Press "Enter" to skip to content

It’s Time to Retire the Language Police | Lindsey Clouse | TEDxRapidCity


in the 1840s legislators and
policymakers across the u.s. began to
realize that they had a problem in the
early days of the Republic when the US
had first declared independence from
Britain only white male landowners had
the right to vote but voting rights had
been expanding steadily since then and
by 1840 most states had dropped the
requirement to own property and over 90%
of adult white men had the right to vote
the problem was that although these men
had the right to vote many of them did
not have the capacity to vote they had
very little formal education they were
not well-informed about civics or the
democratic process and many of them were
illiterate so to combat this problem
States gradually began enacting public
school laws they began putting tax
dollars into expanding public schools
and eventually they enacted compulsory
education laws which required male
children to attend school until a
certain age as the public schools
expanded new curricula had to be created
and new textbooks had to be written in
particular language arts curricula which
had started as very basic literacy and
spelling lessons and now began to
incorporate grammar composition and
elocution and of course the people
creating these new curricula and writing
these new textbooks were the wealthy
white male policy makers themselves then
as now people across the u.s. spoke
different dialects of English a dialect
is just a variety of a language any
variety of a language the dialect that
you speak is influenced by your age your
race your gender your socioeconomic
status your level of education people in
Georgia speak different dialects than
people in Ohio
teenagers speak different dialects than
senior citizens blue-collar workers
often speak a different dialect than
people in the upper income brackets this
has been true of English as long as it
has existed over a thousand years for
most of that time English speakers had
no concept of a standard dialect there
were always different dialects and
that’s all they were different but as
the curricula were created and new
textbooks written to fill these
expanding public schools the wealthy
white male policymakers writing the
textbooks chose their own dialect as the
standard as the model of correctness
that kids would now learn when they
learned grammar and speech and writing
and public schools adopted this very
quickly and they began not just to teach
this dialect but to teach that speaking
or writing anything other than this
dialect was wrong this was a completely
new idea but it spread very quickly
through the country and people began to
learn and spread the idea not just that
speaking anything other than standard
English was wrong but that the people
who spoke anything other than standard
English were uneducated ignorant even
lazy and it still pervades our culture
today if you’re on social media you’ve
probably seen a meme like this maybe
you’ve even shared something like this
yourself it’s intended to promote this
idea that not just that saying I seen is
wrong
non-standard but that people who say
that are ignorant or foolish that’s just
not accurate linguistically speaking
there is no single correct dialect of
English
let’s take ice scene as an example why
is it wrong to say I scene to sea is an
irregular verb it doesn’t follow any
pattern it’s not particularly logical to
say I saw or I seen not only that but
this I
eeeh that I seen is wrong is relatively
new
there was a novel published in York in
1795 called the life of John Metcalf and
in it we see a really good example of a
usage of I scene do you not see two
lights one to the right the other to the
left no replied the gentleman I seen but
one light that there on the right notice
that I seen is attributed to a gentleman
in this instance it wasn’t associated
with ignorance or lower-class speech at
all at that time it’s only in the last
couple of centuries that we have been
taught that I scene is wrong let’s look
at another example pronouncing asked as
X and you might think well it’s spelled
asked surely that’s the correct
pronunciation but keep in mind in
English there’s very little relationship
between how we spell things and how we
pronounce them there’s a common
linguistic process called metathesis
where the sounds inside a word get mixed
around this happens in English and many
other languages all the time if you say
Wednesday rather than wetness day or
February
rather than February then you
participate in metathesis too and ask
and acts are just another example of
this process both pronunciations have
been around in English for over 800
years and in fact the most well-known
middle English writer Geoffrey Chaucer
used acts in his Canterbury Tales in the
1300s you lovers acts I now this
question it is only again in the last
couple of centuries that we have come to
think of Acts as bad English because we
are taught that not because it’s
inherently wrong let’s look at one more
example I was informed day or two before
the receipt of your letter that you was
gone to Plymouth we’re taught again that
form you was is bad grammar that it’s
wrong this was written in on July 3rd
1776 by John Adams in the letter to his
wife
Abigail this was a man who was educated
at Harvard who was a practicing lawyer
and who went on to become one of the
founding fathers of our nation and its
second president and he used you was and
this was not an error it appears
repeatedly in his letters between him
and his wife because nobody at that time
thought of you was as wrong it’s only in
the last couple of centuries that we
have begun to think of this as wrong
people have a very hard time with this
idea that there’s nothing inherently
correct about standard English that it
is not inherently superior to other ways
of speaking English and it’s easy to
understand why the public schools have
been very effective in teaching this
notion that standard English is the only
correct way to speak and right they
sometimes literally beat it into their
students as one elderly gentleman wrote
the reason why the older generation
feels so strongly about English grammar
is that we were severely punished if we
didn’t obey the rules one split
infinitive one whack two split
infinitives to wax and so on and the
idea still pervades our culture today
but there’s a problem with this idea
when we promote the stereotype that some
dialects are inferior or ignorant or
lazy then we promote stereotypes that
the people who speak them are ignorant
and lazy think about Appalachian English
that’s associated with rednecks think
about any of the English is spoken by
poor white rural southerners think about
black English think about any dialect
that might commonly be called bad
grammar bad English broken English these
dialects aren’t broken all dialects have
their own rules for pronunciation for
grammar and
for vocabulary they’re just as complex
and systematic as the rules of standard
English people who speak a stigmatized
dialect like Black English or
Appalachian English aren’t trying to
speak Standard English and failing
anymore than people who speak French are
trying to speak Standard English and
failing they’re following the rules of
their own dialect and those rules are
just as complex and just as systematic
as the rules of standard English they’re
just different rules and the only reason
we think of them as wrong is because
we’ve been taught to think of them that
way when we judge a person based on how
they speak then we shut down
conversation and we essentially say that
their English isn’t good enough to enter
into our conversation and in certain
cases whole demographics of people can
be silenced not only that but it can
have serious impacts on people’s
self-esteem if you tell a child that her
speech and the speech of her family and
her friends and her neighborhood is
wrong is ignorant is lazy it can
seriously impact how she sees herself in
her community and it can discourage her
from speaking up in class from
participating in public debate from
joining public conversation now you
might be thinking isn’t there value and
having a standard variety of the
language a variety that’s considered
correct in professional life in academic
life I’m not saying that we should stop
teaching standard English altogether
it’s certainly useful for teaching
English as a foreign language and
American kids also need to know that
standard English will be expected in
college and in the professional world we
need to be realistic about that but we
can teach it without teaching that other
dialects are wrong or inferior kids need
to learn the complex and fascinating
history of their language just as they
learn the history of their planet and
their government they need to learn
where these ideas about career
this and the stigmas about other kinds
of dialects where this judgment comes
from and adults need to keep in mind
that when we criticize or mock someone
for pronouncing asked differently than
we do or even saying something like I
seen or typing the wrong you’re when
you’re in an online conversation then
what we are saying to them is because
you don’t speak or write like me I’m not
going to listen to what you have to say
and when we do that we shut down
conversation so judge what I say not how
I talk
thank you
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: