Press "Enter" to skip to content

Counting chromosomes-A perspective on Genetic Testing. | Kristen Ewald | TEDxUMDearborn


[Music]
one of the best introductions I’ve ever
seen was by a professor of mine on the
first day of class she ran into the room
holding a large hammer above her head
and she said is this a tool or a weapon
as you can imagine all the students were
very confused and murmurs of confusion
and wishes to drop the course I go
through the classroom until one student
said it depends on how you use it
this idea that a hammer can be used as a
tool to build great things or as a
weapon that can hurt has stuck with me
in the genetic world there’s a lot of
misconceptions and strong opinions that
surround pregnancy what we often fail to
realize is how our opinions impact other
people’s decisions now I’m not a mother
genetic counselor or a medical
professional I have however seen
firsthand how families can feel
pressured to pursue genetic testing and
how our ideas of genetic disorders can
impact other people this is Lucy she
just turned one year old and she’s
learning how to walk
she loves graham crackers her dog her
siblings and her family
Lucy however is likely a little
different from you and I as she was born
with mosaic trisomy 18 this means that
instead of having two identical 18th
chromosomes
she has additional pieces of 1/3 18th
chromosome now most babies born with
mosaic trisomy 18 never fully develop
and pass away before they’re born or
struggle with many health issues after
birth Lucy was born with a congenital
heart defect which means that she had
holes in her heart and she has overcome
failure to thrive had open-heart surgery
at only a few months old and is
currently going through chemotherapy to
ensure that the tumors that were removed
from her liver last month do not return
now most of us will have two copies of
23 chromosomes one from each of our
parents giving us 46
in total traditionally before medical
advances were made the only way to test
for genetic disorders were through
invasive methods such as amniocentesis
amniocentesis is where they will use a
needle to go into the amniotic sac to
extract fluid and while this test is
very accurate it’s also invasive and can
cause miscarriage recently however with
new developments in science and
technology non-invasive prenatal
screening was developed with just a
finger prick or a blood draw from the
mother they can now look for the most
commonly inherited genetic chromosomal
abnormalities so if someone has Down
syndrome they’ll have three 21st
chromosomes when a typical person would
only have two these tests work with the
mother’s blood if there’s a higher ratio
of 21st chromosomes than her other
chromosomes and the mother herself does
not have Down syndrome the test result
will come back that the the child does
have down syndrome the most unique thing
about these non-invasive prenatal
screens is they can actually be
completed at 10 weeks onward
so the typical ultrasound the
gender-reveal ultrasound that most of us
know it by is it can be completed at 20
weeks and that visibly scans for
abnormalities but these non-invasive
screens actually can be done at 10 weeks
onward so Lucy’s parents at this 20 week
ultrasound found out that something was
very different about their baby the
ultrasound technician thought that Lucy
only had half of a heart so they went to
a neonatal specialist and had a series
of genetic test screens everything you
can think of done and all the results
came back normal so why didn’t these
genetic tests and screens and
ultrasounds and everything that Lucy’s
family went through not detect her
genetic condition what’s important to
understand is that non-invasive prenatal
screening is never a hundred percent
that’s why I can be beneficial to parent
with other methods of screenings or
testing with non-invasive prenatal
screening there’s always a chance of a
false positive or you’ll get your
results back and it will tell you that
your
has a genetic disorder when they
actually do not there’s also a chance of
a false negative where you’ll get your
results back and it’ll tell you your
child does not have a disorder when they
actually do this is more common in cases
where the entire chromosome isn’t
inherited and this is exactly what
happened in Lucy’s case because she only
has pieces of the extra 18th chromosome
the test wasn’t sensitive to detect her
genetic abnormalities these tests can be
very useful but there are downsides –
researchers are looking into the fact
that as knowledge increases about
non-invasive prenatal screening will
people feel pressured to pursue this if
people feel pressured to take
non-invasive prenatal screenings it
could change our ideas of genetic
disorders how we look at pregnant women
and how we look at people with genetic
abnormalities what’s important to
understand is that screening is optional
it’s not a must-have so if you and your
spouse just you know found out you’re
pregnant and you go to a genetic
counselor and they say would you like to
test would you test your child for some
families the ability to know that their
child will be hurting or sick before
they’re born can be life-saving for the
child and monumental for the parents
they have time to preemptively schedule
specialist or caregivers to be at the
birth they have time to connect and join
health groups that have people who’ve
been through what they’re experiencing
some families these non-invasive
prenatal screens create more issues and
cause more turmoil and stress than if
they just found out about the child’s
genetic disorder at their birth
sometimes these non-invasive screens
can’t even detect the child’s denied
disorder like in Lucy’s case we as a
society can work together to be better
at understanding these genetic tests and
not pressuring each other into taking
them maybe instead of looking at these
denied tests as tell
it’s what to do or who we are we should
look at them as that hammer if we look
at these tests and we let them tell us
how we feel about genetic disorders or
how we feel about our children they
become a weapon but if we use these
screenings to enable us to make better
decisions to inform us about the child
on the way they can be an invaluable
tool we need to be more conscious and
supportive of families like Lucy’s
non-invasive prenatal screening is only
one thing on the road to pregnancy and
as a society we can do better to not
only support families and the decisions
they make but allow them to choose and
support their decisions thank you
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: