Press "Enter" to skip to content

Navigando i modelli sperimentali | Arti Ahluwalia | TEDxTaranto


much is said about animal
experimentation these days
basically there are two schools of
thought on the one hand we have the on
tv’ section lists and the auntie’s
speciesism and animal rights groups who
claim that animal testing is not only
unethical but completely useless because
as Thomas hearting said we’re not 70
kilogram rats on the other hand we have
the pro human pro life and quite often
self declared through science groups who
hinge their arguments on the value of
human life and on the importance of
animal experiments into the most
important discoveries in biomedical
science so in the name of scientific
progress and for the benefit of
humankind
they claim that analytics firms are
essential because we do after all share
more than 90% of our genes with mice the
two groups basically represent two
contrasting ideologies and they present
their arguments using data from
different sources but they only choose
the data that match their views while
ignoring all the rest this is a well
known behavioral phenomenon known as
confirmation bias for instance the first
group often cite the fact that 92% of
drugs that are tested on animals fail
when they used in humans the data comes
from a 2004 FDA report which actually
states that only 8% of drugs which are
used in the first phase of clinical
testing go on to be sold in the market
in reality only one in five thousands of
the chemical compounds developed of
pharmaceutical purposes actually end up
being sold on the market because most of
them are rooted are long before being
tested on animals
the second group quite often remind us
that vaccines such as polio tuberculosis
measles and hepatitis B as well as
medicines and
biotics which have saved the lives of
millions of people were developed thanks
to animal experiments this is quite true
but they don’t mention drugs like
falooda mite which was sold as an
anti-nausea drug to pregnant women in
the 1950s and because and cause severe
limb deformities in over 10,000 newborn
babies or other drugs like by ox and Roz
glycerin which caused tens of thousands
of heart attacks but without doubt
animal experiments were necessary to
understand us but if we look at the
overall evidence we cannot reasonably
state that animal experiments are
useless in fact we know that infant
mortality has declined whereas life
expectancy has increased considerably
over the past 100 years this is partly
due to access to clean water sanitation
and hygiene but particularly since the
1950s it’s due to progress in medical
science I can cite several examples not
just drugs and vaccines for instance
kidney heart and liver transplants
vascular prosthesis stents hip and knee
replacements to give you an example the
Nobel prize-winning surgeon Joseph
Murray expend experimented on 600 dogs
before safely starting with human kidney
transplants today 8,000 80,000 people
all over the world receive a kidney
transplant every year transplants and
implants were aided by the discovery of
anticoagulants such as heparin which was
first extracted from the livers of dogs
in the 1930s and we don’t even need to
go so far back in time for example the
Nobel prize-winning Japanese scientist
Yamanaka was able to generate induced
pluripotent stem cells from the cells of
adult mice in 2006 these cells are now
considered as a promising method for
curing several illnesses and have
revolutionized biomedical research today
so with that diet animal experiments
were necessary to understand what could
happen in the human body and help thee
know and have helped lead to many of the
scientific discoveries that we all
benefit from today but note that I said
to understand what could happen in the
human body not what does happen that’s
because our hypothesis is based on the
fact that animals as humans are similar
so it’s quite often possible to predict
what will happen to in a human based on
observations made on a rat or another
animal that is the animal is an
approximation of a human being
in fact for 91% of the experiments
carried of the expert animal experiments
carried out only in the EU the animal is
a model of a human being so it’s then up
to us to extrapolate the results
obtained in the lab to humans
accepting the risks and limitations
associated with the model a hundred and
even ten to fifteen years ago animal
experiments were necessary simply
because we didn’t have appropriate
technology to even think of doing
otherwise we couldn’t even dream of
engineering the 3d bio artificial
systems in the lab we couldn’t even
think of replicating the metabolic or
physiological functions of a human or
even an animal using a cell culture but
today we not only dream and think about
it we’re actually trying to replicate
those very functions in our labs but
just because we can’t actually we’re
just because we’re thinking of doing it
at the moment it doesn’t mean that we
should just stop there and carry on
using animals to test drugs chemicals
and human diseases using animals like
our predecessors did I’m going to use an
analogy to help you answer this question
this is the first time I’ve been to
Toronto
we hide a car and drove here from
Brindisi Airport using the navigation
app on my mobile phone a hundred years
ago I perhaps have arrived here in a
horse carriage and used a paper map to
get here in the past 100 years we’ve
made huge progress in our navigation
technology just think about it
thousands of years ago our ancestors use
the map yeah use the Stars to figure out
where they were and where they were
going then we started using tools like
the compass paper maps clocks and radio
the GPS system was developed in 1973 and
by 2004 people had started using it and
handheld units known as tom toms today
almost everybody has a GPS receiver
embedded in their mobile phones and we
know our position to an accuracy of a
few meters and we can navigate almost
anywhere on earth in other fields such
as robotics we can make robots that see
that assemble cars and even talk to each
other our parents and grandparents won’t
have even dreamed of communicating
robots and it’ll were inbuilt navigation
in mobile phones but we’ve not only
dreamed about these we’ve actually built
machines devices and technologies that
substitute humans in simple and boring
tasks so what stops us from thinking of
building device machines devices and
technologies that substitute laboratory
mice technologically we’re at a turning
point in biomedical research today we
could on the one hand using a navigation
analogy stay with Stars and maps on the
basis that no human or animal can
possibly be simulated using a computer
or represented using a cell culture and
so we can continue to use animals models
of humans and human diseases just like
we’ve done for over a hundred years or
we could move from sofas simple cell
cultures and adopt new technologies and
new tools
like those using human induced
pluripotent stem cells that have the
potential to generate a mini intestine
like hands Cleaver showed in 2009 or a
mini liver organoid like turkey we
showed in 2013 we can use advanced
material fabrication technology to
create blood vessels like channels
between one organoid and another so that
they can communicate much like they do
in our bodies these engineered systems
can replace animal models but they’re
still models and so it’ll still be
necessary to critically analyze the
results and then translate them to the
human context just like animal models
will have to accept the risks and
limitations associated with them the
difference is that these engineered
models can be continuously improved and
optimized for example by using heat
cells from a patient in order to predict
his or her personalized response to a
therapy on the other hand the biology of
a mouse is fixed and unchangeable you
might ask then do we still need animal
models today in many areas of research
like toxicology when we need to evaluate
the toxic or harmful effects of a
substance according to the amount were
exposed to probably not most toxicity
experiments in animals are already
accompanied by in vitro tests because
they help reduce the number of animals
used we now know that cell cultures are
simpler and more precise for evaluating
the cancerous or Geno toxic effects of a
chemical compound than animals that’s
because the biological mechanisms of
genotoxicity can be in our analyzed
step by step first in single cells and
then in groups of cells but we do still
need animals to study some of the more
complex organs and systems like the
immune system the endocrine system and
high-level brain function today
it would be impossible to evaluate how a
vascular prosthesis made out of a new
biomaterial will be integrated into the
body but using the tools and
technologies that we have today
developing them further on we will soon
be able to model biomaterial integral
interaction in a mini organ in the lab
and combine it with a computational
model of blood flow in human arteries
using this type of combined technology
it’s highly likely that in the next few
years we’ll be able to model the by
integration of a new implant with even
greater precision than we currently do
in dogs and sheep so based on past
evidence it’s unreasonable to sustain
that animal experiments have served no
purpose but it’s also irrational to
maintain that we have no better way of
modeling human body armed with the
technology we have today just like we’ve
changed our navigation tools it’s time
to change the tools of Experimental
Biology not for one ideology or another
but for the benefit of humanity animals
and scientific knowledge thank you
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: