
we live in a more and more peaceful
world since the end of the two world
wars states have increasingly solved
their conflicts by talking by trading by
inventing common rules but diplomacy the
peaceful conversation between states is
under pressure from our leaders need for
public spotlight and the emergence of
social media what happens when our
political leaders use their smartphones
during negotiations let me take you
backstage into the negotiation room in
Ukraine during one of the most serious
crisis between Europe and Russia since
the end of the Cold War for several
decades European Union and Ukraine have
sought to establish closer ties but then
suddenly in the fall of 2013 the
Ukrainian government changes his mind
and failed to sign the treaty the
association agreement with the EU
protests explode in Kiev the capital of
Ukraine with up to 800,000 people
marching in the street waving the flags
of the EU and Ukraine demanding the
President to step down and the agreement
is be signed thousands of people up
hospitalized and hundreds of people lose
their lives in clashes between
protesters and security forces back in
Copenhagen I’m in shock
and so are my former colleagues in the
Daley’s foreign ministry and ministries
across Europe but we are they thought
was a long tiresome sometimes very
bureaucratic process of decades has
turned into a major geopolitical crisis
in the negotiation room we have the
Ukrainian government
we have a Russian representative and
international mediators the Foreign
Minister from Poland France and Germany
and they’ve flown in to Kiev the same
morning and they’re trying to broker a
deal that would end the violence
negotiations continue throughout the
night and throughout the day 30 hours of
negotiations almost without break and
then early Friday morning people
exhausted the atmosphere is tense still
no green light for any kind of agreement
and then all of a sudden from inside the
negotiation room the Polish foreign
minister Sikorski tweets we’re about to
sign good compromise for Europe give
peace a chance and opens the way to
reform into Europe Poland and you
support it the tweet goes viral the
global media especially picks it up and
sakowski is hailed as a hero the grand
savior of the European peace and I’m
excited to follow this in Copenhagen on
my smart phone but very soon sakowskis
criticized for rushing with the tweet
taking credit for a very fragile peace
agreement before it’s even made official
in fact his critics are saying that with
this premature tweet he’s basically
jeopardizing the entire peace process
but Sikorsky is not the only one playing
with his phone at negotiations in fact
he’s just one example of the
entanglement between confidential
negotiations on the one hand and this
public display as a scholar in political
science with a background in the foreign
ministry I’m faced with one pressing
issue okay diplomacy used to be about
confidentiality a restrained politeness
all keys to international mediation but
diplomacy has entered a new phase some
call it the Information Age others the
digital age and for Bill Gates the
founder of Microsoft
this new era represents a new time a
promise of a world what distance does
not matter where all the historical
divisions that have separated the people
in the world will no longer matter
in fact distance does not matter and
what he called the information Highway
means that we will increase the
understanding that citizens have of the
neighboring countries and thus reduce
international tensions wonderful
unfortunately that didn’t happen we have
seen a digital revolution but not the
one that gates dreamt of today no longer
and only negotiating behind the closed
doors
our leaders engage with the public
through social media such as Twitter and
Facebook and this interferes directly
with the negotiations it happens
simultaneously but not long ago our
leaders were very reluctant to go and
social media back in 2007 Barack Obama
was the first world leader or among the
first to create his own Twitter account
and only a handful of him followed
followed that year of our heads of state
at government didn’t really dare to do
so so he became president and since then
the use of social media by our heads of
state and government has exploded so
today 178 countries from 92% of all UN
member states representing an audience
or reaching out to an audience of 356
million Twitter users they have their
own Twitter accounts these leaders and
many of them they they treat themselves
okay no filter so social media has gone
from being this weird afterthought to
being the very first thing they think
about when they wake up in the morning
now of course the public was always
important but this embrace of online
channels and this transparency has
created a world of openness that we have
never experienced before
but in the hands of our political
leaders a smartphone can become a lethal
weapon and I can clearly see how these
open doors they challenge diplomacy’s
three foundational pillars the first
pillar of diplomacy that’s time by time
why does diplomacy require time it
requires time because you need that time
to mature a process of negotiation when
I was working in the Danish foreign
ministry we were preparing the meetings
between the 28 member states in the EU
and we would start weeks and actually
sometimes months before the summit
circulating ideas having pre meetings at
very low levels drafting ideas and
everything from refugee policy to energy
anti-terrorism to get those compromises
just right and then I remember in the in
the days before the summit we would work
long hours really really long hours
basically staying in the ministry
throughout the night in order to get the
words right for our prime minister
we were drafting the speech notes and
what kept us going through those very
long days and nights that wasn’t caviar
or or champagne but that was pizza
takeaway pizza and coffee lots of coffee
and the knowledge that our colleagues in
Bratislava in Athens and Berlin they
were doing exactly the same thing and
they were doing this because they
sincerely knew and believed that we were
contributing you’re contributing with
peaceful solutions and compromises
between our countries so that’s time
crucial but the second pillar of
diplomacy is space you need a
confidential space to find out where the
other parties red line really lies
without that confidential safe space
there’s simply no room to to maneuver to
have a mental wiggle room or to
improvise or or just brainstorm
collectively and that’s why when you had
to
the civil war in Yugoslavia it couldn’t
end in Yugoslavia you basically had to
fly in 1995 the warring parties out of
the country all the way to Dayton Ohio
put them in a room for 21 days and that
then resulted in that compromise the
Dayton Agreement the peace agreement
away from press away from domestic
constituencies so a confidential space
but the third pillar of diplomacy is
tact or what we in diplomatic language
called protocol it’s all about saving
the face of the other it’s about taking
into consideration the emotions or
feelings of the other prison and it’s
actually not that weird if you think
about entering a bus and the bus is full
and you would really like a seat but
it’s full then there’s an elderly lady
you see her she’s sitting and she’s put
her hand back next to her on their seats
the only free seat then you don’t go
move your stuff lady you say excuse me
is this seat taken and she’ll probably
remove the back
now that’s tact right if you move that
to the international level where the
tensions are really really high where
the cultural differences may be enormous
then you know why diplomats they
disagree but they disagree without being
disagreeable now all these three pillars
of diplomacy are fundamentally
challenged by the 24/7 coverage every
single foreign policy event and social
media if you take time and space leaders
they they rush to be the first to tweet
and of course mistakes and blunders
happen and this leads to a great risk of
conflict escalation last year the
Pakistani Defense Minister reacted to a
news article he read and he’d read that
actually Israel was threatening Pakistan
with nuclear weapons
and so he felt the need to react on
Twitter of course and he said hey Israel
by the way remember Pakistan is a
nuclear power – okay just
about it just for one second this is one
nuclear power threatening almost
explicitly another nuclear power with
war on Twitter
now if the Pakistani Defense Minister
had only double-checked this article he
might have realized as the Israeli
Defense Ministry had to explain that
actually the whole story the statement
attributed to the former Israeli Defense
Minister was never set in fact the whole
story was entirely false fake story okay
patience is gone but so is
confidentiality and tact is gone too
because you can only be so diplomatic in
140 characters so are we just doomed to
watch these Twitter Wars run out of
control and the world becoming a more
dangerous place how can we use social
media constructively in international
relations well a first option that I
think many of my colleagues would
sometimes really want is basically to
take away those smartphones from our
leaders you know just you’ll leave them
outside outside the door when they
negotiate shut down the Twitter accounts
at the conflicts moments the problem
with that option is it it really takes
us away from all the positive aspects of
the digital revolution after all it is
that revolution that has enabled us to
follow events far away to reach out
between nations and also you know if we
took away those smartphones and those
digital devices they would just invent
other ways of reaching us other ways of
inventing a platform so that’s not
really an option okay
another possibility that I thought I
don’t long about was you know why don’t
we create a kind of a rule book am do’s
and don’ts for diplomats on social media
a kind of guideline this is what you
should do and and not do the problem
with that option
that either our leaders wouldn’t follow
these rules because they’re not binding
or if they did nobody would put any
attentions to these tweets because they
would be way too polished and frankly
way too boring so the problem with these
solutions these answers is that they
don’t really touch the core of the
problem the core of the problem is that
we simply only scratch the surface we
only scratch the surface when we talk
about these issues the problem is we
created those that are loud and visible
and we neglect those discreet
negotiators most fundamentally and we
help them doing that social media turns
our leaders attention away from the
tedious work of brokering deals to
managing their public face and worse by
doing that they’re basically taking
themselves away from what they’re
claiming to do namely solving
international conflicts so my idea is
that we should be able to look under the
surface to see the rest of the iceberg
so far what we see is basically the tips
of the iceberg but often not really the
right one you can’t tension to all these
Facebook updates everywhere so how are
we going to do that we first have to
admit that the Paris climate agreement
the Iran nuclear deal that required
years and and months and days and very
long hours to actually achieve and so
digital revolution has helped us follow
these events but we will only harvest
the fruits of the digital revolution if
we’re able to look behind the scenes to
look at the people the women and men who
worked night and day to carve out
compromises and we the public urgently
need to understand what their work means
not just for
your individual interest but for our
collective ability to create and
maintain peace unless we go under the
surface we simply will not be able to
elect the right people to handle well
politics and I don’t think I have to
remember to mention any names here so we
need citizens that participate actively
in foreign policy events engaged
critically with social media and I’m not
saying that we should get all the
details on every single confidential
material on the negotiation table but we
do need to understand what lies between
the updates the Instagram and the
Facebook and I ask you when you leave
this room please remember the three
pillars of diplomacy
please remember that time space and tact
has so far been crucial to arrive at any
kind of peace deal so if we have active
citizens participating actively we also
need these citizens to to demand and to
get the bigger picture the bigger
picture of what it actually takes to get
us into that negotiation room as you do
right this moment thank you
[Applause]
world since the end of the two world
wars states have increasingly solved
their conflicts by talking by trading by
inventing common rules but diplomacy the
peaceful conversation between states is
under pressure from our leaders need for
public spotlight and the emergence of
social media what happens when our
political leaders use their smartphones
during negotiations let me take you
backstage into the negotiation room in
Ukraine during one of the most serious
crisis between Europe and Russia since
the end of the Cold War for several
decades European Union and Ukraine have
sought to establish closer ties but then
suddenly in the fall of 2013 the
Ukrainian government changes his mind
and failed to sign the treaty the
association agreement with the EU
protests explode in Kiev the capital of
Ukraine with up to 800,000 people
marching in the street waving the flags
of the EU and Ukraine demanding the
President to step down and the agreement
is be signed thousands of people up
hospitalized and hundreds of people lose
their lives in clashes between
protesters and security forces back in
Copenhagen I’m in shock
and so are my former colleagues in the
Daley’s foreign ministry and ministries
across Europe but we are they thought
was a long tiresome sometimes very
bureaucratic process of decades has
turned into a major geopolitical crisis
in the negotiation room we have the
Ukrainian government
we have a Russian representative and
international mediators the Foreign
Minister from Poland France and Germany
and they’ve flown in to Kiev the same
morning and they’re trying to broker a
deal that would end the violence
negotiations continue throughout the
night and throughout the day 30 hours of
negotiations almost without break and
then early Friday morning people
exhausted the atmosphere is tense still
no green light for any kind of agreement
and then all of a sudden from inside the
negotiation room the Polish foreign
minister Sikorski tweets we’re about to
sign good compromise for Europe give
peace a chance and opens the way to
reform into Europe Poland and you
support it the tweet goes viral the
global media especially picks it up and
sakowski is hailed as a hero the grand
savior of the European peace and I’m
excited to follow this in Copenhagen on
my smart phone but very soon sakowskis
criticized for rushing with the tweet
taking credit for a very fragile peace
agreement before it’s even made official
in fact his critics are saying that with
this premature tweet he’s basically
jeopardizing the entire peace process
but Sikorsky is not the only one playing
with his phone at negotiations in fact
he’s just one example of the
entanglement between confidential
negotiations on the one hand and this
public display as a scholar in political
science with a background in the foreign
ministry I’m faced with one pressing
issue okay diplomacy used to be about
confidentiality a restrained politeness
all keys to international mediation but
diplomacy has entered a new phase some
call it the Information Age others the
digital age and for Bill Gates the
founder of Microsoft
this new era represents a new time a
promise of a world what distance does
not matter where all the historical
divisions that have separated the people
in the world will no longer matter
in fact distance does not matter and
what he called the information Highway
means that we will increase the
understanding that citizens have of the
neighboring countries and thus reduce
international tensions wonderful
unfortunately that didn’t happen we have
seen a digital revolution but not the
one that gates dreamt of today no longer
and only negotiating behind the closed
doors
our leaders engage with the public
through social media such as Twitter and
Facebook and this interferes directly
with the negotiations it happens
simultaneously but not long ago our
leaders were very reluctant to go and
social media back in 2007 Barack Obama
was the first world leader or among the
first to create his own Twitter account
and only a handful of him followed
followed that year of our heads of state
at government didn’t really dare to do
so so he became president and since then
the use of social media by our heads of
state and government has exploded so
today 178 countries from 92% of all UN
member states representing an audience
or reaching out to an audience of 356
million Twitter users they have their
own Twitter accounts these leaders and
many of them they they treat themselves
okay no filter so social media has gone
from being this weird afterthought to
being the very first thing they think
about when they wake up in the morning
now of course the public was always
important but this embrace of online
channels and this transparency has
created a world of openness that we have
never experienced before
but in the hands of our political
leaders a smartphone can become a lethal
weapon and I can clearly see how these
open doors they challenge diplomacy’s
three foundational pillars the first
pillar of diplomacy that’s time by time
why does diplomacy require time it
requires time because you need that time
to mature a process of negotiation when
I was working in the Danish foreign
ministry we were preparing the meetings
between the 28 member states in the EU
and we would start weeks and actually
sometimes months before the summit
circulating ideas having pre meetings at
very low levels drafting ideas and
everything from refugee policy to energy
anti-terrorism to get those compromises
just right and then I remember in the in
the days before the summit we would work
long hours really really long hours
basically staying in the ministry
throughout the night in order to get the
words right for our prime minister
we were drafting the speech notes and
what kept us going through those very
long days and nights that wasn’t caviar
or or champagne but that was pizza
takeaway pizza and coffee lots of coffee
and the knowledge that our colleagues in
Bratislava in Athens and Berlin they
were doing exactly the same thing and
they were doing this because they
sincerely knew and believed that we were
contributing you’re contributing with
peaceful solutions and compromises
between our countries so that’s time
crucial but the second pillar of
diplomacy is space you need a
confidential space to find out where the
other parties red line really lies
without that confidential safe space
there’s simply no room to to maneuver to
have a mental wiggle room or to
improvise or or just brainstorm
collectively and that’s why when you had
to
the civil war in Yugoslavia it couldn’t
end in Yugoslavia you basically had to
fly in 1995 the warring parties out of
the country all the way to Dayton Ohio
put them in a room for 21 days and that
then resulted in that compromise the
Dayton Agreement the peace agreement
away from press away from domestic
constituencies so a confidential space
but the third pillar of diplomacy is
tact or what we in diplomatic language
called protocol it’s all about saving
the face of the other it’s about taking
into consideration the emotions or
feelings of the other prison and it’s
actually not that weird if you think
about entering a bus and the bus is full
and you would really like a seat but
it’s full then there’s an elderly lady
you see her she’s sitting and she’s put
her hand back next to her on their seats
the only free seat then you don’t go
move your stuff lady you say excuse me
is this seat taken and she’ll probably
remove the back
now that’s tact right if you move that
to the international level where the
tensions are really really high where
the cultural differences may be enormous
then you know why diplomats they
disagree but they disagree without being
disagreeable now all these three pillars
of diplomacy are fundamentally
challenged by the 24/7 coverage every
single foreign policy event and social
media if you take time and space leaders
they they rush to be the first to tweet
and of course mistakes and blunders
happen and this leads to a great risk of
conflict escalation last year the
Pakistani Defense Minister reacted to a
news article he read and he’d read that
actually Israel was threatening Pakistan
with nuclear weapons
and so he felt the need to react on
Twitter of course and he said hey Israel
by the way remember Pakistan is a
nuclear power – okay just
about it just for one second this is one
nuclear power threatening almost
explicitly another nuclear power with
war on Twitter
now if the Pakistani Defense Minister
had only double-checked this article he
might have realized as the Israeli
Defense Ministry had to explain that
actually the whole story the statement
attributed to the former Israeli Defense
Minister was never set in fact the whole
story was entirely false fake story okay
patience is gone but so is
confidentiality and tact is gone too
because you can only be so diplomatic in
140 characters so are we just doomed to
watch these Twitter Wars run out of
control and the world becoming a more
dangerous place how can we use social
media constructively in international
relations well a first option that I
think many of my colleagues would
sometimes really want is basically to
take away those smartphones from our
leaders you know just you’ll leave them
outside outside the door when they
negotiate shut down the Twitter accounts
at the conflicts moments the problem
with that option is it it really takes
us away from all the positive aspects of
the digital revolution after all it is
that revolution that has enabled us to
follow events far away to reach out
between nations and also you know if we
took away those smartphones and those
digital devices they would just invent
other ways of reaching us other ways of
inventing a platform so that’s not
really an option okay
another possibility that I thought I
don’t long about was you know why don’t
we create a kind of a rule book am do’s
and don’ts for diplomats on social media
a kind of guideline this is what you
should do and and not do the problem
with that option
that either our leaders wouldn’t follow
these rules because they’re not binding
or if they did nobody would put any
attentions to these tweets because they
would be way too polished and frankly
way too boring so the problem with these
solutions these answers is that they
don’t really touch the core of the
problem the core of the problem is that
we simply only scratch the surface we
only scratch the surface when we talk
about these issues the problem is we
created those that are loud and visible
and we neglect those discreet
negotiators most fundamentally and we
help them doing that social media turns
our leaders attention away from the
tedious work of brokering deals to
managing their public face and worse by
doing that they’re basically taking
themselves away from what they’re
claiming to do namely solving
international conflicts so my idea is
that we should be able to look under the
surface to see the rest of the iceberg
so far what we see is basically the tips
of the iceberg but often not really the
right one you can’t tension to all these
Facebook updates everywhere so how are
we going to do that we first have to
admit that the Paris climate agreement
the Iran nuclear deal that required
years and and months and days and very
long hours to actually achieve and so
digital revolution has helped us follow
these events but we will only harvest
the fruits of the digital revolution if
we’re able to look behind the scenes to
look at the people the women and men who
worked night and day to carve out
compromises and we the public urgently
need to understand what their work means
not just for
your individual interest but for our
collective ability to create and
maintain peace unless we go under the
surface we simply will not be able to
elect the right people to handle well
politics and I don’t think I have to
remember to mention any names here so we
need citizens that participate actively
in foreign policy events engaged
critically with social media and I’m not
saying that we should get all the
details on every single confidential
material on the negotiation table but we
do need to understand what lies between
the updates the Instagram and the
Facebook and I ask you when you leave
this room please remember the three
pillars of diplomacy
please remember that time space and tact
has so far been crucial to arrive at any
kind of peace deal so if we have active
citizens participating actively we also
need these citizens to to demand and to
get the bigger picture the bigger
picture of what it actually takes to get
us into that negotiation room as you do
right this moment thank you
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: