Press "Enter" to skip to content

Why Girls And Boys Should Compete With Each Other In Sports | John Brenkus | TEDxUniversityofNevada


[Music]
I created and hosted a television show
called sports science that was on the
air for over ten years we were fortunate
enough to win six Emmys and I also wrote
a New York Times bestselling book called
the perfection point that analyzed the
limits of human performance so needless
to say I’ve had a front-row seat in
analyzing the world’s greatest athletes
both men and women and I’m here to tell
you the idea that we have woven into our
fabric into our especially American DNA
that bigger stronger faster means that
you’re better is wrong in that same idea
bigger stronger faster means you’re
better has been projected on a wide
swath of the population and has helped
them down unnecessarily and that group
is winning let me prove it to you let’s
start with the NFL running back
everybody likes to think I want the
biggest fastest strongest guy running
the ball for me
well Newtonian physics is going to tell
us different there’s an equation F
equals MA force is mass times
acceleration that means the greater the
mass the greater the acceleration the
greater the force and if you’re really
big if you’re six five to 16 you run a
four for 40 you generate a tremendous
amount of force it sounds like a good
thing in football right maybe in a
vacuum but not in terms of having a long
career because there is another law
that’s gonna get in your way and that
says that when two objects collide they
each experience the same amount of force
so this giant running back every time he
gets tackled it goes to the ground he’s
experiencing that huge amount of force
every time which leads to injury and a
shortened career this helps explain why
top 5 running backs of all time by yards
game in the NFL
we have Emmitt Smith we have Walter
Payne Barry Sanders Curtis Martin and
LaDainian
all of them are six feet or below in the
average way to the top five is somewhere
around 210
these aren’t giant human beings none of
them were the fastest in the league and
none of them were even the fastest on
their own team in fact if they were the
fastest it would have worked against
them get this step of the top 10 fastest
40-yard dash times clocked by the NFL on
the offensive side another NFL Combine
two of the top ten have a thousand yards
in a season the other eight don’t have a
thousand yards in their careers that
shows you that there is diminishing
returns to speed and sods these top
running backs fall into what I like to
call the Goldilocks zone they’re big
enough fast enough in that Goldilocks
zone helps them because they have a
lower center of gravity and they’re not
moving so fast so that they they can
turn easier it also gives them a chip on
their shoulder they’re looking at the
people who are pursuing them these giant
human beings and they’re say they say to
themselves you know what I’m gonna
redefine for you but you think someone
my size can actually do he gives him
this super human ego they think to
themselves I’m a superhero even though
I’m small I’m gonna prove you wrong and
that works especially for men and not
just in the running back position so
this idea of bigger stronger faster
equal better works to a man’s advantage
in virtually every position in sports
you don’t want to be the top of the
curve you want to be in the Goldilocks
zone but what we do as a society is we
take that same idea you got to be bigger
faster stronger to be better and we
project it onto our girls and we tell
them from day one you will never be as
big you’ll never be as strong you’ll
never be as fast
don’t even try we’re gonna separate you
out there will be girls leagues and
there will be boys leagues we don’t let
them
play together so this is very damaging
to a little girl’s ego of what’s
possible when I was in elementary school
we had the presidential physical fitness
test and of course there were girls
standards and boy standards girls had to
do fewer sit-ups fewer push-ups they
weren’t even allowed to do pull-ups they
had to hang by a bar
even though girls mature quicker
physically than boys we tell them ah
you’re never gonna be able to compete
with them so don’t even try and that’s
modeled for them all the way up to the
professional level look at tennis
women play three sets men play five sets
what a women can explode if they play
two more sets
take a basketball they play eight fewer
minutes
oh there’s such fragile little flowers
we can’t let them possibly play the same
amount of time look at fringe sports
like darts in bowling if darts in
bowling they divide that by gender what
makes a man better prepared to throw a
dart than a woman and here’s the most
ridiculous example golf at every golf
course
the closest tee the one farthest dumb
the easiest one to hit from is called
the ladies tee that’s pretty insulting
to ladies we’re saying we know you can’t
hit the ball as far as a man so we’re
gonna label it such that’s an insult get
this step girl by the name of Lexi
Thompson just shy of her 17th birthday
she was 16 years and seven months she at
the time became the youngest LPGA Tour
player to win a Tour event she averaged
off the tee 286 yards at the same time
the number one men’s player on the pga
side was Luke Donald he averaged 285
yards
so why was Lexie hitting the ball from
much closer that doesn’t make any sense
and get this stuff just which man on the
PGA Tour average the shortest distance
off the tee guy by the name of Jim Furyk
well that must be a disadvantage for mr.
Furyk Oh wrong he’s fourth on the
all-time money list guess how many women
on the LPGA Tour actually average a
farther distance than Jim Furyk 11 and
the reason why it’s not more than that
because now women hit the ball so far
they don’t have to hit a driver off the
tee it’s to their disadvantage so these
stats are all out of whack women can hit
the ball plenty for the world record for
the women’s long drive championships 402
yards so I don’t want her hitting from
the ladies tee now stats provided to me
by Michael pinky and combine performance
show that women from fairway to green
strokes are even between men and women
and putts per round
strokes are even right cuz why would a
man be able to putt better than a woman
there’s no reason so people say well how
could a woman hit a golf ball as far as
the man I mean they’re not as big or as
strong it’s not about size and strength
it’s about kinetic linking you draw
energy up from the ground through your
body and project it out through the end
of the club head the perfect visual
example of kinetic linking is a whip you
transfer the energy all the way down
then at the end of the whip it’s not
it’s actually breaking the sound barrier
women are not constructed to have a
disadvantage at transferring energy from
the ground versus men and this has
proven out in softball versus baseball
did you realize that in softball a pitch
from 43 feet going 70 miles per hour
takes the same amount of time as a 90
mile per hour fastball in baseball
delivered from 60 feet six inches it’s
about four tenths of a second well both
men and women get the bat around
perfectly fine so the reaction time has
to be the same but why are women
swinging at a bigger projectile is there
some study I don’t know about that says
women
have worse hand-eye coordination than
men I mean it’s ridiculous this is also
proven in boxing and sports science we
had we see a Riker to the lab she was an
undefeated female boxer also played the
evil boxer and Million Dollar Baby and
we had her matched up against a male
Olympian of the exact same size and
weight and you know that expression oh
you hit like a girl
well Lucia hit much harder than the man
so I want to be able to hit like a girl
people like to ask me well who’s the
better athlete a man or a woman I’m like
look it depends on what sport what
position we’re talking about I mean is
the fastest man always gonna be faster
than the fastest woman probably but men
are constructed to be faster but that
doesn’t mean they’re better athletes I
mean let’s look at endurance women are
actually constructed better than men to
succeed at endurance events this helps
explain why there are 7,000 people who
have summited Mount Everest but there’s
only one human being in the history of
mankind to swim from Cuba to Florida 110
miles without a shark cage Diana Nyad
and she was 63
[Applause]
Diane is not alone with women achieving
greatness and endurance events look at
Pam Reid in 2002 and 2003 she won
back-to-back titles at the Badwater
ultramarathon which is a hundred and
thirty-five miles through Death Valley
and she beat the pants off of everyone
absolutely everyone including men that’s
a badass female I wish to God I could
run as far in as fast and can swim as
well as Diana but I can’t want to know
why because I’m not a woman that’s why
so here’s my crazy idea I think boys and
girls should be playing the same sports
with the same rules on the same field at
the same time from the word go
now when I put that idea out there
especially a lot of macho men they come
right back and they say women are never
gonna play off since I’m in football
well all right fine I’ll concede that to
you even though I don’t necessarily
agree I’ll concede it to you for the
sake of this argument but you want to
know what the worldwide population is of
men who actually play in the NFL it’s
zero point zero zero zero zero zero zero
two that’s basically zero so let’s not
let the exception become the role my
little nine-year-old daughter right now
is the fastest human in her class boy or
girl and she’s always been the fastest
since kindergarten
now I was the fastest human being in
elementary school but when I got to high
school I wasn’t all that fast and I
didn’t make all the teams and natural
selection is what eliminated me from
competition now Society wants me to look
my little girl in the eyes and to say
you know what I know you’re fast now but
eventually you won’t be and because of
that you can’t play with the boys right
now and I call BS on that I say look she
should be able to play with the boys
right now she should play every sport
that they get to play now the reason why
we do this and the reason why we project
these unfair limits is because we as a
human species are really bad at setting
limits think about the four-minute mile
here we’re never gonna break that
there’s no way a human being is going to
run one mile in under four minutes
well sir roger bannister came along in
1954 and he broke the four-minute mile
46 days later it was broken again in ten
years it was broken 300 times that’s
once every 12 days that’s a crappy limit
and that’s what we’re doing to our girls
we’re telling them
here’s your limit right from the get-go
people might think so what about title 9
how does that affect that look I’m not
talking about taking men and women today
in mixing them up because you’re only as
good as you need to be to win and girls
haven’t had to play against boys right
now men haven’t had to play against
women like that’s an unfair thing to do
but maybe title 9 has been wonderful
because it’s opened our eyes that
millions of women have been able to play
collegiate sports with a full-ride and
rightfully so but maybe dividing sports
by gender isn’t the right way to do it
maybe we should have an A Team a B team
a C team at every level and once you get
to the collegiate level you evenly
distribute scholarships across those
levels this is purely a hypothetical I
don’t know if that’s the right answer
but what I do know is that if you don’t
agree with my argument this is what
you’re saying you’re saying if you line
up every boy and girl in the world from
the time that they’re born and you give
them equal access same equipment same
rules and coaching same everything
you’re telling me that the number of
women who will break that ceiling and
make it at the elite level you’re saying
the number is zero and I’m telling you
you’re wrong it’s greater than zero it
has to be and those women those very
first women who cracked that glass
ceiling they’re gonna influence and
redefine the expectations we have for
our little girls for millions of them
even billions of them to come so if you
are sitting back and you’re scowling at
me and you’re saying girls aren’t gonna
play with my boys status quo is going to
serve you fine but folks we’re in 2018
and I think it’s about time that we say
I want to hear a woman roar as loud as
she possibly can and the only way we’re
gonna be able to do that is by changing
something don’t you want to know what
the limit actually is for a woman
the only way to find out is to have
little girls and boys competing together
from day one
thank you
you
Please follow and like us: