Press "Enter" to skip to content

The Mess of Fake News | Mohammed Shammas Oliyath | TEDxIBABangalore


good morning everyone it was during 2015
when I happened to watch a video of a
trying man his daughter that I expired
because of a fatal disease and was
trying to cope with the loss in the
memory of his demise daughter to add
more fuel to the fire he was getting
calls from people who were totally
strangers who are inquiring about the
well-being of his daughter and trying to
help him financially for the to cure the
disease of his daughter the calls way
because of a post that was circulating
on social media at the time when his
daughter was alive it was a very valid
post he indeed wanted financial help
financial help took to help his daughter
get over the disease but he still
continued to get calls on his personal
number even after the demise of his
daughter unfortunately he was not able
to change his number because of his
business reasons I really thought at
that point there is something critically
missing at how we managed the social
media how data is managed with the
social media today later during 2015
I saw another post a picture of a kid
who was hospitalized in Kim’s Hospital
Bangalore and the desperate description
said there is a missing kid and they
don’t know who the family of the kid is
so I shared it further on social media
hoping that it will help find the kid
and later I realized that it was a kid
at Kim’s Hospital Bombay and it was very
well with his family it was not a true
news I don’t have a TV at home it’s been
like four years since me and my wife
decided that we’ll stop watching TV at
home primarily because my kids used to
get glued to the TV so we wanted that
not to happen and it’s been successfully
running for four years unfortunately but
that made it important for me that I
have to be active on social media
primarily to make sure that I get to
hear about the news that happens around
the world we all know that we hear at
first on social media then we see it on
TV or newspapers right but I also
realized that
a big amount of news that circulates on
social media faith it’s not true it’s
modified either a photoshopped image
being circulating around and a huge
amount of people who are active on
social media are also people who are of
my parents generation of my grandparents
generation who are not tech savvy they
don’t understand that a photo has been
modified when they see it and they kind
of share it across when they see it that
was kind of another trigger for me too
to think that there is something
critically missing which we should do
something about and me being from the
from the software industry I thought
when it takes a V person like me he’s
threatening aborted and not doing
anything what needs to be done it’s not
it’s not right it’s people like us we
should do something I also belong to a
I’m also an active member of a group
called bouillabaisse Reiki that’s a
group of old hindi song lovers right
across the world and we we have traveled
all across India to do shows for old-age
homes hospitals prisons Armed Forces a
lot of lot of NGOs and you know it’s a
totally non commercial non-profit
venture where the real motive of all the
people who are involved in check first
and in Willoughby slayeth it’s spreading
happiness with music I wanted check for
spam to have some model to work on a
model like bouillabaisse together we
called as BBG the primary reason being
that I thought that if the moment I
invite investors into the model what I
have in check was spam they could be a
probability that check for spam is gonna
turn into something like what the media
is today people tend to get biased based
on how your investors are going to
dictate upon you so I wanted it to be a
non-commercial non profit model that was
when I spoke to mr. Balkrishna Barilla
who’s the founder of bouillabaisse vague
youth we have around half a million
followers worldwide and believe is
forgiven so he’s a he’s the guy who has
inspired me all through my life kind of
and
for his selfless way how he has given
back to the society so I wanted such a
model to be there for check for spam as
well so in 2016 I present a check was
spam to him and was very very well
agreed to be a co-founder of sacra spam
and ever since we never stopped looking
back today we we are one of them one of
the main fat checking sites available in
India and we get around 200 messages on
whatsapp requests on whatsapp beep
allows us to verify the post that they
get or on the on the watch our channel
now let me talk about the different
kinds of fake news that we have today
first one is completely untrue for
example you might have seen this post
about fake new find rupees note it says
that if the windowed security thread is
next to Mahatma Gandhi it’s a fake note
and ideally it should be next to the
governor sign but are they RBI
completely denied this news saying that
there is no guideline on how the
windowed security thread is printed his
they said they agree that both the both
the versions are true it’s it’s just a
printing mistake so this is a completely
he said this these are the kind of
completely untrue news that circulates
the first kind second one is a real
incident with wrong description this
post is about turnout then wad
eh-eh-eh-eh young cricketer in
maharashtra and it said for now then
wadi was not selected for under-19 wear
zone because he’s the son of an auto
driver but Arjun Tendulkar who’s the son
of such internal God selected because
his son of such an Tendulkar completely
untrue it’s true that preneur was not
selected and Arjun got selected but the
reason was turnout was ineligible based
on a selection criteria for under 918 of
a zone the next kind is true or old
incidents being used together to create
a new new story you might have heard
this news about Baba Ram they was killed
at a road a road by a road accident who
know who named Bombay Highway the post
comes with a picture which is collage
together the first picture what you see
on top is a is a real accident that
happened in 2017
and it happened in Bihar and no way
related to Baba Ramdev the second one is
an old 2011 incident when Bob Arum they
was hospitalized during at 7:00 after a
seventh day of fast protests that was in
two so people collide different
incidents and try and build a new story
out of out of all these the next one is
the next kind of been the not harmful
ones UNESCO declares that Italy is the
healthiest food among all the breakfast
in the world and it comes with a
certificate as well the people make the
certificates to bring you know the to
make to make us think that it is true
right another one is probably the best
humor you would have ever heard and in
your life this says at Salim Cohen
father of Salman Khan as his fourth
child he is a twin brother of our busca
and Salim Khan wanted all his sons to
enter the film industry but the fourth
son Rajesh was interested in tennis he
was kicked out of house he moved to
Switzerland and cheese’s name – Roger
right
but that’s more on the human side but
the fact is that we got this for
verification and there are people who
are believing it right
the next kind is a completely dangerous
post so I’m going to give two examples
of the kind of dangerous pose that
circulates on social media today this is
a post about Ebola virus spreading in
Mumbai and the post also say is that to
avoid getting Ebola virus you need to
drink a lot of salt water and take bath
in salt water now in Nigeria a similar
hoax killed two people people with high
blood pressure consumed lots of salt
water and they died right it’s extremely
dangerous another one you might have
seen it’s it’s a lady being burned alive
on street and the video circulated with
a description saying that it is a Hindu
girl who was married to a Muslim boy in
Maharashtra and the Muslim people killed
him now it’s a real incident it happened
in Rio Bravo in what him or what got
Amala and it was the lady was alleged to
be involved in the killing of a taxi
driver and that was how the whole
outrage took place now
people pick up real incidents and give
this a different description to it and
circulate on social media right then we
have politically aligned posts and a
variety of promotional posts now the
promotional posts are kind of depending
upon incidents ethics prevent the GST
Kame Kame in India there was a bunch of
GST polls which say that Amazon GST sale
offer Flipkart GST offer so they
actually make you go to their website
download an app on your phone and they
say you have to hold the app on your
phone for 24 hours
and you have to share this link to eight
or ten groups of friends hold the app
for 24 hours and you’re going to get the
offer after that it’s a clear case of
malware it’s going to extract all the
personal information on your phone and
transfer it wherever it is required then
the magic of Photoshop people really put
effort to create photos like this the
first one is a mix of both the photos
that has been created right
and plenty of other ones all Photoshop
plenty of them
now the problem as I said is tech savvy
people like us can understand it but
there are there’s a huge amount of
people out there who don’t realize it
now why is fake news every today it’s
not anymore
an occasional or exceptional case we get
it day in day out every other post is
fake today almost so the default has to
be it could be fake to keep in mind
people are too busy to cross verify it
actually takes an effort to actually go
go somewhere and figure out whether it
is true or not right so people are too
busy you know everybody has their own
schedule problems and they don’t do it
it’s also spreading through private
channels primarily on whatsapp we all
know that is it there is an early 2017
statistics which says there around 200
million monthly active WhatsApp users in
India and that’s a huge number and a
majority of them are not tech savvy so
people tend to believe it and the fact
that that’s a fact being that we get
around 200 messages per day for
verification on ourself number and
unfortunately I’m not able to handle
that that traffic at this point of time
actually there is an increasing
political communal regional bias in the
post that circulates on the media to
example for the example that I gave
where a real incident gets billed with a
different description and gets
circulated on social media so what do we
all do there are existing services
internationally like snob comm hoax –
Slayer dotnet which would be used for
hoaxes that sounds a little
international and in India we have
services like SM hoax lair boom live dot
in you might have heard of all can use
dot in and of course check for spam it’s
today inevitable that each one of us
need to play a little role to fight the
fake mess that we have on social media
today we all need to join our hands
together to make sure that social media
is a beautiful place where we can
network with our friends our families
and get out of
fakeness that the social media is into
today let the truths prevail let the
truth prevail and let’s all put our
hands together for truth to prevail in
me but yet they thank you
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: