Press "Enter" to skip to content

Ghost hunters and the secret power of storytelling | Jacquelyn Benson | TEDxPiscataquaRiver


so I want to talk to you guys today
about a very important question what is
it that makes people change the way they
think so I’m a novelist with a
background in anthropology as you just
heard and I’ve always been fascinated by
this question now I think we can all
agree what the answer is not and it is
not facts and rational arguments right
because if it was talking about politics
wouldn’t make us want to crawl under our
desks and hide but profound
transformations do happen and anybody in
this room who cares about social change
I think there are probably more than a
few of us who do should also care about
what it is that actually makes that
possible so a few years ago to try to
better understand this I spent several
months in the field studying the social
lives of paranormal investigators ghost
hunters for those of you who aren’t
familiar ghost hunters investigate
reported hauntings to try and figure out
first
is there a natural explanation for
what’s going on here and if there isn’t
then they try to collect evidence of
this paranormal activity using all kinds
of equipment from electromagnetic field
detectors and night-vision video cameras
to attacks of the goosebumps so most
ghost hunters believe in ghosts but they
don’t only start out that way so what is
it about ghost hunting that is the power
to turn a skeptic into a believer the
answer to that question is a ghost
hunting as it happens taps into two of
our most fundamental cognitive resources
the resources that actually do have the
power to change the way we see the world
first ghost hunting is a group activity
you don’t go ghost hunting by yourself
every horror movie ever teaches us that
would be a terrible idea
you do this with a team and while you
were sitting there in these dark rooms
for hours and hours and hours and hours
waiting for something to happen you are
also building relationships with your
fellow investigators you’re getting to
know them and to care about them and
relationships are magic bullets for
changing minds we humans guys we are
social animals we are adapted to work
together in groups and part of this
adaptation is that we have a reflexive
not rational tendency for us to adjust
our way of thinking about the world to
be compatible with the people that were
close to or that we look up to or
respect second ghost-hunting
it elicits strong emotions right imagine
spending your Saturday nights hanging
around in a spooky abandoned insane
asylum that sounds relaxing right no
ghost hunting is incredibly intense and
scary and it’s so much fun your
adrenaline is running so hot that if the
door creaks downstairs you are jumping
out of your skin now emotion is
intimately tied to how our memory works
it’s like this synaptic cement right it
just Sears what would otherwise be a
one-off connection into your brain and
makes it stick I’m assuming that
everybody in this room right now
remembers where you were on September
11th right or that time that you got
lost on the beach when you were a kid or
maybe the last three minutes of the 2004
World Series these experiences are
burned into our brains because through
each one of them your emotions were on
fire this is why skeptics that go ghost
hunting even if they start out just
trying to prove everybody wrong
rarely stay skeptical for long this
growing closeness that they form with a
new tribe exerts a psychological
pressure to open up the way they
interpret the world and getting scared
makes that experience stick in their
minds humans guys we are experts at
ignoring the facts that don’t agree with
our existing point of view really good
at it but form relationships strong
relationships with people that think
differently than you do and share
intense emotional experiences with them
and you might just find yourself seeing
things in a whole new way an
anthropologists and psychologists we’ve
seen this happen with a lot more than
just ghost hunting groups it’s happening
with English witchcraft practitioners
Papua New Guinean cargo cults Western
environmentalists American college
students and psych labs but what does
this have to do with us and this current
political climate that we’re in of
seemingly impenetrable opposing views
well if you guys want to change minds
you got to build relationships and share
emotional experiences but I’m guessing
there probably aren’t too many of you
here who have the time or the
inclination to go ghost hunting with
every single climate change denier
clearly what we need here is a way to
scale this up right and change more than
one mind at a time and thankfully there
is a solution telling stories stories
are part of humanity that we’ve been
telling them for as long as we’ve been
hanging around in groups and as it
happens stories tap into exactly the
same cognitive resources we’ve been
talking about first stories bro build
relationships this is how they work how
many of you can name a character that
you know as well as your best friends
right I know that Fox Mulder never got
over the disappearance of a sister love
sunflower seeds and would have been an
absolutely awful boyfriend our brains
don’t care that these aren’t real people
the relationships that we form with the
characters that inhabit our favorite
stories still have the power to impact
the way we think as do the emotional
experiences that we share with them
Thelma and Louise sharing a kiss before
they floor it over the edge of a cliff
right a Owen raising her sword before
the king of the Nazgul telling him I am
no man you are present in those moments
cognitively speaking they are eliciting
real emotions with all the power of that
electricity to reshape the pathways of
your brain now obviously not all stories
accomplish this and unfortunately
there’s not an easy recipe for what
makes a story not only effective in that
it elicits these strong emotions and
makes you care about its characters but
also viral so that it finds its way into
the hands and eyes at masses I mean if
there were I wouldn’t be giving you this
talk right now because I’d be off having
tea and biscuits with JK Rowling and Dan
Brown but each of us storytellers
strives for this every time we set our
fingers to a keyboard and because we
don’t know which story is gonna be the
one to break out we all regardless of
our medium have a responsibility to
think
the greater potential impact of what we
right now I’m a feminist I know I’m not
supposed to use dirty words up here so
sorry I believe strongly in the struggle
for women’s rights and I believe that
that struggle that we have had so many
successes is far from over
and a couple weeks ago when I saw a gal
gadot’s Wonder Woman throw off her
disguise and stride out of that trench
into no-man’s land I fell apart because
it’s rare it’s still an anomaly to see a
grown woman be the hero in a story where
she isn’t just fighting to survive or
looking for love I spend a lot of time
hanging out in the 19th century because
I write historical fiction so I’m
immersing myself and how the people of
our past thought and I can tell you that
the same tropes the same quiet old
assumptions still find their way into so
many of our stories today that women are
inherently more nurturing and
compassionate than men that monogamous
love and a romantic relationship
presumably as a prelude to making babies
this is our true destiny that were less
rational that were physically weaker in
a nude of a big strong man to rescue us
but here is the thing every storyteller
regardless of whether you are scribbling
comic books or directing blockbusters
has the power to turn disbelievers into
believers just like those ghost hunters
we have this unique ability to reach
into the minds of millions to tap into
their most essential cognitive resources
and open up the way they see the world
now a spider-man’s Uncle Ben tells us
with great power comes great
responsibility because we have this
power each of us creatives has a duty to
think critically about the culture we
reproduce in our art now that is not
easy it is in fact deeply unsettling to
question whether your ideas about gender
class race diversity right and wrong
good and evil aren’t actually natural
truths but culture and not only that but
relics of a culture that legitimized
discrimination and oppression but
storytellers have many of the traits
that make for great anthropologists
we’re critical thinkers we are wildly
imaginative and I honestly believe that
we have this capacity not only to
recognize those old tropes for what they
are but to imagine new possibilities and
embody them in what we write we can
conceive of the way the world could be
and move our readers and our audiences
to take a step toward it and if we
succeed its skill and talent and luck
come together with the right wild ideas
then we could just change the world
thank you
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: