Press "Enter" to skip to content

Solving the Global Anesthesia Crisis | Kelly McQueen, MD, MPH | TEDxNashvilleSalon


well thank you so much Dan it’s such a
pleasure to be here I’m starting with a
warning slot slide for all of you
because I was asked by the producers to
let you know that I’m sharing some
graphic content and images because I
think they’ll help you better understand
the crisis that I’ll talk about today
now while I’m an anesthesiologist I’m
not planning to put you to sleep today
in fact I desperately hope that I’m not
going to put you to sleep today I want
to wake you rather to a crisis that is
the absence of anesthesia and ask you to
care about five billion in need of safe
anesthesia and surgery
geography truly is destiny and for the
populations on this map in yellow and
orange their destiny has been to live
without the essential part of healthcare
anesthesia and surgery I’ve experienced
this crisis in real time throughout my
career and I’ve been changed by what
I’ve witnessed I’ll never forget a
mother that I met in northern Sri Lanka
my experience is with her and her family
changed the course of my career you see
I was serving in northern Sri Lanka as
part of a Doctors Without Borders
surgical team serving behind the front
lines of the war that had been going on
for more than 20 years many of you will
remember this crisis the southern
Sinhalese army
battling the north northern Tamil
separatist the Tamil Tigers who were
famous for the Black Tigers the young
suicide bombers which terrorized the
country throughout the conflict those
Black Tigers Armagh more here in this
memorial which was centered in the town
where I lived as part of this team
living in northern Sri Lanka was austere
and for the civilians that lived here
they lived without electricity without
running water
and without access to health care or
basic medicines but somehow life
continued babies were born children went
to school and the Hindu temples
continued to offer worship the hospital
where we worked was also in an austere
shape it had been bombed on many
circumstances and the concrete walls
were crumbling the roof was merely a
piece of tin or in some places a tarp
which blocked out the Sun and the rain
at times but it was here that we offered
surgery for the civilian population and
sometimes for combatants we offered
emergency surgery for landmine injuries
and for motorcycle accidents for
infections and almost on a daily basis
we treated mothers pregnant women who
had been laboring for days and days
would arrive on bicycle asking for a
surgery to take out the baby that was
stuck inside our operating room was
equally in bad condition the room had an
open window with no screen and through
this screen the dust and flies blew
regularly we had limited access to
equipment and to medicines we frequently
ran out of oxygen out of pain medicine
and out of life-saving medicines and so
on the day that the mother arrived that
I mentioned we were doing our work in
the hospital and she arrived with her
physician father asking us for a
cesarean delivery to deliver her second
child her father spoke English and
explained that her first child had been
delivered by cesarean section and
therefore he knew that it would be safer
for her to deliver in these
circumstances again by cesarean delivery
we were able to accommodate her the next
day and so I provided for her a spinal
anesthetic that made her numb from about
her chest down and in no time a
beautiful baby
big boy was born and we were
able to quickly close her incision and
move her on to the recovery ward all was
well but before we left the hospital
that evening we were called back to the
recovery ward because the nurses
reported that this mother was in
distress it was this room where we went
only by then it was dark and so there
were kerosene lanterns burning in the
corners and I as I looked across the
room I could see that this mother was
sitting bolt upright in bed and she was
leaning forward and clutching her chest
she was surrounded by her family by all
the nurses working that evening and by
all the patients in the ward as well as
I move closer I could see that she was
really struggling to breathe and as I
got closer still I could see that her
coloring was gray I sat down next to her
and I felt her pulse her pulse was
racing I asked the nurses to bring the
few emergency supplies and the oxygen
that we had available in the operating
room to me I listened to her lung fields
with my stethoscope and although I had
some ideas about what was going on I had
none of the tests or the x-rays that I
needed to make a good diagnosis so we
had to move forward with treating her
about the time that the oxygen and the
resuscitation bag arrived she collapsed
and stopped breathing we use the bag in
the mask to breathe for her but her
coloring didn’t get better I was feeling
her pulse and I could feel that it was
getting weaker and weaker I finally was
able to take her blood pressure and her
blood pressure was very low I asked for
the life-saving medicine epinephrine
that she so needed to help her hurt beat
better but I was told by the nurses that
we’d run out and so as we continued
standing by about evaluating her her
heart stopped
we didn’t have anything to shock her
heart back into action nor did we have a
breathing machine to breathe for her
overnight
so he started chest compressions because
she was young and healthy and we hoped
that it would restart her heart and I
don’t know if we were there for minutes
or for an hour but sometime in that
process her physician father stepped up
behind me and he put his hand on my
shoulder and he whispered we have to
stop we have to let her go I wish I
could tell you that this was a rare
event but in the countries I’m telling
you about today it’s not only common but
it happens every day because of a lack
of access to the things we need but more
importantly to a generalized at lack of
access to anesthesia and surgery in fact
five billion people lack access to
anesthesia and surgery in the world
today and while this number is
extraordinary I have to tell you that
it’s based in science The Lancet
Commission on global surgery published
this report on April in April of 2015
and this report was life-changing
because for finally we could quantify
the problem and therefore we could move
forward with the solutions now many of
you may be asking yourself how is that
even possible
how could two-thirds of the world lack
access to this basic health care well
I’m here to tell you that the problem
started long ago in in these countries
that you see on the map in orange and
yellow because they were plagued
literally by life-threatening infectious
diseases as well as by other
humanitarian crises including droughts
famine and conflict and these things
combined consumed all the healthcare
resources and there was no money or
resource for anything more but somewhere
in the middle 90s these things begin to
change
infectious diseases had better treatment
and prevention including HIV some
droughts ended people were fed and
conflicts resolved and therefore disease
started to look a whole lot more like it
looks here in the United States trauma
became more common cancer was more
common and heart disease is now
everywhere but none of the resources
were available to begin treating these
problems as they appeared so imagine
with me if you can being in a terrible
car accident and having a badly badly
broken leg but no one there to fix it or
no one to give you pain medicine for
your pain or imagine having a heart
attack without the critical resources to
save your life or to have a cancer that
hasn’t been diagnosed and you’ve had it
for so long that you now have tumors in
both breasts and throughout your body
like this woman who we met and she died
only three months later or this
gentleman who years ago had two very
very small hernias which would have been
fixed in a matter of minutes by a quick
surgery but he had no access to that and
so his hernias grew larger and larger
and his pain and immobility increased
until finally he could no longer work or
provide for his family
in fact the backlog on surgeries is so
big than a hundred and forty three
million cases are needed every year just
to begin to catch up and tragedy further
is that 16 million deaths occur every
year because of the lack of access to
safe anesthesia and surgery and most of
these are preventable I hope I’ve made
you come to the realization that
anesthesiology is
central to the solution for this problem
and in fact anesthesiology is essential
to health care and integral to health
living without anesthesiology is painful
and life-threatening and so how does
that look on the ground in those
countries that I showed you in orange
and yellow well I’ll give you three
examples in Ethiopia there are 22
anesthesiologists for 90 million people
in Rwanda there are 13 anesthesiologists
for 11 million and Sierra Leone has only
one remaining anesthesiologists for 6
million people
well how many anesthesiologist do you
need how many do we have here in the US
well I can tell you that we have
approximately one anesthesiologist for
every 10,000 people in the US which
amounts to about 60,000
anesthesiologists and all that’s more in
this country than for all 80 countries
that I showed you on the map and so
let’s talk about the solutions because
there’s so much good news here for us
now
five integrated solutions exist which
will lead to the scaling up of safe
anesthesia and surgery and provide for
these diseases I’ve described to you
data collection and analysis is much
needed to ensure we know where the
problems are and what is specifically
needed education and training has to
happen for the many doctors nurses and
technicians that we need to improve
access and to improve patient safety
innovation for new equipment that is
cost effective and technology
appropriate and is so needed in all
these operating rooms around the world
and permanent access to medicines that
are in chronic need in many of these
countries oxygen antibiotics pain
medicines and life life-saving medicines
as well and the most important solution
is
that of government government has to
invest in this process and sustain it or
these solutions will not amount to a
permanent fix and this may be the most
difficult part of the solution grouping
because as you might have guessed this
is going to be expensive
in fact The Lancet Commission on global
surgery estimates that it will cost
three hundred and fifty billion dollars
to scale up to safe anesthesia and
surgery but more important is that it
will cost twelve trillion dollars in
lost GDP if we don’t do this today I
hope you’ll agree with me that this has
to happen these important events have
already occurred making this feasible
and we’re well on our way to the scale
up I believe that we are well on our way
to more anesthesia more surgery and to
many lives saved my colleagues and I are
working with our partners on the ground
to help them make sure that this is a
reality we continue with advocacy we
continue to engage new partners in
pharmaceutical companies and medical
industry and we encourage others already
on the ground to take at this effort
this is the global surgery era I
continue to experience this crisis in
real time and I’m impressed by the
changes that I’m seeing I’m inspired by
my partners on the ground like dr. jean
who was the last remaining
anesthesiologist in rwanda she is still
there today teaching and educating
providing advocacy for patient safety
and for anesthesia around the country
and it’s because of her and many like
her that I continue to work for the five
billion in need of safe anesthesia thank
you very much
[Applause]
you
Please follow and like us: