Press "Enter" to skip to content

How can we have better conversations? | Daniel Herrmann | TEDxQuestU


we are social creatures go to a friend
tried to be her to build a bridge across
the agora to cross river or
philosophizing the agora we heard in the
conversations about the world around us
about ourselves
the monkey station is the most common
medium through which we communicate with
each other in this I will be speaking to
you about conversation a few months ago
as I was in the cafeteria here at Qwest
I overheard a conversation between two
of my friends they were arguing about
whether or not some specific policy of
the American government was good for
back beam questions they’re both
relatively educated intelligent people
and so they only presented their
arguments for and against and began
evaluating and disagreeing with the
other’s argument even though they both
listened to the other person they still
disagree to the argument they thought
the other person’s argument didn’t work
I watched the conversation complete
spiral out of control surely it would
seem to think if my friend just
understood what I was saying he would
see the reasoning behind my argument and
agree with me needless to say his
conversation didn’t go as I there so I
walked in it they both felt very sadly
this is not an isolated incidents I’ve
seen many frustrating conversations
personally involved in many more I
imagine we all have please raise your
hand if you’ve ever been a frustrating
conversation yeah pretty much everyone
it’s a common problem and it sucks it
feels like those people in the cafeteria
conversation though you feel under and
people just harass what you were saying
they would see your reasoning and agree
with you after games are far too many
frustrating conversations I decided I
could do better
his 10x clock is part of my a particular
the focus of the talk have better
conversations specifically I’m gonna be
talking to you about conversations at
the cafeteria conversation furnace well
attended one in which both parties are
seeking to understand issue or an idea
better than they did before it often
this takes the form of providing
arguments for one side of an issue or
another and then evaluating the
arguments to see what works this is
obviously different from other kinds of
conversations such as conversations
there is fun and playful or
conversations in which you’re trying to
blow off steam to a friend for the
person of this talk I will be focusing
on some secret conversations ultimately
then the goal of introducing the
conversation is for all parties to
become better person idea or subject and
serving civil and in good spirits
conversation to achieve this goal have a
loosely call good warez conversations
which people get frustrated or little to
no progress is made on understanding
issue
I will loosely call back the FedEx event
is questioning the norm
if the normos bad conversations which
unfortunately it seems to be what can we
do about them this is clearly an
important problem that conversations
have bad consequences
that conversations can lead to issue
between friends one in a discussion you
don’t feel hurt or appreciatively bad
conversations coming to the litical
issues when people at different side of
an issue are unable to come to an
agreement it has been
common ground who wish to converse and
that conversation is finding 10 action
when groups of people are unable to
decide what to do most simply absolutely
secret conversations don’t achieve their
goal what is the point in trying to have
a transient conversation if know what
you’re seeking is taking place so the
question becomes how can you have fewer
bad conversations and more good
conversations
the answer is acquits you today is
logical my thesis is a better
understanding of logic in up us have
better conversations logic is something
that is familiar to most of us in formal
casual way but there is an entire field
of study devoted strictly speaking logic
is the study of arguments it lets you
ask to answer questions like does the
certain twerk in what situations in sari
does the certain fall apart and how can
I make this argument stronger this helps
clarify things who wish it behind the
idea that logic and others have better
conversations logic consists of tool to
evaluate arguments and true scene
conversations rely on evaluating
arguments to turn the truth of something
so where do we go from here I’m gonna
talk any of two examples in this talk on
how understanding simple closets and
logic plus have better conversations
specifically I look at notions have lost
the validity and multiple soundness and
the important distinction between the
two there’s all too often missing
conversations
an argument is logically valid if and
only if the conclusion necessarily
follows from the premises
thus the classic syllogism all men are
mortal Socrates is a man therefore
Socrates is mortal this circuit is valid
is if we agree that a all men are mortal
and B Socrates is a man then we must
agree that some races moral
however the following argument is also
valid all potatoes are said to be space
aliens my left arms and tato therefore
my left arm
space in this art is perfectly about
because if it is indeed true that all
potatoes are sending space aliens and my
left arm is potato then it must be true
to my left arm as a sentence basically
this brings us the difference between
validity and soundness an argument is
logically sound if it only if it is
valid and the premises are true
thus presumably the argument about
Socrates being mortal is worth caring
about my left arm being a sentient space
alien is hopefully not sound probably
the alcohol URI argument is also sound
if I give you a TEDx talk then I’m gonna
live I am giving a TEDx talk
therefore my left understanding validity
can really help us in arguments in
conversations if both you and the person
with whom you are conversing
understanding the minute II then you can
both evaluate the converse it the
arcticus Newton for that conversation
and agree on whether or not there about
if you both agree that they are valid
and yet you still disagree on the
conclusion that you disagree on the
soundness of the area that is you
disagree on the primitive on the
premises an important kind of progress
is up remember a primitive is a very low
level kind of starting point is
something that one simply takes as given
without with money any kind of Gallifrey
for example some people think that
happiness is good and that this is just
a better world if they just ate this
without our even for an hour against and
this is one of their primitives so if we
understand primitives then we can deep
deeper in conversations and find the
difference between our primitives and
those of others we can actually
the real crux of the argument and thus
of the conversation lies this is what
the diagram shows though both arguments
have conversation may be valid
people have different premises to which
they then they can still reasonably
disagree on the conclusions I suspect
that what happened in the cafeteria
conversation I introduced earlier is
something like this though both of the
articles put forward by the parties were
more or less valid they each have
different premises to which they were
committed and thus they disagreed on the
conclusion but because they disagreed on
the conclusion they thought that they
disagreed about whether or not their
arguments worked however if we replace
the informal notion of whether or not an
argument works with the more formal
notions of the Lybian soundness we can
see between that confusion my friends
have been better versed in logic and
they have applied their knowledge in the
situation they would have found that
even though they both valid arguments
they did have different primitives to
which they’re committed
they disagreed on the purpose of
governance thus when they disagreed
about whether or not the specific
American policy was good or bad they
were really disagreeing about whether or
not the policy fulfill the purpose that
the government and because they had
different ideas about what that was they
disagree on the conclusion so we’ve seen
at least three big pieces where better
understand logic helpless and better
situation conversations first understand
it oceans of validity and soundness and
help us understand the other various
perspectives
secondly if we dig deep and we figure
that we have the same primitives that we
should agree on the conclusion in third
if we dig it in front we have different
primitives
then we’ll at least understand why we
disagree and we won’t be talking past
each other
so we’ve seen a basic understanding of
just two of the concepts of logic
we have better conversations while
checking out this have better personal
conversations because when you disagree
with right you can actually dig deep and
figure out their primitives on and thus
understand them better understanding
prudence can help us have better
political conversations because when you
were arguing someone of a different
political slant you can actually find
what the different primitives are and
stop back talking past each other but
actually made to the other person
finally this can lead to having other
plans of action because when you
understand the values of different
parties in a conversation then you’re
able to effectively create plans that
help achieve common goals so I’ve given
you my reasons for why I think logic
will help us have better conversations
by evaluating my argument and trying to
decide whether or not you agree with it
you are already engaging with logic
logic is inescapable so let’s say you
agree with me what actual concrete steps
can you take to achieve this well first
you can learn a little object learning
logic and one of the most empowering
experiences of my life
in particular if you’re curious about
this I would recommend the book of rule
book for running it’s by Anthony Weston
second you can learn not only how to
recognize good arguments but also to
recognize common these are all capable
article policies and there are plenty of
resources on the line out here finally
you can challenge yourself to start
using logic explicitly in your
conversations and challenge your friends
to do the same whether you want to have
better conversations with your friends
the questioning me or society as a whole
you have to help create a culture that
values in logic program quite raising
the quality of your own conversations
you can help raise the quality of all
our conversations furthermore logic
isn’t just a powerful tool for having
conversations there can be a powerful
tool for making your arguments about
things you care about more
Mayson whether you’re fighting for civil
rights promoting effective environmental
legislature we’re trying to convince
your friend to vote for one candidate
over another would have been useful in
the last election then you can make sure
your arguments are sound and this gives
your opponents less room to attack you
so if that’s my talk I want to say thank
you and enjoy the other speakers and
listen to them think about the logic
underlying arias and whether or not
you’re thank you
[Music]
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: