
for those of you who did not hear my
name correctly it indeed is Stalin and
it is does not in any way reflect my
ideology i’m from gujarat an odd
combination for that name i know it
reflects my father’s ideology at the
time I was born I was merely 28 days old
too young to protest a gruesome name
like that my father gave me two things a
bicycle that broke in six years and my
name we never lived together he didn’t
give me much else so I decided to keep
the name
do you love cinema
I love cinema – do you remember the
scenes where the bad guy is giving hell
to people and the people are poor
helpless and then the dashing hero comes
in and single-handedly fight off the
goon and his three three doesn’t the
poorest yeah exhilarating isn’t it when
you see good beat evil even when I was a
kid I did not identify with the hero
though I identified with the nameless
motionless dialogue less people standing
in a circle merely witnessing rarely
participating not that I was not a
romantic I did not dream of superpowers
and flying I did I still do dream of
flying only I admire and I’m inspired
more by the birds that fly together in
hundreds forming beautiful patterns
never crashing into each other we
wondered how they managed that some
flocks are millions and they don’t crash
you don’t see a bird drop from the sky
for me that is a great example of
cohabitation of join collectively
do you know that some birds that fly in
formation like the Cyrus crane that I’m
told appear here they take turns to lead
the flock
anyways let’s look at our flock humans
let’s begin to see how many offers are
flying how many of us are still stuck in
the world and how many of us have yet
not grown wings to fly let’s look at
some numbers I’m told you guys do deep
data no sorry big data analysis here’s
some big data as of last year one
percent of this country own fifty eight
point four percent of the country’s
wealth their wealth increased a whopping
ten percent in the last two years alone
the top 10% of the population together
own eighteen point seven percent of the
country’s wealth if you look at the
bottom fifty percent the bottom half
there together collectively owned and I
guess two percent of the country is well
you guys are engineers and switch
ologists and Exeter etc you can figure
out the math behind this I’m going to
give you some numbers some more numbers
as you hear them
try not to allow your prejudices to slot
me or brand me into a specific type or a
camera
hear me through the stock and then type
cost me if you master in the last twenty
years more than fifty four thousand
people were killed in various armed
conflicts mostly in Kashmir and in
states with very high naxal and Maoist
insurgency x’ of which twenty thousand
people twenty six thousand people with
terrorists eighty-five thousand 8500
people Security Force personnel and
twenty thousand civilians business
school students maker mathematics and
cost-benefit ratios of this number
about 45,000 cases of crimes were
committed against Scheduled Castes or
dull it’s in this country in 2015
in the same year more than 34,000 500
cases of rapes were registered all of us
know how many such cases go unregistered
of this 95% assailants were either a
neighbor and acquaintance a friend or a
relative of the victim some people tell
me that 83 person cases the rapist is a
relative
so this talk about be aware of strange
men we think that that strange weird
person may be sitting or living right
next to you four thousand four four lakh
80,000 people died of tuberculosis in
2015 in the period between 1947 to 2000
65 million or 6.5 crore Indians were
forcibly removed from their homes to
make way for what we call development
that is more than the total population
of my home state of Gujarat so how did
we come to this I believe that this has
happened because we are afraid to know
afraid to discover new realities afraid
to be in someone else’s shoes afraid to
give up our comfort of denial and denial
is a very communities what it does is it
puts like a dystopic veneer you know in
front of our eyes not allowing us to
problematize students of sociology
professors in sociology will tell you if
you don’t problematize you don’t find a
solution in fact if you’re interested in
finding solution to any problem whether
putting a rover on the moon or curing
cancer or treating people with
disabilities with
expect the first essential step is to
acknowledge accept the problem the only
thing you get by denying that this
problem exists is perpetuation of the
problem and I believe it’s time for us
to be vulnerable I know we were all
taught the exact opposite
don’t be vulnerable particularly men
don’t be vulnerable I know that
vulnerability creates pain but I’ll tell
you it also create love and creativity
it definitely creates learning now if
you were one of those concerned type you
care you want to empathize you would
want information right you would want
stories correct now if you are looking
towards mainstream Indian media for your
as a source of your unbiased relevant
information then I would say you’re
courageous and daring and I do extremely
dexterous in manoeuvring split screens
and even splitter persecuted up
personalities I mean you’re engineer
some of you right decode the news in
that now how did the mainstream media
come to this there are several reasons
by the mainstream media is the way it is
today some of us find ourselves holding
our head between our hands in several
different difficult positions like oh my
god am i watching there is a reason
behind that and one reason could be
understood by a study done by center for
studies of developing societies CSDs
right next door in Delhi 10 years back
they surveyed the social profile of key
decision-makers in national mainstream
media only top decision makers so chief
reporters editors chief editors exeter
exeter and found that hindu upper caste
who account for 8% of the total general
population account whole 71% of these
positions perhaps true for your campus
as well on the other hand people from
the other backward communities who
account for 40 percent of the population
hold 4% of those positions and there is
not one tribal or Dulwich key
decision-maker in India’s mass media the
sustained years back situation hasn’t
changed unfortunately even today what
these figures tell us is who controls
media not that who controls therefore
discourses who decides what is important
who decides whose whose agendas decide
what should be discussed today Newshour
it also tells us why there is a certain
outrage on some issues and certain
complete lack of outrage or certain
other issues right now you would say I
don’t look look at TV or newspapers I am
a new-age child or a person I have my
phone and I always on social media and I
use social media platforms to be
informed and to inform remind you that
you are one amongst the lucky privileged
few to be on the right side of the
digital divide in this country there are
the figures for social media
hate the word penetration by region look
at the figure in South Asia 15 percent
our nationwide breakup of this is not
any romantic for India it’s about 16 or
17 percent now this is not surprising
these figures are not surprising because
our region southeast South Asia and
Africa I have the lowest internet access
in the world so we will be there but we
are not quite yet
so all I’m saying is that if you think
that all your Facebook battles and
Twitter trolling and anti trolling and
whatever else that you do on social
media is important but isn’t it using
kind of an echo chamber at the moment
now
he’s everything dim and smuggiing like
the dystopic belly climate or is there a
way out for those who are ready to be
vulnerable for those who are ready to
learn but those were ready to take
informed position for those who refuse
to be mute spectators of democracy and
the good news is there is a way and that
way my friends is to listen to the
stories and opinions of those who live
the realities that I just showed you in
some slide if you my work besides making
documentary films is to and train and
teach is to lead a nonprofit called
video of volunteers headquartered out of
Goa and we train communities from the
margin to create their own media content
in the seven years back myself and my 33
other colleagues set up a network called
India on her today that network is 290
people with more than 250 people
reporting from 192 districts which are
spread across 20 states and together
they have created five thousand seven
hundred plus videos someone was asking
me why did you make a film after I made
Indian touch to ten years back this is
why I don’t make films I’m a Gujarati
the mathematic the health medic doesn’t
add up because in the last 15 years of
my filmmaking I made 18 films and seven
years of working with these communities
5700 films it does not be sub-basin a
envy if you were to look at these
stories and you go to the website
serious stories you’ll understand how
corporation
get away with large-scale environmental
degradation you will understand how
untouchability is still quite rampantly
practiced in this country and how the
law enforcement agencies almost turn a
blind eye to it you will know how
millions 1 million people every year get
displaced from their homes and wide
communities are protesting mining
another extractive industries you will
know how Patriarchate teaches us to be
sexist and misogynist and how some of
them are breaking these stereotypes and
power structures you will know how the
state brands people like me as mouths
and Naxals and then rob us of our
dignity and rights every time I step
into Chhattisgarh I step into what is I
step into charcoal I step industry Nagar
in all the spaces I have my offices
there’s always invariably an IB officer
who will call and said cap land up guys
bar not that I’m bothered with it but
just giving you the scenario if this was
happening in Srinagar when this cannot
happen is remember by the way if you
look at these videos you’ll understand
why Kashmir is think that India has
occupied their lands you’ll understand
why they believe that Indian Armed
Forces are the exact opposite of saviors
we need to have the courage and the
patience to listen now these reports
that we produce our eye openers but we
don’t stop merely by making them and
publishing them we take it back to the
communities mobilize them to act we show
it back to the local government
officials and chase them till we solve
those issues in an at an average we
produce and publish hundred 20 reports a
month we’re able to solve 25 of them
every month so if you go to the website
you will see 1,200 solutions stories or
how people have struggled and made
things happen like they’ve changed
long-standing issues of water sanitation
you know no doctors in pea
sieze teachers who don’t go to school
teachers who have not paid for 35 years
yes those people exist 35 years people
have teachers have not been paid
asha workers were on paper not on the
ground ambulances that
that ferry politician Israel patients
all kinds of issues that we’ve been
solving I believe that these reports
will shake you out of your complacent
positions it will make you at least
think twice before you shoot a messenger
like me before you say protesters are
anti Nationals people who hold views
different than ours are either leftist
or anti Nationals the name like Stalin
definitely electives he should be
branded an anti-national you won’t
imagine the number of college campuses
that have canceled my lectures and my
public lectures the last was iit madras
the officially invited me canceled me
out only because the kind of work I do
but of course the students of students
and they hold a parallel confluence and
hole invite me to the very same campus
so I’m coming from there three days back
I was writing Madras Thank You students
I believe that those who exposed
wrongdoings in society those who expose
abuse of power are heroes of democracy
don’t give them a bharat ratna but pat
their backs no don’t give them some
fancy award but make sure you’re
grateful to them they do so because they
believe in a better world a more
peaceful just inhumane well they believe
that democracy is far too precious to be
left alone in the hands of a political
party or a government or bureaucracy or
Armed Forces they believe that democracy
is everybody’s responsibility nobody no
one is above the rules of accountability
no one there are no holy cows in a
democracy everybody is under the scanner
so I invite you to rethink the three
wise monkeys made popular
by Mahatma Gandhi because our collective
future is dependent on how vigilant we
are a collective hope and collective
future unlike what we were told we must
speak and report on evil we must listen
to the experiences that people have gone
through even experience that people have
gone through so that we understand the
cause and effect we must speak out and
amplify others like me who speak out so
that be together from a critical mass
that is required to make this world a
better place and in that world people
particularly people on the margin will
not be a mute spectator but a key actor
in shaping democracy in shaping our
future you guys have been sitting here
and patiently taking in all kinds of
talks and presentations with varying
range of people and you have not moved
out a single one you only glad you know
what that means you are part of that
collective future you have that gene to
empathize keep that up that’s our future
don’t be a mute spectator of democracy
thank you so much
name correctly it indeed is Stalin and
it is does not in any way reflect my
ideology i’m from gujarat an odd
combination for that name i know it
reflects my father’s ideology at the
time I was born I was merely 28 days old
too young to protest a gruesome name
like that my father gave me two things a
bicycle that broke in six years and my
name we never lived together he didn’t
give me much else so I decided to keep
the name
do you love cinema
I love cinema – do you remember the
scenes where the bad guy is giving hell
to people and the people are poor
helpless and then the dashing hero comes
in and single-handedly fight off the
goon and his three three doesn’t the
poorest yeah exhilarating isn’t it when
you see good beat evil even when I was a
kid I did not identify with the hero
though I identified with the nameless
motionless dialogue less people standing
in a circle merely witnessing rarely
participating not that I was not a
romantic I did not dream of superpowers
and flying I did I still do dream of
flying only I admire and I’m inspired
more by the birds that fly together in
hundreds forming beautiful patterns
never crashing into each other we
wondered how they managed that some
flocks are millions and they don’t crash
you don’t see a bird drop from the sky
for me that is a great example of
cohabitation of join collectively
do you know that some birds that fly in
formation like the Cyrus crane that I’m
told appear here they take turns to lead
the flock
anyways let’s look at our flock humans
let’s begin to see how many offers are
flying how many of us are still stuck in
the world and how many of us have yet
not grown wings to fly let’s look at
some numbers I’m told you guys do deep
data no sorry big data analysis here’s
some big data as of last year one
percent of this country own fifty eight
point four percent of the country’s
wealth their wealth increased a whopping
ten percent in the last two years alone
the top 10% of the population together
own eighteen point seven percent of the
country’s wealth if you look at the
bottom fifty percent the bottom half
there together collectively owned and I
guess two percent of the country is well
you guys are engineers and switch
ologists and Exeter etc you can figure
out the math behind this I’m going to
give you some numbers some more numbers
as you hear them
try not to allow your prejudices to slot
me or brand me into a specific type or a
camera
hear me through the stock and then type
cost me if you master in the last twenty
years more than fifty four thousand
people were killed in various armed
conflicts mostly in Kashmir and in
states with very high naxal and Maoist
insurgency x’ of which twenty thousand
people twenty six thousand people with
terrorists eighty-five thousand 8500
people Security Force personnel and
twenty thousand civilians business
school students maker mathematics and
cost-benefit ratios of this number
about 45,000 cases of crimes were
committed against Scheduled Castes or
dull it’s in this country in 2015
in the same year more than 34,000 500
cases of rapes were registered all of us
know how many such cases go unregistered
of this 95% assailants were either a
neighbor and acquaintance a friend or a
relative of the victim some people tell
me that 83 person cases the rapist is a
relative
so this talk about be aware of strange
men we think that that strange weird
person may be sitting or living right
next to you four thousand four four lakh
80,000 people died of tuberculosis in
2015 in the period between 1947 to 2000
65 million or 6.5 crore Indians were
forcibly removed from their homes to
make way for what we call development
that is more than the total population
of my home state of Gujarat so how did
we come to this I believe that this has
happened because we are afraid to know
afraid to discover new realities afraid
to be in someone else’s shoes afraid to
give up our comfort of denial and denial
is a very communities what it does is it
puts like a dystopic veneer you know in
front of our eyes not allowing us to
problematize students of sociology
professors in sociology will tell you if
you don’t problematize you don’t find a
solution in fact if you’re interested in
finding solution to any problem whether
putting a rover on the moon or curing
cancer or treating people with
disabilities with
expect the first essential step is to
acknowledge accept the problem the only
thing you get by denying that this
problem exists is perpetuation of the
problem and I believe it’s time for us
to be vulnerable I know we were all
taught the exact opposite
don’t be vulnerable particularly men
don’t be vulnerable I know that
vulnerability creates pain but I’ll tell
you it also create love and creativity
it definitely creates learning now if
you were one of those concerned type you
care you want to empathize you would
want information right you would want
stories correct now if you are looking
towards mainstream Indian media for your
as a source of your unbiased relevant
information then I would say you’re
courageous and daring and I do extremely
dexterous in manoeuvring split screens
and even splitter persecuted up
personalities I mean you’re engineer
some of you right decode the news in
that now how did the mainstream media
come to this there are several reasons
by the mainstream media is the way it is
today some of us find ourselves holding
our head between our hands in several
different difficult positions like oh my
god am i watching there is a reason
behind that and one reason could be
understood by a study done by center for
studies of developing societies CSDs
right next door in Delhi 10 years back
they surveyed the social profile of key
decision-makers in national mainstream
media only top decision makers so chief
reporters editors chief editors exeter
exeter and found that hindu upper caste
who account for 8% of the total general
population account whole 71% of these
positions perhaps true for your campus
as well on the other hand people from
the other backward communities who
account for 40 percent of the population
hold 4% of those positions and there is
not one tribal or Dulwich key
decision-maker in India’s mass media the
sustained years back situation hasn’t
changed unfortunately even today what
these figures tell us is who controls
media not that who controls therefore
discourses who decides what is important
who decides whose whose agendas decide
what should be discussed today Newshour
it also tells us why there is a certain
outrage on some issues and certain
complete lack of outrage or certain
other issues right now you would say I
don’t look look at TV or newspapers I am
a new-age child or a person I have my
phone and I always on social media and I
use social media platforms to be
informed and to inform remind you that
you are one amongst the lucky privileged
few to be on the right side of the
digital divide in this country there are
the figures for social media
hate the word penetration by region look
at the figure in South Asia 15 percent
our nationwide breakup of this is not
any romantic for India it’s about 16 or
17 percent now this is not surprising
these figures are not surprising because
our region southeast South Asia and
Africa I have the lowest internet access
in the world so we will be there but we
are not quite yet
so all I’m saying is that if you think
that all your Facebook battles and
Twitter trolling and anti trolling and
whatever else that you do on social
media is important but isn’t it using
kind of an echo chamber at the moment
now
he’s everything dim and smuggiing like
the dystopic belly climate or is there a
way out for those who are ready to be
vulnerable for those who are ready to
learn but those were ready to take
informed position for those who refuse
to be mute spectators of democracy and
the good news is there is a way and that
way my friends is to listen to the
stories and opinions of those who live
the realities that I just showed you in
some slide if you my work besides making
documentary films is to and train and
teach is to lead a nonprofit called
video of volunteers headquartered out of
Goa and we train communities from the
margin to create their own media content
in the seven years back myself and my 33
other colleagues set up a network called
India on her today that network is 290
people with more than 250 people
reporting from 192 districts which are
spread across 20 states and together
they have created five thousand seven
hundred plus videos someone was asking
me why did you make a film after I made
Indian touch to ten years back this is
why I don’t make films I’m a Gujarati
the mathematic the health medic doesn’t
add up because in the last 15 years of
my filmmaking I made 18 films and seven
years of working with these communities
5700 films it does not be sub-basin a
envy if you were to look at these
stories and you go to the website
serious stories you’ll understand how
corporation
get away with large-scale environmental
degradation you will understand how
untouchability is still quite rampantly
practiced in this country and how the
law enforcement agencies almost turn a
blind eye to it you will know how
millions 1 million people every year get
displaced from their homes and wide
communities are protesting mining
another extractive industries you will
know how Patriarchate teaches us to be
sexist and misogynist and how some of
them are breaking these stereotypes and
power structures you will know how the
state brands people like me as mouths
and Naxals and then rob us of our
dignity and rights every time I step
into Chhattisgarh I step into what is I
step into charcoal I step industry Nagar
in all the spaces I have my offices
there’s always invariably an IB officer
who will call and said cap land up guys
bar not that I’m bothered with it but
just giving you the scenario if this was
happening in Srinagar when this cannot
happen is remember by the way if you
look at these videos you’ll understand
why Kashmir is think that India has
occupied their lands you’ll understand
why they believe that Indian Armed
Forces are the exact opposite of saviors
we need to have the courage and the
patience to listen now these reports
that we produce our eye openers but we
don’t stop merely by making them and
publishing them we take it back to the
communities mobilize them to act we show
it back to the local government
officials and chase them till we solve
those issues in an at an average we
produce and publish hundred 20 reports a
month we’re able to solve 25 of them
every month so if you go to the website
you will see 1,200 solutions stories or
how people have struggled and made
things happen like they’ve changed
long-standing issues of water sanitation
you know no doctors in pea
sieze teachers who don’t go to school
teachers who have not paid for 35 years
yes those people exist 35 years people
have teachers have not been paid
asha workers were on paper not on the
ground ambulances that
that ferry politician Israel patients
all kinds of issues that we’ve been
solving I believe that these reports
will shake you out of your complacent
positions it will make you at least
think twice before you shoot a messenger
like me before you say protesters are
anti Nationals people who hold views
different than ours are either leftist
or anti Nationals the name like Stalin
definitely electives he should be
branded an anti-national you won’t
imagine the number of college campuses
that have canceled my lectures and my
public lectures the last was iit madras
the officially invited me canceled me
out only because the kind of work I do
but of course the students of students
and they hold a parallel confluence and
hole invite me to the very same campus
so I’m coming from there three days back
I was writing Madras Thank You students
I believe that those who exposed
wrongdoings in society those who expose
abuse of power are heroes of democracy
don’t give them a bharat ratna but pat
their backs no don’t give them some
fancy award but make sure you’re
grateful to them they do so because they
believe in a better world a more
peaceful just inhumane well they believe
that democracy is far too precious to be
left alone in the hands of a political
party or a government or bureaucracy or
Armed Forces they believe that democracy
is everybody’s responsibility nobody no
one is above the rules of accountability
no one there are no holy cows in a
democracy everybody is under the scanner
so I invite you to rethink the three
wise monkeys made popular
by Mahatma Gandhi because our collective
future is dependent on how vigilant we
are a collective hope and collective
future unlike what we were told we must
speak and report on evil we must listen
to the experiences that people have gone
through even experience that people have
gone through so that we understand the
cause and effect we must speak out and
amplify others like me who speak out so
that be together from a critical mass
that is required to make this world a
better place and in that world people
particularly people on the margin will
not be a mute spectator but a key actor
in shaping democracy in shaping our
future you guys have been sitting here
and patiently taking in all kinds of
talks and presentations with varying
range of people and you have not moved
out a single one you only glad you know
what that means you are part of that
collective future you have that gene to
empathize keep that up that’s our future
don’t be a mute spectator of democracy
thank you so much
Please follow and like us: