
by
why do we fight well we’ve read about
conflict in general in the favelas in
Brazil the gang fighting the American
grand militarism in the world or the
total warfare of the ancient Greeks but
also in very mundane things of everyday
life for example splitting up with your
partner or divorce but the ancient
Greeks have something or two to teach us
and I think through cities in particular
is going to be the man to do it he is an
expert on conflict having written the
history of the Peloponnesian War which
is the history between the war of
between Athens and Sparta which was a 24
year war and he believes that the war
began because of fear okay let’s just
start like that the Athenians
the Athenians becoming great and
arousing fear in the Spartans compelled
them to war okay now the fact is is that
Thucydides looks at any interaction in a
game theoretic way and what is game
theory game theory is a mathematical
theory of interaction and of course
lucidity didn’t use calculus or algebra
but he had a proto game theoretic
perspective on the world where he saw
people’s behavior intertwined and I’ll
show you how so let’s first look at the
first battle and how King OTT kadam owes
the king of the Spartans he invaded
Attica and this is modern Europe of
course transport yourself 2,500 years
ago imagine you know eliminate these
highways pretend it’s ancient Greece
there we go so we have Athens on the
right and we have Sparta in the south of
the Peloponnesus and we have the route
which kid almost took to invade Attica
or the region of Athens of the city of
Athens now what we first would imagine
is that he went as quickly as possible
to make it a surprise attack
but in fact no he was very slowly he
lethargically marched his troops up
through the Peloponnesus through the
corinthian isthmus around the garrison
of annoy and then finally settled in one
of the largest districts around the city
the garrison wall or the the wall of
Athens in the district of a cotton I
okay and which you see with the red dot
and the blue dot is Athens the walled
city of Athens now this is apparently
from what Thucydides tells us was not a
typical Spartans were in fact very
cautious people and the Corinthians who
were part of the Spartan League before
the war actually went to Sparta and told
the Spartans Spartans you alone of the
Greeks pursue a passive policy and this
was a reproach now in this first
invasion is a Adamo’s actually being
lazy or is it a clever tactic let’s try
and analyze this so in fact I could
almost did this on purpose I hadn’t I
the district in which he encounters
troops is in a high position so it’s on
the hilltops near the the valley of
where the walled city is and he knew
that the entire city or all the citizens
in the city would be able to see him and
he was visible his entire encampment is
visible to all the people in the urban
center of course all the people who were
in the urban center were not only the
urban citizens but also the rural
citizens who had evacuated the the rural
areas including a car light to take
refuge inside of the city walls so now
you have all of the Athenians staring
back at each other and this is turns
into a staring match because Akkad
almost seems not to be doing anything so
what our kid almost preferences whether
his options are to damos can either stay
where he is
and do nothing and simply ravage the
local land burn a bit of crops here
destroy some property there but nothing
that will exhaust his troops at all or
he can go on a full-on ravaging campaign
invade the plains of Attica near the
city walls and tried to take the city
and bash his head against those huge
walls and actually exhaust all of his
resources and waste his time and exhaust
his army so our cadavers prefers to be
passive than to be aggressive no matter
what the Athenians choose to do because
if the Athenians choose to come out even
when he’s passive his Spartans have the
lead on the battlefield they are the
most formidable infantry in Greece no
one beats them on land so we call
passive behavior D and aggressive
behavior E and D is preferred to e and
of course when I mean pasture that’s
more of a passive aggressive okay it’s
like you know don’t make me hurt you
so I’m gonna show you mmm how the
Athenians felt watching our ki damos
sitting there at a Karan I so what I
needed to do is not to tell your
neighbor and simply look at this image
and it says in X it’s an experiment okay
and here we go what do you see who sees
a young lady lift up your hand great
look around
lift up your hand up and look around a
lot of people who can’t see the young
lady you you probably see an old lady
right so this is exactly how the
Athenians felt they were collectively
indifferent about what perspective to
take half of the population wanted to
vote to go out and charge against the
Spartans especially the accordions who
were the largest district and the most
the greater number of the people inside
of the the city and the rest of the
Athenians wanted to stay inside the
walls and this collective indifference
we call
therefore be so the opinion preferences
we have no matter what the Spartans do
be is indifference however if the
Spartans are aggressive the best
possible choice for the Athenians to
make is to stay behind the walls and let
the Spartans use their resources waste
their resources and exhaust their
infantry and the worst possible decision
is to actually go out and fight against
them because they were most likely lose
given the formidable Ness of their army
so if we put these two preferences
together both of the Athenians and of
vodka da Mo’s we see that we have our
key Damas if he is passive the Athenians
are indifferent so BB and if a Adamas is
aggressive the opinions always prefer to
be passive a / c got that in the case of
the athenians if the Athenians are
passive arcade ahmo’s prefers to be
passive to aggressive and if they are
aggressive they are kadam’s prefers to
be passive to aggressive so no matter
what the Athenians do he always prefers
to be passive he doesn’t want to exhaust
his troops or waste resources okay so
this is the matrix formulation and these
are the four possible outcomes that are
key damos this is all in the plans of
arc Adamo’s that arc Adamas envisions
and envisions is going to happen so what
is he gonna do about this he says well
everybody is going to act in their own
self-interest and so what he thinks to
himself is one I prefer to be passive if
they’re passive I prefer to be passive
if they’re aggressive therefore I’m
going to be passive no matter what
that’s my dominant strategy those are my
best choices I put a star next to it now
the Athenians he says to himself are
going to think in the following way if
I’m passive they’re going to be confused
and they are going to be split in their
vote because they have their democracy
they’re a collective decision maker
they’re not one king there is a
collective number of people taking a
decision and therefore
of an aggressive very indifferent
between that however if he’s aggressive
and comes against the city walls more
certainly they will take up the passive
position and barricade themselves behind
the walls and then we can star those
best choices as well and in that case
the Athenians let’s just go back to that
in that case the Athenians have a weakly
dominant strategy so they prefer most of
the time to be passive but there is a
potential for error
right so what did we do this information
of these best choices where these best
choices intersect we say that these are
the most likely outcomes okay and this
is what our key damos did he was trying
to force the hand of the Athenians by
being passive to make a mistake to
actually charge them in a battlefield
that they would be more likely to lose
and so when I asked you where they
raised your clever
you should think to yourself obviously
clever very clever tactic on the part of
arcade ammos now this type of civil
strife okay that arcade ahmo’s had
created within athens is something that
is not only typical within States but
also happens within unions
confederacies and leagues and sorts and
anything that requires membership okay
and this was the case of new laws the
Athenian League okay wanted new laws to
stay within the Athenian Empire they
wanted them to be part of the Athenian
League and the median said we don’t want
to be part of your league okay so they
had a very Exeter attitude they wanted
to exit the league now the Athenians
they were afraid that if the millions
didn’t stay within the league that it
would create a contagion effect where
all the other members would say to
themselves well if they’re not joining
why should we
maybe we should Lee and so they said to
the millions you have the choice we need
you to be in the league and we need you
to accept our offer and our offer is the
following you will have to pay as
tribute and submit to our regulatory
control our jurisdiction okay which
usually meant the Athenian courts and of
course the median said this is unfair we
don’t think this very this is a very
similar situation to what is going on in
the UK today the analogy is not perfect
but it still is very well mimicked in
the sense that the UK has been offered
by the EU to stay within the membership
and simply pay a 8 to 9 million pounds
as part of their membership and to also
submit the regulatory control of the ECJ
to which the UK said that’s unfair and
what happens then the thing is it’s not
the bit the offer is unfair it’s that
the consequences of rejecting that offer
are going to be far worse and this is
what the other members of the league are
trying to argue so in the case of the
Athenians the Athenians say to the
millions look if you reject our offer
we’re going to destroy your city enslave
and your women and children kill all the
men in the city and recolonize your
entire territory not a very good outcome
so you know some tribute let them rule
is instead of everybody getting killed
in the case of the UK the Europeans have
said that they will deny a single market
access to Britain which will severely
and seriously damage the financial
sector in the City of London especially
given that the UK is a service run
economy the tax national tax
contributions of those immigrants in
those European immigrants is a
big chunk and they would be losing out
on that and the added bonus that there
would be military alienation given that
they would be separate from the Block in
that’s in from the military block of the
EU and so very negative outcomes now so
what is the negotiation what’s going on
so although these are the offers and
this is the offer and we can either
accept or reject what’s going on behind
the scenes what is the rhetoric so
what’s really going on is that there is
a realist rhetoric okay on the side of
the Athenians as well as the EU which is
simply possible actions are defined by
what the strong do and the weak accept
so if you’re little get with the program
okay and on the side of the millions
just as the UK there is a extreme
rhetoric of fairness and justice and
this is this is something that we should
do that requires that we think ethically
and morally these are the idealists and
in this case this is why we hear Teresa
may talk about her slogan and she’s been
vilified time and time again for saying
no deal is better than a bad deal but
this is very much in line okay this this
attitude towards breakfast brexit is
very much in line with the attitude that
Yanis varoufakis head with the grexit
crisis in fact Yanni’s varoufakis wrote
an entire monograph a book about the
situation that they had with the troika
and he entitled it the very same quote
of the millions as a reproach to this
realist perspective he called it and the
weak suffer what they must and in fact
it says and the weak suffer what they
must should they
so so this is the situation we’ve seen
that fear begins competition and
conflict we see that honor is a desire
for fairness and that selfish
self-interest is and it is a desire to
acquire things and Thucydides kind of
summarizes this strategy of coalition or
this strategy of empire in one sentence
the opinion ambassadors come to Sparta
before the war long before the world and
they come and they say well and I’m
going to read it off here there is
nothing remarkable or contrary to human
behavior and what we have done just
because we accepted an empire when one
was offered and then declined to let it
go overcome by the strongest of all
motives honor fear and self-interest
so honor is the need for fairness fear
compels us us to fight and self-interest
is the desire to acquire I have designed
a game theoretic model that tries to
incorporate these three ideas in a
networked annales analysis and then i
computer-simulated it and i’m going to
show you this computer simulation today
so here i’ve only included one of the
elements in the simulation so we have
fear so compelled to fight and the
number of resources of each node okay
and each of these nodes are the major
states in the 5th century BC ok at the
time of the Peloponnesian War and how
they interacted and hegemony was reached
so Spartan hegemony was reached very
quickly and here you see Sparta in
Laconia which is the lower node called
Laconia that’s just a region where
Sparta is this is very unrealistic
because hegemonies are not acquired so
quickly in this case I’ve added the
costs of war because two cities
explicitly tells us that war is more
about is less about weapons and arms
it is about money and the work and the
word he uses for money is da pani and da
da Pinay just means cost and expenditure
so what we have to do is that we have to
add the costs of war so every time I go
to war with somebody it costs me
something and if we include this we find
in fact that given the the parameters of
the time we we create the two leaks we
find that the brown stabilizes in the
Peloponnesian League and the blue which
is on the left hand side and the blue
stabilizes on the league Athenian League
on the right what I do next is that I
include the idea of fairness to make it
even more realistic so now each state
has the opportunity to decide if it
wants to exit the union or not if we do
this by having the initial state to be
the two leagues the Peloponnesian League
Spartan League and the Delian League the
Athenian League that Sparta actually
takes over and creates a hegemony even
though there are defections throughout
and exits of course if I let this
simulation keep on going the defections
would continue but the idea that
hegemony is still we can still arrive I
arrived at hegemonic States or or
coalitional States even though there are
exits is very heartening and so and this
is what was what actually did happen in
404 BC when Athens Falls and spot that
takes over most of ancient Greece so
it’s all conflict destructive well I
contend that it’s not there’s a lot of
friendly conflict for example that you
can you know use your fake Jedi sabers
when you’re playing tennis in London or
you can have two guys actually wrestling
on a vaaz and athletic competition is
simply a friendly version of the more
serious version of war and what we can
do is simply just keep rolling with the
punches thank you
why do we fight well we’ve read about
conflict in general in the favelas in
Brazil the gang fighting the American
grand militarism in the world or the
total warfare of the ancient Greeks but
also in very mundane things of everyday
life for example splitting up with your
partner or divorce but the ancient
Greeks have something or two to teach us
and I think through cities in particular
is going to be the man to do it he is an
expert on conflict having written the
history of the Peloponnesian War which
is the history between the war of
between Athens and Sparta which was a 24
year war and he believes that the war
began because of fear okay let’s just
start like that the Athenians
the Athenians becoming great and
arousing fear in the Spartans compelled
them to war okay now the fact is is that
Thucydides looks at any interaction in a
game theoretic way and what is game
theory game theory is a mathematical
theory of interaction and of course
lucidity didn’t use calculus or algebra
but he had a proto game theoretic
perspective on the world where he saw
people’s behavior intertwined and I’ll
show you how so let’s first look at the
first battle and how King OTT kadam owes
the king of the Spartans he invaded
Attica and this is modern Europe of
course transport yourself 2,500 years
ago imagine you know eliminate these
highways pretend it’s ancient Greece
there we go so we have Athens on the
right and we have Sparta in the south of
the Peloponnesus and we have the route
which kid almost took to invade Attica
or the region of Athens of the city of
Athens now what we first would imagine
is that he went as quickly as possible
to make it a surprise attack
but in fact no he was very slowly he
lethargically marched his troops up
through the Peloponnesus through the
corinthian isthmus around the garrison
of annoy and then finally settled in one
of the largest districts around the city
the garrison wall or the the wall of
Athens in the district of a cotton I
okay and which you see with the red dot
and the blue dot is Athens the walled
city of Athens now this is apparently
from what Thucydides tells us was not a
typical Spartans were in fact very
cautious people and the Corinthians who
were part of the Spartan League before
the war actually went to Sparta and told
the Spartans Spartans you alone of the
Greeks pursue a passive policy and this
was a reproach now in this first
invasion is a Adamo’s actually being
lazy or is it a clever tactic let’s try
and analyze this so in fact I could
almost did this on purpose I hadn’t I
the district in which he encounters
troops is in a high position so it’s on
the hilltops near the the valley of
where the walled city is and he knew
that the entire city or all the citizens
in the city would be able to see him and
he was visible his entire encampment is
visible to all the people in the urban
center of course all the people who were
in the urban center were not only the
urban citizens but also the rural
citizens who had evacuated the the rural
areas including a car light to take
refuge inside of the city walls so now
you have all of the Athenians staring
back at each other and this is turns
into a staring match because Akkad
almost seems not to be doing anything so
what our kid almost preferences whether
his options are to damos can either stay
where he is
and do nothing and simply ravage the
local land burn a bit of crops here
destroy some property there but nothing
that will exhaust his troops at all or
he can go on a full-on ravaging campaign
invade the plains of Attica near the
city walls and tried to take the city
and bash his head against those huge
walls and actually exhaust all of his
resources and waste his time and exhaust
his army so our cadavers prefers to be
passive than to be aggressive no matter
what the Athenians choose to do because
if the Athenians choose to come out even
when he’s passive his Spartans have the
lead on the battlefield they are the
most formidable infantry in Greece no
one beats them on land so we call
passive behavior D and aggressive
behavior E and D is preferred to e and
of course when I mean pasture that’s
more of a passive aggressive okay it’s
like you know don’t make me hurt you
so I’m gonna show you mmm how the
Athenians felt watching our ki damos
sitting there at a Karan I so what I
needed to do is not to tell your
neighbor and simply look at this image
and it says in X it’s an experiment okay
and here we go what do you see who sees
a young lady lift up your hand great
look around
lift up your hand up and look around a
lot of people who can’t see the young
lady you you probably see an old lady
right so this is exactly how the
Athenians felt they were collectively
indifferent about what perspective to
take half of the population wanted to
vote to go out and charge against the
Spartans especially the accordions who
were the largest district and the most
the greater number of the people inside
of the the city and the rest of the
Athenians wanted to stay inside the
walls and this collective indifference
we call
therefore be so the opinion preferences
we have no matter what the Spartans do
be is indifference however if the
Spartans are aggressive the best
possible choice for the Athenians to
make is to stay behind the walls and let
the Spartans use their resources waste
their resources and exhaust their
infantry and the worst possible decision
is to actually go out and fight against
them because they were most likely lose
given the formidable Ness of their army
so if we put these two preferences
together both of the Athenians and of
vodka da Mo’s we see that we have our
key Damas if he is passive the Athenians
are indifferent so BB and if a Adamas is
aggressive the opinions always prefer to
be passive a / c got that in the case of
the athenians if the Athenians are
passive arcade ahmo’s prefers to be
passive to aggressive and if they are
aggressive they are kadam’s prefers to
be passive to aggressive so no matter
what the Athenians do he always prefers
to be passive he doesn’t want to exhaust
his troops or waste resources okay so
this is the matrix formulation and these
are the four possible outcomes that are
key damos this is all in the plans of
arc Adamo’s that arc Adamas envisions
and envisions is going to happen so what
is he gonna do about this he says well
everybody is going to act in their own
self-interest and so what he thinks to
himself is one I prefer to be passive if
they’re passive I prefer to be passive
if they’re aggressive therefore I’m
going to be passive no matter what
that’s my dominant strategy those are my
best choices I put a star next to it now
the Athenians he says to himself are
going to think in the following way if
I’m passive they’re going to be confused
and they are going to be split in their
vote because they have their democracy
they’re a collective decision maker
they’re not one king there is a
collective number of people taking a
decision and therefore
of an aggressive very indifferent
between that however if he’s aggressive
and comes against the city walls more
certainly they will take up the passive
position and barricade themselves behind
the walls and then we can star those
best choices as well and in that case
the Athenians let’s just go back to that
in that case the Athenians have a weakly
dominant strategy so they prefer most of
the time to be passive but there is a
potential for error
right so what did we do this information
of these best choices where these best
choices intersect we say that these are
the most likely outcomes okay and this
is what our key damos did he was trying
to force the hand of the Athenians by
being passive to make a mistake to
actually charge them in a battlefield
that they would be more likely to lose
and so when I asked you where they
raised your clever
you should think to yourself obviously
clever very clever tactic on the part of
arcade ammos now this type of civil
strife okay that arcade ahmo’s had
created within athens is something that
is not only typical within States but
also happens within unions
confederacies and leagues and sorts and
anything that requires membership okay
and this was the case of new laws the
Athenian League okay wanted new laws to
stay within the Athenian Empire they
wanted them to be part of the Athenian
League and the median said we don’t want
to be part of your league okay so they
had a very Exeter attitude they wanted
to exit the league now the Athenians
they were afraid that if the millions
didn’t stay within the league that it
would create a contagion effect where
all the other members would say to
themselves well if they’re not joining
why should we
maybe we should Lee and so they said to
the millions you have the choice we need
you to be in the league and we need you
to accept our offer and our offer is the
following you will have to pay as
tribute and submit to our regulatory
control our jurisdiction okay which
usually meant the Athenian courts and of
course the median said this is unfair we
don’t think this very this is a very
similar situation to what is going on in
the UK today the analogy is not perfect
but it still is very well mimicked in
the sense that the UK has been offered
by the EU to stay within the membership
and simply pay a 8 to 9 million pounds
as part of their membership and to also
submit the regulatory control of the ECJ
to which the UK said that’s unfair and
what happens then the thing is it’s not
the bit the offer is unfair it’s that
the consequences of rejecting that offer
are going to be far worse and this is
what the other members of the league are
trying to argue so in the case of the
Athenians the Athenians say to the
millions look if you reject our offer
we’re going to destroy your city enslave
and your women and children kill all the
men in the city and recolonize your
entire territory not a very good outcome
so you know some tribute let them rule
is instead of everybody getting killed
in the case of the UK the Europeans have
said that they will deny a single market
access to Britain which will severely
and seriously damage the financial
sector in the City of London especially
given that the UK is a service run
economy the tax national tax
contributions of those immigrants in
those European immigrants is a
big chunk and they would be losing out
on that and the added bonus that there
would be military alienation given that
they would be separate from the Block in
that’s in from the military block of the
EU and so very negative outcomes now so
what is the negotiation what’s going on
so although these are the offers and
this is the offer and we can either
accept or reject what’s going on behind
the scenes what is the rhetoric so
what’s really going on is that there is
a realist rhetoric okay on the side of
the Athenians as well as the EU which is
simply possible actions are defined by
what the strong do and the weak accept
so if you’re little get with the program
okay and on the side of the millions
just as the UK there is a extreme
rhetoric of fairness and justice and
this is this is something that we should
do that requires that we think ethically
and morally these are the idealists and
in this case this is why we hear Teresa
may talk about her slogan and she’s been
vilified time and time again for saying
no deal is better than a bad deal but
this is very much in line okay this this
attitude towards breakfast brexit is
very much in line with the attitude that
Yanis varoufakis head with the grexit
crisis in fact Yanni’s varoufakis wrote
an entire monograph a book about the
situation that they had with the troika
and he entitled it the very same quote
of the millions as a reproach to this
realist perspective he called it and the
weak suffer what they must and in fact
it says and the weak suffer what they
must should they
so so this is the situation we’ve seen
that fear begins competition and
conflict we see that honor is a desire
for fairness and that selfish
self-interest is and it is a desire to
acquire things and Thucydides kind of
summarizes this strategy of coalition or
this strategy of empire in one sentence
the opinion ambassadors come to Sparta
before the war long before the world and
they come and they say well and I’m
going to read it off here there is
nothing remarkable or contrary to human
behavior and what we have done just
because we accepted an empire when one
was offered and then declined to let it
go overcome by the strongest of all
motives honor fear and self-interest
so honor is the need for fairness fear
compels us us to fight and self-interest
is the desire to acquire I have designed
a game theoretic model that tries to
incorporate these three ideas in a
networked annales analysis and then i
computer-simulated it and i’m going to
show you this computer simulation today
so here i’ve only included one of the
elements in the simulation so we have
fear so compelled to fight and the
number of resources of each node okay
and each of these nodes are the major
states in the 5th century BC ok at the
time of the Peloponnesian War and how
they interacted and hegemony was reached
so Spartan hegemony was reached very
quickly and here you see Sparta in
Laconia which is the lower node called
Laconia that’s just a region where
Sparta is this is very unrealistic
because hegemonies are not acquired so
quickly in this case I’ve added the
costs of war because two cities
explicitly tells us that war is more
about is less about weapons and arms
it is about money and the work and the
word he uses for money is da pani and da
da Pinay just means cost and expenditure
so what we have to do is that we have to
add the costs of war so every time I go
to war with somebody it costs me
something and if we include this we find
in fact that given the the parameters of
the time we we create the two leaks we
find that the brown stabilizes in the
Peloponnesian League and the blue which
is on the left hand side and the blue
stabilizes on the league Athenian League
on the right what I do next is that I
include the idea of fairness to make it
even more realistic so now each state
has the opportunity to decide if it
wants to exit the union or not if we do
this by having the initial state to be
the two leagues the Peloponnesian League
Spartan League and the Delian League the
Athenian League that Sparta actually
takes over and creates a hegemony even
though there are defections throughout
and exits of course if I let this
simulation keep on going the defections
would continue but the idea that
hegemony is still we can still arrive I
arrived at hegemonic States or or
coalitional States even though there are
exits is very heartening and so and this
is what was what actually did happen in
404 BC when Athens Falls and spot that
takes over most of ancient Greece so
it’s all conflict destructive well I
contend that it’s not there’s a lot of
friendly conflict for example that you
can you know use your fake Jedi sabers
when you’re playing tennis in London or
you can have two guys actually wrestling
on a vaaz and athletic competition is
simply a friendly version of the more
serious version of war and what we can
do is simply just keep rolling with the
punches thank you
Please follow and like us: