Press "Enter" to skip to content

How one cow story exposed the danger of homogenized lives | Kirsten Hunter | TEDxPiscataquaRiver


I’m April of 2016 a woman came to visit
my family’s farm in New York where we
teach people about the 40 years we’ve
spent home setting on our 16 acre
property raising much of our own meat
and vegetables during her visit she went
on a tour with my mother and during the
tour in response to a question from the
group about the cows age and how long
she would live on the farm my mother
explained that our cow was being raised
for beef the next day the same woman
called the farm spoke with my dad and
said she wanted to buy the cow she
explained to him that she wasn’t a
vegetarian she didn’t have an issue with
eating meat but she felt that because we
allowed people to come to our farm and
interact with our animals we shouldn’t
then be allowed to use them for food she
suggested that we could probably go to
Whole Foods and buy our meat like
everyone else when she was told no that
the cow was not for sale this woman
became angry she did not understand that
for us homesteading was a lifestyle
choice one that involved raising animals
knowing what they were fed knowing that
they were treated kindly and that that
was quite different for us than going to
Whole Foods to buy your meat she was not
interested in the problematic precedent
that would be set if we were to comply
with her request and most importantly
this woman did not feel that we had a
right to say no to her the phone call
that day didn’t go well she eventually
hung up but not before ominously
declaring to my father that she would
find a way to save that cow the Monday
of that week as I spoke to my parents
from here in New Hampshire and heard
them retell the events of the weekend I
took out my laptop and I started
scrolling through their newsfeed and my
stomach sank in a period of less than 48
hours an unbelievable
viral
attack started um it began with a posted
Facebook group save mini the cow the
local news was contacted my parents had
agreed to an interview and the avalanche
of viral media was in motion over the
course of two weeks you’ve seen these
things play out just this viral
firestorm unfolded and I don’t really
need to describe all the details to you
because you’ve seen these kinds of
things in lots of contexts basically the
same format every time first there’s an
issue that’s kind of put for it says
being above dispute and there’s a call
to arms the sides of us versus them are
established people far and wide hop on
board as the media latches on to the
story and really quickly participants on
both sides of the issue lose sight of
the humanity and the people with whom
they now find themselves in opposition
and that loss of a sense of humanity
eliminates our need to try to see the
other perspective to try to understand
someone else’s point of view or even to
agree to disagree
it sounds familiar right on the farm
baby lambs were being born school
classes were visiting seedlings were
sprouting in the greenhouse the rhythm
of the life that my family chose
continued almost without pause but the
fear of what was happening online was
very real for all of us even for me here
in New Hampshire from the moment I
started monitoring the frenzy I felt
this intense mix of adrenaline and fear
it was all happening so fast and no one
on either side seemed to be taking any
pause before throwing more fuel on the
fire
generally I believe that there is great
wisdom in ignoring much of what happens
on social media but it became quickly
apparent last spring that if we remain
silent people feeling protective of us
would speak for us in a way that
often made the situation worse and so I
settled in in front of my computer and
tried to maintain control of our message
if for no other reason than to assure
those coming to our defense that we had
things under control and that they could
go back to their own lives I wrote a
short statement that I posted on the
protest page save miny the cow in which
I explained the circumstances and some
history about my family’s farm and our
business in my post I volunteered to
remain online after posting it for half
an hour should anyone want to have a
dialog and then I sat and sorted through
the barrage of messages that came back
at me putting aside angry hateful
retorts and lifting up anyone who
sounded halfway rational by engaging in
a conversation with them and trying to
come to a place of mutual understanding
my message was simple that we respected
different points of view and that we had
a right to our choice I wanted that
message to be visible to anyone who was
still to come to the protest page and so
I planted it there I planted similar
statements on each of the change.org
petitions that had been created the one
to save many of the cow and the counter
protest that had been laid out to save
the farm not created by us no matter
that we didn’t need saving I also placed
similar statements on the on the hateful
reviews that were popping up on Yelp and
on our business pages my clarity during
all of this stems from an understanding
that’s been growing in me about the way
the culture that we live in operates it
is a culture where our lack of exposure
to different kinds of experiences
compels us to expect agreement from the
people around us and you can imagine
this is kind of problematic in the story
of the cow we are looking at a situation
where people have become so far removed
from the source of their food
that they can no longer relate to the
realities of farming the fact that the
of the four million people living on
Long Island many of them have absolutely
no experience with animal husbandry it
has created my family’s business which
is something of a museum a place where
people can go and have a window into an
experience that they do not know
firsthand and our willingness to vilify
that which we don’t understand has
become dangerously easy because in our
day to day lives we aren’t challenged to
navigate different cultures different
experiences and different perspectives
we live many of us in bubbles surrounded
by people so much like ourselves that we
can hardly imagine it might be any
different
somewhere else online this is perhaps
even more true as we can unfriend and
friend voices based on our comfort with
what they have to say we read a headline
and come to a conclusion about what we
think in a matter of seconds and then we
pass judgment with a thumbs up or a
thumbs down we take intensely
complicated issues and we dilute them to
a value of good or bad and hardly any
time is spent considering all of the
details that are being washed away in
that process the story of many of the
cow gives us a way in to examine the
dangers of this isolation that we’ve
created communities today are divided
across socio-economic lines and across
political lines families find the means
to buy into the best school districts or
they’re shut out from them
decades of discriminatory housing
policies have left us with whole
communities that are almost solely
people white folks other neighborhoods
almost solely people of color it’s
stories like this personal experiences
where we can examine these things that
can cause us to stop and reflect
to sit back and to take a different look
at how our world is navigating and we’ve
been hearing about that all day today
throughout the two weeks of the attack
that was taking place my family received
messages from people all over the world
farmers from as far away as Australia
sent us messages encouraging notes
asking us to stay strong because they
could see in the experience that we were
going through something that they
related to something that they have been
experiencing themselves in their lives
all over at the protest in front of our
house on our opening weekend the
original cow activists found themselves
sparring with PETA activists who had
come to join into the protest but
disagreed as to the reasons for why the
cow should be saved across the street a
counter protest was formed mostly by a
group called bikers for Trump
those guys had decided that this protest
was clearly the work of liberals and
they were there to stand up for the
farmers I was down that weekend and
chose not to mention to the bikers that
my family probably be considered
liberals by most measures seemed best to
just leave the whole thing alone when
around about the two-week point things
started settling down my family and our
farm emerged from all of this drama
relatively unscathed as it turned out
forty years investing in our community
teaching children lessons about living
off the land the grace and beauty of
homesteading proved to be a potent
shield against an emotionally driven and
sudden attack if anything it actually
all became a pretty large advertising
campaign for my family’s farm at the
cost of some sleepless nights and some
long hours in front of the computer
screen
but it offered something else as well a
reminder to look more closely to
withhold our judgement and to value
those experiences that are different
from our own when we have the
opportunity to encounter them if we come
across a different opinion it should not
signal us to draw our weapons rather
let’s look at it as an opportunity to
reach out from our own bubble and into
that of another thank you so much
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: