovery cost was too high the order
systems approach on the other hand is
taught in all good management schools
and all good business consultancy
outfits under this it’s of critical
importance to agree learning objectives
to the party in advance of the party
itself the learning objectives should be
aligned with the
statement for education in the society
to which should be long and should be
clearly articulated and printed off on
motivational posters with pictures of
eagles soaring over valleys and water
dropping into ponds and placed around
the walls of the room where you’re going
to hold the party as the children come
into the party they should be given
Disney playing cards with the party
value statement clearly printed on the
back you will of course have produced a
project plan for the party the project
plan will have clear milestones
throughout the party against which you
can measure progress against the ideal
party outcome and the senior adult will
start the party with a motivational DVD
don’t want the children wasting time in
play which isn’t aligned with the
learning objectives and then they’ll use
PowerPoint to demonstrate their personal
commitment to the party objectives and
show their children how their allowances
are linked to the achievement of the
milestone targets following the highly
successful completion of the party you
conduct after-action review they teach
your best practice database on party
management a mandate future process
improvement if at this stage for any
remote reason the children aren’t happy
you hire one of the new happiness
consultants who will train them to be
really very very happy and God help them
if they’re not the next time they come
to a party the complex systems approach
on the other hand is much simpler we
start off by drawing a line in the Sun
known as a boundary constraint in
complexity theory and we look the
children squarely in the eye and say
cross that and you die
and one of the things you learn pretty
fast as an adult is the value of
flexible negotiable boundaries because
rigid boundaries have a habit of
breaking catastrophically when you least
expect them we then introduced catalytic
probes a football a barbecue or computer
game any type of thing which will
actually trigger a pattern of play which
is called an attractor if it’s
beneficial we give it more resources if
it’s not beneficial well that’s where we
deploy the fire hoses what we manage is
the emergence of beneficial coherence
within attractors within boundaries and
we manage the only three things that you
can manage in a complex adaptive system
the boundary conditions the probes and
the amplification strategy management
and governance is much simpler when you
understand the nature of the system and
you stop trying to take an ecosystem as
if it was an engineering problem when
it’s an ecological problem so the work
I’ve been doing with my research group
and elsewhere is to find new methods or
new ways to deal with us but you have to
understand what’s going on you can only
understand a complex system by
understanding the small particular parts
of day-to-day interaction for humans
those are the anecdotal data of the
school gate the street story there BR
after work they’re not the grand
narratives of workshops it’s the
day-to-day anecdotes of people’s
existence and we need to understand them
through the voice of the people who tell
them not through an AI machine
interpreting the text or an expert
making them fit their cultural
expectations people’s own voice has to
be subject to their own interpretation
and then we need to allow those in power
at any level society that have direct
access to the raw stories of the people
they govern without multiple levels of
interpretation which allow them to hide
from reality behind the guise of policy
reports and everything else so that’s
kind of like the work we’re doing in
order to do that we have to engage
people and people have had enough of
surveys they’ve had enough of focus
groups focus groups are biased by the
facility
within 15 minutes opinion polls aren’t
trusted anymore we’ve never ever lived
by the way in a poll in a print of
fact-based society it’s just we used to
trust experts and now we’re trying
demagogues for a change the reality is
we actually hand over a lot of our
cognitive processes to structures it’s
not based on ourselves as individuals so
in order to do that we have to engage
people so for example in South Wales we
found that girls rugby clubs and the
main agent of change in some of the
rural community in some of the
industrial communities so we give them
tools by which they can capture their
experiences and the experiences the
people trying to recruit then they go
into old people’s homes to actually help
those people become more healthy because
they become engaged we’re actually
working now through schools because
teachers need to teach P kids about
community engagement about statistics so
we give them tools so that every month
their children can go into their
communities and gather stories from
those communities so they become
ethnographers to their own condition
rather than relying on outside experts
this is a huge program which we’re
starting off through small countries and
city states Wales is a small country and
the goal is to allow people to be
ethnographers to their own condition to
report their own stories but within a
quantitative framework not a quality to
framework over the last 30 or 40 years
I’ve seen many attempts at digital
storytelling at gathering people’s
stories but nobody thinks about how to
scale it and nobody allows people the
power to tell you what their story means
because that’s something done by the
people who gather them so that kind of
like leads us on to using people as
ethnographers to their own condition
this is a picture from work in Africa
where we got young girls trying to
understand the abuse that they and their
colleagues have suffered but making them
the ethnographers not external experts
now in order to get there they say we
have to empower people and power comes
from the power to interpret your
narrative not from the power to actually
hand your narrative over to somebody
else there in order to do that we have
to
find a way to scale it so there are
several key elements on this one is we
need to work with abstraction if you
don’t know it art comes before language
in human evolution the ability to
abstract allows for scientific invention
in fact the over emphasis on STEM
education at the moment around the world
will destroy scientific creativity
because without art there is no
invention that’s basic scientific fact
so if we move up a level of abstraction
we avoid gaming we need to increase
cognitive load because we need to use
the popular language to have people
thinking slow not thinking fast we need
reflection not the immediate response
you get on questionnaires so this is an
example from work we’ve been doing in
Northern Ireland another small country
in which we’ve been empowering patients
to keep the stories of their own journey
through the health system and then self
interpret those stories so they become a
subject in their journey for health not
an object it doesn’t challenge the role
of the health professional but it makes
them a partner in the journey not the
dominant partner but a co partner and
here as you can see by place and telling
a story and balancing it between three
try on a triad between three qualities
you don’t know what the right answer is
you get better data that gives us quant
data at scale typically five to six
triangles together with other geometric
shapes it’s more like a game but it’s
quant backed up by qual and it means we
can capture narrative in written form
oral form or pictorial form we’re not
restricting it to text for data
analytics because what you can write
down is at best
tempis and to what you know if you focus
on information you radically reduce
human knowledge it’s far more than we
can write down and then of course we
have to find a way to enact what comes
out of that we have to find a way to
make real change and then we come on to
a whole new theory of change so this is
an example from a project working on
health and safety very similar patterns
whether it’s in aerospace manufacturing
or the
health sector these are two patterns
from two groups the vertical dimension
here is rule compliance the horizontal
dimension is job completion and this
comes from thousands of micro
observations recorded and interpreted by
patients or by health professionals this
is not based on surveys it’s a
continuous mass capture now you can see
immediately on the left they’ve got a
problem you either follow the rules or
you get the job done the two are
mutually incompatible States all of the
questionnaires all of the focus groups
all of the interviews say they’re doing
both because people know that’s the
right answer so that’s what they tell
you the day-to-day micro observations
tell you something completely different
on the right it looks better because
you’ve got a pattern at the top in which
everybody is actually following the
rules and getting the job done but that
tends to work out to be a crisis yeah
it’s accident an emergency it’s not a
day-to-day operations on a day-to-day
basis people have to break the rules to
provide empathetic care to patients but
increasingly bottomleft more people are
just giving up than doing what they need
to do to survive a pattern we’re seeing
in universities so now how do we change
that
a traditional change mechanism and this
is the engineering culture would define
a desired future state and try and close
the gap
that’s bad complexity science in
complexity what matters is we describe
the present when we make small changes
in the present to nudge the system in
the right direction but I don’t mean the
conventional approach of behavioral
economics and ledger economics because
to be quite honest that’s more yanking
than it is nudging it decides where
people want to where it wants people to
be and it tries to tug them towards it
what we want to work out is where people
are and see when it’s ready to change so
in this case I look for what in
complexity is called an adjacent
possible a cluster of narratives a
cluster of stories near to where I am
but going in the right direction and
this by the way is called a vector
measure
I don’t measure outcomes
I measure vectors direction and speed of
travel for intensity of effort and I
click on the material and say what can I
do tomorrow to create more stories like
these and fewer stories like that that
is an instruction which can be
understood by anybody at any educational
level what can I do within the compass
of my power to create more stories like
this and fewer stories like that if this
is a hospital administrator they asked
the questions of themselves they don’t
say what can I get my stuff to do
because basically as we go underneath
that every ward every nurse group every
health group at a government level every
district has their own map from the same
source data so they can all nudge their
systems in a direction appropriate to
their context rather being subject to
the tyranny of the average approach the
global campaign we need to start doing
small things in the present rather in
promising massive things in the future
because that just leaves the perpetual
disappointment and we can go beyond that
this is from work on peace and
reconciliation where we’ve taken ideas
as to how we can resolve a conflict and
we presented it to hundreds and
thousands of people for them to
interpret it and we’ve drawn a pattern
how different groups in society
represent or see the same data okay you
see here that the blue and green groups
see the world in such a different way
that there’s no point in getting them to
sit down and talk but you’ll just
increase conflict the only thing they’re
both agreed on is that the red guys are
really stupid so we actually have to
chain find a way to channel that how can
we create more stories like this fewer
stories like that how can we change the
day to day narratives of the present so
a new future is possible and if you
don’t change the way that people
describe the past and for the present
you haven’t got a new future anyway so
that is called fractal engagement where
the new key concepts on citizen
engagement will void and it goes beyond
that in the South Wales Valleys at the
moment as we gather this data room we’re
then starting to
people instead of young people coming
together and having a great event and be
terribly idealistic and then nothing
happens we’re saying to young people
will train you how to use the software
we train you in data analytics but you
have to bring somebody from your
grandparents generation with you so you
work together as a trans generation
player B that G grandparents will tell
things to their grandchildren they won’t
tell to their children and vice versa
and if you start to create interventions
at your local level which work will make
you a trio with somebody from the
government who can make your ideas
happen so at a ministerial level what
can i as a minister to do to create more
like this fewer like that at a council
level what can I do to create more like
this few like that at a local community
center of the Arts Center what can we do
to create more like this fewer like that
in our community
multiple mass fractal engagement to
achieve genuine sustainable change in
society and based on a scientific
approach not an engineering approach
based on managing a complex ecosystem
rather than trying to maintain a machine
and it’s an open program for governments
for countries for engagement worldwide
thank you very much for your time
[Applause]
for all of our history as a species
we’ve contrasted two types of system
ordered systems and chaotic systems and
other systems have huge value for
Humanity it gives us legal structure at
the present level in operating theaters
it means we can rely on the fact that
they’ll count out the surgical
instruments as they counted them in and
you won’t have to be operated on for a
second time as I get older I find that
sort of process of increasing importance
order is hugely valuable to human beings
on a negative side a fear of chaos has
been used to impose order unnecessarily
and destroy creative creativity and to
destroy freedom the reality is over the
last 40 or 50 years we’ve taken an
engineering focus on society and
engineering metaphor
and we’ve actually compounded order with
excessive outcome based measurement if
you actually look at the whole history
of last 40 or 50 years everything has to
have a target everything has to have a
defined outcome and it has to be a
number yeah whether it’s kpi’s number of
published papers or whatever else the
reality is all of the scientific
evidence says that when human beings are
pursuing explicit targets
it destroys intrinsic motivation there
is no evidence to contradict that and
where do we most need intrinsic
motivation in health and education and
where do we impose the worst targets in
health and education so we need to start
to think differently about this and we
need to move away from a primitive
dichotomy in which we can trust one
highly structured system with an
absolutely chaotic system into something
more sophisticated now there is actually
a third type of system which exists in
nature it’s a complex adaptive system
it’s a system defined not by its
structure by it by its connectivity in a
complex system everything is connected
with everything else but many of the
connections
cannot be known we talk about dark
constraints a reference to cosmology and
dark matter we can see the impact of a
constraint but we don’t know what the
constraint is we see there are boundary
conditions which aren’t defined we see
connections making things novel or
different in different ways the Internet
is an example of a complex system
humanity is a complex adaptive system
now understanding these and
understanding how we manage them is
critical and it’s not about control it’s
about understanding the connections
about change in the linkages the best
way I’ve ever learned to define the
difference between the three types of
system ordered systems complex systems
and chaotic systems is to start to think
about how we would use those approaches
to manage a day-to-day problem so
imagine if you can that tomorrow you
have to organize a party for a bunch of
nine-year-old children everybody can
imagine that yeah and you’re making the
mistake of holding it in your own house
you learn not to do this as you actually
have more than one child all right the
advantage of community centers is they
have fire hoses fire hose is a very
useful for clean up after a party and
they’re occasionally necessary for crowd
control draw in the party itself so
let’s imagine how we would organize a
party based on what assumption we make
about the type of system if we assume
that the system is chaotic then it means
the children are acting without
constraint their behavior is random so
they’re probably discovered drugs and
alcohol and go on a personal experience
of self-discovery your house may burn
down in the process but it was socially
constructed in the first place so why
are you worried about it I have a friend
in California who did try this once
yeah he’s never going to do it again the
recovery cost was too high the order
systems approach on the other hand is
taught in all good management schools
and all good business consultancy
outfits under this it’s of critical
importance to agree learning objectives
to the party in advance of the party
itself the learning objectives should be
aligned with the
statement for education in the society
to which should be long and should be
clearly articulated and printed off on
motivational posters with pictures of
eagles soaring over valleys and water
dropping into ponds and placed around
the walls of the room where you’re going
to hold the party as the children come
into the party they should be given
Disney playing cards with the party
value statement clearly printed on the
back you will of course have produced a
project plan for the party the project
plan will have clear milestones
throughout the party against which you
can measure progress against the ideal
party outcome and the senior adult will
start the party with a motivational DVD
don’t want the children wasting time in
play which isn’t aligned with the
learning objectives and then they’ll use
PowerPoint to demonstrate their personal
commitment to the party objectives and
show their children how their allowances
are linked to the achievement of the
milestone targets following the highly
successful completion of the party you
conduct after-action review they teach
your best practice database on party
management a mandate future process
improvement if at this stage for any
remote reason the children aren’t happy
you hire one of the new happiness
consultants who will train them to be
really very very happy and God help them
if they’re not the next time they come
to a party the complex systems approach
on the other hand is much simpler we
start off by drawing a line in the Sun
known as a boundary constraint in
complexity theory and we look the
children squarely in the eye and say
cross that and you die
and one of the things you learn pretty
fast as an adult is the value of
flexible negotiable boundaries because
rigid boundaries have a habit of
breaking catastrophically when you least
expect them we then introduced catalytic
probes a football a barbecue or computer
game any type of thing which will
actually trigger a pattern of play which
is called an attractor if it’s
beneficial we give it more resources if
it’s not beneficial well that’s where we
deploy the fire hoses what we manage is
the emergence of beneficial coherence
within attractors within boundaries and
we manage the only three things that you
can manage in a complex adaptive system
the boundary conditions the probes and
the amplification strategy management
and governance is much simpler when you
understand the nature of the system and
you stop trying to take an ecosystem as
if it was an engineering problem when
it’s an ecological problem so the work
I’ve been doing with my research group
and elsewhere is to find new methods or
new ways to deal with us but you have to
understand what’s going on you can only
understand a complex system by
understanding the small particular parts
of day-to-day interaction for humans
those are the anecdotal data of the
school gate the street story there BR
after work they’re not the grand
narratives of workshops it’s the
day-to-day anecdotes of people’s
existence and we need to understand them
through the voice of the people who tell
them not through an AI machine
interpreting the text or an expert
making them fit their cultural
expectations people’s own voice has to
be subject to their own interpretation
and then we need to allow those in power
at any level society that have direct
access to the raw stories of the people
they govern without multiple levels of
interpretation which allow them to hide
from reality behind the guise of policy
reports and everything else so that’s
kind of like the work we’re doing in
order to do that we have to engage
people and people have had enough of
surveys they’ve had enough of focus
groups focus groups are biased by the
facility
within 15 minutes opinion polls aren’t
trusted anymore we’ve never ever lived
by the way in a poll in a print of
fact-based society it’s just we used to
trust experts and now we’re trying
demagogues for a change the reality is
we actually hand over a lot of our
cognitive processes to structures it’s
not based on ourselves as individuals so
in order to do that we have to engage
people so for example in South Wales we
found that girls rugby clubs and the
main agent of change in some of the
rural community in some of the
industrial communities so we give them
tools by which they can capture their
experiences and the experiences the
people trying to recruit then they go
into old people’s homes to actually help
those people become more healthy because
they become engaged we’re actually
working now through schools because
teachers need to teach P kids about
community engagement about statistics so
we give them tools so that every month
their children can go into their
communities and gather stories from
those communities so they become
ethnographers to their own condition
rather than relying on outside experts
this is a huge program which we’re
starting off through small countries and
city states Wales is a small country and
the goal is to allow people to be
ethnographers to their own condition to
report their own stories but within a
quantitative framework not a quality to
framework over the last 30 or 40 years
I’ve seen many attempts at digital
storytelling at gathering people’s
stories but nobody thinks about how to
scale it and nobody allows people the
power to tell you what their story means
because that’s something done by the
people who gather them so that kind of
like leads us on to using people as
ethnographers to their own condition
this is a picture from work in Africa
where we got young girls trying to
understand the abuse that they and their
colleagues have suffered but making them
the ethnographers not external experts
now in order to get there they say we
have to empower people and power comes
from the power to interpret your
narrative not from the power to actually
hand your narrative over to somebody
else there in order to do that we have
to
find a way to scale it so there are
several key elements on this one is we
need to work with abstraction if you
don’t know it art comes before language
in human evolution the ability to
abstract allows for scientific invention
in fact the over emphasis on STEM
education at the moment around the world
will destroy scientific creativity
because without art there is no
invention that’s basic scientific fact
so if we move up a level of abstraction
we avoid gaming we need to increase
cognitive load because we need to use
the popular language to have people
thinking slow not thinking fast we need
reflection not the immediate response
you get on questionnaires so this is an
example from work we’ve been doing in
Northern Ireland another small country
in which we’ve been empowering patients
to keep the stories of their own journey
through the health system and then self
interpret those stories so they become a
subject in their journey for health not
an object it doesn’t challenge the role
of the health professional but it makes
them a partner in the journey not the
dominant partner but a co partner and
here as you can see by place and telling
a story and balancing it between three
try on a triad between three qualities
you don’t know what the right answer is
you get better data that gives us quant
data at scale typically five to six
triangles together with other geometric
shapes it’s more like a game but it’s
quant backed up by qual and it means we
can capture narrative in written form
oral form or pictorial form we’re not
restricting it to text for data
analytics because what you can write
down is at best
tempis and to what you know if you focus
on information you radically reduce
human knowledge it’s far more than we
can write down and then of course we
have to find a way to enact what comes
out of that we have to find a way to
make real change and then we come on to
a whole new theory of change so this is
an example from a project working on
health and safety very similar patterns
whether it’s in aerospace manufacturing
or the
health sector these are two patterns
from two groups the vertical dimension
here is rule compliance the horizontal
dimension is job completion and this
comes from thousands of micro
observations recorded and interpreted by
patients or by health professionals this
is not based on surveys it’s a
continuous mass capture now you can see
immediately on the left they’ve got a
problem you either follow the rules or
you get the job done the two are
mutually incompatible States all of the
questionnaires all of the focus groups
all of the interviews say they’re doing
both because people know that’s the
right answer so that’s what they tell
you the day-to-day micro observations
tell you something completely different
on the right it looks better because
you’ve got a pattern at the top in which
everybody is actually following the
rules and getting the job done but that
tends to work out to be a crisis yeah
it’s accident an emergency it’s not a
day-to-day operations on a day-to-day
basis people have to break the rules to
provide empathetic care to patients but
increasingly bottomleft more people are
just giving up than doing what they need
to do to survive a pattern we’re seeing
in universities so now how do we change
that
a traditional change mechanism and this
is the engineering culture would define
a desired future state and try and close
the gap
that’s bad complexity science in
complexity what matters is we describe
the present when we make small changes
in the present to nudge the system in
the right direction but I don’t mean the
conventional approach of behavioral
economics and ledger economics because
to be quite honest that’s more yanking
than it is nudging it decides where
people want to where it wants people to
be and it tries to tug them towards it
what we want to work out is where people
are and see when it’s ready to change so
in this case I look for what in
complexity is called an adjacent
possible a cluster of narratives a
cluster of stories near to where I am
but going in the right direction and
this by the way is called a vector
measure
I don’t measure outcomes
I measure vectors direction and speed of
travel for intensity of effort and I
click on the material and say what can I
do tomorrow to create more stories like
these and fewer stories like that that
is an instruction which can be
understood by anybody at any educational
level what can I do within the compass
of my power to create more stories like
this and fewer stories like that if this
is a hospital administrator they asked
the questions of themselves they don’t
say what can I get my stuff to do
because basically as we go underneath
that every ward every nurse group every
health group at a government level every
district has their own map from the same
source data so they can all nudge their
systems in a direction appropriate to
their context rather being subject to
the tyranny of the average approach the
global campaign we need to start doing
small things in the present rather in
promising massive things in the future
because that just leaves the perpetual
disappointment and we can go beyond that
this is from work on peace and
reconciliation where we’ve taken ideas
as to how we can resolve a conflict and
we presented it to hundreds and
thousands of people for them to
interpret it and we’ve drawn a pattern
how different groups in society
represent or see the same data okay you
see here that the blue and green groups
see the world in such a different way
that there’s no point in getting them to
sit down and talk but you’ll just
increase conflict the only thing they’re
both agreed on is that the red guys are
really stupid so we actually have to
chain find a way to channel that how can
we create more stories like this fewer
stories like that how can we change the
day to day narratives of the present so
a new future is possible and if you
don’t change the way that people
describe the past and for the present
you haven’t got a new future anyway so
that is called fractal engagement where
the new key concepts on citizen
engagement will void and it goes beyond
that in the South Wales Valleys at the
moment as we gather this data room we’re
then starting to
people instead of young people coming
together and having a great event and be
terribly idealistic and then nothing
happens we’re saying to young people
will train you how to use the software
we train you in data analytics but you
have to bring somebody from your
grandparents generation with you so you
work together as a trans generation
player B that G grandparents will tell
things to their grandchildren they won’t
tell to their children and vice versa
and if you start to create interventions
at your local level which work will make
you a trio with somebody from the
government who can make your ideas
happen so at a ministerial level what
can i as a minister to do to create more
like this fewer like that at a council
level what can I do to create more like
this few like that at a local community
center of the Arts Center what can we do
to create more like this fewer like that
in our community
multiple mass fractal engagement to
achieve genuine sustainable change in
society and based on a scientific
approach not an engineering approach
based on managing a complex ecosystem
rather than trying to maintain a machine
and it’s an open program for governments
for countries for engagement worldwide
thank you very much for your time
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: