Press "Enter" to skip to content

What I learned designing for Deaf kids | Marcus Adrian | TEDxGatewayArch


so the year was 1998 I was a young
architect and I was really excited to be
working on my first project it was a
school for deaf children Central
Institute for the Deaf right here in st.
Louis there they are
it was a big project so this was a big
team with a lot of really smart people
on the team architects engineers on my
side on the client side were some really
smart people deaf educators who had been
teaching deaf children for 20-30 years
there were even a couple of research
scientists who were experts in sound and
human hearing so imagine that whole
group of smart people around a really
big table and we got all the drawings
spread out all over the table and we’re
going through this thing and the task
that we were on right then was figuring
out how to make this building as quiet
as possible so there was a kind of a
break in the action at one point and and
I popped off with that question that you
might be thinking right now that turned
out to be a really provocative question
and that question was this is a school
for deaf children why would it need to
be quiet
immediately all attention was focused
straight on me everybody looked up from
what they were doing and they’re all
looking at me and all their gazes said
exactly the same thing wow he really
doesn’t know I think they were tickled
actually I think there were they were
really played by my curiosity because in
the next few minutes I learned one of
the first things about human ability
that really started me on a journey and
that was the deafness at least at this
school is not an all-or-nothing
condition at CID
they teach kids spoken English spoken
oral communication and but they can only
do that in a really quiet environment
over the next 20 years I’ve been
learning more broadly about human
ability and the lesson has been the same
and that’s that human ability is never
an all-or-nothing condition now I want
to dispense here with a word it’s a word
that I’ve begun to distrust as a
designer and that were
is disability and I’ve learned to
distrust it not just because it’s
impolite or or hurtful but because it’s
imprecise it doesn’t tell us anything
useful that we can use for design to
generate any ideas I’m gonna I’m gonna
luminate this with an example
consider a bird – a bird every single
one of us every person in this room has
the same tragic disability we can’t fly
so now imagine Olympic athlete an
Olympic gold medalist would you call
that Olympic gold medalist disabled
because they can’t fly now is it not
descriptive it belies everything that
they’re capable of it skips right over
focusing on that one disability and it
focuses it takes focus away from
everything that human being is capable
of doing and it’s the same thing in
design so in my work what I’ve been
trying to do is to try to invert that
instead of focusing on disability and
barrier-free design and and trying to to
focus on what people can’t do to turn it
around and focus on ability and focus on
what people can do and I found that to
be a more productive source of design
ideas very noble thank you it is noble
but it requires a deeper understanding
of human ability and it turns out of how
to create that for myself a more varied
understanding of human ability I
developed these four as as lenses that
you can look through to look at a design
or a building or even a school and when
you look through just one of these
lenses say say social ability human
social ability and all the differences
in human social ability it illuminates a
lot of problems in in a typical school
or a typical design but it also
illuminates a world of solutions and
that means that each of these four is
also a seed for a thousand different
design ideas that that that’s bring
forth I’m gonna I’m gonna talk about
some of those I’m gonna talk about the
bottom three of these because physical
ability has been really well covered and
I only have a short period of time so
I’m going to start with sensory now
human sensory ability is really
important for schools because you can’t
go directly into the brain the only way
to get knowledge into the brain is to go
through the census generally through the
eyes
the ears and the other senses play a
role and we’ll talk about that in a bit
but the only way you there’s no way to
just just insert knowledge into the
brain now I knew this intuitively as an
architect but when you become a father
you learn it more viscerally my wife and
I have three children actually in the
room tonight
so and they’re beautiful right and I
love these guys but I gotta confess that
on occasion I’ve been tempted to just
make a minor modification just minor
surgery go in and just put a USB port
right in the center of their forehead so
you could imagine you take a flash drive
and just go and just plug that right in
there and upload maybe common sense
2.0 right right into the brain right but
but I can’t do that I have to go through
their senses so what I resort to doing
and they hear this all the time is to
say my children all your father really
wants is your attention attention that’s
the gold standard in the classroom
that’s what we need for communication
right if I have your eyes if I have your
ears I have some chance of getting you
to learn something so not only did I
have to understand human ability in a
better context I actually had to define
attention this is my definition of human
attention in a design standpoint it is
focus on signal in the context of noise
and it’s simple it’s it’s beautifully
simple and in this context signal is
everything that reinforces learning it’s
everything that carries the lesson
it’s the teachers voice it’s the image
on the smart board it’s the the formulas
that are scrawled on the blackboard
noise is anything that interrupts so it
could be a bus rumbling outside a window
just outside the classroom it could be
footfalls of corridor traffic on the
other side of the classroom it could be
a kid who sits in front of you with a
really big head and you can’t see the
blackboard I may or may not have been
that kid so I’m gonna tread lightly here
signal and noise is not just a good
definition for attention it turns out
that it’s a really good strategy also a
design strategy and I’ve learned that
what you can do is you can take all of
the decisions thousands of decisions
that go into designing a school or
designing a classroom and you can apply
those decisions through that lens
through that that that understanding of
signal noise every wall every ceiling
every door every window the mechanical
system every one of those decisions
thousands of them can all be leveraged
towards signal and noise and
occasionally you have a chance to
elevate the signal but mostly it’s about
keeping background noise low especially
with regard to the mechanical system I’m
going to showcase a few of those ideas
here with a single classroom this is
from the Delaware School for the Deaf we
designed this one sometime after CID the
difference is that this population
they don’t teach spoken communication
here all instruction is in American Sign
Language so when you learn math you’re
learning math through American Sign
Language it’s all it’s purely visual and
it’s beautiful to watch by the way the
richness of that language but it meant
that our classrooms had to be really
keen and really keenly focused around
that sensory ability of the visual
experience so I’m gonna explain a few of
the things that we did here out of the
thousands look at that window the window
that that’s low enough that you can see
out of and you notice that it’s at the
back of the room if I had placed that at
the front of the room close to the
chalkboard then you’re sitting there
trying to attend to a lesson and you can
see your friends playing on the
playground out that window and if you
can do that if I’ve given you the
ability to do that your brain could very
easily decide that your friends are the
signal and the algebra is the noise and
I know this because my brain decided
that many many times when I was in
school also notice the shape of the room
it’s kind of a long skinny room most
classrooms are kind of squarish this one
is narrow enough that we can put slide
those desks forward and put them in a
nice arc and everyone has the same
visual access to the teaching wall and
everybody’s really close to it nobody
sits behind anybody else this one has
nothing to do with your ability to see
or hear but it was really important as
well in the early
hood classrooms this is Delaware and it
gets cold in the winter in the early
childhood classrooms where the kids
spend the majority of the day on the
floor we’ve provided radiant floors
radiant heated floors and that’s not so
much about signal it’s about noise
because when your legs are numb and
turning blue
learning is pretty much done another
thing that we did in those classrooms in
that building is we provided a dedicated
ventilate a dedicated fresh air
ventilation system not just because
young brains need a steady supply of
oxygen but because sometimes cafeterias
like to bake cookies and if my
mechanical system is recirculating air
in such a way that I’m pushing this
smell into classrooms all around the
building then we haven’t just lost the
students we’ve lost the teachers so
that’s sensory it and I’ve talked a
little bit about how signal and noise
impact the the sensory landscape of the
classroom now we’re going to go straight
into the brain I’m going to talk about
that cognitive ability now I’d love to
tell you that I’ve found ways to make a
school that makes children more
intelligent and I haven’t done that I’m
still working on it but you can’t do it
so when we’re talking about cognitive
ability what I’m talking about is
something called executive function
which is decision-making it’s it’s how
kids navigate not only the school day
but it’s how they begin to learn how to
navigate life and it has to do with
decisions about behavior but take you to
another school this is the Maryland
School for the Deaf and and for this
school we did three buildings to take
kids all the way from birth through
grade five now with regard to decisions
and you may know this if you have
children with regard to decision where
kids fail a lot is in transitions so you
imagine in this environment this kind of
sprawl of three buildings really well
organized but still it’s a lot to manage
all the transitions that go on in that
school day-to-day hour-to-hour and then
year to year to try to make all of those
decisions rational more comprehensible
to kids who are still learning how to
make those decisions
cognitive signal is when designers use
all of those decisions about the
interior of the building finishes colors
lighting to try to communicate the
children the kind of behavior that’s
expected of them
in each space to give them that
predictability might be easier to
imagine if you imagine in Reverse that
cognitive noise is when you take a child
and you put them in let’s say in an over
stimulating classroom get a new teacher
who just goes crazy and decorates the
room and everything about that room is
telling that child dial up dial up and
the teacher is saying no dial down
that’s cognitive noise that’s when the
building is working at cross-purposes
and sending mixed messages to children
about the decisions that they should be
making one of the things I really like
about this building is that we also made
it narrative this this sort of this
stream this ecosystem that we developed
along the corridors that connect all
these buildings to try to not not just
to suggest the behavior that’s required
but you know the stream what do we do in
the stream we move we sort of Bob along
the stream and there are banks where we
can sort of sit and watch the activity
and there are places little pools where
we can just sort of wait and play now
making decisions is hard enough but
these kids are making decisions in
context with other kids who are also
learning to make decisions and a lot of
them getting it wrong so now we’re on to
social ability and social ability is
really in flux right now and a lot of
school populations particularly higher
education as the autism spectrum
generation begins to move forward so
understanding this is really really
critical I’m going to talk first about
social noise I’m going to do it with a
story we were working on the master plan
of a high school master planning some
changes to an existing high school and
the principal was taking us on a walking
tour through the building and he took us
into a social Commons and it was a
pretty bad space it was bleak it really
wasn’t very stimulating it was an
antisocial social space and it was
connected to the lunchroom through this
this bottleneck this really bad little
space if it if I had to say it was
shaped like anything was shaped like a
reactor core and and the students would
come into the Commons and do whatever
they’re doing their small groups and
then they would transition at a certain
point into the cafeteria they’d walk
through that bottleneck and the
principal walked us into the bottleneck
and he said guess where the fights
happened that’s social noise that’s when
the building is working at
cross-purposes with what you’re trying
to do to help make meaningful
interactions and not unplanned ones not
surprise encounters not taking hot
groups of social
interaction among teenagers who are
probably talking about one another and
then move them and funnel them through a
space that’s too small for those
interactions finally I want to talk
about social signal now there’s a lot of
exciting things going on in education
and I’m going to start this off by
saying have you ever tried to lecture to
a pre kindergartner and they won’t do it
which is one of the reasons that that
early childhood education has always
been so rich about creating environments
where you’ve got teaching modalities
that are different than just lecture
where you’re not you’re not trying to
command a child’s attention for hours on
end so it can be really instructive when
you’re talking about social signal and
how do we design for social signal to
look at that kind of environment I’m
gonna call out a few of these areas and
I’m gonna talk about how higher
education for example could maybe learn
from this right there in the center
you’ve got storytime and that’s easy
that geometry is lecture the geometry of
that social interaction is lecture one
person talking to many and if you
understand that simple geometry you can
design a room like this you can design a
college an University lecture hall down
on the left there’s a little bit more
subtle geometry and subtle social
exchange going on there it’s the art
tables and at the art tables we’re
working in close proximity to one
another without separation and I’m
working on my work but I can see yours
it’s a kind of collaboration where we’re
inspiring one another and then at a
certain point you take your work and we
hang it up on the wall and we talk about
it all the social geometry is around
that are exactly the same as they are in
a design studio and if you understand
those geometries you’re in a position to
design for design work all the way up
through higher education up at the top
right is another one this is a little
more subtle this is one of my favorites
it looks like it’s just play right where
we’ve got blocks on the floor and we’re
playing with blocks but look at the
interaction what I do is I build my
little tower with the blocks and you’re
maybe sitting there watching me doing
something else and you come over and you
knock the blocks over and then you’re
gonna stack them up in a slightly
different way maybe you’re going to
build a taller Tower or a more
interesting tower and then we knock them
down and together now we’re gonna build
something that’s even cooler than that
and we do it again and again that social
interaction is called prototyping and
the geometry that we see in every
research and development lab in the
world not just through higher education
but in some of the biggest corporations
in the world it’s difficult to summarize
human attention something as big as
human attention but I’m gonna leave you
with this what I’ve learned throughout
my career so far about signal and noise
about human ability is it noise is
generally the accident of design noise
is the unintended consequence of
something that wasn’t considered about
human ability and I explained how with
those classrooms if you understand the
human geometry then you’re in a position
to design a pretty decent classroom but
if you understand the differences in
human ability that every kid comes to
that classroom with a slightly different
ability in each of those dimensions
some of them come and they’re so engaged
that they can’t wait to just you know
tell you everything they know and others
that are so terrified that they can’t
raise their hands if you take that
understanding and you will allow it to
nuance that geometry and mostly around
the edges of a classroom I found and it
impacts the lighting and it impacts the
furniture and a lot of other choices
then you’re finally in a position to
create learning spaces that allow
everyone to succeed I began with a
provocative question and I think as as
design is never an accident it’s always
a purposeful act it often begins with
that purposeful question and in my
context what I’m saying is that the
purposeful question can be very
revealing about human ability and when
we finally understand human ability
we’re in a position to design a better
world around it
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: