Press "Enter" to skip to content

Why educating the poor is in our interest | Yandiswa Xhakaza | TEDxLytteltonWomen


[Music]
my earliest memory off school dates back
to 1992 the year before I started grade
one we were dead-set with my grandmother
that I was going to go to a particular
school because this school was viewed or
deemed to be a very good school it was
an English medium school and my
grandmother believed that because they
teach in English it should therefore be
a good school my application was however
unsuccessful I did not get to the school
and I was very depressed
I was devastated for a six-year-old to
not have gotten into the school I ended
up at a local primary school in lab high
primary school and it was a walking
distance from my grandmother’s house and
when I looked back today I am grateful
to have gone to in-lab high grateful
because I had an opportunity to be
taught in my mother tongue is tazza
a language I can speak read and write
exceptionally well today when I also
looked back and I realized that home
language instruction has somehow always
been deemed to be inferior and if your
child is taught in English therefore
that that’s the better way of educating
I did my fourth year research on home
language instruction and it was clear
that if you teach a child in their
mother tongue at least in the foundation
years of learning they will do far
better later on in their lives by the
end of grade six going into grade seven
my father a businessman living in power
in the Western Cape negotiates with my
grandmother and asks her if we could
join him in Paul in order for us to
access better
he had to negotiate with my grandmother
because who is going to raise two young
girls if he wants to take them on but
because they have always been in a
pursuit for good education good quality
education
my grandmother agreed that my father
could take my sister and I in pursuit of
a good education so here’s a scenario of
learner migration here’s a scenario of
children who lived in the Eastern Cape
born in the Eastern Cape with their
Korean mother and their mother and have
this maternal support people raising
them but having to leave the province
and migrate because clearly there isn’t
good education the problems we leave for
the beautiful wine town of Paul in the
Western Cape and we attend a series of
interviews to get into a Catholic
Primary School we eventually get in
Andrey accepted I’m only there for one
year and to prove my point of home
language instruction I first top of my
class in grade seven in an English
medium Catholic private school I do
pretty well and by the end of that year
I am already very well acquainted with
good schools in the region in fact the
whole country and at this point I’m well
aware of the typical location of good
schools I know where they are situated
and I know where they are not I also
know that great schools are often almost
always white I also know that good
schools have a culture a very strong
culture of sports and sportsmanship I
also know that good schools are very
expensive almost exclusive and elitist
applied to my preferred school high
school for grade eight and I apply well
on time and I really look forward to my
acceptance letter I don’t think I read
further than thank you for for your
application to La Rochelle goals
hi your application is unfortunately
unsuccessful so I was devastated
ah it broke me and I remember not
understanding why but with the help of
my father who felt I was crying over
split milk he thought there are better
school schools let’s apply to another
one and we did now the school he wanted
me to go to is Powell’s high
now Powell’s high in Powell is
affectionately known as were mrs.
welfare oh and very much would not
resonate with in the first instance so
how am I going to be excited about it
going to the school but I eventually get
in and I’m not thrilled really I’m not
excited this for me is just last resort
oh really I really wanted the other
school I arrive at power goals high and
state-of-the-art buildings teachers who
are subject matter experts in their
fields and this is a bunch of passionate
people there is a myriad of sporting
codes to choose from I take up hockey I
play netball even though it was all f
team but I was part of her team and I
auditioned to form part of the choir I
learned to swim because swimming was
compulsory for all the girls in the
school but the values were not hanging
on walls
we lived them so the culture of
excellence the culture of sportsmanship
the culture of commitment the culture of
finishing what you started these are
things we understood very well as the
girls in the school at the end of grade
10 going to grade 11 we used to visit my
grandmother in my mother in the Eastern
Cape every December and upon our return
this is the day before we open school
and this is the year I was going to be
going to grade 11
my father and I have a massive
altercation so massive that I’m sent
back to it the what to my grandmother
and they’ll be full schools open for
grade 11 and so I go back to battle it
and I am hysterical so I’m looking for a
school in battle it but my my standards
are high I’m looking for a park called
high equivalence and I searched January
comes to it and I can’t find anything I
panic and I search for the school
February now anything close to a pal
goes high is an odd 130 kilometers out
of town eventually it sinks in that
maybe you’re not going to find something
like a pal called high a childhood
friend as mother comes to my rescue
so mama got handle cos it takes it upon
herself to find me a school and she
eventually says no I’ll have a word with
the principal of one of the best schools
in town and so I start asking people
around so this school is the school of
grade school
people say oh no it’s the most expensive
in town it’s absolutely the greatest
well okay I don’t know I I know my
school’s pretty well so I didn’t know
about this one and I get into school end
of April that here so the whole time
finished whilst I was busy looking for
power girls I in battle with and I
eventually get to the school and the
buildings and debilitated there is a
handful of passionate teachers and
passionate and worried about the future
of the children not passionate in
subject matter expertise really or
having a rapport 12 teaching
methodologies that they can use not that
passionate but passion that we worry
about you patience there is no visible
culture of anything of anything
there is no sports absolutely nothing to
do so this breaks my heart breaks my
heart because this is the best school in
town now if this is the best school in
town show me or mediocre sport
show me your bad school because of this
the best that this town has to offer we
have a problem this experience shaped
the trajectory of my life and the work
that I do today having lived in both
worlds having experienced these two
education systems that are so glaringly
different worries me today worries me
because clearly we have become so
comfortable in our bubbles of
middle-class South Africans we can take
our kids to particular schools while
millions of others are subjected to
substandard education it became clear to
me during that experience that firstly
by virtue of being born poor you are
going to be relegated to a substandard
education but also secondly that by
virtue of where geographically you are
born you are going to suffer and go to
substandard schools there’s millions of
our children in this country and these
stark polarities should not be a norm
because it is not uncommon in South
Africa to find a school that looks like
that and one that is within a five
kilometer radius with another one so
it’s it’s actually I don’t know how we
continue to live like this and we make
this okay so this is not okay and to
give you a basic example so if we take a
group of children who started school in
2004 of that 51% don’t even make it they
don’t even make it to create 12th they
don’t even finish high school and the
question we should be asking is what
happens to them where do they go that is
that is a lot of children who just don’t
get to great off and even in the 49% of
those that actually get to grade 12 12
percent fail they don’t pass right 23
percent they pass but not well enough to
get into University
only 40% 14 so what is wrong with our
basic education system what happens to
those 51 percent where are they what are
they doing where do they leave what do
they eat how do they make a living those
are the questions we need to begin to
ask ourselves but also it’s clear that
if we have such a massive and a chunk of
young people who don’t actually get
through education
they must be unemployed they must be
sitting somewhere and they are
unemployed the unemployment rate and
these are the recent statistics is quite
high in our country but I’m going to
just look at the age group that is
between 15 and 34 that’s the young
people in South Africa we have 20
million of those people right and then
almost 60% of that is either employed or
still in school still in basic education
or some higher education training but
almost 40% is idling
somewhere it’s it’s unaccounted for it’s
not in school it’s not an employment
it’s not in training that is a high
percentage and then we wonder why we
have such high crime rates and we wonder
why we have such social ills because
there is a group of people in millions
that is idling and we’re going to cause
a problem for ourselves and it is in our
interest to care and to do something
about it and yes education may not be
the only way to solve the problem but we
know many of us know I know that it is
the single most important weapon that we
can move people from poverty to end off
I just want to urge everybody I mean who
we are all involved in different sectors
and different activities but I think it
is important that we begin to care and
we begin to do things intentionally and
to think at scale about the solutions
that we can bring forward to make
sure that education is not just
accessible to the elite to the wealthy
and to the middle class but that the
millions of South African but really
really deserve it and need it also
access it so that we have an educated
population of people an educated country
maybe then we will lead better maybe
then we will govern better maybe then we
will vote better thank you
[Applause]
[Music]
Please follow and like us: