Press "Enter" to skip to content

Want to save democracy? Elevate the debate. | Elissa Margolin | TEDxPiscataquaRiver


I helped lead a political campaign to
victory using tactics I now regret
I didn’t do anything criminal and not
anything even remotely illegal and I
helped elect someone I really believed
in a true progressive he voted against
the Iraq war advocated for single-payer
health care helped the disenfranchised
the year was 1996 and I was a recent law
graduate hungry to make a difference in
fact at my law school graduation when
the photographer arrived to take the
class picture
he asked the class to smile by saying
money and they obliged
instead I threw my fist in the air and
said justice and now here I was campaign
manager for US congressman in the
toughest reelection campaign of his
political career our opponent was a
young smart dynamo moderately
conservative female state senator who
would give us a run for our money and
you know the challenge with winning
elections right
elections are not won by the ideologies
of either side they’re won by the people
in the middle the undecideds and it’s
the candidate who can persuade more of
those undecideds to break to their team
who wins most of a general election is
about messaging to the undecided so I
guess it’s no wonder that I didn’t speak
up when a consultant to the campaign
suggested that our tagline be working
people first what does that even mean
and I guess it’s no wonder that I helped
develop a negative TV ad that morphed
the image of our opponent into the image
of Newt Gingrich now we wanted to make
the case that about for her was a vote
for the Gingrich agenda and there’s some
truth to that but to morph her image
into his to depict them as one in the
same
was just not true but that didn’t Donna
me at all at the time I remember pretty
vividly sitting in that studio with the
ad team some recent polling had just
come out our lead had narrowed she had a
real shot and all I could think of is we
need to go bathe we need to go negative
I remember sifting through photos of her
until we could find the most on
flattering one and then manipulating
that photo even more until it was more
unflattering you’ve seen these ads I’m
not here for absolution rather I’m here
to explore how the sting of these early
ethical transgressions helped form and
sustain for me a personal moral compass
that I’ve come to rely on for the rest
of a career in public policy it was
actually these early missteps that
helped me grow a commitment to elevate
the debate I know we all have it that
voice that personal inner ethicist but
it’s our institutions it would seem that
drown out this voice until we no longer
hear it and then we no longer trust it
these are institutions that drive home
our duties to our shareholders that
celebrate our profit motive that push
political campaigns to the edge of truth
and then reward viral tweets when they
have gone too far have we tired yet of
this hyperbolic state of affairs and
where do we even begin to restore the
ethical health of our institutions well
I submit that we can start by changing
the way we’ve been debating public
policy our level of political debate has
eroded and I think it would even shock
our framers they understood the tensions
between the branches of government they
created them by design of course they
understood the tensions between
individual rights states rights and the
federal government they certainly
understood the challenges of taxation
and the need to promote interstate and
international commerce and while we may
think that our issues of today are so
much more Colette complex our political
parties are organized around the same
contest of ideas perhaps it’s time to
remind each other that it’s not only
okay to disagree but it’s essential to
the health of our democracy to disagree
but let’s look at the typical debate of
today to do so I’m gonna propose some
fictional legislation and I’m gonna call
my legislation shoes for schools this
bill proposes using federal education
funding to provide a stipend for
low-income families who are struggling
with back-to-school expenses
like shoes our hope is that by providing
this stipend students from low-income
families will improve school attendance
and thereby school performance so in the
typical debate of today a typical
response to a proposal like shoes for
schools looks like this party a responds
with you’re a wasteful spending right
and then party B responds with if you
don’t like this program then you hate
the poor it might have in my job as an
advocate for issues that affect
low-income populations I see this debate
play out again and again your wasteful
spending your hater
and sometimes this debate is disguised a
little so one side says you’re wasteful
spending
data point data point data point and the
other side says you’re hater you know
the data point data point data point but
we’re still back to name-calling with
data points but what if we really valued
that contest of ideas what if we were
careful with language and claims of
urgency
what if our debate looked more like this
what if party a said yes we have low
income families who struggle but a
costly federal government program is not
the way to go instead we should provide
market incentives and meet families
needs at the local level what if party B
said ok government can be costly and
market incentives do work but they can
be uneven and region by region they
could be different and they don’t
protect families against discrimination
so let’s have a comprehensive federal
program that ensures fairness now how
much harder was it to have that kind of
debate you know clearly not that hard to
take this even further the
superficiality of our current debate is
creating an informational void and it’s
also creating some organizational chaos
the new generation of the party faithful
may not understand right now what
they’re supposed to be faithful to what
I like about the yes but instead model
is particularly the
portion yes government can be costly
yes low-income families struggle this is
the counter-argument right this strategy
that many of us learned in high school
debate club is now frightening lis
absent from state houses and in Congress
it’s as if our current desire to never
show weakness is actually undermining
our ability to problem-solve as a
society progressive friends I think it’s
time for us to admit that sometimes
government can be really expensive and
inefficient it’s gonna be okay
conservative friends I think it’s time
to recognize that we have a lot of
economic disparity in this country and
there are a lot of low income families
who struggle and can’t afford basic
needs like shoes after all if we’re not
willing to name the problems of
government how are we ever going to
improve it and if we’re not going to
name the fact that we have low-income
families who are struggling how are we
ever going to address their disadvantage
so I’m proposing a pipedream no I don’t
think so I think this is what democracy
is designed to do instead let’s take a
pledge to elevate the debate imagine if
we asked every candidate for public
office will you elevate the debate could
we have progressive candidates that
talked about the challenges of
government and pledged to improve it
could we have conservative candidates
that talked about the challenges of an
unregulated free market but still pledge
to support responsible business as we
grow hungrier for a more ethical body
politic so will our commitment to
participate more thoughtfully I can
envision a day where I would be asked to
speak to the merits of a program like
shoes for schools and if that day comes
I promise to do the best job I can make
the best arguments available and get
some good data to back it up but I am
also prepared to lose the other side has
a valid point of view and it’s by
respecting that point of view that I’m
inspired to be more on my toes
I’m inspired to be a better advocate and
I’m inspired to elevate the debate I
would like to believe that we would have
won that 96 race without the silly
tagline or the negative TV ad I’ll never
know but I do hope that the next
generation of hungry idealists will take
the necessary steps to recalibrate our
institutions restore meaning and save
democracy
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: