Press "Enter" to skip to content

Are Millennials ruining the workplace? | Patricia Grabarek | TEDxPershingSq


[Music]
so full disclosure I’m a millennial and
I’m gonna be talking about whether or
not we’re ruining the workplace so maybe
a little bit biased but hang with me
I’ve got some research to back
everything up you’ve probably heard a
lot about Millennials right people talk
about them in the media all the time
that were lazy we’re entitled as soon as
we get into the workplace we’re
expecting that promotion and that raise
immediately right I have clients that
are coming up to me all the time and
asking how can I attract a millennial
how can I retain them should we change
our application process you know they
don’t have any attention span we should
make it shorter I’ve actually had a
client come up to me and say worry we
want to implement a snapchat like
application where millennial can upload
a 10-second video application that
freaked me out
it was awful I’m assuming most of you
would agree with that but the point is
that there’s just been a lot of focus on
Millennials and concern that they’re
gonna come in they’re gonna make some
big changes the older generations are
looking at us and thinking that we’re
just really different than they are so I
want to start with a quote this quote
here is talking about how companies need
to adjust to the new workforce right
this lazy workforce but what’s
interesting is that this quote was
actually published in 1990 so this is
not about Millennials these are the Gen
Xers they were also lazy so what we’re
looking at here is that there’s a trend
there’s something going on that might be
bigger than generational differences as
new generations are coming into the
workplace or reaching adulthood older
generations are looking at them and
judging them based on where they are in
their lives so one more quote to make
this point this one was actually
published 200 years before the first one
if you remove the words romances novels
and plays put in TV smartphones social
media can’t you imagine someone saying
that today about our youth that this
free access of information who’s going
to corrupt their minds really what I’m
trying to say here is that there is
something else going on that we need to
think about what we’re doing when we’re
judging new generation
as they’re coming in we need to take a
step back and imagine what we used to be
like and those well not me but the Navy
boomers and the Gen Xers need to be
thinking about where they used to be in
their lives and they were coming in and
the types of stereotypes they were
getting so first let’s define a
generation really briefly it’s a group
of individuals that are roughly the same
age and they’ve gone through key
historic events during major
developmental times in their lives so
for Millennials you can imagine 9/11
would be one of those events the baby
boomers would be the JFK assassination
so they’re kind of in their youth and
adolescence when these major events are
happening and they’re experiencing them
at the same time so the generations are
gonna be talking about today are the
baby boomers they’re the individuals
that were born right after World War two
imagine they’re the ones that are
bringing in like the hippie movement etc
now the first generation to have TVs in
their house the next generation are the
Gen Xers they were called the MTV
generation the latchkey kids then we’ve
got the Millennials so these are the
individuals that are really coming into
the workplace now been in the workplace
for a few years and we’re the group that
grew up with computers always being
around and more accessibility to the
Internet and social media during our
adolescence and then the next group
we’re gonna be judging soon they’re the
gens ears so these these individuals
have always had cell phones and
smartphones right so they’re a little
bit different in that sense their
experience might feel a bit different so
I’ve been talking a lot about
stereotypes and how maybe this is a
trend that keeps happening over and over
again and I wanted to talk a little bit
about some writing by an economist dr.
Alec R Levinson who discusses the
natural work lifecycle that everybody
goes through so when people start out in
the workplace like the Millennials today
they’re going through a steep learning
curve Tom actually made this point for
me earlier about how we’re focused on
work people that are just coming in they
really want to figure out what is their
career what are what does it look like
what do they want to do is this industry
right for them they’re just really
focus on work in the workplace in their
careers as you progress to kind of that
middle phase within the work-life cycle
where the Gen Xers are today they’re a
little bit more focused on work-life
balance so they have kids potentially or
aging parents there’s other things going
on in their life that they want a little
bit more stability and aren’t looking to
move continuously within their careers
of course generalization and then we
have the baby boomers or the older
generation within the workplace so these
individuals are really focusing on the
nature of their retirement what is that
going to look like when is it going to
happen so you can imagine that as you go
through these different work-life cycles
your experience is very different and
your perspective on the workplace is
really different so the problem that
we’re seeing as we talk about new
generations is that someone in that
middle or later stage in their work life
cycle is judging those new Millennials
coming in and not taking account where
those people are coming from the same
happens on the reverse right Millennials
might be coming in and judging baby
boomers for not knowing how to use
computers or whatever weird stereotype
they have so we really need to think
about where we are in our lifecycle and
where the person is that we’re looking
at and we’re talking to so I’m gonna be
going through some research today
talking about you know how does this
life cycle work and are there actual
differences between Millennials and
everybody else so the first question
kind of goes back to that life cycle
piece that do Millennials job hop more
often so are we seeing that they’re
actually leaving jobs more frequently
than other generations and that’s true
they are Millennials do tend to leave
jobs more frequently but they’re no
different than people that were in their
20s and 30s 10 20 30 40 years ago so
they aren’t different than other
generations they’re just in a different
life phase so another thing we want to
think about those why are these
Millennials leaving are they leaving for
different reasons than everybody else so
this is where we see that there’s
actually no difference we see that
Millennials Gen Xers Baby Boomers
they’re all leaving for more money and
to work in a more innovative work
environment so they everybody still
wants to work somewhere that’s
interesting
and we also hear a lot about Millennials
being less satisfied less engaged on the
job at least that’s what I hear and we
don’t find that at all so in our
research we see that Millennials are
leaving for reasons of dissatisfaction
just as frequently as everybody else is
another fun question that we looked at
in the research is do Millennials expect
more rewards so a lot of people talk
about Millennials being the
participation trophy generation right so
we’re the ones that want the pat on the
back every time we do or jobs not
necessarily a good job just doing it
well Millennials don’t actually expect
more rewards what’s interesting is we
see that Gen Xers expect more rewards
and Baby Boomers expected the least so
everybody does expect rewards to some
degree of course but those Gen Xers are
really the most different than everybody
else but I’m gonna make the same plug
here is this a life fit work-life faced
issue we don’t know one thing to think
about when you’re looking at
generational research is that most of
the time it’s and it’s happening at a
place in time right so it’s happening
today we’re looking at these generations
and we’re saying the Gen Xers are so
different than everyone else but we
don’t have this longitudinal study to
show you that over time they continue to
be these people that really want rewards
we have no idea so maybe in a few years
Millennials are gonna want more rewards
and those gens ears are gonna be at that
lower rate another thing we hear a lot
about with Millennials is culture so
Millennials really want to work at the
cool culture the googles of the world
you know they want that casual
environment and they really care a lot
about their culture of the organization
that they’re gonna work in what we found
in our research is that that’s actually
not true they don’t care any more than
anybody else does everyone cares
everyone wants to be in a work
environment where they’re happy they’re
fitting in then it fits what they want
right
so when we
Millennials Gen Xers baby boomers to
rate the importance of culture over
their job responsibilities and duties
everyone actually think it’s a little
bit more important what the culture is
which is really interesting but when you
think about it if I’m a software
engineer my tasks are gonna be the same
across most organizations right I’ll be
doing similar things so that that focus
on culture makes sense when you’re
making decisions around what
organization you want to be a part of so
millenials being lazy this is another
hot topic you saw that quote about Gen
Xers also being lazy what’s really
interesting is that we I found a study
that was talking about workaholics or
work martyrs is how they termed it and
all generations took a survey to
determine whether or not they would be
considered of work martyr Millennials
were work moderate martyrs at a much
higher rate than everyone else and
that’s kind of makes sense we talked
about that work-life phase right they’re
starting out they want to be seen as
someone that’s committed to the job they
are less likely to use their PTO they
feel guilty when they use PTO they don’t
want to burden anybody else with their
work so they don’t want to let go of it
when they leave for PTO so there’s a lot
of a lot of issues there with
Millennials that are just focusing on
getting their work done wanting to make
a good impression and becoming these
work martyrs the other generations if
you remember Gen Xers they’re kind of
one of that balance so obviously they’re
not going to be work martyrs at the same
rate
the baby boomers are focusing on
retirement probably not caring to be a
work martyr anymore so we also looked at
leadership expectations you know I’ve
had leaders that come up to me from
different organizations and ask how can
I lead a millennial how can I inspire a
millennial you can imagine my answer
there’s really no difference and how you
inspire one generation compared to the
next we actually have found that Gen
Xers expect more in terms of
face-to-face time with their leadership
then Millennials do but I’d argue that
this is that work-life phase again right
Gen Xers have been
organization a little bit longer or
within their career a little bit longer
they might be higher level so they have
different type of leaders probably
leaders with fewer direct reports so it
makes sense that someone at that level
might expect more in terms of
face-to-face interaction and that as a
millennial maybe we just don’t know what
to expect yet or because of the level of
the organization we just don’t have that
same expectation but when it comes to
what we want out of leaders everyone’s
the same
everyone rates we want ethical and fair
leaders in our organizations make sense
that’s the most important attribute
annette was rated across all generations
we also looked at professional
development so we hear that Millennials
want everything handed to them on a
silver platter right in that
hand-holding right off the bat we found
that actually all generations believe
that professional development is their
own responsibility so regardless of what
any are in you want to own your
development and you think that that’s
the only way you’re going to get your
development is if you take charge
another interesting thing that we found
is that Millennials actually prefer
face-to-face training just like
everybody else so Millennials have this
stereotype of being you know more
computer savvy maybe wanting to be on
the computer more or being more
comfortable in that situation when it
comes to actual training they really
prefer face-to-face just like every
other generation does and the last thing
we looked at was career goals so we hear
a lot about Millennials you know wanting
to make an impact on the world and these
kind of high lofty ideas what we found
in terms of career goals is that the
majority well the highest percentage of
all generations want to make a positive
impact on their organization but you can
see that’s only quarter of the
population that’s saying that so really
as a psychologist I’m going to tell you
individual differences matter a lot more
so there’s so much variability and what
people say in terms of their career
goals and it doesn’t matter what
generation you’re and that variability
is all based on the individual and who
you are we
coming from and those types of variables
personality so again we’re not really
seeing any differences by generation
when it comes to generational
differences I’m gonna tell everybody to
not think about it so much don’t judge
people based on where they’re coming
from generationally don’t don’t think
about their age think about who they are
as a person individual differences
really impact work attitudes and work
behaviors a lot more than these
generational differences do and I think
it’s really dangerous when organizations
are trying to create programs that are
geared towards just the Millennials
and I’ve hear that so often I mostly
discourage it of course but I’m sure
people still go and do these things and
what you’re doing is you’re separating
this group of people and you’re
alienating them from everybody else
instead of trying to make all of your
employees happy trying to make your
application process easy for everybody
you’re really focusing too much energy
spent too much time on just this one
group in this one population so just
remember we’re no different than you
guys
so just treat us the same that’s what we
want okay thank you
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: